Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Taking older son into the ladies?

358 replies

Chichimcgee · 05/02/2022 16:14

He’s severely autistic, incontinent, anxious etc hes 12 but looks a lot older

There’s been two occasions where he’s gone into the men’s loos that ended up with me asking a random man to check they were empty and keep guard so I could sort my son out. We have a disability key and use that when we can but sometimes there’s not a disabled toilet.

I know he looks like teenager and it’s not nice for women using the loo and I do try to explain but there’s been a couple of toilet emergencies recently where I’ve been shouted at because he’s in the ladies with me. But I can’t go into the men’s?
WWYD?

OP posts:
gettingolderandgrumpy · 06/02/2022 09:55

Please if a woman is in fear of a disabled child / adult using the ladies with a female carer then sorry these ladies need to have a serious word with themselves.

x2boys · 06/02/2022 09:50

The safety of the disabled child is paramount here ,I cannot leave my disabled son for a minute when we are out and about as he has zero concept of danger
If I had to take him into a female toilet than I would it's not ideal ,and we need more disabled facilities ,but his well being is always my main concern.

nolongersurprised · 06/02/2022 09:44

They don't care about women in the OP's situation

Of course that’s not true. But there are competing needs. There’s no easy solution that meets everyone’s needs. Most people agree (including me, actually) that the OP should take her child to the female toilets. However, just because MN posters are comfortable with it, it doesn’t mean that girls the age as the OP’s son will be. Even if they don’t need privacy at the basins at that time, or are in full cubicles that are completely private some will be discombobulated by seeing a pubertal male child their own age in a space they assumed was single sex.

Yes why is it a issue , your in a cubicle they are chaperone with a female so nothing to worry about

WhT do you mean by, “They are chaperone with a female?”

tackling · 06/02/2022 09:43

@HouseOfGoldandBones

I'm not sure that telling women & girls "they have nothing to worry about" is fair.

Fear & trauma are not always rational.

This.

It's always the women being told off too and told to ignore or look the other way.

Why can't men be told off for being unaccommodating instead?

rookiemere · 06/02/2022 09:40

What about OP - or other female carers - if they are forced to use the mens toilets. Surely there is an increased risk of actual physical attack from that, which outweighs feelings ( although of course they are valid too)?
I wonder what a male carer would do in these circumstances. Of course much less likely to happen as women generally are the default carers, but should he take a disabled DD into the mens or ladies loos ? Or only go out if disabled facilities exist?

HouseOfGoldandBones · 06/02/2022 09:35

I'm not sure that telling women & girls "they have nothing to worry about" is fair.

Fear & trauma are not always rational.

VelvetChairGirl · 06/02/2022 09:33

i would take him in the ladies and announce he's SEN if it isnt obvious, I still take my 11 year old into the ladies no one has moaned yet but I am not going in the mens.

Spikeyball · 06/02/2022 09:33

"I am still waiting for those who think it’s wrong or who post the “what happens when he is 20/30 etc” type posts to come up with an alternative for the OP and others when faced with this issue."

They don't care about women in the OP's situation.

I don't think the OP's son has a 'right' to be in the women's toilet but out of consideration for the mother it is compassionate to allow it.

gettingolderandgrumpy · 06/02/2022 09:30

@nolongersurprised

The disabled CHILD isn't a risk to the females in their toilet and is being cared for and supervised

No, but a pubertal male will make some pubertal children his own age feel uncomfortable in their own spaces.

Will this continue when he’s 25? 50?

Yes why is it a issue , your in a cubicle they are chaperone with a female so nothing to worry about .
HouseOfGoldandBones · 06/02/2022 09:28

[quote Honeysuckle45]@eejervis op has clearly stated that there aren't always disabled toilets available. If there are then this should obviously be the default option.

Your 10 year old dd may feel uncomfortable but what about the 12 year old disabled boys comfort and safety? Could you not reassure your dd and explain that he needs help? [/quote]
If the OP uses the men's does that not deal with that issue?

It's a horrible situation & there will always be someone who feels unsafe & uncomfortable.

zoeFromCity · 06/02/2022 09:27

@GreenUp

It wouldn't bother me to see a mother accompanying her disabled son in the ladies. I'm sorry you've been shouted at and I'm sorry you've got so much on your plate. I hope things get easier for you.

I used to work with a grown man with incontinence and learning disabilities and when there wasn't a disabled toilet available I'd accompany him into the men's toilets. I operated from the position that it was my job to facilitate him to live the life he'd ordinarily live if he didn't have a disability so using the men's toilets seemed most appropriate from that perspective.

As long as you look away from the urinals and don't make eye contact, there should be no issue from the men. A majority of men don't want to start chatting in the toilet, they just get in and out so they pretend not to notice you.

This.

When a grown man neads to use a toilet and bring in his help, he does it. Doesn't go into ladies because of that.

(I know OP is mother of still-a-child, but this shift will need to happen at some moment)

strawberrrycheeesecake · 06/02/2022 09:24

No, but a pubertal male will make some pubertal children his own age feel uncomfortable in their own spaces.

Will this continue when he’s 25? 50?


If there isn't a disabled toilet, what would you do?

He will still be a vulnerable person needing care and supervision. He wouldn't be mooching around woman's toilets alone preying on anyone. I would pop my head in first and explain I'm a registered carer for an adult male and there isn't a disabled toilet for him to use so I will be walking him straight into a cubicle, and crack on. Wash hands, leave.

