Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To bring up how unfair the 11+ is?

291 replies

Jaggerdagger · 05/02/2022 21:04

I live in a notorious grammar school area in the south east (I'm sure you can guess which one!).

Reasons why I dislike the 11+:

  1. Tutoring is an unfair advantage and can only be accessed for those that can afford it. How can the 11+ be accurately assessed if the majority are tutored and only a handful manage to pass the test without additional support?
  2. If a child is tutored just to pass a test, it doesn't necessary mean that they will thrive in a grammar school. I'm a teacher and I've seen lots of pupils not coping well in the high pressured environment.
  3. It's divisive and can make those children that don't get in feel that they are inferior. Feeling like a failure age 11 for something that could be totally avoidable if this system wasn't in place seems terribly sad to me.
  4. Comprehensive schools in the area suffer in various ways because of grammar schools. For instance, more private schools are opened in the area due to parents wanting to pay for better facilities for their children that didn't get into grammar school.

I'm sure this has been discussed before on here but I think it's worth bringing it up once more for debate.

Aibu to think that this is an archaic and unfit system that should be either be abolished or drastically changed?

OP posts:
MrsBaublesDylan · 06/02/2022 19:11

The grammar school system is broken. My working class Dad got into a Northern grammar school and went on to Oxford.

When he took his 11+ no one was tutored.

The tutoring makes a nonsense of the grammar school system.

I don't think ds14 would have passed the 11+ without tutoring. However, he is clever like my Dad and despite being at the local under-performing comp, is doing really well.

I am pleased my son will have the confidence that comes from knowing everything he has achieved is 100% his own.

Blossomtoes · 06/02/2022 18:51

@SynchOrSwim

How do people propose to make the test impossible to tutor for?
Randomise it. Introduce different elements every year. Make it so unpredictable that tutoring becomes pointless.
SynchOrSwim · 06/02/2022 18:47

How do people propose to make the test impossible to tutor for?

Refrosty · 06/02/2022 18:47

The schools in my area are dire in comparison to the inner London schools*

Refrosty · 06/02/2022 18:44

People who have money can always do whatever they can to give their kid a 'leg up'. I don't hold it against them, but I do hate the fact that there are 'winners' and 'losers' in the 11+ situation.

My area is out of catchment for all but one grammar (and that one grammar has a very large catchment area, which is aspirational but means it's the only grammar on offer for many of the poorest kids, and the distance itself is limiting). We didn't consider schools when moving here, DH's family are from here. The secondary schools in my catchment are notoriously poor performing, with the usual groans about pupil behaviour, etc. I've been to an inner London comp and visited many for work, these schools are dire in comparison. The catchment line for the closest grammar is a stones throw away. Cross that line, house/rent prices explode. That's understandable. So what actually happens = parents of all income brackets will tutor their kids for the 11+/selective private school bursary (quite like Kent). If they have a bit more money, they'd save to move house into a grammar school catchment, or move house to an area where the average comprehensive school performs way better than our best school. I'm sure many pupils will feel 'left behind', and that's the saddest part about the current system.

However, I do find it interesting when people condemn the 11+ (grammar/private) school system but those same people live in areas with decent comprehensives. In many areas, the area itself is self-selective. There's a reason why many parents around here move their kids in year 4/5, but again, only the ones who can afford to. Ultimately, we need to focus on poor performing schools, so that grammars aren't so starkly advantageous. Getting rid of grammars before doing that would be dumb imo.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/02/2022 18:44

The other selection locally is by religion. The only C of E secondary is in a different town so it’s popular with parents as it requires 2 years weekly church attendance yr 4 and 5 and an expensive school bus pass. It’s popular because standards and results are high - the sort of parents that tutor for 11+ are the same sort that will jump through religious hoops.
DC’s grammar is far more racially diverse than our area and any of the other schools because the 25% from OOC come from surrounding towns with more diverse populations.

thing47 · 06/02/2022 18:41

Deciding on a child's educational future on the basis of a particular type of test, taken on a single day, at the age of 10, is a terrible system. If you were trying to devise the most unfair, awful way of assessing children you'd be hard pushed to come up with an alternative to the 11+.

All those saying 'but grammar schools are great', well yes, of course they are! It's easy when you syphon off the highest-achieving whatever percentage of children (as assessed by the 11+ at least) and educate them separately. The issue is that the minority of children are benefiting at the majority's expense, because that majority have to attend less good schools than they otherwise would. Can't we do better than that?

underneaththeash · 06/02/2022 18:28

We did 11+ for our eldest, he went to a state school for KS1 and then a prep school. I did the tutoring (it isn't difficult to go through the work, our prep school only "prepped" for 13+), he's academic, but not brilliant, but he got in easily.

