Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that JK Rowling is being vilified for standing for women and children?

285 replies

ExtraPlinky · 05/02/2022 12:41

Getting sick of seeing her being torn down constantly on social media.
Her essays are thoughtful and careful and she's primarily concerned with safeguarding.

AIBU to say it's a witch hunt?

OP posts:
longwayoff · 07/02/2022 11:45

YANBU OP. Her treatment is shameful and wilfully ignorant, just more misogyny.

DdraigGoch · 07/02/2022 11:44

@Gizacluethen

Threatening to rape and murder anyone is obviously vile.

I personally think she latches onto whatever "struggle" is going off into the world to stay relevant. But I wouldn't spit vitriol about it, alot of people are doing the same.

How on earth do you work that out? If your hypothesis was correct she'd just fall onto the TWAW side to earn woke cookies.

She has no need to 'remain relevant'. She's almost a billionaire (only reason she isn't one is that she's such a generous philanthropist) and still has new films coming out.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 11:42

What I'm talking about is someone posting any single one of those comments on a thread online (NOT about her women's rights stance) and almost immediately getting a ton of messages from JKR supporters

And what I'm saying is that if you see a thread about the revolting, violent minded, misogynistic abuse she gets daily, and you think what it needs is your contribution on why you don't like her personally - which, according to your list, will be a subjective, non-moral issue that you can't explain at best - it's quite likely that you do have some sort of prejudice you're not exploring or admitting, because your priorities within the discussion are a bit whacked.

And you do find, as we've shown you, that these people do tend to have... corresponding issues elsewhere.

Nobody minds if you don't fancy having a drink with JKR personally, but it's not exactly relevant, so why try to insert it? What's the purpose?

SamphiretheStickerist · 07/02/2022 11:41

On Mumsnet, perhaps Well, you are currently on Mumsnet.

Do you tell people on Twitter to mind their manners because Mumsnet says something different? Or is it just here that you feel free to tell women to mind their manners?

SamphiretheStickerist · 07/02/2022 11:40

What I'm talking about is someone posting any single one of those comments on a thread online (NOT about her women's rights stance) and almost immediately getting a ton of messages from JKR supporters calling this poster anti-feminist and how dare they say those things, they must not be very smart, have you READ her essay for goodness sake etc. The same wouldn't be done for almost anyone else.

Maybe that's because those of us who HAVE bothered to read the actual words she used, what she really did say, are waiting for any single one of thoie people who have not to admit they have not and maybe even to go and read her words as she wrote them!

It's a very long running theme across most SM sites. If you are unaware, go read her essay and se why "She's so transphobic" etc is really irritating. It is just as irritating as the "Well, what has she actually done for women?" crap!

Here, horses mouth:

www.jkrowling.com/opinions/j-k-rowling-writes-about-her-reasons-for-speaking-out-on-sex-and-gender-issues/

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 11:38

[quote SamphiretheStickerist]@CosmosLily we get that. But just as Tom Cruise is hounded for his religious beliefs JKR is hounded for her beliefs that women are women and men are men. Comments about their personal lives, business acumen etc are coloured by the posters perception of those beliefs.

They don't happen in a vacuum.[/quote]
On Mumsnet, perhaps, certainly if you know a certain posters history etc on women's rights. But on twitter, reddit and the likes when Susan from Southshields says she doesn't like JKR (and she has no suspicious posting activity and it's not in the context of women's rights) she's often met with the same nasty comments, questioning her sanity and morals. When Jane from Brighton says she doesn't like Tom Cruise or Holly Willoughby, everyone just skirts on by thinking "fair enough, can't like everyone".

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 11:35

@DrSbaitso

Don't like her writing.

Fair enough, but no reason to dislike her personally.

Didn't like Harry Potter books and think that she's overly praised for them.

See above. And direct the criticism to the people doing the actual thing you dislike, ie overpraising her. That's not her doing.

Seems patronising when she speaks.

Ok. Entirely subjective. No need to watch. Not a moral issue.

Seems like she thinks she's better than everyone.

Unless one says why, this is pretty meaningless.

Just bugs me.

