Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Taking older son into the ladies?

358 replies

Chichimcgee · 05/02/2022 16:14

He’s severely autistic, incontinent, anxious etc hes 12 but looks a lot older

There’s been two occasions where he’s gone into the men’s loos that ended up with me asking a random man to check they were empty and keep guard so I could sort my son out. We have a disability key and use that when we can but sometimes there’s not a disabled toilet.

I know he looks like teenager and it’s not nice for women using the loo and I do try to explain but there’s been a couple of toilet emergencies recently where I’ve been shouted at because he’s in the ladies with me. But I can’t go into the men’s?
WWYD?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
oceanblueship · 07/02/2022 21:49

@iumerp

I've name changed to post this. I'm diagnosed autistic with severe anxiety and ocd.

I was sexually assaulted in a toilet when I was about eleven (by a man I knew from church, not a random stranger, but still).

Is it still just "ableist" and "unempathetic" of me to be terrified, rooted to the floor in terror by by men (and their deep voices) in toilets, no matter who they are or who they are with?

Is it really just my unbelievable privilege talking that if possible, I'd prefer mums to take their sons to piss somewhere else if they could as they get older and older? Really?

Of course, if it helps you feel better, there are loads of places I wouldn't dare go because of the fear I live with anyway. Years of therapy haven't helped.

I am really sorry to hear about your experiences, but I live in fear that my son will be attacked as you were if he goes into a male toilet on his own, unfortunately a real and realistic fear. Men assault and rape boys as well as girls.

Boys who go into women's toilets with their mothers, are with their mothers all the time. They are also still children.

I am very sorry about your experiences Flowers

BABAHOTEL · 06/02/2022 15:53

@Chichimcgee

It just feels like, once again, same sex spaces are being opened up to accommodate males

I think that’s really unfair, it’s not like he asked to be a disabled male with a single mum or loves going to the ladies loos. It’s a rare occurrence and I want to make sure if/when it happens again I do what I can to make sure it’s not traumatic for anyone.

Those saying go to the male loos. Would you be ok with a dad taking his 20 year old disabled daughter into the ladies?

@trunktoes I’m happy for him to wear a lanyard, happy to call out and let people know we are there, we have hand sanitizer so we’re not in there longer than necessary. I take every action to make sure he won’t need the toilet.
However I will NOT limit his life by saying we can’t go somewhere when he already misses out on so much.

Well said Thanks
Chichimcgee · 06/02/2022 15:29

It just feels like, once again, same sex spaces are being opened up to accommodate males

I think that’s really unfair, it’s not like he asked to be a disabled male with a single mum or loves going to the ladies loos. It’s a rare occurrence and I want to make sure if/when it happens again I do what I can to make sure it’s not traumatic for anyone.

Those saying go to the male loos. Would you be ok with a dad taking his 20 year old disabled daughter into the ladies?

@trunktoes I’m happy for him to wear a lanyard, happy to call out and let people know we are there, we have hand sanitizer so we’re not in there longer than necessary. I take every action to make sure he won’t need the toilet.
However I will NOT limit his life by saying we can’t go somewhere when he already misses out on so much.

OP posts:
Honeysuckle45 · 06/02/2022 14:56

@iumerp I'm sorry that happened to you, it's horrific. Nobody would deny that. But surely you can still understand the need for a disabled child to be supervised and assisted by his mother in this scenario?

The fault lies with establishments that haven't provided disabled facilities for whatever reason.

Your trauma is valid, of course it is. But a woman going into the mens is at risk of the same sort of attack. So is a vulnerable boy going in alone.

It's a shit situation but it's so unfair to make the op feel like she's doing something wrong here.

x2boys · 06/02/2022 14:55

@iumerp

I've name changed to post this. I'm diagnosed autistic with severe anxiety and ocd.

I was sexually assaulted in a toilet when I was about eleven (by a man I knew from church, not a random stranger, but still).

Is it still just "ableist" and "unempathetic" of me to be terrified, rooted to the floor in terror by by men (and their deep voices) in toilets, no matter who they are or who they are with?

Is it really just my unbelievable privilege talking that if possible, I'd prefer mums to take their sons to piss somewhere else if they could as they get older and older? Really?

Of course, if it helps you feel better, there are loads of places I wouldn't dare go because of the fear I live with anyway. Years of therapy haven't helped.

We are not talking about a man though this is a severely disabled child ,if I was in the ops position I would do the same what's the alternative,my son can't be left alone ,In an ideal world we would have " changing places " available everywhere,I doubt the Op wants to take her son into the female toilets I know I wouldn't ,but my priority would be my son's safety.
iumerp · 06/02/2022 14:44

I've name changed to post this. I'm diagnosed autistic with severe anxiety and ocd.

I was sexually assaulted in a toilet when I was about eleven (by a man I knew from church, not a random stranger, but still).

Is it still just "ableist" and "unempathetic" of me to be terrified, rooted to the floor in terror by by men (and their deep voices) in toilets, no matter who they are or who they are with?

Is it really just my unbelievable privilege talking that if possible, I'd prefer mums to take their sons to piss somewhere else if they could as they get older and older? Really?

Of course, if it helps you feel better, there are loads of places I wouldn't dare go because of the fear I live with anyway. Years of therapy haven't helped.

Honeysuckle45 · 06/02/2022 14:26

There are some really awful people on this post. What possible threat do you think a disabled 12 year old being supervised by his mother is to you?

Where is your empathy? You are crying about it being unacceptable like some predatory male is invading your safe space but where is your concern for the well-being and safety of a disabled child? Ableism at its finest.

