Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you sleep trained your baby

411 replies

babyjellyfish · 05/02/2022 11:12

What approach did you take, how old was your baby and how successful was it?

Looking for a range of views and experiences.

Thank you.

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 07/02/2022 02:32

I am losing my mind.

This kid just doesn't want to sleep between midnight and 4am.

I don't know what to do.

OP posts:
Bizawit · 07/02/2022 01:13

@RidingMyBike

Look up the Emily Oster book 'Cribsheet'. She assesses the actual research into all sorts of baby stuff (sleep, feeding, childcare etc) for quality and what it's actually saying. Sleep training doesn't cause harm. Children abandoned in orphanages and never responded to are harmed. But that isn't sleep training and doesn't mean leaving them to cry for hours. There are various methods of doing it, stick with one for a while and see how you get on.

FWIW we needed a baby who slept well (I had severe PND and we had zero family support) and did the 'pause' method from a few weeks old. She slept thru from about 6-8 weeks old and has been a good sleeper ever since (now 6yo). Sleep deprivation is dangerous and has similar effects to drink driving. Which is illegal! One of my friends crashed on the motorway after barely getting enough sleep because her baby had her up so often.

Good luck OP and I hope you can get it sorted soon - having a good night's sleep makes such a difference to how you're feeling.

I don’t think you can “measure” whether sleep training causes harm through that kind of research. I think the truth is we don’t know what the long term psychological effects may be- just as it would be difficult to measure the isolated impact of any single traumatic event in childhood. I agree with a PP - some of the wilder claims of those apposed to sleep training (eg it causes “brain damage”) are pretty fantastical, but in general it’s probably not a good idea to do something that strongly violates your instincts as a mother (eg leave a small baby to cry). On the other hand sometimes you have to do what you have to do, and it may be the lesser of two evils for parents who really aren’t coping.
GinAndTopic · 06/02/2022 23:44

Oh bless 🙂 good luck, hard working out what's best, I would just say changing routine needs commitment and consistency so stick with it dont chop and change

RidingMyBike · 06/02/2022 22:51

Look up the Emily Oster book 'Cribsheet'. She assesses the actual research into all sorts of baby stuff (sleep, feeding, childcare etc) for quality and what it's actually saying. Sleep training doesn't cause harm. Children abandoned in orphanages and never responded to are harmed. But that isn't sleep training and doesn't mean leaving them to cry for hours. There are various methods of doing it, stick with one for a while and see how you get on.

FWIW we needed a baby who slept well (I had severe PND and we had zero family support) and did the 'pause' method from a few weeks old. She slept thru from about 6-8 weeks old and has been a good sleeper ever since (now 6yo). Sleep deprivation is dangerous and has similar effects to drink driving. Which is illegal! One of my friends crashed on the motorway after barely getting enough sleep because her baby had her up so often.

Good luck OP and I hope you can get it sorted soon - having a good night's sleep makes such a difference to how you're feeling.

MatronicO6 · 06/02/2022 21:52

So this is something that is very contentious as people have different views, even in my own circle of friends.
Been in two minds about doing it or not, but one of my friend's had twins and basically sleep trained by chance as she simply couldn't pick both up. But they ending up sleeping so well. My nephew, the same age, wasn't at all and was and still is a terrible sleeper.
I have babysat both, the twins were far easier. I think the hardest part will be getting over the guilt of simply letting your baby cry, and I don't think it is going to be easy for me. But I believe it works so I'm going to give it a go.

JustAnotherUserinParadise · 06/02/2022 21:40

I was similar to you op, it was OK while I was on maternity leave, but when I went back to work, I realised after the first week that I just needed more sleep to be productive, so that Friday night we started with the controlled crying.
Honestly those 2 nights were horrible, I made dh do it, but it was so so worth it! I feel orders of magnitude better!

Giraffesandbottoms · 06/02/2022 21:30

It does take a week or so to see results from moving naps etc so stick with it

babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 21:20

I was considering trying to do one nap today and see what happened but he was rubbing his eyes by 10am. That said, maybe that's because he was awake half the night. It's a vicious circle. But this afternoon he only had a crappy short nap, so maybe he'll be tired enough to sleep tonight...

OP posts:
HorseInTheHouse · 06/02/2022 21:11

Obviously an overtired baby is counterproductive as it won't make them sleep more, but it could be that you've currently got an undertired baby. It's tricky to get that sweet spot!

HorseInTheHouse · 06/02/2022 21:09

10 months is the earlier side of normal for going to one nap, but honestly you might find it better. He's currently doing 3-3.5 hours in two chunks, but is he desperate for that first nap or could he hang on for another hour and a half? Early lunch at 11, down to nap at 11.30, he might well do the whole 3-3.5 hours in one go leaving him nice and tired for bed time.

For my two children the routine was much better after the transition to one big nap.

Continentalmama · 06/02/2022 21:06

Yes, only regret I have was not doing it sooner with DC1.

Petrarkanian · 06/02/2022 20:28

Yes, both at 8 months with CC. They are now 19, 15. No long term effects.

babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 20:22

Yes I think I will speak to the childminder tomorrow about that second nap.

We can't feasibly move bedtime any earlier (so that'll be fun when he drops to one nap) but we can probably increase that last wake window.

We are trying the gradual retreat method, starting tonight. Just sitting in the dark stroking his little hand now.

OP posts:
Bizawit · 06/02/2022 19:56

He’s probably just going through a developmental stage. I think there is a horrible regression around 9-10 months. Everything is a phase- it will get better with time..

