Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or is DH selfish

139 replies

Iamasingingtelegram · 05/02/2022 12:24

DH works 8-5 in a low paid job. He doesn’t like the job particularly and the says the company is awful, but he works with friends so likes that.
We have 3 small children, oldest due to start school this year.
He can’t help with getting them ready in the morning, getting them to nursery if they are going, picking them up, doing tea etc. when he gets home he helps with bath and bed.
My maternity leave finishes soon and I’ll have to work my hours around school and nursery.
For the same salary (or probably higher) he could work an hour less a day and be more help with the kids. He might even get flexible hours or work from home options (no chance in current job).
I never wanted life to be like this, where I do so much of the childcare. I’d always hoped for more balance. However he is working full time so I get it falls to me as I’m on maternity. But even when I go back it will still fall to me and because my job is more flexible I will have to make it flex.
I’ve told him I’m not enjoying things at the moment. Got a young baby who cries a lot, a wilful toddler and a four year old who wants a lot of attention. I’m often reduced to tears with frustration in getting out in the morning, not to mention feeling so down about the constant housework and mum admin.
His job is going nowhere and has no perks. I think he should look for something else, AIBU?

OP posts:
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/02/2022 19:59

Here is where she said she is having to change her hours to stretch them over more days because he can't do drop offs any more

But she's still only working part-time to his full-time, so why shouldn't she be doing more of the school runs?

If she doesn't want that stress/responsibility, she could always go back full-time and the DC could be in full-time childcare. Plenty of childminders start at 7am to accommodate full-time working parents, or they could employ a part-time nanny or sitter to do mornings and evenings.

Staffy1 · 05/02/2022 19:58

I think YABU. It’s not just that easy to change jobs and I would resent it if someone expected me to look around for a different job for their sake.

Iamasingingtelegram · 05/02/2022 19:58

DD1 in preschool until 3:30. That’s what time it closes. DS in nursery until 3:45 to sync. DD2 at home.

My hope would be something like that if DH didn’t start til 9 he could do drop offs on days what I work. I could then start really early to then get away early to do pick ups.

OP posts:
Classicblunder · 05/02/2022 19:54

@Iamasingingtelegram

I’ll go back three days a week but will have to do all getting ready, drop off and pick up so will have to stretch my hours across more days.

What id like is for DH to apply for jobs that have fewer hours (eg 9-5) and/or WFH and/or flexible hour options.

His current role would never allow for a change in his hours.

Here is where she said she is having to change her hours to stretch them over more days because he can't do drop offs any more
mummykel16 · 05/02/2022 19:54

Are you jealous he works with friends op?

Chichimcgee · 05/02/2022 19:53

Secondly, she has had to change her working hours to accommodate his

Nowhere has she said this. At the end of the day most people have to sacrifice for the kids, op doesn’t want to do majority of childcare but decided to have 3 children very close together. How is 3 school runs a week going to make any difference?

The fact he comes home, cooks dinner and spends time with his kids essentially means he doesn’t stop 8am-8pm (assuming 8pm bedtime) op said he does a lot at the weekend. Is it really worth disrupting a secure job and making him do even more? It seems to me that OP should be doing more, not him.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/02/2022 19:52

Firstly, she isn't asking him to quit, just apply for jobs that work better around family life, which she herself has done

He already works a job that fits around family life. He is around every single evening and all weekend. 8-5 is a standard working day for millions of full-time working parents up and down the country.

Secondly, she has had to change her working hours to accommodate his - this has likely come at some cost to her career prospects which may well from the sounds of things be better than his

But he had no choice but to change his hours in the first place. He lost his job and with three young children, he needed to work and couldn't afford to be fussy.

And she didn't have to change her hours - she could also go and work full-time and put the DC in full-time childcare, the same as millions of other dual-income households do.

WorriedGiraffe · 05/02/2022 19:48

Firstly, she isn't asking him to quit, just apply for jobs that work better around family life, which she herself has done

How’s that not asking him to quit? She’s not asking him to get a second job is she?

mummykel16 · 05/02/2022 19:45

@Chichimcgee

I just don't get how anyone can see this as unreasonable

Imagine it the other way round

‘my husband is on paternity leave, when he goes back to work it’s part time and flexible. I work full time 8-5, get home and make him and the kids dinner, bath the kids and read stories. I do my fair share of cleaning and housework and am a hands on mum at the weekend.
DH wants me to quit my secure job despite losing my last job due to covid so I can do the school run 3x a week as he finds it difficult.’

