Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that JK Rowling is being vilified for standing for women and children?

285 replies

ExtraPlinky · 05/02/2022 12:41

Getting sick of seeing her being torn down constantly on social media.
Her essays are thoughtful and careful and she's primarily concerned with safeguarding.

AIBU to say it's a witch hunt?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Toseland · 08/02/2022 16:09

I was so pleased and relieved when JK spoke out. I had been following the feminist board in absolute horror as women’s rights were given away by police forces, schools, shops, politicians and corporations without any consideration at all. All these people should actually be looking out for women and protecting safeguarding of children but we have been betrayed by them all.
I think JK could see where this path was leading for women and children and bravely spoke out in an attempt to stop it.

DrSbaitso · 08/02/2022 13:11

Thank you, @SamphiretheStickerist. If it helps, please feel free to use those same words in any other places. And everyone else too.

SamphiretheStickerist · 08/02/2022 11:11

@DrSbaitso

People will tell you that of course the threats are wrong BUT....

The threats are to be expected for any prominent woman who stands up for women. But in this context, the refusal to take them seriously is particularly telling because they are especially relevant.

JKR's concern is not about trans women, but about a relaxing of safeguards that would be wide open to terrible abuse by predatory men posing as transwomen and would make both women and transwomen less safe. The fact that the response to this is an avalanche of death and rape threats from male people who want the very access she's worried about is damning proof that she's right to he concerned. These are the very people she's worried about and they're not even hiding what they wish they could do to her.

For people to come along and attempt to dismiss this concrete proof that she's right and women would be exposed to these people - and to use mawkish, dishonest emotional blackmail to try to paint women and JKR as the aggressors - is quite breathtaking.

And it is, yet again, somewhat remarkable that a mere woman can put that into words.

My hat is off to you @DrSbaitso It must have been tremendously difficult, given all of those others, those who have berated us on this thread and many others, who have not been able to even begin do the same!

theemperorhasnoclothes · 08/02/2022 10:27

The other thing is that if JKR - with her wealth, her very clear moral fibre and bravery and her easy access to lawyers - is receiving this kind of abuse, how on earth would any normal woman (like me) stand up for safeguarding in the real world?

Women like Posie Parker have had their kids doxxed by standing up for women and for safeguarding. Look at what happened to Marion Millar and Kate Scottow. Real harms visited upon their children or threatened to their children. The state machinery being used by TRAs to heap stress on vulnerable women and children.

Normal women are scared to speak up, of course they are. JKR knows this, she gets thousands of anonymous emails from women thanking her because they feel, they know, they cannot speak up for fear of the harms that would happen to their children if they are brave enough to state that sex is real.

If THIS is happening to JKR, imagine how easy it is to silence a normal Mum.

Mumsnet, by virtue of its anonymity, is one of the few places women can speak relatively freely and say what they really think (and we can't even do that on the feminism boards). MOST people absolutely agree with JKR, especially once they've actually bothered to read what she wrote.

Remember in the HP books how lots of people pretended they agreed with Doloris umbridge out of fear even when they secretly thought Harry was probably right and there was increasing evidence that he was? We're about there.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 08/02/2022 10:18

@DrSbaitso

People will tell you that of course the threats are wrong BUT....

The threats are to be expected for any prominent woman who stands up for women. But in this context, the refusal to take them seriously is particularly telling because they are especially relevant.

JKR's concern is not about trans women, but about a relaxing of safeguards that would be wide open to terrible abuse by predatory men posing as transwomen and would make both women and transwomen less safe. The fact that the response to this is an avalanche of death and rape threats from male people who want the very access she's worried about is damning proof that she's right to he concerned. These are the very people she's worried about and they're not even hiding what they wish they could do to her.

For people to come along and attempt to dismiss this concrete proof that she's right and women would be exposed to these people - and to use mawkish, dishonest emotional blackmail to try to paint women and JKR as the aggressors - is quite breathtaking.

Brilliant post - absolutely 100%
deleteasappropriate · 08/02/2022 09:59

It's definitely not ok - wish you'd had a vote on it OP.