The problem lies with an establishment not providing adequate facilities for everyone. They are causing this. As far as I'm concerned if you've got to go, you've got to go, and as long as the situation is handled sensitively for all involved then there shouldn't be a problem, and it should be very rare, not the norm.

HouseOfGoldandBones · 06/02/2022 09:24

@sparepantsandtoothbrush

Does he have x-ray vision? I've never understood women getting all het up over this. They can't see you sitting on the toilet through the cubicle door!

Men expose themselves to use urinals and the OP going in to the men's isn't fair on either party

It's a really difficult situation.

But, given that some women obviously feel uncomfortable with a boy in the women's loos (as evidenced by the shouting), but if the only options are making men feel uncomfortable or making women feel unsafe, I think the former is the lesser of 2 evils.

I really do feel for you OP, it's a terrible situation to find yourself & your son in.

Sirzy · 06/02/2022 09:23

I am still waiting for those who think it’s wrong or who post the “what happens when he is 20/30 etc” type posts to come up with an alternative for the OP and others when faced with this issue.

x2boys · 06/02/2022 09:21

@nolongersurprised

The disabled CHILD isn't a risk to the females in their toilet and is being cared for and supervised

No, but a pubertal male will make some pubertal children his own age feel uncomfortable in their own spaces.

Will this continue when he’s 25? 50?

Quite possibly , untill we have better disabled facilities.
Gowithme · 06/02/2022 09:19

Of course taking a male autistic child in the women's toilets is not the same as the OP going in the males with him. Women's toilets are all cubicles and men's have urinals.

Some people on here are dicks, I'm GC but this is where they lose me. Some people here are so extreme/obsessive with it that they seem not to be able to see anything beyond it. This is not eroding women's spaces it is giving a woman carer somewhere to take her autistic child. How can they not see that expecting you to go in the men's is making your life harder and taking away from you - a woman.

To me them saying that you're not welcome in the ladies toilets but at the same time saying they don't want gender neutral toilets that would allow you to help your autistic child is completely ableist. But I guess it's easy to be that self absorbed when you don't have a child with ASD.

sashh · 06/02/2022 09:18

@Gizacluethen

How can there be no accessible toilet? I thought it was a legal requirement where there's toilets. If you have to take him into the women's then you have to accept women might not be happy about it.
Nope.

Businesses need to make, "reasonable adjustments" and there used to be a complete get out for any business with less than 20 employees.

Never notified this, but yes let's change this into a male bashing thread. When In fact the OP was talking about the unkindness of women.

It happens, a lot. And if you have to use the accessible toilet you have to get used to the stink of male shit.

nolongersurprised · 06/02/2022 09:18

The disabled CHILD isn't a risk to the females in their toilet and is being cared for and supervised

No, but a pubertal male will make some pubertal children his own age feel uncomfortable in their own spaces.

Will this continue when he’s 25? 50?

strawberrrycheeesecake · 06/02/2022 09:15

"It just feels like, once again, same sex spaces are being opened up to accommodate males"


But the carer is female and would prefer not to enter a male toilet where they use urinals. The men in there could potentially be a risk to the female carer especially as she is in their territory.

The disabled CHILD isn't a risk to the females in their toilet and is being cared for and supervised.

It's all about the context of the situation. Life isn't always straightforward black and white, men and women, disabled toilet, sometimes people have to make choices that don't fit the ideals of everyone else.

Wheelz46 · 06/02/2022 09:14

To those who say OP should check if her disabled son is okay to be accompanied in the ladies toilets, what if he is desperate to use the toilet and if they say no, then what?

Spikeyball · 06/02/2022 09:05

"It just feels like, once again, same sex spaces are being opened up to accommodate males"

A female carer is being accommodated here.

nolongersurprised · 06/02/2022 09:03

Those who are uncomfortable with a male having a female chaperone in the ladies, what age does the male/boy have to be to make you feel uncomfortable?

I don’t care at any age. My daughters became very private after puberty, so probably puberty and beyond?

It is very difficult, because obviously females are usually the main carers of their sons with disabilities.

Whatafustercluck · 06/02/2022 09:03

I thought all public venues had a legal obligation to provide disabled facilities. Clearly, it's a disgrace if they're not.

In those circumstances I agree with @GreenWhiteViolet and would check in the women's toilets that anyone in there was OK with my disabled ds using them.

Spikeyball · 06/02/2022 09:00

"I have to say I find these replies interesting, with the vast majority saying it’s fine to go in the ladies. Yet when someone posts about their 8 year old going swimming they’re told he must be in the men’s by himself"

Changing rooms are different. I don't know anyone with a severely disabled older male child who would think it is reasonable to take them into a female changing area.

GregoryFluff · 06/02/2022 08:57

@GreenWhiteViolet

I wouldn't have a problem with this if you went in first and let any women already in there know that you were bringing in your disabled son.

I was once in the female changing room at the gym when a woman and two teenage boys walked in there. It's possible that she was their mum and they had disabilities. I didn't stay long enough to find out - I had a panic response at the sight of unexpected males in a female space. Luckily I was dressed enough that I could immediately leave. If there was a good reason for them being there, then their mum/carer should have first made sure that the women in the room knew they'd be coming in and had time to cover up if needed. Yes, toilets have cubicles, but there might well be someone dealing with blood or fixing their hijab or something else they wouldn't want anyone male present for.

Agree with this