Again, subjective and not a moral issue. And again, if you can't explain why, it's possible the fault isn't with her.

She just seems odd and I can't put my finger on why I dislike her

As before. I wouldn't expect someone who could conceive of plots and worlds as wildly imaginative, detailed and well laid as Harry Potter to come across as completely on an ordinary wavelength. Her brain is exceptional.

Don't get what all the fuss is about, there are so many much much better authors who don't get anywhere near as much praise, from equally as working-class backgrounds

See first and second points. Not her doing.

Of the few points here that are based in stuff she's done, and not things other people have done (eg overpraising), they're all subjective and mostly based in things people can't define or explain. That doesn't mean they haven't got a right to feel that way, but in my experience, a strong dislike that you can't actually explain when asked usually points elsewhere. I'm sure we would all agree that even if she does come across as odd or patronising, that's no reason for threats of pipebombs and rape by cactus. So if there is a thread about that problem, and someone finds it more important to pipe up that they wouldn't choose to have a beer with her, it's possibly a sign of priorities gone a bit awry.

Those are all of your own reasons for disagreeing with those comments, which is fair enough and your prerogative to feel. What I'm talking about is someone posting any single one of those comments on a thread online (NOT about her women's rights stance) and almost immediately getting a ton of messages from JKR supporters calling this poster anti-feminist and how dare they say those things, they must not be very smart, have you READ her essay for goodness sake etc. The same wouldn't be done for almost anyone else. I see "I don't like Tom Cruise" (or whichever other celeb/person of high profile) constantly and no one gets that "abuse" (for lack of a better word). But as soon as it's JKR, a general dislike of her (not her women's rights stance) is turned into "if you hate her you must hate all women and women's rights and think this and that". Their comment is analysed, their reasons are analysed and turned into something much bigger than a simple "don't like her personally".
DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 11:26

Don't like her writing.

Fair enough, but no reason to dislike her personally.

Didn't like Harry Potter books and think that she's overly praised for them.

See above. And direct the criticism to the people doing the actual thing you dislike, ie overpraising her. That's not her doing.

Seems patronising when she speaks.

Ok. Entirely subjective. No need to watch. Not a moral issue.

Seems like she thinks she's better than everyone.

Unless one says why, this is pretty meaningless.

Just bugs me.

Again, subjective and not a moral issue. And again, if you can't explain why, it's possible the fault isn't with her.

She just seems odd and I can't put my finger on why I dislike her

As before. I wouldn't expect someone who could conceive of plots and worlds as wildly imaginative, detailed and well laid as Harry Potter to come across as completely on an ordinary wavelength. Her brain is exceptional.

Don't get what all the fuss is about, there are so many much much better authors who don't get anywhere near as much praise, from equally as working-class backgrounds

See first and second points. Not her doing.

Of the few points here that are based in stuff she's done, and not things other people have done (eg overpraising), they're all subjective and mostly based in things people can't define or explain. That doesn't mean they haven't got a right to feel that way, but in my experience, a strong dislike that you can't actually explain when asked usually points elsewhere. I'm sure we would all agree that even if she does come across as odd or patronising, that's no reason for threats of pipebombs and rape by cactus. So if there is a thread about that problem, and someone finds it more important to pipe up that they wouldn't choose to have a beer with her, it's possibly a sign of priorities gone a bit awry.

SamphiretheStickerist · 07/02/2022 11:25

@CosmosLily we get that. But just as Tom Cruise is hounded for his religious beliefs JKR is hounded for her beliefs that women are women and men are men. Comments about their personal lives, business acumen etc are coloured by the posters perception of those beliefs.

They don't happen in a vacuum.

SamphiretheStickerist · 07/02/2022 11:22

@Janesmom

I don’t understand which women and children she’s meant to be standing up for. Please stop pretending all women hold these views.

Not in my name.

Well let's see shall we?

Volant Trust - 20 years this has been a grant-making trust, which primarily helps fund charitable organisations and projects based in Scotland working to alleviate social deprivation, particularly concerned with women, children and young people. Grants of up to £45K available across Scotland - £26million grants since 2017

£1million donation to Crisis and Refuge during corona virus lockdowns

I suspect she speaks on a lot of issues that the women in those charities agree with. So that's women and children who are the victims of domestic abuse.