DrSbaitso · 08/02/2022 09:13

People will tell you that of course the threats are wrong BUT....

The threats are to be expected for any prominent woman who stands up for women. But in this context, the refusal to take them seriously is particularly telling because they are especially relevant.

JKR's concern is not about trans women, but about a relaxing of safeguards that would be wide open to terrible abuse by predatory men posing as transwomen and would make both women and transwomen less safe. The fact that the response to this is an avalanche of death and rape threats from male people who want the very access she's worried about is damning proof that she's right to he concerned. These are the very people she's worried about and they're not even hiding what they wish they could do to her.

For people to come along and attempt to dismiss this concrete proof that she's right and women would be exposed to these people - and to use mawkish, dishonest emotional blackmail to try to paint women and JKR as the aggressors - is quite breathtaking.

gardenhelpneeded · 08/02/2022 08:24

Too right @ExtraPlinky “hidden from women”- exactly.

ExtraPlinky · 08/02/2022 07:41

I really want to know how many women here think the vilification of JKR is ok or not ok. Because right now anyone who isn't toeing the party line is being threatened.
I don't care if someone likes her work or not. I don't give a shit if you don't like her hair or her earrings or her right eye.
Do you think it's right that she is being given rape and death threats for talking about safeguarding concerns for women and children? Safeguarding concerns that have now come to pass? Do women here support her or are we happy to be gagged by the rainbow flag of kindness?

Women absolutely should be visiting the feminist boards and the idea that posts like this are moved is ridiculous - as if what happens to women should be hidden from women.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 15:12

Thanks for clarifying, I genuinely didn't get what you meant and thought your suggestion for making a new thread was a disguised "fuck off".

No, it wasn't.

I don't think there is a phenomenon of righteous JKR detractors being silenced, so I'm feeling slightly cynical about that, but I certainly don't think you shouldn't be allowed to say it. But going on about it in a thread about her misogynistic abusers doesn't come over well. Find a clear space.

And yes, I do think one needs better reasons than the ones you gave previously if they're going to be taken seriously. All the ones that weren't about disliking her writing or the level of acclaim she's received from other people were "don't like her but don't know why". A person can feel that way, but how much weight are we supposed to give it?

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 15:08

Samphire - I do understand the whole be kind thing, I just really think that some posters use it as an incentive to be really really awful. I'm not asking for people to be kind to me, I'm just asking for them to show me the same respect I show them, but as soon as I ask that, I'm met with "don't tell me to be kind" so I feel completely stuck. I don't want to fight with people on the internet, I want to learn and have conversations.
I've no issue with my arguments being blown out of the water, but I just don't see how they can blow arguments I haven't even made out of the water, whilst referring it all back to me and then having lots of other people pile in. That's why I use disclaimers, so that hopefully they won't assume what I mean and will indeed get straight to the point of what I'm asking, without analysing everything else that comes before it. But, it doesn't work, so I don't really know what to do.

Thanks for all your advice, really, I just really don't think I'm strong enough for it all.

SamphiretheStickerist · 07/02/2022 15:01

@CosmosLily

Samphire - But those conversations make me feel like utter shit. I end up sitting there having been piled on by a bunch of posters, some of whom have been downright nasty, having not learned a damn thing because hardly anyone is willing to have a conversation. It's all a "debate" and analysis of everything everyone says in every post (and whilst that's great if you've been there for 10 years, it's not good for learning).

If I (or others) dare to say anything about people being really fucking rude for no reason, we're told to shut up because "women are tired of being kind, are you telling me to BE KIND" and I'm kind of like no, I'm asking you to be respectful and not be a dick. No, it's not constructive for learning, trust me, I've tried time and time again and I'm just so beyond it, I can't get "in" at all despite constantly issuing disclaimers on all my sodding posts to avoid the conflict of people assuming I mean something else. I'm tired of it.

Shout FUCK OFF at the screen, have a gin, move on!

