Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that JK Rowling is being vilified for standing for women and children?

285 replies

ExtraPlinky · 05/02/2022 12:41

Getting sick of seeing her being torn down constantly on social media.
Her essays are thoughtful and careful and she's primarily concerned with safeguarding.

AIBU to say it's a witch hunt?

OP posts:
Leafstamp · 05/02/2022 13:51

[quote PinkyU]@gardenhelpneeded but surely that’s true for all humans? The majority of people charged with infanticide are women, given we don’t know which ones are dangerous perhaps we should stop all women from having babies?

In London in 2020 the majority of perpetrators of knife crime were young black men, given we don’t know which are the dangerous ones perhaps we should just view all of them as dangerous. Yes, let’s view an entire group of individuals as dangerous:

Mothers
Men
Young black men
Trans women

Let’s view them all as potential killers and rapists because a minority of their group commit these crimes.[/quote]
Very poor logical reasoning skills there.

That’s not how safeguarding works.

That’s not how risk assessments work.

Suggest you read up on legitimatacy and proportionality.

Keeping men out of women’s spaces is not just about safety, its about privacy and dignity as well.

In sport it’s also about fairness.

ExtraPlinky · 05/02/2022 13:51

[quote PinkyU]@gardenhelpneeded but surely that’s true for all humans? The majority of people charged with infanticide are women, given we don’t know which ones are dangerous perhaps we should stop all women from having babies?

In London in 2020 the majority of perpetrators of knife crime were young black men, given we don’t know which are the dangerous ones perhaps we should just view all of them as dangerous. Yes, let’s view an entire group of individuals as dangerous:

Mothers
Men
Young black men
Trans women

Let’s view them all as potential killers and rapists because a minority of their group commit these crimes.[/quote]
Do you think that my 14 year old daughter should be going to the same toilet as a 55 year old man?

Do you think male sexual predators should be in prisons with women?

Do you think women should call their male rapists "she"?

OP posts:
ExtraPlinky · 05/02/2022 13:46

[quote PinkyU]@gardenhelpneeded but surely that’s true for all humans? The majority of people charged with infanticide are women, given we don’t know which ones are dangerous perhaps we should stop all women from having babies?

In London in 2020 the majority of perpetrators of knife crime were young black men, given we don’t know which are the dangerous ones perhaps we should just view all of them as dangerous. Yes, let’s view an entire group of individuals as dangerous:

Mothers
Men
Young black men
Trans women

Let’s view them all as potential killers and rapists because a minority of their group commit these crimes.[/quote]
What does this have to do with anything that JKR has said?
Of course entire groups of people don't behave in the same way but it doesn't mean you don't put in safeguarding in obvious cases - for instance not housing men in womens prisons especially if they have committed sexual crimes.

OP posts:
anothersmahedmug · 05/02/2022 13:46

Let's leave the door unlocked too shall we?

Something like 20% of women have been raped. Many more suffered harm motivated by sex

Something around 10% of men have sexually abused a women

The numbers are shocking . And good men know this and support a certain separation of the sexes

SisterRuth · 05/02/2022 13:43

She's brave, logical and fair. Thank god for JKR. Few women have the standing she has to tell the simple truth. It's frightening how quickly & thoroughly a mob mentality can take over with no evidence whatsoever of the things she is accused of. People burning her books should really look at history to see what sort of people do that. But they seem incapable of seeing clearly, of learning anything. We're living in weird, emperor's new clothes, times.

Wimpeyspread · 05/02/2022 13:42

@CorrBlimeyGG

She is transphobic, she conflates trans women with sex abusers. She does not speak for all women, thankfully.
Only for the female kind?
PinkyU · 05/02/2022 13:41

@gardenhelpneeded but surely that’s true for all humans? The majority of people charged with infanticide are women, given we don’t know which ones are dangerous perhaps we should stop all women from having babies?

In London in 2020 the majority of perpetrators of knife crime were young black men, given we don’t know which are the dangerous ones perhaps we should just view all of them as dangerous. Yes, let’s view an entire group of individuals as dangerous:

Mothers
Men
Young black men
Trans women

Let’s view them all as potential killers and rapists because a minority of their group commit these crimes.

VelvetChairGirl · 05/02/2022 13:40

anon12345678901 its an utterly meaningless word, reminds me of Kevin the teenager shouting I hate you all the time, it really says more about the person who uses it then anyone else, I just roll my eyes at them.

and TERF just means Tired of Explaining Reality to Fuckwits to me.

we should start accusing everyone of Gynephobia and running off, they seem to think accusing people of having phobias is like daggers somehow.