TheOnlyMrsMac · 06/02/2022 13:48

@SartresSoul

There should always be a disabled toilet available and I’ve never been anywhere where this isn’t the case.
Lucky you.
bedheadedzombie · 06/02/2022 13:10

[quote HappyDays40]@bedheadedzombie OP has said that this is when continence pads leak so......
He is not likely to suddenly become continent when older.[/quote]
No she didn't. She said he leaks. That means urine. She in fact even stated that they don't use nappies now. This is her quote:

He’s been out of nappies since 10 on the advice of his doctor, I think as they hope he will gradually gain control and nappies would hinder that? Like potty training I suppose. we have good days and bad days depending on how his meds, diet and anxiety effect him.

SartresSoul · 06/02/2022 13:01

There should always be a disabled toilet available and I’ve never been anywhere where this isn’t the case.

Spikeyball · 06/02/2022 12:37

The neighbouring council to mine has most of their public disabled toilet facilities in single sex toilets - no separate unisex facility. So someone who didn't require a unisex facility may not even notice the problem there.

Franklydear · 06/02/2022 12:35

@harbourlane my boy is in such situation, he does not want to go into the ladies, we would take any other safe option, last time a lady tilted her head and tutted, he actually asked her if she thought he wanted to be there?, that definitely shut her up, saying that the last time we were forced to use the ladies was a couple of years ago, we do the best we can, but sometimes is unavoidable, we'll take disabled toilets, accessible toilets, family rooms, unisex toilets, staff toilets but I will not go into the men’s.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 06/02/2022 12:35

"For those on here suggesting you go into the mens, would you suggest a Dad take their daughter into the ladies if roles were reversed?"

Now that's an interesting point. I didn't suggest that the OP should use the men's loos, because I think she should use the ladies if the disabled loo is absent/busy - but I also think that, above a certain age, if a man has a disabled daughter then he should take her into the ladies loos, but announce that he's bringing her in. I wouldn't want to take her into the men's loo once she's around the age of puberty.

trunktoes · 06/02/2022 12:24

Well incidentally @strawberrrycheeesecake I use the disabled toilets because of a severe medical issue and I have a key - they are not unicorn poo. I can't remember the last time I went somewhere that didn't have them. That's the point - there are plenty of places that have them if one doesn't I go to the other 99 that do. If there were not I would think differently

strawberrrycheeesecake · 06/02/2022 12:16

@trunktoes

What I would do in this situation is not go to places that don't have disabled facilities. The vast vast majority do. So if you can't visit the tiny museum visit another - it's not like there are not options. Most places have disabled toilets including pubs and restaurants. There are plenty to choose from. He is 12 at the moment but as others have said he will get older and a 20 year old man in female toilets is not OK
Wow.

All about equality aren't you.

Spikeyball · 06/02/2022 12:15

As I said before you don't understand disability discrimination.

trunktoes · 06/02/2022 11:59

@Spikeyball no I did not. There are toilets available to him - the ones that match his sex. It's not an issue now but in a couple of years it will be. If OP doesn't want to use the toilets available to him she has choices to go to other places that do. Most places do.

Spikeyball · 06/02/2022 11:50

That was to trunktoes.

Spikeyball · 06/02/2022 11:50

Having kids or a dog or not liking unisex facilities aren't which is what you likened disability to. I know you have form for not understanding discrimination so I will leave it there.

KitBumbleB · 06/02/2022 11:49

Sex is a protected characteristic, as is race (which includes culture) and religion.

It must be an absolute nightmare for the OP and any other parent of a disabled child, as I said, a young male with his mum coming into the ladies wouldn't bother me at all, I would assume there was a good reason for it, but not every woman would agree, and I have no right to tell any other woman how to feel about a sensitive topic.
The real villain here is the lack of accessible toilets

LittleBearPad · 06/02/2022 11:46

@trunktoes

I don't think it's an issue now because he is still young, but once he gets to 15/16 it will be. Do those in support advocate him changing in the ladies when swimming? There are plenty of pools with disabled and unisex facilities so you just don't go to the ones that are single sex with a boy that can't undress himself
Which isn’t equivalent to the situation the OP finds herself in.

There are a lot of straw men on this thread - pretty much all of which are based in unkindness and lack of empathy.

trunktoes · 06/02/2022 11:38

@Spikeyball being female is a protected characteristic

Spikeyball · 06/02/2022 11:38

trunktoes disability is a protected characteristic. The other things you mention are not. If people want to say that using the female toilet in the OP's situation is not reasonable that is an opinion they are entitled to have. Saying that he shouldn't go to wherever it is, is the solution is discriminatory.

x2boys · 06/02/2022 11:37

@harbourlane

I don't think anybody on the thread has talked about which facilities the boy himself might feel more comfortable using, especially as he gets older and further into his teenage years. Will he want to continue to be taken into the womens toilet with his mum like a child?

If the consensus is that the mum should warn people before she goes into the womens, then why couldn't she do the same going into the mens? There might be men at the urinals but she wouldn't be looking at them, she'd be leading him to a cubicle and loudly announcing sorry, I need to help my disabled son.

If the Op,s son is anything like my son ,he won't care which toilets he goes in my son has no concept of male and female toilets ,he will always need assistance.
trunktoes · 06/02/2022 11:32

I don't think it's an issue now because he is still young, but once he gets to 15/16 it will be. Do those in support advocate him changing in the ladies when swimming? There are plenty of pools with disabled and unisex facilities so you just don't go to the ones that are single sex with a boy that can't undress himself