And sometimes 'nasty' is more 'unrelenting'.

The "Be Nice" thing is something I think every woman needs to understand. It isn't the same as being respectful of other people it is a demand that, as a woman, we have a different onus placed upon us, to be the one that acquiesces, doesn't rock the boat, doesn't say "fuck off". It is all those female socialisation things. rather than an interpersonal communication thing.

So stop issuing disclaimers, that's your female socialisation showing. Just say what you think. See every 'robust' response as a challenge rather than something personal - or just laugh, shout "fuck off" at the screen and move on.

It's all a "debate" and analysis of everything everyone says in every post (and whilst that's great if you've been there for 10 years, it's not good for learning) So maybe try hitting it it all head on, knowing that is what you are doing. Don't take anything personally. It's experiential learning, flooding - and many other flummery names.

But mostly remember, most posters in AIBU and FWR in particular, enter into those spaces FOR debates. FWR is really big on analysis at the moment, because of the legal attack on women's rights it has to be. None of the back and forths are personal, they can't be, we don't know each other. They are simply responses to a toneless written word. Remembering that has helped me not bite, a little!

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 14:59

I literally don't know what point you are trying to make then. As I understood it, you think lots of people dislike JK Rowling because of ERM, reasons and are afraid to voice them.

I'm just of the opinion that if you are going to negatively slate someone, a few words of explanation are reasonable. Just as you did for Tom Cruise.
And yes, I imagine that it would go down like a lead balloon on a Tom Cruise appreciation thread. But at least you'd be able to defend your view.
And the statistic of 99% was used btw because you seem to think this is a common problem. It's not meant to be read as an actual statistic, just to express my disbelief that that many JK Rowling critics who are unable to go their opinion and reasons exist.
I work in education and usually most people can use because adequately by age eight.

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 14:59

DrSbait - Thanks for clarifying, I genuinely didn't get what you meant and thought your suggestion for making a new thread was a disguised "fuck off". I do realise that this isn't the place for this conversation and have stated it a couple of times, as well as apologised for bringing it up here. As this was posted in AIBU, it was more a passing thought that I thought would be interesting to have a conversation about, so I really don't feel strongly enough about it to start a thread. As I said, I wouldn't have posted if this was in FWR.

Ddraig - I'm talking about in the Feminism section, not on this thread. I have had people in the Feminism section be very nasty to me in the past yes, I have also seen it being done to others. Not for saying anything nasty/untrue/accusatory or anything like that, simply for posting on a subject I/they weren't 100% knowledgable on, for asking someone to stop responding so aggressively to them, for asking a question or for questioning what someone else said. If you've never experienced that then I'm very pleased for you, but I unfortunately have a few times.

DdraigGoch · 07/02/2022 14:53

some of whom have been downright nasty

Have they?

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 14:48

@CosmosLily

DrSbaito - I really don't understand how any of that is relevant to my post? No, I genuinely didn't say I believe 99% of the haters of JK are in it because of some inane unnamed dislike... but the way the poster is writing is as if I do believe that - Fact is, whilst you might believe 99% of the haters of JK are in it because of some inane unnamed dislike

So their argument is going off of something I didn't say or allude to, so what other choice do I have but to respond "I didn't say that?!". It's just constant going round in circles.

Ok, maybe I wasn't clear.

You seem to have identified an issue in which people who have a perfectly reasonable dislike of JKR are being intimidated into not expressing it. I'm suggesting that you start a thread about it if you want to discuss it, because it doesn't come over well in a thread about people whose dislike of her is violent minded, misogynistic and threatening.

You're worried about having your words twisted etc. (The irony.) I'm saying that while this might happen, your posts will be there for all to see, and I do believe that even the most facetious of us will be able to tell if you're accused of saying things that you really, absolutely, definitely did not say or imply. Right now, by obsessing with all the really good reasons to dislike JKR on this particular thread, you're making implications.

I'm not telling you to shut up. I'm suggesting that you start a new discussion where you have a bit more control over the context of discussing this issue you appear to have identified.