It's crap, it's meant to be one of the best state schools in the country, the teaching is really variable, even for GCSE, there is little ownership of anything and I really feel that we've failed DS. Everyone seems to tutor. We had plenty of money to send him to a decent private school.

Howshouldibehave · 06/02/2022 18:09

But school sixth forms and some colleges will require certain grades to take A levels

Our local secondary school takes all pupils into their sixth form who want to stay, no matter what GCSEs they got. I’m sure they are not alone.

user1487194234 · 06/02/2022 17:58

It is unfair but the vast majority of parents will do whatever they can to get their children the best education they can
So it would be necessary to ban all private and grammar schools,can't see much political appetite for that
And what about tutoring generally how do you stop that
And moving to a better catchment
A lot of it comes down to £

CecilyP · 06/02/2022 17:43

At my DC's comprehensive, there is masses of tutoring for GCSE and A levels. That is also unfair, in the same way as tutoring for grammar entry is, but you don't mention this inequality

That’s a good point.

I disagree. With the 11+, children are completing for a finite number of places, so if tutored child A gets a place, untutored child B loses the place. Tutoring for GCSEs isn’t a competition; it (hopefully) raises a child’s grades in particular subjects, whether to get a really good grade or simply scrape a pass. It doesn’t really effect anyone else in the same way.

Andante57 · 06/02/2022 16:24

At my DC's comprehensive, there is masses of tutoring for GCSE and A levels. That is also unfair, in the same way as tutoring for grammar entry is, but you don't mention this inequality

That’s a good point.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/02/2022 14:55

TyotyaKlava there is a pupil with autism in my DC’s grammar year. She has meltdowns and has a support assistant. The other children are understanding she’s not bullied. I’d speak to the school. The doesn’t like being under pressure you’d have to look at. Expectations are high - a 7 is pushed to an 8, an 8 to a 9 it’s definitely not a oh you got a 7 (A) rest on your laurels type atmosphere. It suits mine but I can see it could be stressful to some children.

Eightiesfan · 06/02/2022 14:30

@TyotyaKlava

Sorry for slightly off topic question but what does everyone think of sending an (Hugh functioning) autistic child to a grammar school? My 7 year old dd has not been diagnosed but we are on waiting list for an assessment. She struggles with friendships and high anxiety. She is very bright, on top of her class, she reads every spare moment she has. She has emotional issues she has huge meltdowns etc. Our comprehensive school is the only one in area and doesn’t have a great reputation. I’m worried about level of education and bullying due to her being slightly different. Because she is quite bright shall I give 11+ a go in a few years time? I’m worried about her anxiety though as she doesn’t like being under pressure
I can only speak for the school I work at which has an excellent Student Support, and offers amazing support to children who have statements as well as those borderline cases who need extra help. It’s early days for your DC, but when the time comes visit the school and ask the SEN lead to give you a tour with your child. Don’t be afraid of asking detailed questions about provision and encourage your DC to ask questions to gauge how they are answered as well as whether or the answers are directed at you or to him.
Blossomtoes · 06/02/2022 14:27

@Hb12

All those saying "well I passed 30/50 years ago with no tutoring" etc are missing the point massively. The landscape has changed massively since then, it isn't the same 'vehicle of social mobility' that it used to be.
And that’s a very bad thing. If the 11+ was a test for which it was impossible to be tutored, grammar schools would return to being vehicles for social mobility as they were originally intended.
Hb12 · 06/02/2022 14:25

All those saying "well I passed 30/50 years ago with no tutoring" etc are missing the point massively. The landscape has changed massively since then, it isn't the same 'vehicle of social mobility' that it used to be.

TheKeatingFive · 06/02/2022 14:15

I grew up in NI and in my time (80s/90s) grammars did mostly succeed in what they set out to do. Give poor, bright children a top notch education. I know many who benefitted hugely from them.

But I also know many who benefitted from the excellent secondary modern education that was available in my town - and many of these children transferred to grammars for A levels having spent five years in an environment very suited to their needs.

