Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that JK Rowling is being vilified for standing for women and children?

285 replies

ExtraPlinky · 05/02/2022 12:41

Getting sick of seeing her being torn down constantly on social media.
Her essays are thoughtful and careful and she's primarily concerned with safeguarding.

AIBU to say it's a witch hunt?

OP posts:
CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 12:48

I'm not defending "kick her while she's down" people. It is mean spirited, I'm sure absolutely no one would like to read it and in an ideal world, no one would do it. But there is a world of difference between calling JKR transphobic, and saying you just don't like her. I just don't get why both of these situations are met with the same level and content of response, certainly when it's not the case for plenty of other celebrities.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 12:33

I'm aware of what your posts say.
What I'm unaware of is why you think it's appropriate to defend 'kick her while she's down people'.
You seem to think that posting on social media about disliking someone is mean spirited. Yet you are defending those who are not only doing that, but are doing it in tandem with others giving out false allegations, death and rape threats.

It's an odd position to take unless you have an axe to grind.

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 12:30

DrSbait - here is a quote from my own post less than an hour ago. I fully get your point, please read my response that I've already made to another poster: I was speaking in more general terms on the online world in general. All sparked by seeing a poster say something along the lines of "jealous much?" to a poster who said they didn't like her. I've since been told that poster has a history of posting certain things, hence the responses from other posters that gave them short shrift - I didn't know any of that and simply thought it was another example of someone saying "I don't like her" and then getting piled on by loads of other posters who hold JKR as a hero. I also have acknowledged that whilst my point remains valid in my own head, that this probably wasn't the place to post it, the above reasons are why I did, and turns out was wrong about it as I don't know the history of some posters here.

Dutch - I'm afraid you're barking up the wrong tree here. Someone said "I wonder if he gets rape threats" and I responded "I'm sure he has". This isn't FWR where I expect my every sentence to be analysed and asked for proof and evidence for my every post, this is AIBU and my opinion is that yes, I'm sure a bunch of celebs and high profile people get rape threats amongst many other awful threats. Plenty of them speak out about it. Am I 100% sure and have seen these myself as Mr Cruise sent them all to me in an email? No, I haven't. "I'm sure he has" isn't the same as "I'm 100% certain I have all of the proof", it's just a sentence that we all use.

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 12:26

Samphire I've actually been on MN for quite a while, but don't post very often at all. I know the topic is very "brusque", but as this thread was (and remains, wow!) in AIBU, I happened to see it more easily than if it had been in FWR and assumed that the conversation would be different and not such a "debate" as it usually is in the naughty corner, as I'm not a very good debater, haha! Regardless, it's been interesting talking to you Smile

Worried Please do read back on my posts, I haven't personally bashed her at all. I was simply speaking about something I've seen time and time again online and wanted to hear others opinions on it/have a conversation, which I now have done. I'm fully aware of the abuse JKR has received and am not here to disregard that or excuse it in any way, none of my posts were about that.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 12:25

@CosmosLily

WorriedMums and DrSbaito - I've just said that I'm not comparing the two. A poster said "I wonder if he has" and I responded "I'm sure he has".

WorriedMums, I'm really not sure why your responses towards me are so aggravated? I have not for one second disregarded what JKR has been through, I have not personally insulted her/criticised her in the slightest.

And on it goes...

Think of it like this. You have a work colleague. You don't like her very much, you find her a bit patronising but you can't really say why. Anyway. One day, you see her getting the absolute shit kicked out of her for things nobody has ever actually managed to quote her as saying, indeed she's on record saying the exact opposite. Nonetheless, they're kicking the shit out of her for it.

Do you go for help and try to get this stopped and discuss with people how it happened and could have been prevented?

Or, when everyone in the office is talking about it, do you use it as a reason to talk about how she wasn't really your type of person and it's so unfair because when you say this about Barney in accounts, who has never been attacked, people don't say "where are your priorities?"? Are you concerned mostly with expressing your subjective and unexplained dislike for her?

Dutch1e · 07/02/2022 12:24

@CosmosLily

WorriedMums and DrSbaito - I've just said that I'm not comparing the two. A poster said "I wonder if he has" and I responded "I'm sure he has".

WorriedMums, I'm really not sure why your responses towards me are so aggravated? I have not for one second disregarded what JKR has been through, I have not personally insulted her/criticised her in the slightest.

I wonder if it's because the sidestep into 'oh yes, everyone in the public eye gets threats of rape' is A) difficult to prove, despite you being sure, and B) deliberately misses the point being made about the constant intimidation of women because of their sex

Funny how women are easy enough to identify when it's time for us to be threatened, stalked, and harassed

CityMumma78 · 07/02/2022 12:21

I stand with JKR 100%

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 12:20

I usually respond to half baked ideas with sarcasm. It's a personal flaw.

