Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that JK Rowling is being vilified for standing for women and children?

285 replies

ExtraPlinky · 05/02/2022 12:41

Getting sick of seeing her being torn down constantly on social media.
Her essays are thoughtful and careful and she's primarily concerned with safeguarding.

AIBU to say it's a witch hunt?

OP posts:
Abhannmor · 05/02/2022 15:33

She is a true hero. I read the first 4 books to my children. This gave them a love of reading. They agree with JK on women's and children's rights.

SamphiretheStickerist · 05/02/2022 15:09

[quote PinkyU]@gardenhelpneeded but surely that’s true for all humans? The majority of people charged with infanticide are women, given we don’t know which ones are dangerous perhaps we should stop all women from having babies?

In London in 2020 the majority of perpetrators of knife crime were young black men, given we don’t know which are the dangerous ones perhaps we should just view all of them as dangerous. Yes, let’s view an entire group of individuals as dangerous:

Mothers
Men
Young black men
Trans women

Let’s view them all as potential killers and rapists because a minority of their group commit these crimes.[/quote]
Ah. But that is precisely what safeguarding does.

And in some instances it is possible to legislate, discriminate against a specific cohort in specific circumstances. In others it is not.

So, ban mothers and the human race dies out.

Ban men from female spaces... and VAWG is reduced.

That sort of logic. We rely on it, logic that is, for many things in law across the whole of society.

So it makes no sense, is not kind of Gotcha! to suggest banning mothers and it does make sense to treat transwomen like any other male.

browneyes77 · 05/02/2022 14:58

It’s batshit how people are treating her.

And the irony is most of them haven’t properly read or understood anything she’s said. She has done nothing but advocate for women’s rights and safeguarding. And I completely agree with her and I’m glad she hasn’t let the shouty crowd silence her.

But people have to find things to be outraged about now, so they can jump on the next bandwagon.

FOJN · 05/02/2022 14:55

As to equating trans people with sex offenders, well some of them are. At least with the same regularity as the rest of the male population.

Evidence gathered by Fair Play For Women show almost half of the trans prison population has at least one conviction for sexual offences. The rate in the general male prison population is 20%. This is not conflating transwomen with sex offenders but we have to accept either transwomen are more likely to be sex offenders OR that sexual predators can and do exploit prison self ID policies. We already know sexual predators will go to extraordinary lengths to gain access to victims, a statuary declaration of gender (as proposed in GRA reforms) is hardly a safeguard.

fairplayforwomen.com/campaigns/prisons/

ElephantOfRisk · 05/02/2022 14:54

@theemperorhasnoclothes

Agree with WorriedMums the decent men, the honest men, know why there are safeguards in place in regard to the male sex. And they support them because they want their daughters, wives, mothers and sisters and indeed all female children and adults to have safety, privacy and dignity.

Why would anyone be against safeguarding? The answer to that question is never satisfactory.

My DH cannot for the life of him understand why any woman or decent man would be voting for parties in thrall to this (SNP/Scottish greens in particular). We have sons not daughters but I honestly don't my sons to think that this is the way that women should be treated either. It is dangerous for all our children but catastrophic for girls and women. I cannot believe the dignity that JKR possesses to deal with the shit that is thrown at her.
theemperorhasnoclothes · 05/02/2022 14:45

Agree with WorriedMums the decent men, the honest men, know why there are safeguards in place in regard to the male sex. And they support them because they want their daughters, wives, mothers and sisters and indeed all female children and adults to have safety, privacy and dignity.

Why would anyone be against safeguarding? The answer to that question is never satisfactory.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 05/02/2022 14:40

As PP have said the mob mentality is so damaging. I find it worrying how so many people including those who claimed to read and enjoy the HP books thoughtlessly parrot a slur without bothering to find out the truth.