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 14:46

Samphire - But those conversations make me feel like utter shit. I end up sitting there having been piled on by a bunch of posters, some of whom have been downright nasty, having not learned a damn thing because hardly anyone is willing to have a conversation. It's all a "debate" and analysis of everything everyone says in every post (and whilst that's great if you've been there for 10 years, it's not good for learning).

If I (or others) dare to say anything about people being really fucking rude for no reason, we're told to shut up because "women are tired of being kind, are you telling me to BE KIND" and I'm kind of like no, I'm asking you to be respectful and not be a dick. No, it's not constructive for learning, trust me, I've tried time and time again and I'm just so beyond it, I can't get "in" at all despite constantly issuing disclaimers on all my sodding posts to avoid the conflict of people assuming I mean something else. I'm tired of it.

ThreeRingCircus · 07/02/2022 14:44

She speaks for me and I stand with her. Her support for the rights of women is nothing short of incredible. She supports transwomen too and their right to safety but doesn't confuse that with women's right to single sex spaces. She is heroic.

Like a PP, it was the uproar in response to her perfectly sensible essay that highlighted the danger of the TWAW ideology to me. I will go to my grave defending women's rights to single sex spaces and safeguarding from male violence.....the rape and death threats JKR has received only highlights to me EXACTLY why this is so important.

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 14:40

DrSbaito - I really don't understand how any of that is relevant to my post? No, I genuinely didn't say I believe 99% of the haters of JK are in it because of some inane unnamed dislike... but the way the poster is writing is as if I do believe that - Fact is, whilst you might believe 99% of the haters of JK are in it because of some inane unnamed dislike

So their argument is going off of something I didn't say or allude to, so what other choice do I have but to respond "I didn't say that?!". It's just constant going round in circles.

SamphiretheStickerist · 07/02/2022 14:38

Those boards are a fantastic place for people who have been on them for 10 years or who have the debating skills of a lawyer, but for people like me who are simply keen to learn and get a bit involved, they're not welcoming at all.

Stick around, learn those skills. Have at it! It doesn't really mater, given that this is an anonymous board. You can just take a run at it and change your name when you feel the one you are using has been 'burned'.

I did! I flung myself wholeheartedly into discussion, all bluster, little elan. I got my arse handed to me on any number of occasions. I would stop posting, digest what had been said, and come back, new understanding of myself, the forum and a brand new username .

I imagine, from what pother posters have said, many others have done the same.

Use this place in as many ways as you can. I can't think of anywhere else that allows such a wide range of debates, learning opportunities, support, general silliness and STILL manages to remain relatively sane and pleasant!

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 07/02/2022 14:34

I've been jumped on, my words twisted, taken out of context

Not exclusive to fwr. Very aibu trait.

And the reason it may feel like a more one sided pile on is because everyone on fwr will be looking at it from a feminist pov. If you march on their with a half baked idea without thinking of the implications for women, they're going to tell you them, aren't they. They don't sit around going oh you're pro sex work is work, yay surrogacy, you go girl.

There are very little places on Mumsnet you won't have your views examined. Even suggesting skinnies are in on style and beauty can feel intimidating.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 14:31

@CosmosLily

Why? Because things I've said have been taken out of context, assumptions have been made about me/what I've said. Even the latest post "Whilst you might believe 99% of the haters of JK are in it because of some inane unnamed dislike" where have I said or even eluded to that?! So my time is spent repeating myself again and again.

To be perfectly honest, the few times I have joined in a conversation on the Feminism and FWR boards and simply asked a question or stated that my opinion wasn't 100% the same as the majority, or questioned something someone said out of a desire to learn, I've been jumped on, my words twisted, taken out of context. Even recently, a random poster did a search history on me, took a post of mine on a completely unrelated thread out of context, posted one sentence of it and declared "that's not very feminist of you, is it?".

Those boards are a fantastic place for people who have been on them for 10 years or who have the debating skills of a lawyer, but for people like me who are simply keen to learn and get a bit involved, they're not welcoming at all.