Leafstamp · 05/02/2022 13:40

YANBU. Agree with those supporting JKR here - we need more like her in the world.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 05/02/2022 13:38

@CorrBlimeyGG you can't have read the essay if you still think that. Stop with your bullshit

MrsJaxTellerPlease · 05/02/2022 13:36

JKR is a wonderful brave woman who should be applauded. It horrifies me the abuse she gets. She is not transphobic. She stands up for womens and girls rights and is a staunch supporter of single sex spaces.she does not want women to be erased.

Why the world is listening to a small group of men who want to tell women what to do is beyond me. We need many other women like JKR.

Ionlydomassiveones · 05/02/2022 13:35

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

anon12345678901 · 05/02/2022 13:32

@334bu

13:11CorrBlimeyGG

She is transphobic, she conflates trans women with sex abusers. She does not speak for all women, thankfully.

Are we still waiting for any evidence of this?

Perhaps Corr is confusing JKR with all the people who post pornography onto JKR's twitter account because they hate her for standing up for women.

We'll be waiting a while... they're trying to find some. It's an easy word for them to throw around but when it comes to proving it, that's not as easy.
SamphiretheStickerist · 05/02/2022 13:32

@CorrBlimeyGG

(And yes, I've read her 'essay'.)
Good You will be able to provide us with specific quotes that actually are, in any way whatsoever, transphobic.

I look forward to seeing what it is that is being objected to as nobody, to date, has yet come back with any such evidence

VelvetChairGirl · 05/02/2022 13:31

all women are vilified if they are not hand maidens welcome to the age of misogyny

334bu · 05/02/2022 13:31

13:11CorrBlimeyGG

She is transphobic, she conflates trans women with sex abusers. She does not speak for all women, thankfully.

Are we still waiting for any evidence of this?

Perhaps Corr is confusing JKR with all the people who post pornography onto JKR's twitter account because they hate her for standing up for women.

SilverontheTree · 05/02/2022 13:27

She’s amazing.
I stand with JKR.

gardenhelpneeded · 05/02/2022 13:26

Well of course not all transwomen are sex abusers (no one especially not JK has said that) but they are biologically men. And some men are sex abusers. That’s why single sex provision exists. We don’t know which ones are a danger so they should all be kept out. This about womens’ rights.

anothersmahedmug · 05/02/2022 13:24

@CorrBlimeyGG

She is transphobic, she conflates trans women with sex abusers. She does not speak for all women, thankfully.
Proof please

Tempted to report - is that slander or libel ?

DdraigGoch · 05/02/2022 13:23

@CorrBlimeyGG

She is transphobic, she conflates trans women with sex abusers. She does not speak for all women, thankfully.
I notice that you don't (ever) offer any evidence of her alleged 'transphobia'.

It's a good job that you don't speak for all women. Or even most women. Or - for that matter - most men.

gardenhelpneeded · 05/02/2022 13:22

Incredible, brave woman. 💕 Fantastic role model. Men don’t like women standing up to them especially ones like her who are too powerful and wealthy to be silenced. It makes them crazy. Those calling her transphobic have most likely not even read her essays or applied any critical thinking whatsoever.

MarshaBradyo · 05/02/2022 13:21

That message on your FB feed is horrendous op

In terms of JKR I’m not sure why she gets so little protection from hate speech online - thinking of footballer while was targeted on Twitter and person was arrested

RavenclawDiadem · 05/02/2022 13:20

Big fan of JKR in general and all things Potter in particular.

She is a smart, clever woman who puts her arguments across articulately and persuasively. Some people don't like that, so resort to sweary name calling on social media, or posting pictures of themselves standing on her doorstep.

We need more people like JK Rowling.

anon12345678901 · 05/02/2022 13:17

@CorrBlimeyGG

She is transphobic, she conflates trans women with sex abusers. She does not speak for all women, thankfully.
Please can you give direct examples of this.
Aroundtheworldin80moves · 05/02/2022 13:17

I've come to the conclusion they genuinely think they are being kind. They are fortunate enough not to have needed DV refuges, or rape counselling or a womens prison or similar services and don't understand the trauma and PTSD of people who do, or that every person experiences these differently.

It isn't as black and white as they want it to be. We don't live in utopia, we need compromises in real life.