Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To bring up how unfair the 11+ is?

291 replies

Jaggerdagger · 05/02/2022 21:04

I live in a notorious grammar school area in the south east (I'm sure you can guess which one!).

Reasons why I dislike the 11+:

  1. Tutoring is an unfair advantage and can only be accessed for those that can afford it. How can the 11+ be accurately assessed if the majority are tutored and only a handful manage to pass the test without additional support?
  2. If a child is tutored just to pass a test, it doesn't necessary mean that they will thrive in a grammar school. I'm a teacher and I've seen lots of pupils not coping well in the high pressured environment.
  3. It's divisive and can make those children that don't get in feel that they are inferior. Feeling like a failure age 11 for something that could be totally avoidable if this system wasn't in place seems terribly sad to me.
  4. Comprehensive schools in the area suffer in various ways because of grammar schools. For instance, more private schools are opened in the area due to parents wanting to pay for better facilities for their children that didn't get into grammar school.

I'm sure this has been discussed before on here but I think it's worth bringing it up once more for debate.

Aibu to think that this is an archaic and unfit system that should be either be abolished or drastically changed?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hoppinggreen · 08/02/2022 08:38

@DdraigGoch

The comps are mediocre because of the grammar. Can't you see that?

So what's the excuse of the mediocre comps which aren't in selective areas?

Sure, you take out the top set it will make the school's aggregate grade score look bad, but would Johnny actually perform any worse as an individual? Individual performance (in relation to one's potential) is surely what counts, not some pretty meaningless figures.

Done right, Secondary Moderns could help struggling pupils who would otherwise get lost as teachers struggle to differentiate among a wide range of abilities.

I agree We aren’t really in a Grammar area. There are 2 Grammars in the next town (different LEA) that Dc in our town can apply for but many parents don’t even know about them and the majority of pupils there are from the immediate area - especially since proximity pushes you further up the ranking So this, coupled with some reasonably affluent areas here should mean we have good State Comps shouldn’t it? Well one is ok but the other 2 closest are awful
interferingma · 08/02/2022 08:10

@DdraigGoch

The comps are mediocre because of the grammar. Can't you see that?

So what's the excuse of the mediocre comps which aren't in selective areas?

Sure, you take out the top set it will make the school's aggregate grade score look bad, but would Johnny actually perform any worse as an individual? Individual performance (in relation to one's potential) is surely what counts, not some pretty meaningless figures.

Done right, Secondary Moderns could help struggling pupils who would otherwise get lost as teachers struggle to differentiate among a wide range of abilities.

Gosh where to start? Underfunding? Low parental expectations because it's an area where the tradition of getting on isn't strong? Deprivation so that frankly families see university as just another debt? I'm sure teachers could wade in with more. I'm just a parent whose children went to a mediocre comp outside a grammar area but whose children managed to do ok.
Lollipity · 08/02/2022 03:54

Whether we should have grammar schools or not is a complex subject, with lots of competing arguments.

I think they do help bright children from ordinary backgrounds access a good education that their parents couldn't otherwise afford. My friendship group my grammar were predominantly from working-class backgrounds (not free school meals, but not professional/upper MC backgrounds either).

If parents are motivated and able, they can tutor them through. I'm not sure why there is such an outcry about paid tutoring, when you can just buy the workbooks, take the answers out, give them to your child to do, and then go through the answers together. I couldn't afford tutoring as a single parent albeit one working full-time and did this, and my child qualified for grammar.

As someone mentioned in a comment above, there is always some type of selection. If not by ability through a grammar system, then by money through more expensive housing in MC catchment areas, or through jumping through religious hoops.

However, the secondary modern/upper schools do not get the "parity of esteem" that was once hoped for. Most staff and many students work exceptionally hard in these institutions, and face greater barriers. Grammar schools find it easier to recruit due to the high status afforded to them by the excellent grades they achieve through creaming off the academically most able.

Pupils can feel like they are failures before they've started year 7 and can internalize this as their "worth". However - most state primaries send very few children to grammar schools, so maybe this impact is limited.