I worry about the mental capacity and / or moral compass of those who say that the HP books are 'ruined' for them because JKR wrote a calm thoughtful essay about biological sex being real and important. They can't have read the books very thoroughly because they're behaving exactly like Dolores Umbridge and her enforcers - a nasty mob wanting to pull down one person for speaking the truth.. Harry Potter in the books (for saying Voldemort was real and had come back) and JKR in real life for saying biological sex is real (which it is obviously - do people these days really not know how human reproduction works? Of course they do, no-one is lining up for surrogate transwomen) .

Misogyny these days seems worse than ever - just look at the Met. JKR is one of the very few people in public life who give me hope for our daughters. She is a true hero.

anon12345678901 · 05/02/2022 14:38

@CorrBlimeyGG it's taking you a long time to present these transphobic comments. Are you struggling to find some?

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 05/02/2022 14:37

She's an amazing woman with the exceptionally rare quality of standing by her beliefs.
The belief that women should have their own spaces, prizes and sports, including places to recover from attacks by men.

As to equating trans people with sex offenders, well some of them are. At least with the same regularity as the rest of the male population. Women committing those types of offenses are vanishingly rare.

Trans people should be subject to as much safeguarding as other males. Regardless of skin colour or gender identity or orientation. There is no data that shows having one of these characteristics makes them any more 'safe' than the rest of the male population. Most of whom,.I might add are our lovely father's, brothers and husbands, who despite being lovely understand the reasons for women only spaces.

anon12345678901 · 05/02/2022 14:37

@VelvetChairGirl

anon12345678901 its an utterly meaningless word, reminds me of Kevin the teenager shouting I hate you all the time, it really says more about the person who uses it then anyone else, I just roll my eyes at them.

and TERF just means Tired of Explaining Reality to Fuckwits to me.

we should start accusing everyone of Gynephobia and running off, they seem to think accusing people of having phobias is like daggers somehow.

So true. And I'm 100% remembering that when someone calls me a TERF. I roll my eyes usually, I really just don't care about their opinions on me.
Avocadoandlemons · 05/02/2022 14:32

@Fluffymule

She's also the 27th highest tax payer in the UK (according to the list in the Sunday Times last week) - £36m this tax year.

No tax havens or offshoring her wealth like many others.

Her contribution to this country both culturally and financially is immense. The sustained efforts to libel her, to discredit her and to threaten her are an absolute disgrace.

This.

I love JK .

I am so pleased there are people like her in the world.

bishophaha · 05/02/2022 14:29

CorrBlimey has said some horrendous discriminatory things on other threads, so their idea of what's an acceptable thing to say perhaps isn't one I'd agree with anyway.

Back to JKR, have you noticed how other people who might otherwise have been quite vocal on the subject have gone quiet since the amount of abuse/death threads etc against JKR made so much noise?

That's the intent.
I notice the same people aren't also vilifying ableist, homophobic and sexist men.

ElephantOfRisk · 05/02/2022 14:27

But all the actual examples appear to be of young women.

Are they women though?

To be fair, loads of young women do get involved in this stuff because they are trying to be kind and inclusive etc. nothing wrong with that, but they aren't looking at the bigger picture. They are thinking about friends who have "transitioned" who are lovely people, as are the majority of people who have been sold short when not treated for their mental illness and instead been fed the untruth that you can change sex and you will feel better.

They weren't alive when women fought for rights and equalities that they can (and should be able to) take for granted.

Jaxhog · 05/02/2022 14:25

@CorrBlimeyGG

She is transphobic, she conflates trans women with sex abusers. She does not speak for all women, thankfully.
Utter rubbish. She's simply concerned that some men PRETEND to be trans in order to abuse women. As am I.
RandomLondoner · 05/02/2022 14:20

People keep saying it's men who have a problem with her. But all the actual examples appear to be of young women.

