Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you sleep trained your baby

411 replies

babyjellyfish · 05/02/2022 11:12

What approach did you take, how old was your baby and how successful was it?

Looking for a range of views and experiences.

Thank you.

OP posts:
Piglet89 · 07/02/2022 18:05

@babyjellyfish maybe ask @mnhq to change the “if” in the title of your thread to “how”.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 07/02/2022 18:01

OP, your thread title asks a very simple question: 'AIBU to ask if you sleep trained your baby?'

I didn't. You requested a range of experiences, so I briefly posted a response, with an equally brief explanation as to why not. Had circumstances changed, perhaps with a 3-year old who still didn't sleep, then things would have been different. To me, SIDS was a legitimate concern pre-one.

That's all. I wasn't criticizing you, or conflating cry it out with other forms of sleep training which might not be as damaging. I followed precisely the brief you gave in your post: no more, no less.

RoastedTurnip · 07/02/2022 17:42

Just on the day Vs night, we found that once night was sorted, days worked afterwards and sorted themselves.

www.mybabysleepguide.com/2013/02/average-sleep-charts-by-age.html?m=1&fbclid=IwAR0bLCT6fcV3fH9pmM_-JQSo7SMtvM6tcjlYu8io_xywd2V6_MYrIfvzleE

We used this as a guide for dropping naps etc and found it really helpful.

I'd echo what everyone else with experience says- consistency is key. We literally wrote down our plan and agreed we'd stick to it for at least 5 days- otherwise any crying was 'wasted'. Neither of ours were left for more than 7 minutes at a time and both were sorted within 3 nights.

Parker231 · 07/02/2022 17:12

There is no way I could have coped with a year of sleepless nights, let alone 2.5 years.

Many on this thread have no idea of how sleep training can work. Our consultant stayed with us for three nights when DT’s were seven months. It was very calm and no crying to sleep. She was training DH and I how to perfect a routine. 100% worth everyone trying it.
When you’re back at work you have to have proper sleep!

BluebellCockleshell123 · 07/02/2022 17:07

Yes.

DS was 9 months old and I had been following my instincts, feeding on demand and had rarely had more than 2hrs continuous sleep since he had been born.

I figured that since he had been on solids from 6 months he was not waking because he was hungry so I decided to go for controlled crying. First night I went in to reassure him the first time he cried and then I left the room quickly. Then I doubled the number of minutes each time before I went in again. It took about 2 hours before he went to sleep…but he slept all night. The next night it took 30 minutes. The 3rd night he didn’t cry at all.

That first night was absolutely horrible but to be honest the whole thing saved my sanity. I wish I’d done it a bit earlier.

GrendelsGrandma · 07/02/2022 17:05

[quote Giraffesandbottoms]@Bizawit

Agree so much with everyone you’re writing.

It’s funny how I didn’t have to “teach” my 3 year old to sleep through, he just learnt around 2-2.5 after 2-2.5 years of feeding to sleep and cuddling (and being an awful sleep). Funnily enough they “learn” by themselves without having to leave them to cry for 49 mins as one PP did![/quote]
@Giraffesandbottoms

2.5 years of sleep deprivation would break some people.

If cuddling him to sleep throughout the night worked for you, great. That doesn't make it wrong that other people do it differently.

I think if you've spent 2.5 years of sleepless nights, you're inclined to think it must have been necessary and valuable, because otherwise why do all the extra work? In truth, they all sleep better eventually but sometimes it's worth giving them a nudge in the right direction.

EgSk · 07/02/2022 16:51

No . I don’t think it’s what best for my children or me.

My first born started sleeping through the night consistently by 10 months . My second born , who is 15 months, is very up and down with his sleep still. We on again off again coslept for the first year and he’s now transitioned to his crib . When he wakes up and cries I go in and nurse him or rock him. Sometimes he sleeps through the night. It’s been happening more and more recently🤞

ManicPixie · 07/02/2022 16:46

Yes. Best decision I ever made and I find the general aversion to it on certain sections of this site utterly perverse. It must have needlessly put off lots of parents who desperately needed it,

Giraffesandbottoms · 07/02/2022 16:39

@Bizawit

Agree so much with everyone you’re writing.

It’s funny how I didn’t have to “teach” my 3 year old to sleep through, he just learnt around 2-2.5 after 2-2.5 years of feeding to sleep and cuddling (and being an awful sleep). Funnily enough they “learn” by themselves without having to leave them to cry for 49 mins as one PP did!