Does that really seem fair to you?

It's selfish.
WorriedGiraffe · 05/02/2022 19:45

Is your job higher paid? You only work part time but want him to cut his hours more so that he can do drop offs even though your job is flexible enough to allow it. I think YABU, I get it’s hard, but that’s because your have 3 small children so it’s hard no matter what you do. There’s a lot to be said for not job jumping when he already lost a job due to the pandemic, and he already does his fair share whenever he’s home, and he works more hours than you. It all sounds pretty evenly split to me.

Classicblunder · 05/02/2022 19:45

@Chichimcgee

I just don't get how anyone can see this as unreasonable

Imagine it the other way round

‘my husband is on paternity leave, when he goes back to work it’s part time and flexible. I work full time 8-5, get home and make him and the kids dinner, bath the kids and read stories. I do my fair share of cleaning and housework and am a hands on mum at the weekend.
DH wants me to quit my secure job despite losing my last job due to covid so I can do the school run 3x a week as he finds it difficult.’

Does that really seem fair to you?

But it's not accurate?

In two ways

Firstly, she isn't asking him to quit, just apply for jobs that work better around family life, which she herself has done

Secondly, she has had to change her working hours to accommodate his - this has likely come at some cost to her career prospects which may well from the sounds of things be better than his

TrufflesAndToast · 05/02/2022 19:44

@Classicblunder

I really despair at the low standards for men. Apparently it's "plenty" that he helps after work, totally impossible to find a low paid job with perfectly standard not especially flexible hours like 9-5. If the OP decided to do that and leave her DH to figure out the childcare that he has also had a year to think about, no one would tell him that she did plenty and to stop whining
He has a stable full time job which he enjoys and works full time as the main earner. His hours aren’t that unusual, it’s not like he works nights or something. It also means he’s around plenty at the end of the day. Lots of full time working partners barely make it home before kids are in bed.

If a woman was being told by her part time working husband to leave the stable full time job that she enjoys and which supports her family, because he wanted her to do more school runs (while continuing to work part time himself) he would be handed his arse on here.

If the Op wants to tell her husband to figure out childcare himself he would be well within his rights to tell her to figure out meeting half of all household and living costs herself.

MN is usually very pro women but many posters are pointing out that this one is pretty unreasonable.

TrufflesAndToast · 05/02/2022 19:39

I’m not trying to be horrible or unhelpful but honestly, three children under four when you’re on low incomes is a lot for anyone to deal with. Did you not discuss the balance of work/childcare etc before each subsequent baby? If you’re unhappy with him not doing drop offs, what was decided before you decided to have a third baby? If you want things to be more equal then you would work full time as well - if you do three days to his full time and your job is flexible then I’m struggling to see why you wouldn’t do the drop offs etc. Three children especially that close in age was always going to be insanely hard work and I’m not surprised you’re struggling to get ready in the morning but I can’t help thinking did you not expect that when you already had two and went for a third?! What plans were made then?

Not trying to be a twat honestly and I know the kids are here now etc etc I’m just always a bit baffled when people with several kids and a low income seem surprised things are hard!

Tohaveandtohold · 05/02/2022 19:39

I can’t see what he has done wrong here either. He works and the times he’s not working, he does his fair share of the household tasks.
The op wants him to find a 9-5 job which is not easy to go by in this climate especially if he’s not educated or skilled.
He needs to try to develop himself anyway but op just needs to be realistic as he may get a 9-5 job and it might include some weekend work, it may be at a distance making it impossible to do the school run, etc.
The morning in the three days you work will be tricky for both of you no matter what because you have three children under 4, you just need to be realistic in your expectations.

AlDanvers · 05/02/2022 19:37

Op has avoided saying why he doesn't do pick ups.

So I am guessing he does.