I also see more mental health issues at girls' GSs, more anxiety over how they present to others and their identities, although this is also anecdotal.

DdraigGoch · 08/02/2022 00:43

The comps are mediocre because of the grammar. Can't you see that?

So what's the excuse of the mediocre comps which aren't in selective areas?

Sure, you take out the top set it will make the school's aggregate grade score look bad, but would Johnny actually perform any worse as an individual? Individual performance (in relation to one's potential) is surely what counts, not some pretty meaningless figures.

Done right, Secondary Moderns could help struggling pupils who would otherwise get lost as teachers struggle to differentiate among a wide range of abilities.

Cutesbabasmummy · 07/02/2022 16:23

My sister in law feels the same as you Op. Didn't stop her getting a tutor for her eldest and appealing when he didn't get in. She managed to get him in. I'll be getting a tutor for my son in a few years and hoping to goodness that he will get a scholarship and a bursary to an independent school.

Peregrina · 07/02/2022 13:34

I am not sure what the solution is. I think in market towns with mixed catchments and no real extremes of wealth comprehensives are usually good. In cities where there are very poor areas adjacent to wealthy ones where the catchments become very stratified then it's easy to see how some become sink schools and some get the children with committed parents.

I wonder if the grammar schools should be more strict about asking children to leave if they are not up to standard after the first year? I know my old grammar school did that. It bucked up the lazy ones, and despatched those who really couldn't keep up. Such a policy might stop some of the tutoring going on.

MrsBaublesDylan · 07/02/2022 11:10

It isn't only the grammar system which promotes educational inequality.

Children in areas without grammar schools experience postcode inequality.

My sister lives 20 minutes from me in an area which is populated with Doctors, lawyers and bankers. Her children had the choice of two outstanding secondaries within catchment. She also pays for tutors for her dc.

I live in an area which has lots of people on benefits or in very low paid employment. DS secondary within catchment 'Needs improvement'. We can't afford tutors.

My ds is no less clever than his cousins, but it's not equality is it?

Peregrina · 07/02/2022 10:15

And SynchOrSwim's post is why the Sed Mod system was deeply unpopular before most authorities phased them out. Although in those days the measure was O levels, or even getting the chance to take them. Notwithstanding that, there were some good Sec Mods.

It seems a totally sterile argument to me to want to re-introduce a system which by the late sixties/early seventies was seen to be second rate for most children.We need some fresh thinking as to what is needed for the 21st century.

In genuine comprehensive areas, I don't think parents are clamouring for grammars, they want a good school for their children, as above.

SynchOrSwim · 07/02/2022 07:42

@Andante57

The school she's going to is the best in the city - what else can you do

Harbourlane if you disapprove of grammar schools then don’t send your dc to one. Send her to the comprehensive school.

Where I live there are no comprehensive schools as the grammars take 25-30% and even take a fair few who don't pass the 11+ through headteacher assessment.

Looking at catchment areas my daughter will have the choice of one school where 95% of students get a 5
5 or above in Maths and English GCSE and a school where 10% do. I can't imagine many mumsnetters being ok with the second option.

thing47 · 06/02/2022 23:39

Which is why I said 'in an area with a number of grammar schools'!
Where I live the grammar schools are larger than some of the alternatives.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/02/2022 23:30

It’s only true in full grammar area. One grammar in area doesn’t make all the rest mediocre or secondary moderns. In my area there’s only 1 grammar. It has intake of 150. Very large catchment only 100 places filled from catchment. The 3 nearest comprehensives all have excellent results - 2 are outstanding, one good. Grammar in area attracts involved parents who prioritise education which then benefits all local schools. So many New build estates here to accommodate families moving in.
The schools in non grammar area 8 miles away are poor/underperforming in contrast despite huge sums being spent (superschools project) I used to live in that area and from junior age ‘what are you going to do’ is main topic of conversation - find religion to get in out of town c of e, catholic, move across border to grammar area or tutor for grammar ooc but need child to be scoring 90% plus.

