Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that JK Rowling is being vilified for standing for women and children?

285 replies

ExtraPlinky · 05/02/2022 12:41

Getting sick of seeing her being torn down constantly on social media.
Her essays are thoughtful and careful and she's primarily concerned with safeguarding.

AIBU to say it's a witch hunt?

OP posts:
WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 14:15

That's a shame Cosmos, I think it's good for people to be open to challenge and debate.

Fact is, whilst you might believe 99% of the haters of JK are in it because of some inane unnamed dislike, the reality is she's not that divisive a figure to attract such random vitoral. Apart from being female and understands the importance of sex based rights.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 14:12

@CosmosLily

Goodness me, this is the last time I'll try to participate in any type of debate that has anything mildly close to do with feminism or JKR on Mumsnet.

WorriedMum - Fully agree, they're both dangerous roads and thanks for stating what you were pointing out, that's made it clearer.

Why? You've apparently identified a very serious issue in which righteous JKR detractors are being intimidated into silence. So start a thread about that.

I haven't seen anybody be abusive to you, but if you have, report the posts.

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 14:06

Goodness me, this is the last time I'll try to participate in any type of debate that has anything mildly close to do with feminism or JKR on Mumsnet.

WorriedMum - Fully agree, they're both dangerous roads and thanks for stating what you were pointing out, that's made it clearer.

HoliHormonalTigerlilly · 07/02/2022 14:01

@WorriedMumsDontSleep

. I have simply pointed out that yes, people who just say "don't like her" get met with the level and content of response as if they had called her a massive transphobe, when the same isn't done about pretty much any other celeb. Almost as if no one is "allowed" to have a negative opinion or share than negative opinion of her, because "she's done so much good" and that's a pretty dangerous road to go down. And I am simply pointing out that I don't think that's what's happening.

It's also a dangerous road to go down where people can say they dislike someone and not expect to be asked questions as to why.

She's not a "celeb" she's an author.
HoliHormonalTigerlilly · 07/02/2022 14:00

YANBU OP.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 13:59

. I have simply pointed out that yes, people who just say "don't like her" get met with the level and content of response as if they had called her a massive transphobe, when the same isn't done about pretty much any other celeb. Almost as if no one is "allowed" to have a negative opinion or share than negative opinion of her, because "she's done so much good" and that's a pretty dangerous road to go down.
And I am simply pointing out that I don't think that's what's happening.

It's also a dangerous road to go down where people can say they dislike someone and not expect to be asked questions as to why.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 13:58

@CosmosLily, if you think there is a serious issue at the moment about people feeling intimidated and silenced and unable to express their entirely reasonable personal dislike of JKR, why don't you start a new thread to discuss it?

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 13:55

And I don't think you're playing "fair", you're assuming a whole bunch of me despite the fact I have not said anything bad towards JKR, I have said I don't agree with the public bashing of anyone on any level and that in an ideal world it wouldn't happen. I have simply pointed out that yes, people who just say "don't like her" get met with the level and content of response as if they had called her a massive transphobe, when the same isn't done about pretty much any other celeb. Almost as if no one is "allowed" to have a negative opinion or share than negative opinion of her, because "she's done so much good" and that's a pretty dangerous road to go down.

SamphiretheStickerist · 07/02/2022 13:49

Yep, this is AIBU. So everyone is answering your posts and telling you that YES, YABU!

You'd get a slightly different set of responses if we permanently forgot this was AIBU Smile

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 13:48

Aibu is just as robust as fwr. The only difference being on aibu you are not limited to the words you can use.

You have every word of the English language at your disposal, if you think my addressing your points is unfair debate then perhaps consider that your argument is poor.

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 13:45

WorriedMums, you're debating with me as if this is the FWR board. This is AIBU and I gave my opinion/shared a thought I had, you don't have to agree by any means whatsoever, but please do stop putting words in my mouth and making assumptions. Had this thread have been created in FWR then I wouldn't have posted at all, but as it stands, it's in AIBU and I was expecting conversation to come from it, not an analysis on everything I'm saying and how that links to this this and this and therefore I must feel this and have this as an opinion.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 07/02/2022 13:40

What there is to dislike. Obviously Grin

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 07/02/2022 13:36

@Viviennemary

Exactly. I don't like her. Never have. Long before this Trans issue reared its head.
Unless you know her personally and maybe know she has a favourite hobby of kicking kittens, I can't get my head around what's not to dislike about her especially considering all the highlights DrS gave earlier.
tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 07/02/2022 13:34

@Janesmom

I don’t understand which women and children she’s meant to be standing up for. Please stop pretending all women hold these views.

Not in my name.

