Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you sleep trained your baby

411 replies

babyjellyfish · 05/02/2022 11:12

What approach did you take, how old was your baby and how successful was it?

Looking for a range of views and experiences.

Thank you.

OP posts:
MarvEll · 05/02/2022 15:41

Wonder how many of the 'no way' have good sleepers and feel well rested themselves 😄
We did the leave her for a few mins then come back, maybe pick him up if he needed it, maybe not. But sometimes me being there really really didn't help. He was tired, needed to go to sleep and just has to crack on. 99% of the time now he's straight to sleep all night on his own, we've had one wake up in the night since about week 10 when he was teething/ill. I can tell from his cries if there's something wrong or if it's just for attention.
Only took a couple of nights to work and then every night is really simple for us, he's happy falling asleep on his own, we're happy because we gets to spend the evening together

FourChimneys · 05/02/2022 15:41

I would always suggest a very gentle and gradual retreat with lots of reassurance.

Times have changed though. In the 50s and 60s my siblings and I were tucked up in our Silver Cross pram and parked in the garage for naps so our mother could get on with the housework. Shocking nowadays but I have never noticed any ill effects. I guess we weren't the only ones either.

Somethingsnappy · 05/02/2022 15:39

@OfstedOffred

3 minutes not 3 months of wailing
Grin
Gynaesaur · 05/02/2022 15:36

In my head, "sleep training" means gradually retreating rather than just leaving them to scream. That's not "training", it's just negligence.
However, I think I've only once seen someone on MN say they just left their baby to cry for hours. The rest of the time, people advocating sleep training are referring (and often explicitly stating so) to a gentle method of gradual retreat. This is then ignored by a large number of people decrying it as cruel and unusual because they've somehow associated the term only with leaving distressed babies to cry for hours, despite numerous posts indicating something very different.

Porcupineintherough · 05/02/2022 15:32

@Alias your post is dripping judgement. And it's weird that you feel the need to justify your stance, esp by saying everyone who chooses the alternative is lying.

bellsbuss · 05/02/2022 15:30

I did with my first 3 , my 4th was sent to punish me for being smug about having 3 who were all good sleepers. Youngest is only now in a routine due to starting school and being exhausted. Nothing worked and it nearly broke me.

GiantHaystacks2021 · 05/02/2022 15:28

@MaryShelley1818

Absolutely no. Cruel and damaging.

I'm a Student SW (but worked in the team for many yrs) and the amount of evidence on the damage it does to the brain to not have a child's basic needs met is heartbreaking. I could never do that to my child, or any child. A child crying needs their parent.
I have 2 children, both coslept, oldest was a dream sleeper but the little one is dreadful. I often go to work on a couple of hrs sleep but even in my most desperate times couldn't do that to her.

Sorry SW for who - because that is total rubbish. L. Ron Hubbard?
GiantHaystacks2021 · 05/02/2022 15:26

In my opinion, there is a correlation between PND and some of those who have not sleep trained their baby.

AliasGrape · 05/02/2022 15:23

No, just never felt right to me and I know I couldn't do it.

Not judging anyone else's approach.

DD has spells of sleeping well and spells of it being more difficult. Getting her down is particularly tricky at the moment.

I know being 'consistent' is seen as the holy grail of parenting but I've honestly found it far easier to take it as it comes with DD - we have a bedtime routine that we aim for but if it's not working for whatever reason I'll be flexible, go back to cosleeping for a bit if needed eg if she's unwell or teething. When she sleeps really well never seems to correspond to anything in particular I've done so for us I just think it's developmental (apart from lots of fresh air and leaving a long enough wake window after last nap which genuinely do seem to help).

I don't understand the 'oh you'd rather complain about lack of sleep rather than do anything about it' sneering either. Well no, I'd RATHER get a decent night's sleep every night but it doesn't always happen. I still don't think sleep training is right for me or my baby and I don't actually think it works half as well as its advocates on these threads always claim anyway - if that means you've 'no sympathy' for me well okay, it's not going to affect my view of how I want to parent.

MaryShelley1818 · 05/02/2022 15:06

To clarify, I'm talking about cry it out or anything that advocates leaving a baby to cry.
Not things like gradual retreat etc

MaryShelley1818 · 05/02/2022 15:04

Absolutely no. Cruel and damaging.

I'm a Student SW (but worked in the team for many yrs) and the amount of evidence on the damage it does to the brain to not have a child's basic needs met is heartbreaking. I could never do that to my child, or any child. A child crying needs their parent.
I have 2 children, both coslept, oldest was a dream sleeper but the little one is dreadful. I often go to work on a couple of hrs sleep but even in my most desperate times couldn't do that to her.