thing47 · 06/02/2022 23:23

@Peregrina

It only seems to be Mumsnet that refers to Secondary Moderns as Comprehensives. You would never think either that there are only 160 or so in the country.
Absolutely. If you live in an area with a number of grammar schools, the other schools on offer are NOT comprehensives, they are secondary moderns. You don't hear that term used much these days because it's considered pejorative – they are called Upper Schools or High Schools – but secondary moderns are what they are.
Peregrina · 06/02/2022 23:05

160 Grammars, that is, and a greater proportion of Sec Mods in Grammar Counties - which you would expect, if the Grammars only take 1/4 of the cohort.

Peregrina · 06/02/2022 22:57

It only seems to be Mumsnet that refers to Secondary Moderns as Comprehensives. You would never think either that there are only 160 or so in the country.

harbourlane · 06/02/2022 22:45

@interferingma I'm well aware that the comps are mediocre because of the grammar, that's obvious.

As I said I don't agree with the system. But the system exists, and so I'm not going to deny my child the best education in order to make a moral stand.

Andante57 · 06/02/2022 22:02

The school she's going to is the best in the city - what else can you do

Harbourlane if you disapprove of grammar schools then don’t send your dc to one. Send her to the comprehensive school.

Angrymum22 · 06/02/2022 21:48

My DS goes to a selective independent. A handful of children are asked to find alternative schools if they are not able to keep up after the first year. Most have been tutored to pass the exam but there is no point if the child can’t keep up with the accelerated pace. It doesn’t matter how much money the parents are willing to throw at the system talented children will thrive, those less able will not.
I don’t defend the system. We chose the school initially because of wrap around care in primary school. It became obvious that DS was naturally able and has breezed through. Unfortunately he has worked out just how much work he needs to do to get by but thrives under exam conditions so is happy.
I know a number of parents that pay for extra tuition on top of grammar school or selective independent. I don’t think it does the child any favours and they are often taking the place of a much more capable child. The only fare way to educate children is in a comprehensive system where children are streamed and in ability sets.
Even within an independent selective school the children are taught in groups of similar ability. Each subject at DS’s school is setted at GCSE with Maths and English setted in the lower years. It allows each group to develop at their own pace.
I was state educated in the comprehensive system. I received an excellent education but that was 40 yrs ago. DS’s school is very similar in its approach albeit with smaller classes but with the same discipline and ethos. It is sad that these early state models have been lost.

converseandjeans · 06/02/2022 21:42

I went to grammar school in the 80s and nobody was tutored - we just turned up to school & all did the papers.

Lots of working class girls there & on the whole they performed better than the private school girls who got in.

10 out of 90 came from my primary - we were taught in an old fashioned style.

Facilities at grammar school were dire, lessons were quite boring (copy this down girls), teachers have no help if you didn't understand & it was embarrassing to ask as everyone was so clever. I was always middle of the class but assumed I wasn't that clever as I was comparing myself to clever people.

I think instead of criticising the grammar schools we need as a society to value other skills. It doesn't suit everyone to sit still quietly working away. Why are people so obsessed with academic success?

I have two children - one who is extremely bright but hasn't got much confidence & can't make chit chat. The other is middle ability but has great social skills. DD would probably get into grammar school if we had one but DS will probably end up doing better later in life. It's not all about GCSE grades.

DdraigGoch · 06/02/2022 21:33

@Jinglebellsoncake

Sorry if this is a silly question. But what are comprehensive schools like? And why are they considered inferior? Is the teaching poorer? Less academic subjects?

How do they compare to standards secondary schools across the country?

The answer to this question can partially be found a few posts above yours:

The downside is that I massively underestimated how much disruption there would be caused in her classes

When I went to school (comprehensive, no local grammars unless you paid for private, modern buildings and facilities, good/outstanding Ofsted reports, average performance in the league tables, few on FSM) I had my fair share of ducking to avoid flying chairs. It has made me determined that when the time comes I shall move heaven and earth to make sure that my children don't have to share classes with the sort of shits I went to school with.

interferingma · 06/02/2022 21:15

@harbourlane

I think the 11+ system is inherently wrong and favours those whose parents can afford tutoring.

