Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Taking older son into the ladies?

358 replies

Chichimcgee · 05/02/2022 16:14

He’s severely autistic, incontinent, anxious etc hes 12 but looks a lot older

There’s been two occasions where he’s gone into the men’s loos that ended up with me asking a random man to check they were empty and keep guard so I could sort my son out. We have a disability key and use that when we can but sometimes there’s not a disabled toilet.

I know he looks like teenager and it’s not nice for women using the loo and I do try to explain but there’s been a couple of toilet emergencies recently where I’ve been shouted at because he’s in the ladies with me. But I can’t go into the men’s?
WWYD?

OP posts:
trunktoes · 06/02/2022 11:30

@Sirzy maybe his dad could take him if the toilets are an issue or maybe you can go somewhere else. If only 10 percent of places had disabled toilets I would get your point but it's more like 90 percent so there are plenty of other options

mugoftea456 · 06/02/2022 11:29

As a woman and a mother I wouldn't even take any notice of you taking your son in the women's.

If anyone did raise it with you, I would imagine most decent humans would be understanding of the situation.

I think it's far worse asking a random male to keep an eye on him in the men's.

harbourlane · 06/02/2022 11:28

I don't think anybody on the thread has talked about which facilities the boy himself might feel more comfortable using, especially as he gets older and further into his teenage years. Will he want to continue to be taken into the womens toilet with his mum like a child?

If the consensus is that the mum should warn people before she goes into the womens, then why couldn't she do the same going into the mens? There might be men at the urinals but she wouldn't be looking at them, she'd be leading him to a cubicle and loudly announcing sorry, I need to help my disabled son.

MaggieFS · 06/02/2022 11:28

A teenage looking boy obviously being assisted by his mum clearly has some kind of need. It's completely different from an unaccompanied teenage boy sauntering in. I might wonder why you hadn't used the disabled loo, but it really wouldn't bother me.

Please ignore those who shout at you.

Sirzy · 06/02/2022 11:28

Ds rarely wants to go out. On top of all his issues he has crippling anxiety.

According to some on here if he asks to go somewhere which has poor disabled facilities I should say no rather than make the best of it?

trunktoes · 06/02/2022 11:27

@Spikeyball we all have to make decisions based on our circumstances. There are places you can't bring kids so if you want to go out with kids you go somewhere else. There are places that won't allow dogs, places where you need to wear a mask etc etc. if there are no other options then fair enough but there are plenty of places that will accomodate. Some places only have unisex toilets if you don't like it you can go somewhere else. I hardly think that compares to removing ladies toilets that are there for a safeguarding issue

Crayfishforyou · 06/02/2022 11:26

If I saw an older boy in the ladies being assisted I wouldn’t bat an eyelid. Some people have no empathy or understanding whatsoever.

Wheelz46 · 06/02/2022 11:23

@trunktoes depends where you live there doesn't it, what if it's the only museum close by, why should a child be deprived of going somewhere because the venue haven't provided the correct facilities.

Yes he will get older but at present he is 12 and she is asking about the now, and posters are telling her she should go into the men's toilets with her 12 year old, that's not safe for the poster.

Spikeyball · 06/02/2022 11:22

How about if there aren't enough facilities we get rid of the female toilet and if females don't like it there are other places they can go.

Spikeyball · 06/02/2022 11:19

"What I would do in this situation is not go to places that don't have disabled facilities. The vast vast majority do."

I love the caring about equality in that statement.

trunktoes · 06/02/2022 11:15

What I would do in this situation is not go to places that don't have disabled facilities. The vast vast majority do. So if you can't visit the tiny museum visit another - it's not like there are not options. Most places have disabled toilets including pubs and restaurants. There are plenty to choose from. He is 12 at the moment but as others have said he will get older and a 20 year old man in female toilets is not OK

Wheelz46 · 06/02/2022 11:11

@KitBumbleB as many posters have mentioned it is much safer for a lone woman with her son to enter the women's toilets and not the men's.

KitBumbleB · 06/02/2022 11:05

Out of curiosity, if you did ask if anyone minds and someone said yes, they do mind, or wait until I am out of the toilet, what would you do?

And yes women should be able to expect females only in the female toilets. Many of my female relatives wear hijab, they should be able to adjust it at the mirrors without the worry that a man will come in.

Maybe if more female carers took their sons into the mens it might actually make the men and companies sit up and listen, because lets be honest, they dont listen to women who say they are uncomfortable

Wheelz46 · 06/02/2022 10:59

@Ozanj what would you expect OP to do in this situation? Not use the only toilet available?

She hasn't decided her son takes precedence, she has used the only option available to her at the time.

x2boys · 06/02/2022 10:57

We are not talking about a vulnerable man this is a disabled child .

Spikeyball · 06/02/2022 10:56

"Anyone shouting at you (wtf) is the unreasonable one here."