So in the right circs, with the right alternative education in place, they can have fantastic benefits. But it's all about the overall picture. Good grammars with poor alternatives could cause very different outcomes.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/02/2022 14:01

We are in Lancashire area with one grammar. Not super selective - pass in catchment gets you in (rumoured to be 75% so top table child will get in not just the super bright) The other local schools are good and high achieving. Parents interested/supportive tend to gravitate to area which benefits all schools. Parents tend to be sensible and only enter those with a good chance. Children do need prep either diy or tutor. Some local state primaries run 11+ prep clubs. Reading a wide variety of books especially classics was a big thing for vocabulary but I did that anyway as both myself and DC enjoy reading so I wouldn’t class that as 11+ prep. Main issue was maths they need to know all yr6 maths by time of exam which is only 3 weeks in yr 6. No matter how bright you are you need to be taught it - one minute a question is not time to work stuff out. Exam technique needs teaching too - they are only 10 things like don’t miss any out, pace so you finish, guess don’t leave it need spelling out.
Only 75% places fill from catchment rest get allocated on score order - I know children in none catchment are tutored much more extensively as they need to be scoring 90%+ and local comps are poor.
Grammar School has suited my dc as I thought it would. She benefits from peers working at similar level, debates are interesting and go at a pace she likes. Curriculum is traditional, they all have to do 3 sciences, a modern language etc, Classics and Latin as options.
It’s not an issue locally the kids mix at extra curricular activities. It’s not unusual to have children at 2 schools.

getboosted · 06/02/2022 13:52

@Smileyaxolotl1

getboosted ‘All sixth forms, are selective, even comprehensives’ This isn’t true unless you mean selective in terms of the subjects the students can pick. Where do you think the kids who get grades 1 -3 at GCSE go? At my school all current pupils can stay on regardless of their grades.
I did say that sixth form colleges would be different!

But school sixth forms and some colleges will require certain grades to take A levels, therefore they are selective. Plus colleges will be offering other qualifications in addition to A levels, which may have lower admission criteria.

BrieAndChilli · 06/02/2022 13:19

We are in wales where there are no grammar schools. The choice is state Comp or private. Admittedly we live in the most well off county and we have no cities in our county so all the schools are pretty much the same.
DS1 is very intelligent but we couldn’t afford the local private school even with scholarship. We could have looked into 11+ but he would have had an 1.5hour plus trip on public transport to the nearest one which we felt would have been detrimental to his life balance.
His state Comp has been great. He’s in year 10 and has just got into a couple of university run programs - one with Oxford so I don’t feel his lost out by going to Comp.

The problem with the state/grammar/private school areas are that is becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. If all the gifted and ‘nice’ well behaved kids are creamed off then the states only have the less able or trouble lessons kids so the results are going to be worse than grammar. If all the kids went to the same school like where we are then the whole range is catered for and people who maybe hadn’t come into their own at 10. It are ready at 14 to crack down are still able to move up to the top sets etc

Smileyaxolotl1 · 06/02/2022 13:14

Redskythisnight
I don’t disagree but there is no way to make it equitable because the success or otherwise of a school is dependent mostly on its pupils.
Better performing schools attract better pupils and parents whether through selection or by catchment continue to frequent their school.
Even if you say everyone has to go to their nearest school it wouldn’t help that much as if there was an upwards trend at a school then people with means would move nearer to it and the trend would continue.

RedskyThisNight · 06/02/2022 13:10

I agree completely that the 11plus isn't fair, but it does seem to be one of the only areas that people get upset with the financial unfairness of it. Surely this happens with everything?

Education is more fundamental to a person's future life chances than being able to do more sports or go on holiday. And perhaps people feel that education provided by the state should be equitable? Not that the better education is only available to those who already have the most money?

Howshouldibehave · 06/02/2022 13:06

All sixth forms, are selective, even comprehensives. You can't go to sixth form with poor GCSEs

That is just untrue. Some 6th forms ask for certain grades, many don’t. Our local sixth form has plenty of kids in it who got 1/2s at their GCSEs!

What's really unfair is that access to grammar schools is a postcode lottery. We didn't live in a grammar school area so my kids had to go to sink comps

Generally you get the sink comps IN grammar school areas because they have creamed off the top cohort!

arethereanyleftatall · 06/02/2022 13:05

I agree completely that the 11plus isn't fair, but it does seem to be one of the only areas that people get upset with the financial unfairness of it. Surely this happens with everything? For example, you can't do most sports (other than at school) unless your parents can afford it. You can't go on holiday unless your parents can afford it. Etc etc. it's not fair. But there isn't a way around it. You can't ban parents from buying whatever help they can to improve their own child's chances in life.
If they did away with grammar schools, this would still exist - parents who could afford it would pay for tutors to get their kids in to the top sets at comp.

SerendipitySunshine · 06/02/2022 12:55

That wasn't my experience. I was a poor kid from a single parent household, and went to the local grammar school in second hand uniform. I had no tutoring. It gave me a chance to see a different life. I went on to a good university and a good career. I don't think I'd have had that in the secondary modern or a comprehensive school. I'd been mercilessly bullied at primary school for being clever and different, but at grammar school I could find my tribe much more easily.