Had you read her essay, her words rather than the bastardised version so popular cross so much of SM, you would know that, as she set it out REALLY plainly!

Why would you not agree with that? Is supporting women who have experienced domestic violence anathem to you? Or have you not enquired too deeply into the truth of what she has actually said?

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 11:15

@DrSbaitso

I've seen it plenty and they're all valid reasonsto the person disliking her, doesn't mean anyone need agree with them, of course, but some do give their own reasons when asked. Again, this is outside of her women's rights stance that I'm talking about.

Ok. I haven't seen them...what are they?

These are some I've seen online from people, off the top of my head (and remember, this is out of the context of her women's rights stance, and not my reasons, just stuff I've seen said online.)
  • Don't like her writing.
  • Didn't like Harry Potter books and think that she's overly praised for them.
  • Seems patronising when she speaks.
  • Seems like she thinks she's better than everyone.
  • Just bugs me.
  • She just seems odd and I can't put my finger on why I dislike her
  • Don't get what all the fuss is about, there are so many much much better authors who don't get anywhere near as much praise, from equally as working-class backgrounds

Now put "Tom Cruise" in front of all of those. "I don't like his movies. I didn't like Mission Impossible, don't get what all the fuss is about. Saw him in an interview and he seems really patronising and like he thinks he's better than everyone else. He just bugs me. Can't put my finger on it but I just don't like the guy. Don't get what all the fuss is about, I can name so many more actors who are far more talented who worked just as hard to get where he is".

None of the comments above about Tom Cruise would warrant being vilified (in general) as it's taken as just an opinion. But when the same is said about JKR, it's turned into something much much bigger, like you're incredibly wrong and awful to dislike such a person and that you should disregard all of those opinions because "Look at all the good she's done!".

It's not a perfect comparison by any means, but JKR is definitely seen as a massive hero, to the point that if you don't like her for whatever reason, you're insane, anti-feminist, what's wrong with you etc when for some, it's the same as disliking Tom Cruise cause he bugs the hell out of you.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 11:11

@Janesmom

I don’t understand which women and children she’s meant to be standing up for. Please stop pretending all women hold these views.

Not in my name.

The ones who don't want a feminine gender identity (ie, a natally male body, even one with no alteration whatsoever) to be considered as exactly the same as a female body when considering issues such as sport, a rape survivor's wish for a female counsellor at a crisis centre and schemes set up to try to level the playing field for girls in, say STEM or aviation.
DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 11:08

@Viviennemary

Exactly. I don't like her. Never have. Long before this Trans issue reared its head.
Yes, but we all know what else you don't like, so this won't surprise anyone.

Anyone else?

Viviennemary · 07/02/2022 11:04

Exactly. I don't like her. Never have. Long before this Trans issue reared its head.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 11:04

very strange person wrapped up in a cult
Valid reason.
More substance than too big for boots.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 11:03

I've seen it plenty and they're all valid reasonsto the person disliking her, doesn't mean anyone need agree with them, of course, but some do give their own reasons when asked. Again, this is outside of her women's rights stance that I'm talking about.

Ok. I haven't seen them...what are they?

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 11:01

DrSbaitso Then I'm sorry you haven't seen people give their explanations as to why they don't like her (outside of her stance on women's rights) as I've seen it plenty and they're all valid reasons to the person disliking her, doesn't mean anyone need agree with them, of course, but some do give their own reasons when asked. Again, this is outside of her women's rights stance that I'm talking about.

I personally dislike Tom Cruise, he annoys me whenever I see him on screen and he seems a very strange person wrapped up in a cult, yet whenever I express that online, I'm never met with angry messages, rather just people either speaking of their own dislike of him, or asking for more info because they're interested. Yet if I was to say I don't like JKR for whatever reason (outside of women's rights stance) then I would be vilified for that and called anti-feminist, I've seen it happen to people.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 11:01

@Janesmom

I don’t understand which women and children she’s meant to be standing up for. Please stop pretending all women hold these views.

Not in my name.

