Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or is DH selfish

139 replies

Iamasingingtelegram · 05/02/2022 12:24

DH works 8-5 in a low paid job. He doesn’t like the job particularly and the says the company is awful, but he works with friends so likes that.
We have 3 small children, oldest due to start school this year.
He can’t help with getting them ready in the morning, getting them to nursery if they are going, picking them up, doing tea etc. when he gets home he helps with bath and bed.
My maternity leave finishes soon and I’ll have to work my hours around school and nursery.
For the same salary (or probably higher) he could work an hour less a day and be more help with the kids. He might even get flexible hours or work from home options (no chance in current job).
I never wanted life to be like this, where I do so much of the childcare. I’d always hoped for more balance. However he is working full time so I get it falls to me as I’m on maternity. But even when I go back it will still fall to me and because my job is more flexible I will have to make it flex.
I’ve told him I’m not enjoying things at the moment. Got a young baby who cries a lot, a wilful toddler and a four year old who wants a lot of attention. I’m often reduced to tears with frustration in getting out in the morning, not to mention feeling so down about the constant housework and mum admin.
His job is going nowhere and has no perks. I think he should look for something else, AIBU?

OP posts:
RobertaFirmino · 05/02/2022 18:52

Forgot to add - with the amount of children and their ages being such hard work, it would be sensible to consider the timings of any additional DC (that's if you want any more, obvs.) and to double up on contraception so you're not stuck in this phase for longer/

Iamasingingtelegram · 05/02/2022 18:52

@FangsForTheMemory

Is he deliberately staying in his current job because it gives him an excuse for not doing his share of childcare?
I can’t be sure, and he’d never say so, but it is easier in many ways to go out to work!
OP posts:
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/02/2022 18:51

@Iamasingingtelegram

I’ll go back three days a week but will have to do all getting ready, drop off and pick up so will have to stretch my hours across more days.

What id like is for DH to apply for jobs that have fewer hours (eg 9-5) and/or WFH and/or flexible hour options.

His current role would never allow for a change in his hours.

So is it only three mornings a week you'll need his help?
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/02/2022 18:50

@Classicblunder

Many jobs are set hours and that's that - there is no other choice unless you change jobs.

That is exactly what the OP is suggesting he do! This isn't a great well paid job, he doesn't even like it so why not look for a new one?

But how many jobs are out there that a) pay well enough to help support a family of five and b) have the hours OP is after?

I'm not saying he shouldn't look, but I think you need to be realistic - lots of people don't have the skill se to apply for these well paying, flexible jobs.

Myhusbandisadick · 05/02/2022 18:49

He works a full day then helps in the evening. What do you want him to do exactly?

I think he should be able to choose his job as long as he's not being massively unreasonable!

RobertaFirmino · 05/02/2022 18:49

For the same salary (or probably higher) he could work an hour less a day and be more help with the kids. He might even get flexible hours or work from home options (no chance in current job)

None of this is guaranteed though. It's all 'he could, he might', not 'he will'. Of course, there is nothing to stop him from trying but it's in no way a cert.

In the meantime, what can you both do to make mornings easier? If DH did decide to look for a new job, it could take months. That's no use when you're being driven to tears. 3 under 5 is obviously going to be a complete nightmare but I'm sure there are plenty of mothers here who could tell you how they managed. There's a wealth of advice here on MN, all you need to do is ask!

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/02/2022 18:47

@Bintymcbintface

Why does everyone think that DH can just easily change his hours or find another job?! This he's selfish because he won't go flex-time/find another job is insane to me as really it isn't always that easy. If he lost the job he had because of covid he hasn't been in this role very long so it's unlikely that he can just start dictating his hour or requesting changes when OP has had a year to figure things out from her end
Because this is MN where anyone can just change jobs and working hours at the drop of a hat Grin

It's bonkers. I've never, ever worked a job where you can just decide to change your hours so you can do the school run. The hours are set, or if you are allowed to change your times, you just lose pay - there's no TOIL or coming in early to make up for it.

Iamasingingtelegram · 05/02/2022 18:47

I’ll go back three days a week but will have to do all getting ready, drop off and pick up so will have to stretch my hours across more days.

What id like is for DH to apply for jobs that have fewer hours (eg 9-5) and/or WFH and/or flexible hour options.

His current role would never allow for a change in his hours.

OP posts:
Classicblunder · 05/02/2022 18:47

Many jobs are set hours and that's that - there is no other choice unless you change jobs.

That is exactly what the OP is suggesting he do! This isn't a great well paid job, he doesn't even like it so why not look for a new one?

StatisticallyChallenged · 05/02/2022 18:44

@Bintymcbintface

Why does everyone think that DH can just easily change his hours or find another job?! This he's selfish because he won't go flex-time/find another job is insane to me as really it isn't always that easy. If he lost the job he had because of covid he hasn't been in this role very long so it's unlikely that he can just start dictating his hour or requesting changes when OP has had a year to figure things out from her end
It's selfish because he isn't even willing to try; he's decided that he's happy, he's staying put, and therefore OP has to solve the issue and be responsible for all the morning running around whether she likes it or not.

