Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To bring up how unfair the 11+ is?

291 replies

Jaggerdagger · 05/02/2022 21:04

I live in a notorious grammar school area in the south east (I'm sure you can guess which one!).

Reasons why I dislike the 11+:

  1. Tutoring is an unfair advantage and can only be accessed for those that can afford it. How can the 11+ be accurately assessed if the majority are tutored and only a handful manage to pass the test without additional support?
  2. If a child is tutored just to pass a test, it doesn't necessary mean that they will thrive in a grammar school. I'm a teacher and I've seen lots of pupils not coping well in the high pressured environment.
  3. It's divisive and can make those children that don't get in feel that they are inferior. Feeling like a failure age 11 for something that could be totally avoidable if this system wasn't in place seems terribly sad to me.
  4. Comprehensive schools in the area suffer in various ways because of grammar schools. For instance, more private schools are opened in the area due to parents wanting to pay for better facilities for their children that didn't get into grammar school.

I'm sure this has been discussed before on here but I think it's worth bringing it up once more for debate.

Aibu to think that this is an archaic and unfit system that should be either be abolished or drastically changed?

OP posts:
CointreauVersial · 05/02/2022 21:45

I detest the grammar school system.

In my opinion, the only people who support it are those with bright children. Or those who can afford tutoring. And it condemns those who fail to inferior schools, with no option to "move up" beyond the age of 11.

So relieved we don't live in a GS area.

DialsMavis · 05/02/2022 21:44

I agree OP, we tutored (once a week for an hour in a group and a couple of practice tests), not sure if we needed to in the end to pass but it clearly helped as DD got a surprisingly good mark. She has two friends who are also very clever and hardworking girls who just missed out on the pass mark, who in a fair world would have a place. However, as others have said, we have struggled our whole lives and want her to have a better start in life than we did, so whilst I feel guilty, I also don't regret it.

Daisy03 · 05/02/2022 21:44

I totally agree with you.

I'm not sure if I'm in the same area as you but in this area children have to opt in to sitting the test. I feel this is unfair for those children capable of passing but who's parents neglect or chose not to register them for the test.
All the children I know who passed this year have received tutoring, they have little chance of passing otherwise as it's curriculum they haven't covered yet

Inspectorslack · 05/02/2022 21:44

My youngest is only 19. It hasn’t changed that much here. I have friends with kids in their early teens and whilst some kids are tutored most aren’t.

Jaggerdagger · 05/02/2022 21:42

"It is an odd system but at the end of the day we’re parents who want our children to have the best education available to them, that they are also happy with."

Absolutely understand this - and I'm sure I would do the same in your shoes! As mentioned earlier, the system is to blame and while it remains the way it is, parents will have no choice but to to go down that route.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 05/02/2022 21:41

@Jaggerdagger

For those that are commenting about their experience growing up: It's definitely changed. Vastly. My mum went to grammar school and I just asked her if there was such a thing as a tutor for the 11+ back then. Absolutely not! Lots of kids round here start at year 4. Some even as young as year 3! Shock
Then the problem isn’t grammar schools but sharp elbowed parents. It’s not beyond the wit of man to devise an exam where the chances of passing can’t be improved with tutoring.
Jinglebellsoncake · 05/02/2022 21:41

Sorry if this is a silly question.
But what are comprehensive schools like? And why are they considered inferior? Is the teaching poorer? Less academic subjects?

How do they compare to standards secondary schools across the country?

Onairjunkie · 05/02/2022 21:41

My older brother’s kids (one school year apart) wound up with one passing and the other not. Was a bit shit at the time. The one who passed did a STEM degree and bought his first house at 22. The one who didn’t did a STEM degree, then went to drama school, then LAMDA and is an actor. I think familial support counts for a lot. It’s a shit way to classify kids at such a young age but it’s not the end of the world.

HelpINeeedSomebody · 05/02/2022 21:39

I live in a grammar area and tutoring is a huge part in gaining a place. Everyone I know whose child has gone has used tutors but just for varying lengths of time.

My eldest dd has always been bright but I couldn't afford tutors and she missed out on passing by a few marks.

I thought she would be ok as we were just within catchment of a pretty good secondary (bypassing 2 more local awful ones). She enjoys her school, is in the top sets of most subjects and has had access to some schemes that target bright kids in comprehensives in the name of 'levelling the playing field'. The downside is that I massively underestimated how much disruption there would be caused in her classes by kids who have zero interest in school and who often are pretty troubled individuals. The teaching turnover is quite high and I can't blame them based on what I hear. I know how much work teaching is anyway but it must be so stressful with how much added behaviour management is involved.

Looking back I wish I'd taken a loan out to pay for a tutor for her and I often feel like I failed her in not doing so.

Retisestress · 05/02/2022 21:38

I live in the south east and yes my children all went to the local grammar schools. They had tuition in year 6 because the local primary school understandably didn’t offer it and the actual exam requires the child to understand the concept of VR ,, NVR and Maths . I definitely agree that all children should have access to the same tuition…problem is though is that it is a waste of resources for the children who are not as academic and not good for their self esteem…catch 22 TBH .

Jaggerdagger · 05/02/2022 21:38

For those that are commenting about their experience growing up: It's definitely changed. Vastly. My mum went to grammar school and I just asked her if there was such a thing as a tutor for the 11+ back then. Absolutely not! Lots of kids round here start at year 4. Some even as young as year 3! Shock

OP posts:
Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 05/02/2022 21:37

I agree op and have decided not to go down that route with dd.
Just think it unfair that those who can afford a tutor (us included if we wanted to) have a massive headstart - and doesn't mean they could cope with grammar school or the pressures it brings.
The closest one to us buses kids in from miles away so school friends wouldn't be local.
Really thought about it long and hard and although dd seems quite clever, l am not sure she could handle it nor would lmwant her to be out the house from 7 30am til nearly 5pm every day.