I am mostly just tired of people who think they know what they are talking about trashing her and those that support her, with no evidence other than wishy washy feelings.
I do hope that you read her essay and pwrhaps research the types of threat she received and the volume. At least then you'll have a good context to refer to next time you accuse posters defending her of xyz.

SamphiretheStickerist · 07/02/2022 12:18

I also have acknowledged that whilst my point remains valid in my own head, that this probably wasn't the place to post it, the above reasons are why I did, and turns out was wrong about it as I don't know the history of some posters here.

I'll save you a little bit of time. This topic on MN is brusque. Quite sweary. Has little truck with any version of 'be nice' - as it usually translates into "Women stop saying no" or some such.

Posts such as this are usually moved to the Feminisn Boards, because someone complains that the topic is boring, overdone, nasty, transphobic etc. That this one is still here in AIBU days after it was started is something of a miracle. Many, including me, will post almost assuming it has been shuffled off to the Naughty Step (the corner of MN that is for Feminism, recently buggered around with because of yet more cries of "It's boring/not fair/ too busy, etc")

That and MN is, in general, quite a brusque space. You might need to buckle up and go with the flow sometimes Smile

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 12:13

WorriedMums and DrSbaito - I've just said that I'm not comparing the two. A poster said "I wonder if he has" and I responded "I'm sure he has".

WorriedMums, I'm really not sure why your responses towards me are so aggravated? I have not for one second disregarded what JKR has been through, I have not personally insulted her/criticised her in the slightest.

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 12:10

@SamphiretheStickerist

Samphire You're missing my point. I am trying hard not to. But do feel you are sidestepping mine.

This is Mumsnet. Not Twitter etc. The discussion is about JK Rowling. Not Tom Cruise. The history of the abuse heaped upon JK Rowling is long discussed here and many women, gender critical or otherwise, are going to treat to the banality, brevity, uninformed nature of many posts in a way that is specific to Mumsnet because of the nature of the site.

Don't like Tom Cruise or Holly Willoughby, fine! But don't join with those who regularly tell women to die in a grease fire, piss up the office doors of women who believe that sex is immutable, send police to the homes of women for simply stating biological facts and actively set out to doxx or to no platfom women, lose them their jobs, fight for legislation to put male bodied people sentenced for sex crimes in to the female estate then look away when that man commits sexual vioence against the female prisoners.

If you join your voice with theirs you will get short shrift here. Well, actually, initially you will get a long and detailed explanation of why you are being challenged and later given short shrift if you don't engage with what is being offered up for perusal.

I'm really sorry, I wasn't trying to sidestep yours at all. I think in my original post, or one soon after, I did mention that I wasn't just talking about MN (despite posting on MN, indeed). I was speaking in more general terms on the online world in general. All sparked by seeing a poster say something along the lines of "jealous much?" to a poster who said they didn't like her. I've since been told that poster has a history of posting certain things, hence the responses from other posters that gave them short shrift - I didn't know any of that and simply thought it was another example of someone saying "I don't like her" and then getting piled on by loads of other posters who hold JKR as a hero.

I also have acknowledged that whilst my point remains valid in my own head, that this probably wasn't the place to post it, the above reasons are why I did, and turns out was wrong about it as I don't know the history of some posters here.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 12:09

I'm sure he has over the years. Not comparing the two, but I'm sure he has

You're comparing the two.

But given that you are, how much do you think he got compared to JKR? And from whom? And why?

Compare the two.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 12:06

Not comparing the two

No, that would be ridiculous. Perhaps you need to start your #benice Twitter campaign with him.

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 12:06

@WorriedMumsDontSleep

The things JK Rowling did for literacy levels alone are such a huge contribution to the world.

Do people on Twitter genuinely have conversations where they're like: Don't like X person. No reason. Just my own ridiculous subjective feeling?
What a hate filled place it must be. Perhaps instead of inserting your random thoughts on this unrelated Mumsnet thread, you need to pop off to Twitter and tell them if they can't say something nice it's better to say nothing at all.

Unfortunately, those conversations are everywhere, even on MN. There have indeed been threads about which celebs people hate.
SamphiretheStickerist · 07/02/2022 12:05

Samphire You're missing my point. I am trying hard not to. But do feel you are sidestepping mine.

This is Mumsnet. Not Twitter etc. The discussion is about JK Rowling. Not Tom Cruise. The history of the abuse heaped upon JK Rowling is long discussed here and many women, gender critical or otherwise, are going to treat to the banality, brevity, uninformed nature of many posts in a way that is specific to Mumsnet because of the nature of the site.