Women is refuges don't want access for males made easier Jane. Having fled her abusive husband and used one, JK would know why they're important.

If you want to 'be kind' crack on. But you don't get to give away women's sports, spaces and rights on behalf of other women either.

Janesmom · 07/02/2022 10:58

I don’t understand which women and children she’s meant to be standing up for. Please stop pretending all women hold these views.

Not in my name.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 10:55

@CosmosLily

DrSbaitso And that's all absolutely fine, but we can't police who people like and who people don't. It really isn't out of the ordinary to dislike someone regardless of their achievements, I can think of many people in the public eye that people dislike despite their work, yet when people share this opinion they don't tend to get vilified for it (the majority of the time, I accept it does happen), but it happens really often with JKR. Just because JKR has done great things, it doesn't mean that no one is allowed to dislike her.

The comments that I've seen (not on this thread) that I'm talking about are all over the internet - people simply say "can't stand the woman" "nah I don't like her at all" etc and are immediately met with angry posters who fully support her, calling them out, calling them anti-feminist and a bunch of other things. That's what I think is a bit silly, because it's everyone prerogative to dislike whoever they dislike and no one is immune to it, just because they've done good things like donate to charity, etc.

Well I take your point on that, and just the other day on another thread I was saying that accusations of jealousy aren't usually helpful.

But the thing is, these people are repeatedly asked precisely WHY they don't like her, and apart from "too big for her boots" or equivalent, we never hear any actual reasoning. Given there's nothing objectionable outside, arguably, her stance on women's rights, it's hard to see what else they could be getting at, especially if they've got form for, say, calling women evil for holding a man responsible to his financial commitments to his children.

Still, I could be convinced otherwise. Come on, all you people who think she's awful and transphobic. What's she done? What's she said? If you're going to make such strong accusations of such terrible things, you should be able to back them up. What, exactly, has she actually done?

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 10:55

And I would expect someone who dislikes a writer due to their writing style to expand on that a bit.

Like when I say I don't like Dickens because of the endless description. I also don't like him because he tried to have his wife commited when he tired of her. Him handwringing about poor, vulnerable rings hollow when you know something about his personal life.

But if I just said he was a hypocritical and overrated writer I would expect some disagreement.

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 10:49

DrSbaitso And that's all absolutely fine, but we can't police who people like and who people don't. It really isn't out of the ordinary to dislike someone regardless of their achievements, I can think of many people in the public eye that people dislike despite their work, yet when people share this opinion they don't tend to get vilified for it (the majority of the time, I accept it does happen), but it happens really often with JKR. Just because JKR has done great things, it doesn't mean that no one is allowed to dislike her.

The comments that I've seen (not on this thread) that I'm talking about are all over the internet - people simply say "can't stand the woman" "nah I don't like her at all" etc and are immediately met with angry posters who fully support her, calling them out, calling them anti-feminist and a bunch of other things. That's what I think is a bit silly, because it's everyone prerogative to dislike whoever they dislike and no one is immune to it, just because they've done good things like donate to charity, etc.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 10:42

Oh, sorry...she's also known for being very pro gay rights and anti-racist. Despite the increasingly deranged lies being spread everywhere about her, including false tweets.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 10:41

[quote CosmosLily]@SamphiretheStickerist I wasnt aware of that at all, so yes would definitely be good to add a note for other posters who may not be aware 😊[/quote]
The thing is, Cosmos, when you take the trans issue out of the equation, she's not known for much else outside of being a phenomenally successful and imaginative writer, a domestic abuse survivor and a shit ton of charity work and charity donations. She's one of those people who chooses not to be a billionaire because she gives so much away.

One may not like her books, and that's fair enough, but there's actually nothing to object to morally unless you think she's wrong not to compromise women's rights and safety to a system that would allow any intact male people in completely unchecked. So when people like dear, girlish "Vivienne" and others plop on threads about her to say nothing except that she's got ideas above her station or she needs to stop speaking, yet never actually say WHY....well, it often goes alongside another particular set of beliefs that shouldn't really surprise anyone.

ButWhereDidTheWindComeFrom · 07/02/2022 10:34

I stand with JKR