Bizawit · 07/02/2022 16:35

@velvet24

Utter rubbish saying you are not teaching them a life skill!! Of course you are, they wont feel rejected or unloved or be mentally scarred for life ! Controlled crying done right is not cruel in any way, id rather do that for 3-4 nights than years of sleep deprivation for the entire family.
What “life skill” are you teaching them ? @velvet24
velvet24 · 07/02/2022 16:13

Utter rubbish saying you are not teaching them a life skill!! Of course you are, they wont feel rejected or unloved or be mentally scarred for life ! Controlled crying done right is not cruel in any way, id rather do that for 3-4 nights than years of sleep deprivation for the entire family.

Bizawit · 07/02/2022 14:28

And I certainly don’t “prefer” to stay awake with my baby. Who would prefer that?? Sleep deprivation is horrendous - that’s why it’s used as a form of torture!

Bizawit · 07/02/2022 14:26

[quote Porcupineintherough]@Bizawit who said anything about leaving the baby alone? Not me, not the vast majority of people on this thread.

Baby's are human just like the rest of us. What starts off as a primal need - waking to feed - becomes a habit. Sometimes stopping the offer of food stops the waking. When we offered ds1 everything (cuddles, company, a drink of water) except the milk he started sleeping through and we all felt better.

If you prefer to stay up with your children do so. No need to justify it through false claims. No need to attack others who make different choices.[/quote]
I’m not attacking anyone. I understand why people sleep train, and it may be the best choice for many families.
I just think it’s important to call a spade a spade- it drives me nuts when people say you are “teaching babies a valuable life skill” by not responding to their cries in the night.
You are right that when people say “sleep training” they can mean many different things, and also it’s a very different process for babies/
Toddlers of different ages.
I was speaking of the method where you “train” a young baby to sleep in a cot by themselves , through allowing them to cry until they are too exhausted to continue. (Not methods that involve simple things like dimming the lights/ nighttime routines etc.) in my experience the crying method is the only one that works for a very wakeful baby). In my experience the “sleep training” methods that work on young babies (who were previously not sleeping well) almost always involve a fair amount of crying , however they may be marketed by various sleep consultants etc.

babyjellyfish · 07/02/2022 14:24

[quote Shitandhills]@babyjellyfish Bingo! This is an absolute classic. I promise you his sleep will settle down once he nails crawling. In my experience, night parties aren't 'standard' wakefulness, there is ALWAYS something going on developmentally and they ALWAYS resolve themselves once that thing has been achieved. I'm not saying baby will suddenly start sleeping through, but the long stints awake will go away and those are the real killer.[/quote]
If that is the explanation, does that mean that reducing his daytime naps won't help?

Also, er, how long does it take them to nail it?

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 07/02/2022 14:22

@CrimbleCrumble1

If you can get him in his own cot in his own room he can be wide awake and singing on his own.
Unfortunately it's a choice between:
  1. Wide awake and singing in our bed; or
  2. Wide awake and sobbing his heart out in his own room.

We went for the cosleeping option when it was a choice between sleeping in our bed or crying in his, but that's not currently what's happening.

OP posts:
Shitandhills · 07/02/2022 14:17

@babyjellyfish Bingo! This is an absolute classic. I promise you his sleep will settle down once he nails crawling. In my experience, night parties aren't 'standard' wakefulness, there is ALWAYS something going on developmentally and they ALWAYS resolve themselves once that thing has been achieved. I'm not saying baby will suddenly start sleeping through, but the long stints awake will go away and those are the real killer.

Porcupineintherough · 07/02/2022 14:15

Babies

Porcupineintherough · 07/02/2022 14:14

@Bizawit who said anything about leaving the baby alone? Not me, not the vast majority of people on this thread.

Baby's are human just like the rest of us. What starts off as a primal need - waking to feed - becomes a habit. Sometimes stopping the offer of food stops the waking. When we offered ds1 everything (cuddles, company, a drink of water) except the milk he started sleeping through and we all felt better.

If you prefer to stay up with your children do so. No need to justify it through false claims. No need to attack others who make different choices.

CrimbleCrumble1 · 07/02/2022 14:07

If you can get him in his own cot in his own room he can be wide awake and singing on his own.

Bizawit · 07/02/2022 14:06

@babyjellyfish

Any baby is capable of falling asleep, they just prefer the company and cuddles - who wouldn’t?