Therefore I am a hypocrite because DD starts at a grammar school this year. I wish the system didn't exist but it does, and our local comprehensives are mediocre, so we have taken advantage of it. The school she's going to is the best in the city - what else can you do.

It's the tutoring situation that really gets me though. When I sat the 11+ in the 80s nobody had private tutoring, it was some practice papers from whsmith and so a more level playing field. Now, pretty much child who sits the exam has been tutored - I only know of one last year who wasn't (but her parents are both teachers, so they did it themselves.) I really would have preferred not to have forked out for it, but you feel as if your child will be at a disadvantage if you don't, even if you're confident in their abilities. And so we all perpetuate it amongst ourselves and make it harder for lower income families. I don't feel great about it to be honest.

The comps are mediocre because of the grammar. Can't you see that? Without the grammar the more driven families would send their kids to the comp, and its results would Look far better
bluebellsis · 06/02/2022 21:10

Someone made a good point here: you probably spend some money on vocational activities for your kids and probably spend more than you would ever on tutoring. Swimming, tennis, dancing, musical instruments. Nobody can do it all but you chose what's important and what the kids "like" - 11+ tutoring is only for 1,5 yrs and a lot of it is actually commitment by the parents rather than the 1 hour lesson a week! Put this in perspective, a lot of parents just tutor their kids alone whilst still holding down a full time job and there are plenty of materials available without a professional tutor. It's not that unfair unless we are really talking about the ultra poor who can't afford to feed their kids and they certainly won't be doing any extra curricular stuff. Teaching in whichever form is about a growth mindset and that's more important. This includes tuition and exam practice. ANY exam practice and techniques on which most certifications /degrees etc are based.....

harbourlane · 06/02/2022 20:46

I think the 11+ system is inherently wrong and favours those whose parents can afford tutoring.

Therefore I am a hypocrite because DD starts at a grammar school this year. I wish the system didn't exist but it does, and our local comprehensives are mediocre, so we have taken advantage of it. The school she's going to is the best in the city - what else can you do.

It's the tutoring situation that really gets me though. When I sat the 11+ in the 80s nobody had private tutoring, it was some practice papers from whsmith and so a more level playing field. Now, pretty much child who sits the exam has been tutored - I only know of one last year who wasn't (but her parents are both teachers, so they did it themselves.) I really would have preferred not to have forked out for it, but you feel as if your child will be at a disadvantage if you don't, even if you're confident in their abilities. And so we all perpetuate it amongst ourselves and make it harder for lower income families. I don't feel great about it to be honest.

Howshouldibehave · 06/02/2022 20:13

People who have money can always do whatever they can to give their kid a 'leg up'

It’s not even just money, it could be time or education. Parents will do what is in their power to give their children the best start. We didn’t have the money to pay someone to come and do tutoring, but had the knowledge and time to work with DC at home. Reading widely, exam technique, past papers etc. All our DC passed the 11+.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/02/2022 19:40

I don’t see how you can make 11+ un tutorable.
Exam technique absolutely can be taught - familiarisation with sitting at a desk in a timed set up, with putting lines in boxes, checking how many questions versus time, attempting all multiple choice etc.
Reading widely. Left to own devices children tend to pick popular and easy books, they need to read classics for comprehension and VR. I enjoy reading as does DD so used to order DD books from library etc. I’d have done anyway but gave her a big advantage for 11+
Things like games, puzzles, crosswords all teach 11+ skills.
So just as mumsnetters now say oh we didn’t tutor we just familiarised her using bond books it would be we didn’t tutor we just played games and of course she read.

SynchOrSwim · 06/02/2022 19:16

I still don't get what you mean? Different subjects like history and geography, instead of the maths/English/VR/NVR?

Swipe left for the next trending thread