Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you sleep trained your baby

411 replies

babyjellyfish · 05/02/2022 11:12

What approach did you take, how old was your baby and how successful was it?

Looking for a range of views and experiences.

Thank you.

OP posts:
coraka · 08/02/2022 15:50

From Oster again: "I think it is fair to say that it would be good to have more data—it’s always good to have more data! And yes, it is possible that if we had more data, we would find some small negative effects. The studies we have are not perfect.

However, the idea that this uncertainty should lead us to avoid sleep training is flawed. Among other things, you could easily argue the opposite: maybe sleep training is very good for some kids—they really need the uninterrupted sleep—and there is a risk of damaging your child by not sleep training. There isn’t anything in the data that shows this, but there is similarly nothing to show that sleep training is bad.

You could also argue that the effects of maternal depression on children are long-lasting, and therefore this intervention may have beneficial long-term effects. This seems in many ways more plausible. You’ll have to make a choice about this without perfect data. (This is true of virtually all parenting choices. Blame the parenting researchers!) But it would be a mistake to say, for example, that not sleep training is the “safest option.”

Does all this mean you should definitely sleep train? Of course not—every family is different, and you may really not want to let your baby “cry it out.” You need to make your own choices, just as with everything else. But if you do want sleep train, you should not feel shame or discomfort about that decision. The data, imperfect as it is, is on your side."

Oster, Emily. Cribsheet (pp. 181-182). Profile. Kindle Edition.

coraka · 08/02/2022 15:30

@Bizawit of course, but don't you think there could also be long-term harm from being chronically sleep deprived during infancy and childhood? With so many of these decisions there isn't a risk-free option, we just have to look at the evidence we have available and make the decision in the best interests of our child.

So many posts on here are nothing but hyperbole, truly unhelpful!

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 08/02/2022 15:21

We did. She was about 8 months and we'd tried everything else. Every night up till then was just hours of sitting in her room and trying to soothe her, getting up in the middle of the night etc, having her in our bed. We were existing on about 3 hours sleep a night

So we decided to try it. Went in every 10 minutes, gently told her it was time for sleep, stroked her head and then let her cry again for another 10 minutes

1st night was horrendous. Me and my partner sat on the stairs beating ourselves up about what bad parents we were. Took about 4 hours for her to finally go to sleep. And then she woke up again at 2am and we did another 3 hours.

2nd night took about 2 hours, and we were just about to give up when she went to sleep. She woke up in the night but it only took about 20 minutes.

3rd night she was asleep within 15 minutes and it was job done.

It's not for everyone, but it worked for us when nothing else would. And she's now 14, and doesn't seem to have been psychologically scarred by it. I suppose we'll find out whether there's some deep seated resentment when she chooses our nursing home.

peboh · 08/02/2022 15:10

No.

Samanabanana · 08/02/2022 15:01

I can't imagine leaving a baby or toddler alone in a room crying. And I say that as the mother of a child who slept terribly until they were two (and a baby who will only sleep in my arms Grin). They all learn to sleep through the night eventually, it's not a skill you can teach, it's developmental. All babies left to cry will go silent eventually, bevause evolution taught them that if no one comes to their rescue when crying, it's safer to shut down Sad

3WildOnes · 08/02/2022 14:59

The problem with the studies that Emily Oster cites, is that parents were able to move from the sleep training group to the control group or leave the study at anytime in the experiments. This will be the case for all sleep training studies, ethically you can not force a parent to continue with sleep training if they feel it is not beneficial/harming their children. So yes sleep training is probably not harmful for a majority of babies but possibly it is for some but those parents were aware it was having a detrimental effect so removed them from the study. This is why I hate the cries of martyrdom for parents who aren’t comfortable sleep training, maybe they are just aware that it would be detrimental for their child. Also none of the studies looked past 6 years so we still dont know if there will be any differences in adulthood in the sleep trained vs not sleep trained long term.

Bizawit · 08/02/2022 14:57

[quote coraka]@Shitandhills I recommend the Emily Oster book as mentioned by PP. She quotes numerous studies suggesting that, as opposed to being harmful, cry it out and other sleep training methods actually beneficial for babies. Just one example:

"There are a number of good randomized trials that speak to this. One representative study from Sweden, published in 2004, took ninety-five families and randomized them into a sleep-training regime involving a form of “cry it out.”8 The authors focused on whether behavior during the day was impacted by the nighttime—basically, they asked whether the infants were less attached to their parents during the day as a result of being left to cry during the night. This particular study found that, in fact, infant security and attachment seemed to increase after the “cry it out” intervention. It also found improvements in daytime behavior and eating as reported by the babies’ parents. Note that this is the opposite of the concerns raised about “cry it out” methods.