Don't like Tom Cruise or Holly Willoughby, fine! But don't join with those who regularly tell women to die in a grease fire, piss up the office doors of women who believe that sex is immutable, send police to the homes of women for simply stating biological facts and actively set out to doxx or to no platfom women, lose them their jobs, fight for legislation to put male bodied people sentenced for sex crimes in to the female estate then look away when that man commits sexual vioence against the female prisoners.

If you join your voice with theirs you will get short shrift here. Well, actually, initially you will get a long and detailed explanation of why you are being challenged and later given short shrift if you don't engage with what is being offered up for perusal.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 12:05

It's funny that people think she could be cowed by hate mail from lunatics who read shitty press outlets. Didn't they read Goblet of Fire?

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 12:04

@Dutch1e

I wonder if Tom Cruise gets rape threats for being a bit odd
I don't know but I wouldn't be surprised if his Katy Holmes had to use a women's refuge when exiting him.
CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 12:02

*Unfortunately, the walls of abuse heaped on JKR have changed the context so this is very much a false equivalence. Feeling the need to express your inexplicable and subjective dislike for someone who receives death and rape threats daily is not the same as expressing it for people who are not mired in the same poison.

If you don't like being told you're anti feminist or whatever, imagine what it's like being told to choke on dicks daily.*

I'm sure that there are plenty of people in the public eye who have received mountains of absolutely awful abuse on a daily basis. Britney Spears and Lindsay Lohan as a couple of examples have received so much, certainly in recent years, but their names are also thrown around with "don't like her, can't stand her" without anyone batting an eyelid. Granted, Tom Cruise wasn't the best example, I just used him because I personally don't like him!

I wonder if Tom Cruise gets rape threats for being a bit odd

I'm sure he has over the years. Not comparing the two, but I'm sure he has, I'm sure everyone in the public eye has and it's awful.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 12:01

The things JK Rowling did for literacy levels alone are such a huge contribution to the world.

Do people on Twitter genuinely have conversations where they're like: Don't like X person. No reason. Just my own ridiculous subjective feeling?
What a hate filled place it must be. Perhaps instead of inserting your random thoughts on this unrelated Mumsnet thread, you need to pop off to Twitter and tell them if they can't say something nice it's better to say nothing at all.

Dutch1e · 07/02/2022 11:58

I wonder if Tom Cruise gets rape threats for being a bit odd

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 11:52

On Mumsnet, perhaps, certainly if you know a certain posters history etc on women's rights. But on twitter, reddit and the likes when Susan from Southshields says she doesn't like JKR (and she has no suspicious posting activity and it's not in the context of women's rights) she's often met with the same nasty comments, questioning her sanity and morals. When Jane from Brighton says she doesn't like Tom Cruise or Holly Willoughby, everyone just skirts on by thinking "fair enough, can't like everyone".

Unfortunately, the walls of abuse heaped on JKR have changed the context so this is very much a false equivalence. Feeling the need to express your inexplicable and subjective dislike for someone who receives death and rape threats daily is not the same as expressing it for people who are not mired in the same poison.

If you don't like being told you're anti feminist or whatever, imagine what it's like being told to choke on dicks daily.

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 11:51

DrSbaitso - I take your point, it's an unnecessary comment on a thread that isn't relevant to whether you like her personally, I suppose these thoughts came to my mind after seeing the "you must be jealous" comment, which granted, was made towards a poster who holds certain views that I wasn't aware of when I first posted.

My own point doesn't change and remains just as valid in my own mind, but this thread isn't the correct context for it. Fair enough.

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 11:47

Samphire You're missing my point. If someone pipes up with "JKR is transphobic" then by all means get into a discussion, question their morals etc. What I am talking about, is someone simply posting "I don't like JKR because (insert banal reason)" VS "I don't like Tom Cruise because (insert banal reason)" within a discussion that has nothing to do with their religious, feminist etc views. The latter is taken as "oh alright then fair enough" whereas the former is treated as something terrible, linking to the essay (as you have done to me, for some unknown reason) and more.

If it's fair to say you don't like Tom Cruise because you can't stand the guys acting, then it's also fair to say you don't like JKR because you can't stand her writing, without everything good they've ever done being brought into the discussion. I'm not saying it'll make sense to you, or that you'll agree, but it is ok to say you don't like someone without having every single good thing they've done thrown in your face and told you're wrong and how dare you, you must hate all women.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 11:46

To believe she is against trans people after reading that essay, you have to believe that a) she meant things she didn't say AND b) she said things she didn't mean. In other words, that she intends the exact opposite of bloody everything she wrote.

Perhaps you do believe her to be a gross liar, but
what discussion, or solution, can there be if you're just going to say she's lying every time she agrees with you?

DdraigGoch · 07/02/2022 11:45

@Binglebong

That should have said Umbridge's Army. Bloody autocorrect.
Or even the Inquisitorial Squad.