FourChimneys · 05/02/2022 14:55

DD was sleep trained in a fairly gentle way. I was broken with sleep deprivation, it made us all feel so much better.

As a well adjusted young adult, DD thinks it is funny that she is supposed to be affected by it. She once pointed out she couldn't remember anything about it but lots of nice things had happened since.

T00Ts · 05/02/2022 14:50

I didn’t, not only because I was somehow given a child that set through on his own from eight weeks old. Magic. But had he not done that, I absolutely would have sleep trained. Sleep is important and I had no designs on co-sleeping. Just to lend some rare support, MN is quite anti any kind of sleep training. 🙄

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/02/2022 14:26

Oh and they still cried when they were ill etc and we would get up with them or bring them in with us, it wasn't a case of them 'thinking there was no point in crying as they knew we wouldn't respond'. More a case of breaking the habit of needing feeding to self settle between sleep cycles

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/02/2022 14:22

My bottle refusing baby woke every 90 min to comfort feed. I lasted 7 months before we got a sleep trainer. They did the disappearing chair method. PM me if you want any details

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 05/02/2022 14:15

YANBU to ask but the majority will say don't do it here.

I didn't do cry it out and never even would. I agree with pp that its horrific and very cruel.

What I did was feed my baby to sleep for ages every time he woke. Once he was around 9 months old we decided he didn't need more milk so for a few days decided to refuse milk and stay with him. So when he cried I'd go in and place my hand on his chest so he knew I was there but I didn't offer a bottle. I gently shushed but didn't pick him up.

So he learned that he wasn't alone and would be comforted but there was no more milk or cuddles as it was time to sleep.

It took a few days but eventually he realised he wasn't getting milk at night.

I think my way is a world away from cry it out though.

Mwnci123 · 05/02/2022 14:02

Yes. No regrets.

fullofpips · 05/02/2022 13:57

No. Sleep is developmental.

rainyskylight · 05/02/2022 13:49

Yes. It was fine. She was mainly just pissed off that she wasn’t getting her own way. If she sounded properly distressed I would go in. I started it when I realised she was waking up for boob and cuddles just for the sake of it. I need to earn money to keep her in peekaboo books, and I need sleep to work.

When she started nursery she was able to settle and sleep for naps from the second week.

She’s 15 months old and only wakes if she’s ill or teething, when I cuddle her back to sleep.

When I’m doing bed time and she is mega tired she actually pushes me away after cuddles and squirms when she really wants to sleep, because she wants her own space and own bed.

Porcupineintherough · 05/02/2022 13:46

Yes both, at around 10 months. Worked brilliantly for ds1, not so well w ds2 who would regress after each bout of teething.

For us it was about me not feeding them every 2 hours through the night (ie they were waking up and needing the breast to get back to sleep). So what we did was that, when they cried they got dad w a bottle of water instead. He'd stay with them, cuddle them, comfort them as long as they liked but no milk. They were outraged, so lots of crying the first night (them and me) but no crying alone. After 3 nights they decided he wasnt worth waking up for an started sleeping through.

MondayYogurt · 05/02/2022 13:45

Yes 8mo, very gently and with no crying. Life changing.

ItsSunnyOutside · 05/02/2022 13:36

No.

Controlled crying is not something I have or would ever feel comfortable doing.

There are different methods of 'sleep training' though, not all are as full on as CC.

afrika · 05/02/2022 13:35

Yes, both kids. At about 11 months. In both cases because they seemed keen on waking and crying all night regardless of whether they were in with us or not. Worked pretty well for them & us - all of our sleep dramatically improved!

updownroundandround · 05/02/2022 13:33

@babyjellyfish

Of course you're NOT being unreasonable to ask that ! (And it's only an idiot that would consider the asking of a question 'unreasonable' ffs ! Isn't a forum to enable us to ask any question to something we're thinking about or worried about the whole point of MN ?? Hmm)

But because any form of 'sleep training' is currently 'unfashionable', you will definitely get most answers from people who are invested in todays 'fashionable' ideas about infant sleeping etc

I can tell you that you will choose to do what you consider the best for your baby, which is the right thing to do, regardless of what methods are currently 'in vogue'.

And I can also tell you, that generations of babies have been brought up by very differing 'methods', and that all of them have, at one point in time, been seen as the most 'current' and 'progressive'.

So............you do you, and ignore other peoples 'opinions' when it's not what works for you ! (And don't discuss what you're doing/planning to do with people who you already know have differing views either !)

Boombastic22 · 05/02/2022 13:31

Yes I did, both kids exclusively breastfed, strictly on nap times, woke them up, fed them regularly. They did not cry there endlessly because they were in a rhythm ahd we were consistent.

They are both now at school and still sleep fantastically. Never had to co sleep they self settle and are brilliant at bedtime.