Oster, Emily. Cribsheet (p. 178). Profile. Kindle Edition.

The data about attachment disorders comes from studies of children from Romanian orphanages, where children were seriously neglected, not from brief episodes of parents not responding in the context of a loving and nurturing relationship.

It's good news - sleep training does not harm babies! That must be good news to you, even if you have chosen not to do it! Of course we all make different choices and we just make the best decisions we can with the information we have at the time.[/quote]
I agree that the orphanages research is a poor example to generalise from, but it’s equally naive to think you can determine the long term psychological effects of sleep training from that random control trial. There are far too many variables at play to draw definitive conclusions. It’s very difficult to empirically validate the isolated impact of any single traumatic event in infancy in that sort of manner.

Sexnotgender · 08/02/2022 14:41

Honesty if I tried rocking my second to sleep in my arms he’d never.. ever.. sleep.

My daughter is a bit like that.

When she was a few weeks old she was sooooo restless. I was at my wits end, I’d done everything. Fed her, burped her changed her rocked her…

In desperation because my back was aching and I needed a wee, I popped her in her cot. She settled immediately, she just wanted put down!

Amichelle84 · 08/02/2022 14:26

I wouldn't say we sleep trained as such but we followed a programme that structured his whole day including meal times as well as bedtime routine.

It wasn't letting him cry himself to sleep at all.

He was about 9 months old and his sleep was becoming awful and with another LO on the way we needed to do something.

After 3 nights he was settling himself to sleep and sleeping through.

Cap89 · 08/02/2022 14:19

Yes, at 6 months, and I 100% believe it was the right decision. DS1 was a terrible sleeper. We went through months of him screaming the house down for hours as my DH and I tried everything to get him to sleep. Rocking, bouncing, singing, feeding. We’d finally get him off and in his cot, tiptoe out of the room and 5 minutes later it would start again. Eventually the only thing that worked was me going up to bed with him at 7, feeding him to sleep and staying there all night. Even then, he’d wake several times overnight, sometimes hourly, and would need me to resettle him. Anyone who thinks this was a reasonable or sustainable way for any of us to live, including poor DS who was so exhausted and distressed through all of this, can do one.

We tried controlled crying on the advice of a friend. I kid you not, the first night he woke once and resettled before I could get to his room, and from the second night he slept through. He’s now two and apart from when poorly (when of course we went in and cuddled etc) he’s slept 12 hours a night ever since. He is a happy, healthy, well rested child with happy, healthy well rested parents. We will do the same with DS2.

FTEngineerM · 08/02/2022 13:48

DD2 didn't need sleep training. If I'd had 2 like her then perhaps I'd have had different ideas too

I think this is key.

Problem is a baby cries when they need to communicate ANYTHING to you, so if they’re tired they’ll cry.. if you going in and fussing them is actually elongating the time it takes them to get to sleep then it’s not actually being kind to stay with them, regardless of how loving you’re being it’s not the kind thing to do.

Overall if your baby is actually one that needs to be alone to sleep but it’s had 4/5/6/9 months of being rocked shh’d and what ever because that’s what society tells you baby’s need to sleep then it’s not surprising that it may take a few days to undo.

Honesty if I tried rocking my second to sleep in my arms he’d never.. ever.. sleep.

coraka · 08/02/2022 13:41

@Shitandhills I recommend the Emily Oster book as mentioned by PP. She quotes numerous studies suggesting that, as opposed to being harmful, cry it out and other sleep training methods actually beneficial for babies. Just one example:

"There are a number of good randomized trials that speak to this. One representative study from Sweden, published in 2004, took ninety-five families and randomized them into a sleep-training regime involving a form of “cry it out.”8 The authors focused on whether behavior during the day was impacted by the nighttime—basically, they asked whether the infants were less attached to their parents during the day as a result of being left to cry during the night. This particular study found that, in fact, infant security and attachment seemed to increase after the “cry it out” intervention. It also found improvements in daytime behavior and eating as reported by the babies’ parents. Note that this is the opposite of the concerns raised about “cry it out” methods.

Oster, Emily. Cribsheet (p. 178). Profile. Kindle Edition.