Wonnle · 05/02/2022 14:17

I wonder where people vented this rage before anti social media ? That Cocksuckerberg has a lot to answer for

GiveMyHeadPeaceffs · 05/02/2022 14:14

I may be in the minority here...I love JKR but I'm not arsed about Harry Potter Grin

SlapBet · 05/02/2022 14:10

Men hate it when women won’t play along and do what they want. Most of the people threatening her haven’t even read the thing they’re complaining about.

Iwonderifiwonderwhy · 05/02/2022 14:09

Joanne Rowling speaks for me, and I am in awe of her bravery and persistence in doing so. It would have been so easy just to allow herself to be bullied into chanting slogans, like all of the HP movie stars did. But she’d already been a victim of male bullying, first in her violent marriage, and also in not being allowed to put her unacceptably-female first name on her books, because male readers would disapprove.

She is the most talented writer in the world and I love her books.

She is the most generous philanthropist I am aware of. The amounts she has given to children’s charities is incredible. As is her refusal to avoid tax.

There is no point trying to convince people of these things, they know this already. They don’t hate her despite her bravery, intellect, talent, generosity, and integrity, they hate her because of these things.

History will judge us all and I think Joanne Rowling’s descendants will be very proud of her.

ElephantOfRisk · 05/02/2022 14:06

"friend" saying "F£&k that TERF JK Rowling for ruining the Harry Potter books for me."

Your "friend" isn't the sharpest tool in the box is she? One would almost think that it wasn't JKR that wrote the books....

I agree it's utterly disgusting the way she is being treated by radical trans groups that don't have 2 brain cells to rub together and the folk that then jump on the bandwagon are even worse imo.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 05/02/2022 14:06

@CorrBlimeyGG

She is transphobic, she conflates trans women with sex abusers. She does not speak for all women, thankfully.
What has she said thats transphobic?
Arabellla · 05/02/2022 14:00

@CorrBlimeyGG

(And yes, I've read her 'essay'.)
She speaks for me, and I’m glad.
bigdecisionstomake · 05/02/2022 13:55

[quote PinkyU]@gardenhelpneeded but surely that’s true for all humans? The majority of people charged with infanticide are women, given we don’t know which ones are dangerous perhaps we should stop all women from having babies?

In London in 2020 the majority of perpetrators of knife crime were young black men, given we don’t know which are the dangerous ones perhaps we should just view all of them as dangerous. Yes, let’s view an entire group of individuals as dangerous:

Mothers
Men
Young black men
Trans women

Let’s view them all as potential killers and rapists because a minority of their group commit these crimes.[/quote]
We DBS check all teachers and school support staff to ensure we don't put our children in a dangerous situation. This isn't because society views everyone that works in a school as dangerous but instead that that is the best way to screen out the unsafe ones.

The best way to keep women and children safe is to have spaces that are only available to people of one sex. That doesn't mean to say that e.g all Transwomen are dangerous, merely that in the absence of any way for women to know which may be, the safest way is screen out anyone not of that sex.

We really need to stop viewing this as women hating transpeople but instead of women trying to keep themselves safe.

FOJN · 05/02/2022 13:54

Over the last few months I have seen supposedly normal friends saying they would like to burn her books.

You should ask them to do a bit of reading about the history of book burning and ask them to report back with their findings.

Spoiler alert: it never ends well.

She is transphobic, she conflates trans women with sex abusers. She does not speak for all women, thankfully.

"So I want trans women to be safe. At the same time, I do not want to make natal girls and women less safe. When you throw open the doors of bathrooms and changing rooms to any man who believes or feels he’s a woman – and, as I’ve said, gender confirmation certificates may now be granted without any need for surgery or hormones – then you open the door to any and all men who wish to come inside. That is the simple truth."
JK Rowling June 2020

Why would you advertise your poor reading comprehension on the internet?

Sn0tnose · 05/02/2022 13:52

@CorrBlimeyGG

She is transphobic, she conflates trans women with sex abusers. She does not speak for all women, thankfully.
She really doesn’t.

If you disagree with what she actually said, then fair enough. It’s your opinion. But don’t make stuff up.