RandomMess · 06/02/2022 19:28

I suppose I would move him into his cot in his room. If he is happily awake during the night and not disturbing you then it's less of an issue.
That may take some time to achieve.

His big daytime nap is too late. It would probably work better if his first nap were longer and then he went to bed at 7pm without a second nap.

Thanks
Sexnotgender · 06/02/2022 19:21

I’d definitely play with the daytime sleep. My daughter is roughly ages with your baby and I do a 1/2 hour nap 9.30-10 (give or take 15 minutes) if she’s still sleeping I wake her.
Then her lunchtime nap is around 12.30/1 for about 1.5 hours. Bedtime is 6.30, she wakes at 7am.

secretllama · 06/02/2022 18:57

@jgjgjgjgjg

Sleep training does not teach babies not to have needs, it just teaches them not to continue expressing their needs. It breaks the link between a baby signalling that they need help and an adult responding. Personally that's nor what I want for my children.
Do you think sleep trained babies won't still cry for their parents on the nights when they are ill? Because they do. It doesn't change them into non-crying robots.
Giraffesandbottoms · 06/02/2022 18:53

The last nap is far too late! You usually want 5 hours between last nap and bed time, at this age. I would try to change naps first of all as that’s usually easiest. Perhaps push first nap back 30-60 mins and hope it lasts a bit longer and then scrap the second. Or wake him up at 3 from the second.

No idea re the meds.

FWIW I’m not sure it’s possible to really see “trauma” in a child from this sort of thing. Or many things. Doesn’t mean there hasn’t been an impact.

I wouldn’t focus on what anyone else says anyway, really, I would think about what’s best for your family.

babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 18:45

@Giraffesandbottoms

What time are his naps currently and for how long?
Usually about 10-11 and then 2-4 or 4:30. Bedtime is 8pm. I think the afternoon nap may be too long. He naps much longer and more successfully with the childminder than he does at home. (So we know he is capable of sleeping in a cot.)
OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 18:43

Another thing I should mention is that he is taking propranolol for an infantile hemangioma. This is relevant for two reasons. Firstly, it can cause sleep disturbances. Secondly, he needs to take it first thing in the morning on a full stomach, which means I shouldn't really feed him after about 3am at the latest because if I do he isn't hungry enough in the morning and can't take his medication.

I discussed his sleep with the doctor at his last appointment and I said it's difficult to know for sure whether the medication has affected his sleep or not because it wasn't great beforehand. She basically said that if we are letting him sleep with us, of course he doesn't want to go to sleep because being with mum and dad is much more fun, and we need to put him in his own room and be a bit tougher with him.

We live in a country where maternity leave is only 16 weeks, usually 6 weeks pre due date and 10 weeks post birth, and most babies are in full time childcare from the time they are about 3 or 4 months old. Most are also formula fed from that time onwards, if not from the beginning. Most people here would consider me to be practically a hippy given that I went back to work when he was 7 months old and am still breastfeeding. So the advice here is pretty much, he should be in his own bed all night every night and definitely shouldn't still be feeding overnight. The children here don't seem traumatised, for what it's worth.

OP posts:
Giraffesandbottoms · 06/02/2022 18:38

What time are his naps currently and for how long?

babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 18:36

[quote Shitandhills]@babyjellyfish my advice would be for you and hubby to tag team every other night and for the sleeper to go to a different room with 'deep sleeps' wax earplugs, go to bed super early, catch up on sleep at the weekends, take a holiday day here and there to sleep and just wait it out. Things get better over time, there is so much going on developmentally in the first year or so that can affect sleep, but it does end. Download the wonder weeks app if you haven't already.

Or you can sleep train, but you'll need to make peace with the fact that a lot of people feel it is cruel and the longterm effects are unknown. Yes, there are no credible studies proving it is harmful, but equally there are also no credible studies that show it isn't.[/quote]
That's what we're currently doing and we're at our wits' end.

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 18:35

@HorseInTheHouse

Have you tried playing around with daytime naps? If he's just awake for ages in the night and doesn't seem tired, could he be sleeping too much in the day or finishing his last nap too late?

I assume you're not interacting with him unless it's necessary.

Have you ever tried having him in a separate room to you? If he's basically happy during his midnight parties, would he just chat to himself and roll around happily by himself in a cot without you? What would happen?

There's really nothing in the current situation that you can change with sleep training so I think you might be on the wrong track. He already seems to know how to fall asleep by himself and he's not distressed, so it seems like the main problem is he's just not tired?

Sleeping too long during the day might be the culprit but it's hard to tell. I've said to the childminder that we are going to spend a couple of weeks really working on night time sleep but if it doesn't improve we want to reduce his daytime naps. I don't think he's anywhere near ready to go down to one nap per day though.

We have had brief, not very successful stints of putting him in his own room. Basically, for a while it was a choice between him crying in his own room or sleeping soundly in our bed, so we went for the bedsharing option. But now it's between him crying in his own room or pratting about all night in our bed and none of us getting any sleep, we are having to re-evaluate.

OP posts:
edenhills · 06/02/2022 18:29

Yes did controlled crying at 9 months, took three days and they have both been great sleepers since. Currently lovely and well adjusted 12 year olds. We are much better parents when we get enough sleep. Would do it again in a heartbeat.

Rosieposie101 · 06/02/2022 18:28

No. I didn't with any of them and I wouldn't if I had another. I think it's quite barbaric if I'm honest.

Swipe left for the next trending thread