The data about attachment disorders comes from studies of children from Romanian orphanages, where children were seriously neglected, not from brief episodes of parents not responding in the context of a loving and nurturing relationship.

It's good news - sleep training does not harm babies! That must be good news to you, even if you have chosen not to do it! Of course we all make different choices and we just make the best decisions we can with the information we have at the time.

Bizawit · 08/02/2022 13:35

@coraka

It's ok, don't worry, my DD is 6 now and totally fine! Like I say, she was much better off crying for 50 minutes once in her life than having years of a depressed mother! I was hallucinating and dangerous on the road. Depression in mothers is proven to affect babies badly. Car crashes are also a known danger. All the evidence indicates that sleep training has no negative outcomes.

Of course it was awful hearing her cry but it was the best decision. It had immediate benefits for all of us! DD was a much happier baby once she was sleeping better 😀 I really think this "cruel/damaging " narrative puts such tremendous strain on families and it's simply not supported by evidence.

I think if you went through years of broken sleep and found that really tough then it is hard to contemplate the idea that you could have fixed it and your baby would have been just fine (or better). You have to justify it and make it worthwhile so sleep training must be cruel / damaging whatever. But that is not my experience , so I'm happy to share it with other desperate families!

Or perhaps these people just didn't have the bad sleeping babies we had so they don't know what it feels like it to hit rock bottom and they never really needed to sleep train. DD2 didn't need sleep training. If I'd had 2 like her then perhaps I'd have had different ideas too.

It sounds like you did what was right for your family, and you were honest about what the process involves. I had an horrendous sleeper , and it was hard. It is difficult to contemplate that had I just done CIO we would have all been better off, but I am totally willing to acknowledge that possibility (however hard it is). (Having done sleep training, I wonder if you are willing to contemplate the reverse?) Nevertheless CIO was not compatible with my philosophy of parenting, and violated my instincts/ intuition as a mother, so I persevered. I don’t think anyone can say what the long term impacts of different methods are, we all just have do what feels right to us , at the time, as best we can. I think we’ll all end up living with some regrets at some point along the line!
Shitandhills · 08/02/2022 13:05

@coraka I think if you went through years of broken sleep and found that really tough then it is hard to contemplate the idea that you could have fixed it and your baby would have been just fine (or better). You have to justify it and make it worthwhile so sleep training must be cruel / damaging whatever.

That's such a ridiculous thing to say! Leaving a baby crying on their own in the dark for 50 minutes is, objectively, cruel. Dress it up or justify it how you want, it's cruel. You say you were all happier at the end of it, great, but you can't try to claim that the method wasn't cruel. To suggest that everyone who didn't subject their infant to that ordeal and was sleep deprived as a result regrets it and so retrospectively decides it is cruel is just bonkers.

Also, there are no credible studies showing no damage from this kind of sleep training, so what you are saying is inaccurate.

Saracen · 08/02/2022 13:01

I sleep trained my first baby at eleven months. Until then she had slept in our bed and had been okay - lots and lots of night wakings, but went back to sleep after breastfeeding. I went to bed early and was able to nap in the daytime, so it was fine for me too.

From ten months old she changed. She was often crazy tired and really unhappy. The GP didn't think anything was wrong. Simply moving her to a cot didn't help, so then I did full-on sleep training. I found it heartbreaking but I stuck with it. It "worked" in the sense that she slept regular hours and for longer stretches, but she was still just as tired. So the only thing sleep training achieved from my point of view was to rule out the possibility that she was tired because she had poor sleep habits. That was useful to know, so I guess I don't regret the sleep training. I do feel bad for her, however.

I kept on looking for a medical explanation for her tiredness and eventually, about 18 months later, discovered she was much better when off dairy.

My second child was never sleep trained, instead sleeping in our bed until she was six years old. That worked really well.

Thinkingthinking · 08/02/2022 12:48

I haven't but I think the term sleep training is a massively confusing term for a myriad of methods between very gentle to CIO. My DC has never really moved on from the newborn stage at night time and is now over 2. To say I am broken by lack of sleep is an understatement. I honestly feel if I could have had my time again I would have got professional help very early on to implement gentle methods as now I have an extremely wilful toddler and changing habits is near on impossible. I'll add that my husband has never once put her to bed or got up in the night which made it difficult for me to even think about anything beyond 'survival' ie. Getting us both back to sleep in the quickest way possible - in bed and on the boob.

kirkandpetal · 08/02/2022 11:42

I did the super nanny method with dc2 when they were 8/9 months.
Put them down, then go in after 2 mins, then 4, then 8 doubling the time each time until they are asleep. Took 2 nights and then we had a more reliable and settled sleep pattern. It's not for everyone I guess, and you have to be careful to attempt it when they are not ill or going through anything like teething etc. For us (and I include dc1 in that who was being affected too) it was brilliant and I would do it again.

coraka · 08/02/2022 11:31

Oh yes, completely OP, every baby is different, sounds like what you're doing is working, good luck! SmileI just didn't want to let those PP comments go unchallenged.