Someone shouting probably doesn't like anyone with a learning disability near them. It's an excuse to have a go. Someone saying he shouldn't be in here is an opinion they are entitled to have but the shouting comes from something else.

GreenWhiteViolet · 06/02/2022 10:54

@rookiemere A teenage girl shouldn't come into contact with a disabled man in a female-only space.

In an ideal world, there would always be a single accessible toilet available for people with disabilities who need it, and their carers. I'm aware that we don't live in that world. Therefore, as has been said previously, the best thing is for the female carer to warn other occupants of the female facility that a male will be with her. That respects the need of the disabled man to use the toilet, and the need of vulnerable women not to be shocked by the presence of an unexpected male. Some disabilities are immediately visible, but not all are.

Female facilities aren't there as a shelter for vulnerable men or men who need compassion. They're for women. I can't imagine that women would object to a disabled man being present in the circumstances I outlined above, but just going in with no warning and then getting annoyed if a woman says something is very different.

Ozanj · 06/02/2022 10:47

@rookiemere

On balance if the choice is a teenage girl potentially feeling discombobulated or a disabled person shitting themselves, I'd generally go for the former.

I'm an absolute advocate for women's spaces,but in the scenario OP describes I believe she should be able to use whatever option is available to her to stop her DS soiling himself.

Could be a teenaged girl / woman with a disability who then has a meltdown because another mum has decided her adult son (Op’s situation could continue way past childhood in the absence of disabled loos) takes precedence in a woman’s space.
Spikeyball · 06/02/2022 10:43

"When a grown man neads to use a toilet and bring in his help, he does it. Doesn't go into ladies because of that."

Professional carers should have training in how to deal with this including safety training in situations that put themselves at risk. Parent carers do not have this ( and are not usually allowed to have it).

mirabellemadrigal · 06/02/2022 10:19

I dont see the harm in a 12 yo using ladies with his mother present. Who on Earth would?

rookiemere · 06/02/2022 10:15

Something disturbs me about this thread.

It's hard to put my finger on it, but it's almost as if the disabled shouldn't exist and heaven forfend a teenage girl may have to come into contact with a disabled man.

OP doesn't want to use the ladies or mens. She has said she will always in preference use a disabled toilet if it exists . I understand that a very small minority of women are triggered by seeing men in women's spaces, but here I would have said that the disability transcends the gender and teaching everyone to have a bit of compassion for someone in a difficult situation is not a bad thing surely?

If the very worst thing that happens to a female is an obviously disabled male coming into the female toilets with a female chaperone, then that doesn't sound too dreadful. It's not Eddie Izzard arguing with teenagers about his divine right to use whatever toilets they want because they wear high heels.

nolongersurprised · 06/02/2022 10:03

They don't care about women in the OP's situation

It could also be claimed that the OP doesn’t care about the women and girls who desire a same sex toilet.

That isn’t true either.

I just don’t think all of the hand wavey, “It’s fine” responses are considering the minority of girls and women who whom it wouldn’t be fine, either for religious reasons, or trauma, or extreme shyness over bodily functions.

Most people don’t care about boys (and men, from the sound of things) with female carers in female toilets and some do but can appreciate that the OP is in a very difficult situation. However some will care a lot, and scolding them and referring to their objections as “moaning” isn’t fair either.

StickerPlace · 06/02/2022 10:00

Honestly I'd not be bothered at all assuming we're talking UK public toilets. (In the US where there's a 1" either side of the doors I'm a bit more precious Wink)

I'd maybe be taken aback at first seeing an older teen male in there. But as soon as it was apparent he was with you then I'd have no issue once I'd realised.

Anyone shouting at you (wtf) is the unreasonable one here.

rookiemere · 06/02/2022 09:59

On balance if the choice is a teenage girl potentially feeling discombobulated or a disabled person shitting themselves, I'd generally go for the former.

I'm an absolute advocate for women's spaces,but in the scenario OP describes I believe she should be able to use whatever option is available to her to stop her DS soiling himself.

gettingolderandgrumpy · 06/02/2022 09:57

@nolongersurprised

They don't care about women in the OP's situation

Of course that’s not true. But there are competing needs. There’s no easy solution that meets everyone’s needs. Most people agree (including me, actually) that the OP should take her child to the female toilets. However, just because MN posters are comfortable with it, it doesn’t mean that girls the age as the OP’s son will be. Even if they don’t need privacy at the basins at that time, or are in full cubicles that are completely private some will be discombobulated by seeing a pubertal male child their own age in a space they assumed was single sex.

Yes why is it a issue , your in a cubicle they are chaperone with a female so nothing to worry about

WhT do you mean by, “They are chaperone with a female?”

What do I mean a disabled male will only go to the ladies with a female carer / chaperone.