Credit us with a little intelligence. We can read your posts, we can read the responses. Credit us that if people really are accusing you of things you never said (oh, the irony!), we will be able to tell that from your posts, as we can see those too.

I recounted an exchange on an old thread the other day. Someone replied to say that she remembered the exchange, and posts had "definitely" not been made in the order I described. They "definitely" had, and I pulled up the thread so people could see for themselves. Poster blustered a bit and then came up with some other stuff that also didn't happen. Thread's there for anyone who wants to check.

But I accept it must be frustrating to be judged constantly on stuff you didn't say...

DdraigGoch · 07/02/2022 14:25

@CosmosLily

DrSbaitso Then I'm sorry you haven't seen people give their explanations as to why they don't like her (outside of her stance on women's rights) as I've seen it plenty and they're all valid reasons to the person disliking her, doesn't mean anyone need agree with them, of course, but some do give their own reasons when asked. Again, this is outside of her women's rights stance that I'm talking about.

I personally dislike Tom Cruise, he annoys me whenever I see him on screen and he seems a very strange person wrapped up in a cult, yet whenever I express that online, I'm never met with angry messages, rather just people either speaking of their own dislike of him, or asking for more info because they're interested. Yet if I was to say I don't like JKR for whatever reason (outside of women's rights stance) then I would be vilified for that and called anti-feminist, I've seen it happen to people.

But that's a valid reason. As is disliking various celebrities (the Sussexes, Lewis Hamilton etc.) for the hypocrisy of preaching about the environment from the back of a private jet, or saying that you think the PM is a scruff or that the Leader of the Opposition is boring. Other people may not agree with those reasons but at least everyone should be able to respect that you've put some thought in. "I just don't like her" or "She's too big for her boots" beckon further explanation.

"Too big for her boots" is a rather telling turn of phrase. It has echos of the Harry Enfield parodies of what happens when a woman has an opinion of her own: "Women: know your limits!" etc.

ApplesinmyPocket · 07/02/2022 14:23

@Gizacluethen

Threatening to rape and murder anyone is obviously vile.

I personally think she latches onto whatever "struggle" is going off into the world to stay relevant. But I wouldn't spit vitriol about it, alot of people are doing the same.

You might personally think that, but personally I came to the opposite conclusion. I think JKR stayed quiet as long as she could bear while the whole issue grew and grew, but finally and very bravely spoke out. She knew it would lead to trouble for her, she'd seen enough by then to know people lost their jobs, their good name, their livelihood for speaking up; she probably knew it wouldn't end with that one initial tweet and that she'd have to defend herself in an escalating situation of trouble, but still she waded in on the side of women and girls.

And that brought down the inevitable upon her and life for her will never be the same again. Her name among the young woke is spat out with contempt; to them it's a given she's a vile person who let slip her inner bigotry.

I'd stake everything that nothing could be further from the truth. That she considered the whole issue very thoughtfully, but then began to see someone like her weighing in on the side of women and girls could do so much good.

And what a price she's paid for it. How much it must have hurt to see those silly younger people who came to fame and fortune through her works, reject her so utterly?

CosmosLily · 07/02/2022 14:22

Why? Because things I've said have been taken out of context, assumptions have been made about me/what I've said. Even the latest post "Whilst you might believe 99% of the haters of JK are in it because of some inane unnamed dislike" where have I said or even eluded to that?! So my time is spent repeating myself again and again.

To be perfectly honest, the few times I have joined in a conversation on the Feminism and FWR boards and simply asked a question or stated that my opinion wasn't 100% the same as the majority, or questioned something someone said out of a desire to learn, I've been jumped on, my words twisted, taken out of context. Even recently, a random poster did a search history on me, took a post of mine on a completely unrelated thread out of context, posted one sentence of it and declared "that's not very feminist of you, is it?".

Those boards are a fantastic place for people who have been on them for 10 years or who have the debating skills of a lawyer, but for people like me who are simply keen to learn and get a bit involved, they're not welcoming at all.