Chichimcgee · 05/02/2022 19:36

I just don't get how anyone can see this as unreasonable

Imagine it the other way round

‘my husband is on paternity leave, when he goes back to work it’s part time and flexible. I work full time 8-5, get home and make him and the kids dinner, bath the kids and read stories. I do my fair share of cleaning and housework and am a hands on mum at the weekend.
DH wants me to quit my secure job despite losing my last job due to covid so I can do the school run 3x a week as he finds it difficult.’

Does that really seem fair to you?

AlDanvers · 05/02/2022 19:33

That isn't the point - it is that she has had to change her working hours because he has changed his and he has no plans to look for work which would help him to take anything approaching equal responsibility for his kids

Not doing 3 school runs a week is not, not doing your fair share.

He didn't change his hours. He lost his job in a pandemic and got another one.

Op says she has flexibility. If a man had flexibility he would be expect to exercise it.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/02/2022 19:32

@Classicblunder

If a man suggested his wife change jobs because he found the school run too stressful, he would be slaughtered

That isn't the point - it is that she has had to change her working hours because he has changed his and he has no plans to look for work which would help him to take anything approaching equal responsibility for his kids.

But he didn't have a choice! He lost his job due to COVID - he didn't decide to pick a job with awkward hours - he needed to work and took a job that he dislikes because there are bills to be paid.

And the school run is a TINY part of raising kids. Loads of parents don't or can't do school runs, it doesn't mean they're selfish or bad parents who aren't taking responsibility.

My dad did all the school runs when I was growing up because my mum worked an inflexible job - does that mean she didn't take equal responsibility for me?

AlDanvers · 05/02/2022 19:31

The OP has said this already - it is not some incredibly fancy complex working pattern which would help...

But that's assuming he finds a 9-5 that will allow him to drop at nursery and time to get to work.

So a 9-5 needs to be close enough to do it.

Being able to do it in one job, doesn't mean you can do it in all jobs even if the hours are the same.

I agree above, a man saying he can't cope doing 3 school runs, despite being lucky enough to have a flexible job and wants his wife to change jobs to do it, would be told to suck it up.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/02/2022 19:29

@Chichimcgee

So they lose 5 hours a week of paid work so he can do the school run on 3 days?

Never mind that even with op on maternity leave he’s coming home, cooking tea, bathing kids, reading stories, doing housework? It’s up to him to give up a secure job, find another one, just to do the school run?

Exactly, and it's not even just losing five hours a week, it's the lack of security that comes with changing jobs in an unstable market.

It seems bonkers (to me) to give up a consistent, stable job that leaves him free in the evenings and at weekends for the sake of doing his "fair share" of the school run three days a week.

Classicblunder · 05/02/2022 19:29

@Iamasingingtelegram

I’ll go back three days a week but will have to do all getting ready, drop off and pick up so will have to stretch my hours across more days.

What id like is for DH to apply for jobs that have fewer hours (eg 9-5) and/or WFH and/or flexible hour options.

His current role would never allow for a change in his hours.

I just don't get how anyone can see this as unreasonable
Classicblunder · 05/02/2022 19:27

If a man suggested his wife change jobs because he found the school run too stressful, he would be slaughtered

That isn't the point - it is that she has had to change her working hours because he has changed his and he has no plans to look for work which would help him to take anything approaching equal responsibility for his kids.

Bintymcbintface · 05/02/2022 19:26

@Classicblunder

Why should he have to change job again to accommodate OPs pt job??

This is my point about standards for men. It isn't to accommodate her job, it's to take responsibility for his children.

He is taking responsibility for his children by being out working full time to provide for them and then taking over the childcare and household chores when he's home... I'm honestly amazed that people are thinking the bloke is selfish because OP finds the school run hard. If it was the other way round and a guy came on and said his wife should change job because he can't cope with the morning rush 3 days a week he'd be called a lazy bastard and the wife would be told to leave him
Chichimcgee · 05/02/2022 19:26

So they lose 5 hours a week of paid work so he can do the school run on 3 days?

Never mind that even with op on maternity leave he’s coming home, cooking tea, bathing kids, reading stories, doing housework? It’s up to him to give up a secure job, find another one, just to do the school run?

Classicblunder · 05/02/2022 19:23

@Iamasingingtelegram

In a previous role he did 9-5 and dropped off kids in morning
The OP has said this already - it is not some incredibly fancy complex working pattern which would help...
Swipe left for the next trending thread