Unfortunately mine doesn't just want company and cuddles, he also wants to be wide awake and singing for most of the night.

Yes I understand- sorry I didn’t mean to derail the thread by responding to another users comment.

There are various periods of “regression” where babies do end up being wakeful for hours in the night. My baby went through periods of this too and it was awful , so definitely feel your pain! And you absolutely need to do what you need to do to survive.

For what it’s worth, my understanding from the mums I know who’ve tried various things is that the “gentler” methods of sleep training are not particularly effective for a baby that is determined not to sleep- you may just end up with a couple of weeks of being up all night / trauma whilst you delay the inevitable. you may find you have to go for the extinction option if you don’t want to wait this phase out.

PotatoGoblins · 07/02/2022 14:05

I haven’t sleep trained any of my 3. I bedshared with all of them from birth.
I I did attempt it once with my eldest when she was about 10 months old due to pressure from family members telling me it wasn’t normal for her to still be sleeping with me. It was awful. The advice I was given was to let her cry for a couple of minutes before returning to the room to resettle. It felt so wrong. I lasted about 5 mins before I decided that it simply wasn’t worth it. Went straight back to bedsharing.
All of my DCs made the transition into their own beds around about their 2nd birthdays.
They are 6, 5 & 2 now and all sleep together in one room by their own choice. DCs 1 & 2 generally sleep through the night without a fuss. DC3 usually sleeps until around 2am, then makes her way into my room.
DC1 started sleeping through consistently from about 18 months old.
DC2 didn’t sleep through until he was 4.
DC3 has slept through a handful of times but is very easy to resettle.

babyjellyfish · 07/02/2022 14:00

Any baby is capable of falling asleep, they just prefer the company and cuddles - who wouldn’t?

Unfortunately mine doesn't just want company and cuddles, he also wants to be wide awake and singing for most of the night.

OP posts:
Bizawit · 07/02/2022 13:59

[quote Bizawit]**@HorseInTheHouse* @Porcupineintherough* yours is a convenient narrative spun to make parents feel better. Any baby is capable of falling asleep, they just prefer the company and cuddles - who wouldn’t? There are obvious , evolutionary reasons why babies are programmed to desire closeness and proximity to their caregivers. They are not yet cognitively able enough to understand that you are there just in the other room/ they are safe etc. the reason they learn to fall asleep without crying is they learn that no one will come, so they only cry when desperate- not just for comfort/ cuddles.
It’s a wonderful trick of logic @porcupine that you have persuaded yourself that what is cruel is to respond to their cries, rather than to leave them crying![/quote]
In fact breastmilk and cuddles is biologically designed to help babies sleep. The idea that babies need to be “taught to sleep” by leaving them in a cot on their own to cry is absolute codswollop.

babyjellyfish · 07/02/2022 13:58

[quote Shitandhills]@babyjellyfish did you download wonder weeks app? Just saw an update that the night partying has only been for a few weeks. It really sounds like this is a developmental leap - please do check on wonder weeks. Is baby learning to crawl/walk? Night time parties are frustrating, but they really are a sign of a developmental thing going on in the brain rather than a sleep thing.[/quote]
He's 10 months today and not crawling yet. He only started rolling at 7 months and still isn't hugely into it. We've got him a rubber play mat to help facilitate crawling and basically he can bum shuffle a little bit, very slowly, and he can shuffle backwards on his tummy (but not forwards), again very slowly, and sometimes he gets on all fours and rocks back and forth a bit. So I guess he might be on the point of crawling, or he might not. If we put things just out of his reach he will try and grab them by leaning forward but if he can't get them he'll lose interest and try and go for something nearer rather than making a real effort to move, if you see what I mean!

OP posts:
Bizawit · 07/02/2022 13:55

@HorseInTheHouse @Porcupineintherough yours is a convenient narrative spun to make parents feel better. Any baby is capable of falling asleep, they just prefer the company and cuddles - who wouldn’t? There are obvious , evolutionary reasons why babies are programmed to desire closeness and proximity to their caregivers. They are not yet cognitively able enough to understand that you are there just in the other room/ they are safe etc. the reason they learn to fall asleep without crying is they learn that no one will come, so they only cry when desperate- not just for comfort/ cuddles.
It’s a wonderful trick of logic @porcupine that you have persuaded yourself that what is cruel is to respond to their cries, rather than to leave them crying!