Which views are you going referring to?
DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 13:32

[quote CosmosLily]@Spookytooth Have I said once on this thread that I don't like her?[/quote]
By this point, I'm taking every irrelevant post about why it's so important for people to be able to say they dislike her, in the face of a storm of people expressing, in violent misogynistic terms, their dislike of her, as its own statement.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 13:30

I think you'd find the same people defending JK Rowling would likely be calling out people doing the same for Britney, seeing as much of the Britney hatred is misogyny.

James Corden has mostly alienated his fans because he went to the USA. I don't know but I believe that will be most of the negative feedback he gets. Or people saying he's not funny. As a comedian, that's a fair point. I don't see people randomly staffing that they dislike him for a feeling on the internet, and I would assume that the Corden fans would, quite rightly, call them out on it.

If you genuinely, genuinely think a woman who survived domestic abuse, is a self made millionaire, a feminist, inspires most of the subjective hatred of her based on, what, the fact that she sports a layered cut? Has a grating voice? Then I can't help you because to me it's blindingly obvious.

It's certainly not comparable to hating a man like Tom Cruise, whom there have been numerous documentaries on his borderline abusive/cult led values.

Thing is you're expecting jk Rowling fans to be held to a higher moral code than everyone else. If Beliebers are ok to argue that you can't dislike his music unless you've listened to his albums, then why can't feminists ask what baseless dislike is coming from and pre emptying it by directing them to her essay.

And besides, I doubt anyone saying that they dislike Rowling on a baseless feeling are given anywhere near the level of abuse or death threats she receives. So sorry, my sympathies are limited.

SamphiretheStickerist · 07/02/2022 13:23

Don't apologise @CosmosLily. This is AIBU (for the moment). Go against the apparent grain as much as you like!

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 13:17

WorriedMums - It happens constantly on all forms of social media. A Facebook article about Holly Willoughby, a Twitter post about Claudia Winkleman, a Reddit thread about David Beckham, a TikTok video about Jennifer Lopez. It's social media, people share their one-sentence opinions on whether or not they like another person constantly. I'm not saying it's right, but it happens every single day, there have even been entire threads dedicated to it on MN.

Should they weigh in on a discussion talking about the cinematography on Tom Cruise's latest movie? Probably not. But plenty of people pipe up with "can't stand her/him" on all forms of social media and my point was simply that when it's JKR, the accusations of being anti-feminist begin, the links to her essay, the analysing of everything begins when that wasn't the context, whereas when it's James Corden/Britney Spears etc, people skirt on by.

However, as I've said a few times now, this conversation is in the wrong place and that's my fault, so for that I do apologise.

londonrach · 07/02/2022 13:14

Yanbu. I feel vvv hurt that the harry potter stars have stabbed her in the back. She deserves better than how the media is treating her

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 13:09

when it's not the case for plenty of other celebrities.

Again, I would be surprised if people are expressing dislike for other adults based on very little.

Imo, it's fine to not like someone's work. Or their values. Or their actions. However it takes very few words to specify why. Anyone who cares enough to write down their thoughts on the internet, especially if they are interrupting an actual discussion point, rather than a banal vacuous comment of subjective dislike, should care enough to add a few words on the matter. If you join a pile on with something like that why would anyone think otherwise.
It's not 1999. Words are not expensive and so few words are needed to clarify.

For example:
I do not like JK Rowling because I think her work is boring.

Do you really think people are so thick they can't use a handful of words to make their position clear.

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 13:07

@Spookytooth Have I said once on this thread that I don't like her?

Spookytooth · 07/02/2022 13:05

@CosmosLily - but you haven't explained why you don't like her.

Nor have most of the others who say that

That's why I accuse people of misogyny or whatever - they just dislike someone (whom they've never spoken to, met in real life, actually know). WHY WHY. I think the problem is people dont' know themselves so can't recognise when their comments are from jealousy or anger. They are convinced they are a 'nice' person and admitting envy would blot that image and make them uncomfortable.

Personally I have no time with any unjustified, unexplained criticisms of people but can recognise that when I think I hate or dislike someone that I don't actually know, then there is something else going on in me.

ExtraPlinky · 07/02/2022 12:56

It does seem to be the women most concerned with safeguarding are they first ones that people try and silence with threats of violence in this (no) debate. Wonder why that is?

OP posts:
ExtraPlinky · 07/02/2022 12:55

@Rheia1983

JKR is awesome.

The hullabaloo that went off regarding her remarks is what made me aware of the sinister nature of TRA activism and active in supporting those who stand against TRA abuse. Her courage and integrity in the face of fire is admirable.

Yes she's always been very dignified and measured in her responses even as they ramped up the abuse.
OP posts:
Rheia1983 · 07/02/2022 12:49

JKR is awesome.

The hullabaloo that went off regarding her remarks is what made me aware of the sinister nature of TRA activism and active in supporting those who stand against TRA abuse. Her courage and integrity in the face of fire is admirable.