Why is that ok? She's going to be back at work too, he's not supporting the family alone. Sometimes jobs are inflexible and especially if one person earns the majority of the household income then it has to be like this to make things work but if he's in a low paid role then (once OP return from mat leave) that's probably not the case.

If he was trying and couldn't find anything else then fair enough. But he isn't.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/02/2022 18:43

He doesn't have to support a family of 5, the OP also works, she is just on mat leave.

I know he doesn't do it alone, but generally you need two incomes to support three small children.

And it's perfectly possible to work fairly standard hours and do some pick ups and drop offs - nursery is usually 8-6, ditto wraparound care.

Absolutely, I never said otherwise. But it does depend on your job, your commute etc.

The whole point of the OP is that she has to work her hours around the children because he is refusing to

Refusing to or unable to? I don't know where all these jobs are that you can just demand flexible working and change your start/finish times to collect the children.

Many jobs are set hours and that's that - there is no other choice unless you change jobs.

fuckoffjournalists · 05/02/2022 18:34

Really not good enough at all in your partner, and co-parent with as much responsibility for your shared children as you, he dosen’t need to help, he needs to do his share. He has the easy job here.

Bintymcbintface · 05/02/2022 18:31

Why does everyone think that DH can just easily change his hours or find another job?! This he's selfish because he won't go flex-time/find another job is insane to me as really it isn't always that easy. If he lost the job he had because of covid he hasn't been in this role very long so it's unlikely that he can just start dictating his hour or requesting changes when OP has had a year to figure things out from her end

Classicblunder · 05/02/2022 18:24

*But let's be fair - very few jobs allow people to do pick-ups and drop-offs and provide enough income to support a family of five. Unless you're really high up the scale (management and above) - you can generally pick one or the other - money or flexibility - it's rarely ever both.

Also, all OP has said is that she'll be working her hours around school and nursery - she doesn't say how much she earns (ie. is she the breadwinner or not) or even whether she'll be going back full-time.*

He doesn't have to support a family of 5, the OP also works, she is just on mat leave. And it's perfectly possible to work fairly standard hours and do some pick ups and drop offs - nursery is usually 8-6, ditto wraparound care.

The whole point of the OP is that she has to work her hours around the children because he is refusing to

Classicblunder · 05/02/2022 18:21

*Or is being flexible only the job of the woman.

I don't think anyone has said that, have they?*

It's pretty strongly implied - if the OP should be happy doing all the pickups and dropoffs because he helps when he gets home, that is her doing all the flexibility

Bintymcbintface · 05/02/2022 18:18

@fairylightsandwaxmelts

Well if it is the better paid job, it is important.

Absolutely, so she needs to clarify that.

He IS being selfish if he remains in a low paying job which doesn't allow him to share the parenting load.

From what I've read, the only thing he doesn't/can't do is help in the mornings. OP has said he does his fair share of housework, after school jobs, bedtimes and weekends.

Not everyone has the means to get a job that's well-paid with lots of flexibility. It doesn't make them selfish.

His wife is struggling and the thought of returning to work and carrying the stress of every bit of childcare when there could be an easier way is stressing her further.

But we don't know if there's an easier way - theoretically, there may be, but you have to be realistic. Very few people can just walk into a new job that's well-paid and flexible.

Childcare may be stressful but so is working full-time and supporting your family. I don't think playing stress top-trumps is helpful, really, especially as OP does say he does his fair share outside of work.

He is selfish if he refuses to explore options.

Is he? Should he do a job that makes him miserable so that OP has help for five hours a week?

Or is being flexible only the job of the woman.

I don't think anyone has said that, have they?

Thank you for putting what I was trying to say much more eloquently than I have managed to
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/02/2022 18:12

Well if it is the better paid job, it is important.

Absolutely, so she needs to clarify that.

He IS being selfish if he remains in a low paying job which doesn't allow him to share the parenting load.

From what I've read, the only thing he doesn't/can't do is help in the mornings. OP has said he does his fair share of housework, after school jobs, bedtimes and weekends.

Not everyone has the means to get a job that's well-paid with lots of flexibility. It doesn't make them selfish.

His wife is struggling and the thought of returning to work and carrying the stress of every bit of childcare when there could be an easier way is stressing her further.

But we don't know if there's an easier way - theoretically, there may be, but you have to be realistic. Very few people can just walk into a new job that's well-paid and flexible.

Childcare may be stressful but so is working full-time and supporting your family. I don't think playing stress top-trumps is helpful, really, especially as OP does say he does his fair share outside of work.

He is selfish if he refuses to explore options.

Is he? Should he do a job that makes him miserable so that OP has help for five hours a week?

Or is being flexible only the job of the woman.

I don't think anyone has said that, have they?