AliceW89 · 05/02/2022 21:37

In a lot of ways, I think grammar is more morally questionable than private education for the reasons you list. State funded classism as opposed to individuals spending their own private wealth. Maybe not historically - I’m sure they were once tools for social mobility. But they’ve been utterly hijacked now. Of course I don’t blame parents: a) you can’t help where you live and b) nobody is going to actively chose to send their DC to a worse school. But overall the concept is outdated and discriminatory.

Blossombo · 05/02/2022 21:36

My DD is in year 7 at a grammar school. Passed without tutoring.

I am very grateful she is in that environment now, they all seem really driven and dedicated to achieving. I think DD would have struggled in a comp as she just wants to get on with the work not put up with other’s behaviour (which was a huge issue at primary school!)

Skinnydecafflatte · 05/02/2022 21:34

Not sure if I live in the same borough as you. My DH and I grew up in different areas, neither of which had the grammar system so this was a bit of an unknown to us.

The local comp (closest school) had an awful reputation and the local grammar (second closest to us) had a great reputation. We had to do lots of this through word of mouth as no schools had open days due to Covid. I did not want my DS to get to a school though and feel out of his depth so we didn’t have him tutored. DS wanted to go to the grammar as most of his friends wanted to go. He sat the 11+ and fortunately passed comfortably so we were all happy.
DC2 is year 4, so a couple of years before we need to make this decision. We’re not sure if DC2 will be up to the standard (not quite as bright as DC1) or will want to go to grammar but regardless we won’t get them tutored as I want them to get there (if they want to) on their own merit. We will let them have the choice.

It is an odd system but at the end of the day we’re parents who want our children to have the best education available to them, that they are also happy with. We’re fortunate that in the area there are single sex and mixed sex schools of both grammar and non selective so there’s a good choice for them.

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 05/02/2022 21:33

I grew up in NI with the grammar school system. The difference was that schools taught to the 11+. Primary schools in England’s grammar school regions don’t teach the 11+ style questions, so it’s virtually impossible to access without tutoring or invested parents.

The grammar system stinks; the middle classes have completely hijacked it’s original intentions.

TheSoapyFrog · 05/02/2022 21:30

I'm sure we live in the same area. I'm going to say YABU because I'm biased. I got into a grammar school as a child from a working class family, with no extra tutoring.
I'm hoping my son will follow.

Inspectorslack · 05/02/2022 21:30

And like others. They have been a vehicle for social mobility for my children. They will never (I hope) have to live the life I did. And for that I am and always will be grateful.

Jaggerdagger · 05/02/2022 21:30

In my area, it's much more common for a child to have been tutored for the test than not to have been. Obviously I don't have exact figures but I am confident this is the case from talking to children and colleagues over the years.

OP posts:
jay55 · 05/02/2022 21:29

I grew up in a non grammar area and all the comprehensives were shit. The lack of choice (no local private schools either) meant complete apathy from all of them. It was a total race to the bottom.

At least where there is some competition for pupils, some effort is made.

So while I don't think the grammar system is doing what it set out to do, I do think something is better than nothing.

Blossomtoes · 05/02/2022 21:29

@Meatbadger

No tutoring here when I passed the 11+ 30 years ago. I benefitted hugely from my grammar school education and feel very grateful for it. No system is perfect but grammars were designed to give opportunities to those from less well off backgrounds, which in lots of cases they do.
Same here only it was over 50 years ago for me. Grammar schools were a vehicle for social mobility for so many of my contemporaries.
Inspectorslack · 05/02/2022 21:29

I’m in a grammar area - Northern Ireland.

None of my 3 were tutored because I couldn’t afford it. They all passed and went on to university. Two are now in professional jobs and the youngest is in her 2nd year.

EvilPea · 05/02/2022 21:28

I agree. It’s getting worse. When I moved to the area there was no tutoring adverts. I didn’t even know it was a grammar area and had no clue about what it entailed.

Suddenly 9 months before the 11+ the tutoring comments started and people had been tutoring since year 4! 6 months before it was upped to twice a week. During the summer holidays it was every day. How did I not know??
For one reason or another I had been privy to how the entire class were performing when dd sat hers. Not one of the top 5 got through the 11+. Where were these high flyers on that day. The ones that have gone to the questionable comp are now all in the top set. They aren’t wealthy and a few (like us) tutored for a few months before because that’s all they could afford, or didn’t at all.

Due to the tutoring the test is getting harder and harder so even more unattainable. The area I live in now has tutor adverts everywhere. It’s changed. However, incidentally fewer and fewer are taking the exam with more parents pulling them out because “it’s not for them” which is the whole ethos of the grammar system, it’s meant to be for everyone.

You’ve private schools tutoring for it as standard, wealthy parent tutoring for it. The questions are not something I’ve ever come across before. So the mumsnet “just sit with them and do the papers” is fine, if you can answer them.
So you either need to be wealthy to send them to private
Wealthy to tutor
Or knowledgable enough about the reasoning questions to teach them

Indecisivelurcher · 05/02/2022 21:27

My teacher friend told me tutoring is pretty much necessary because the test is early in yr6 but covers the full yr6 curriculum which of course they have not been taught yet.

Toseethezoo · 05/02/2022 21:26

I used to write the 11+ (for a different borough), and I worked really hard to make sure that we matched what local primary schools were teaching, and did something different each year so students couldn’t be coached through.

Grammars are bad news for neighbouring schools, however: I agree with you, there.