3WildOnes · 08/02/2022 11:28

Yes I started very gentle sleep training with mine from about 6 weeks old. I would give them a chance to settle themselves, if it was a grizzle I would leave them, if they were upset then I would always comfort them. It was a slow and gradual process. They could all settle themselves from about 8 weeks with a dummy. Two were going through with just a dream feed at 11pm from 8 weeks and one kept feeding in the night until I night weaned at 12 months. They have alll gone through periods where they have wanted to stay with them whilst they settle and I have been happy to go with that. They have all stayed great sleepers. I was never comfortable leaving them to actually cry.

babyjellyfish · 08/02/2022 11:23

If I genuinely thought that by leaving my son to cry it out he would be putting himself to sleep independently within three days, I would absolutely do it.

But I know my son and I don't believe it would work (at least not at the moment) so we need to adopt a different approach.

Different babies.

Provided the babies are safe and loved and well cared for, I think all approaches are valid.

I also think a lot of people's views about sleep training are shaped by what kind of baby they end up having. If you had asked me this question when my son was three months old and he was going to sleep in his next to me crib, waking up twice in the night to feed and then going back to sleep again, I might have told you I didn't think sleep training was necessary.

But then it all went to shit and here we are.

I think parents with babies who struggle to sleep independently, or who have to go back to work and simply can't afford to be sleep deprived all the time, often have different views to parents who have naturally "good" sleepers or don't work outside the home. And that's OK.

OP posts:
coraka · 08/02/2022 11:19

I'd tried EVERYTHING else before I got to cry it out, by the way. Every gentle method, gradual retreat, shush pat, read every book, we even went to a residential sleep school for a week. Nothing had worked. Thank goodness another mother from my baby group recommended this sleep consultant and we got it sorted. Joy returned to our home!

coraka · 08/02/2022 11:17

It's ok, don't worry, my DD is 6 now and totally fine! Like I say, she was much better off crying for 50 minutes once in her life than having years of a depressed mother! I was hallucinating and dangerous on the road. Depression in mothers is proven to affect babies badly. Car crashes are also a known danger. All the evidence indicates that sleep training has no negative outcomes.

Of course it was awful hearing her cry but it was the best decision. It had immediate benefits for all of us! DD was a much happier baby once she was sleeping better 😀 I really think this "cruel/damaging " narrative puts such tremendous strain on families and it's simply not supported by evidence.

I think if you went through years of broken sleep and found that really tough then it is hard to contemplate the idea that you could have fixed it and your baby would have been just fine (or better). You have to justify it and make it worthwhile so sleep training must be cruel / damaging whatever. But that is not my experience , so I'm happy to share it with other desperate families!

Or perhaps these people just didn't have the bad sleeping babies we had so they don't know what it feels like it to hit rock bottom and they never really needed to sleep train. DD2 didn't need sleep training. If I'd had 2 like her then perhaps I'd have had different ideas too.

Piglet89 · 08/02/2022 11:05

Well said @babyjellyfish

babyjellyfish · 08/02/2022 10:59

I think everybody makes what they feel is the right decision for their family and their baby. Can we please not accuse people of being "cruel" for adopting a different approach to baby sleep?

There are thousands of children being abused and neglected as we speak and so I don't think it is constructive to accuse someone of cruelty for deciding to let their baby cry in their cot in order to teach them to go to sleep independently. Not everyone is comfortable with these methods and that's absolutely fine, but the research does seem to suggest that they are effective, which is why a lot of people choose to use them. They don't do it because they don't care about their baby or enjoy listening to them cry.

If the older generation of doctors and grandparents where I live are to be believed, my entire generation were left to cry in their cots, and that doesn't stop them from having a close and loving relationship with their parents.

I wasn't left to cry alone but apparently I was a unicorn baby who just randomly decided to sleep through the night from 6 weeks.

If only my son had inherited that particular gene.

OP posts:
5keletor · 08/02/2022 10:46

MN, not MM.