Luredbyapomegranate · 05/02/2022 18:05

Yep, if he can do a different but similarly ok job for the same money and better hours then he needs to do that. Just tell him - if neither of you are high earners then you need to work in a way that works for the whole family. If you are a significantly higher earner then if anything working hours should swing in your favour.

It might be selfishness/unwillingness to pick up more domestic work, might also be anxiety/lack of confidence in applying for something new? - so approach in a little tactfully, but be very firm.

Bintymcbintface · 05/02/2022 17:42

@billy1966

Well if it is the better paid job, it is important.

She is returning to work and is clearly struggling with the stress of it all.

He IS being selfish if he remains in a low paying job which doesn't allow him to share the parenting load.

His wife is struggling and the thought of returning to work and carrying the stress of every bit of childcare when there could be an easier way is stressing her further.

He is selfish if he refuses to explore options.

Or is being flexible only the job of the woman.

Who's job pays the most, and by how much OP?

Where are you all where its possible to walk out of one job and into a super flexible better paid one so easily?!

I hate my job but have a home to pay for and ds to provide for, it's not the best paid job in the world but others out there need years of experience or a degree I don't have. OP states that she didn't expect DH to be a high earner which would imply he doesn't have a degree or experience in a skilled field so his options are limited too. I'd get it if DH was out of work and not mucking in but being out at work all day and coming home and making dinner, tending to the kids and other household tasks isn't selfish at all. OP has been on mat leave so has presumably had a year to work this out, being annoyed DH won't move out of a secure "low paid" job imo is more selfish than staying put when he has limited options himself

Hankunamatata · 05/02/2022 17:27

He used to work 9-5 until covid and he lost his job. I think yabu. The only thing that's changed is he cant help on a morning. You would have still had to do pick ups and dinner.

You say he comes home and mucks in with dinner and getting kids ready for bed etc.

If you want more help then you pay for daycare and afterschool care like most other parents who both work full time

Spectre8 · 05/02/2022 17:26

@Mummytobe93

Why do people not discuss those things BEFORE having 2-3 kids, all under 5 and mother at wits end?
This 100%!

What did you expect if you had so many children.

He isn't staying in the job to avoid doing the drop off and pick ups. He is staying cos whilst he might hate the actual work being in company of people he enjoys for 8hrs of the working day makes it bearable.

There are times I've stayed in a job because of people, lets face it in my experience its the same shit different door when you change jobs. Better for his mental health if he is working with people he enjoys.

He comes home and does his share.

Maybe next time you decide to have another child have a discussion about it and how you'll manage your time and finances.

billy1966 · 05/02/2022 17:25

Well if it is the better paid job, it is important.

She is returning to work and is clearly struggling with the stress of it all.

He IS being selfish if he remains in a low paying job which doesn't allow him to share the parenting load.

His wife is struggling and the thought of returning to work and carrying the stress of every bit of childcare when there could be an easier way is stressing her further.

He is selfish if he refuses to explore options.

Or is being flexible only the job of the woman.

Who's job pays the most, and by how much OP?

Bintymcbintface · 05/02/2022 17:17

@billy1966

It's selfish because he swans out the door to a low paying job and will leave the OP to get 3 children out the door and she has to work around all drops and pick ups.

It's selfish because he could get a job that helped more with the drops and collections of 3 children.

It is selfish because he is staying in a badly paid job because of friends.

Taking on a job you hate after losing one isn't selfish, nor is finding a silver lining by making friends and staying because of them in a really volatile job market. He's working full time and supporting his family and taking on the household tasks and dc when he's home. Nursery pick up and drop off, many struggle with this, why are DC in nursery when OP has been on mat leave and home anyway? I still don't see the selfishness, it sounds like op resents the low paid job DH has and thinks that her job is more important
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/02/2022 17:15

@Classicblunder

What is this dream job that allows employees to pick their hours and be available for drop offs and pick ups, while simultaneously paying enough money to support a family of five?

How is this impossible for a man but the OP can find one?

I didn't say it was impossible though, did I?

But let's be fair - very few jobs allow people to do pick-ups and drop-offs and provide enough income to support a family of five. Unless you're really high up the scale (management and above) - you can generally pick one or the other - money or flexibility - it's rarely ever both.

Also, all OP has said is that she'll be working her hours around school and nursery - she doesn't say how much she earns (ie. is she the breadwinner or not) or even whether she'll be going back full-time.

With three small children, unless someone earns big money, you generally have to sacrifice someone's career somewhere, or the childcare costs are going to totally cripple you.

Loopytiles · 05/02/2022 17:06

It’s not ‘childcare’ or ‘helping’ it’s parenting and as much his responsibility as yours.

As he’s a low earner, unwilling to seek to earn more, it’s even more important than it usually is for mothers that you maximise your earnings. Often, reducing or ‘flexing’ hours leads to negative impact on career and earnings. So would look for good childcare and work full time.

If he has alternative job options that would mean he could cover the parenting (including drop offs or pick ups) one end of the weekdays, or some of them, then yes, he’s behaviour is selfish.

Swipe left for the next trending thread