Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you sleep trained your baby

411 replies

babyjellyfish · 05/02/2022 11:12

What approach did you take, how old was your baby and how successful was it?

Looking for a range of views and experiences.

Thank you.

OP posts:
coraka · 06/02/2022 09:25

Yes, at 9 months, cry it out and DD slept through by 5 nights. The whole house was much happier including DD. She needed her sleep too, and she also needed a mother that wasn't hallucinating, suicidal and dangerous on the road through uttter exhaustion.

I was so reluctant to do it but it was the best decision we've made!

Chely · 06/02/2022 08:58

Tried with our 1st and it was an epic fail.
Younger ones I didn't bother trying, we've had a mixed bag of good and not so good sleepers. Youngest is fab and been sleeping 10hrs at night from 3 months.

canyoutoleratethis · 06/02/2022 08:53

@Ragwort

Not exactly but I followed the GF routine, I never fed or cuddled my baby to sleep ... 7pm, in his cot and I left him to self settle, we were probably lucky in that he was just a naturally good sleeper ... but we never fussed over him.
I’m sorry, but this is the saddest thing I have ever read on here. Each to their own, obviously, but you seem to think not fussing over a newborn is a good thing?! Jesus fucking wept…..
AFS1 · 06/02/2022 08:36

My advice would be to read up on various methods and choose one that makes the most sense for you and your family.

And then the key is consistency, consistency, consistency. The main reason we used a sleep consultant was because we’d tried various techniques ourselves and had abandoned them, convincing ourselves that they wouldn’t work. The consultant gave us the confidence to stick to it.

Good luck, OP. It will work and will lead to a happier baby and happier parents.

FinallySomeNormality · 06/02/2022 07:37

Yep - with both DS. Neither had awful sleep to begin with though but some sleep training sorted some issues with DS1 random night waking and DS2 inability to nap. Both brilliant little sleepers now (5yr and 8m)!

There have now been a lot of studies around controlled crying and the age old article stating your child "learns you won't come when it needs you" and that it's damaging for the child has largely been debunked.

On MN sleep training gets a bad rep and somehow no one would possibly do such a barbaric act..... but you only need to looo on the Sleep board to see many, many people do try it. And in the real world loads of people do! It might not always be controlled crying too... there are gentler methods of sleep training available.

PollyRae16 · 06/02/2022 07:15

Yes at about 7 months was losing my sanity with a child who would only nap on me and would take forever to rock to sleep.
Took 3 nights, the first being the worst of half an hour of crying total with me settling every couple of minutes and it was the best thing for all of us.
There was some regression from it around 1.5 and we were having to sit in the room whilst they fell asleep but now they go to bed fine and sleep through.

I agree with previous posters that I'd do it again in a heartbeat. I was at complete breaking point which was no good for me or my child

MrsGatsby99 · 06/02/2022 06:58

Just read your latest post. Yes, and also I had to go back to work and function there too, as well as driving etc... Gradual retreat worked for us as we didn’t leave her to cry for too long. I feel it was better for her in the long run too. It takes time though. It was several years ago now but probably took us a month.

MrsGatsby99 · 06/02/2022 06:54

Gradual retreat with DD at 9 months old. Incredibly necessary as I had only slept in two hour blocks for 9 months. Better that I was a functioning mother to her.

Giraffesandbottoms · 06/02/2022 06:46

@babyjellyfish

If you cosleep I assume you breastfeed in which case I reiterate Jay Gordon. They might cry a bit but you’re cuddling them the whole time, so they aren’t abandoned. Can’t believe someone here left a baby to cry for 49 mins and thinks that’s ok!

@CafeConLechePorFavor
Ignore Piglet, she’s goady AF. She wanders into threads with ridiculously contrarian statements about her parenting for attention/to start arguments. I CBA with her.

babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 02:05

Thanks for the replies to this.

I probably should have been a little clearer in how I phrased my question, because I'm now asking whether I should sleep train my baby or not, I'm trying to decide the best way of doing it.

My baby is 10 months old and for most of the last few months we have been cosleeping because that was the best way for the three of us to actually get some sleep. It's now no longer working for any of us. We have a baby who sleeps in our bed and will more often than not wake up at around midnight or 1am and spend the next three to four hours singing and chattering to himself. All his needs have been met. He's fine. He would just rather be awake than asleep.

It's all very well saying this is normal or what have you. Or instead of training my baby to sleep I need to train myself to accept that my baby doesn't sleep.

The reality is that my husband and I both work full time and I have to get up in the mornings, get behind the wheel of a car, get myself to the office without killing myself or any other road users, do a full day of work, and get home again. Doing that on almost no sleep every once in a while is one thing. Doing it on almost no sleep every day is dangerous.

Thanks for the constructive replies. We need to choose a method and stick to it.

OP posts:
HappyDays40 · 06/02/2022 01:20

Yep but a no tears version, we wnt from awake every half hour to twice a night. It was loosely called pick up out down and worked after about a week hard going but my baby was a three month old Foster baby so we needed one that involved zero tears and lots of cuddles if needed.

Wafflesnsniffles · 06/02/2022 00:15

Threads on this topic always split opinion with both sides arguing that theirs is "the best" etc.
I tried cosleeping - not a good result for me or my children. Routine and teaching them to go to sleep on their own meant they were happier, I was happier. Result. For other families though cosleeping would be a the better option, not for my dc or me.

thefamous5 · 06/02/2022 00:13

@pregnantmummy22

So everyone who's against letting them cry. When you put them down at night and leave the room and they cry, do you ever leave them for a few minutes or do you go back immediately?

I mean more with older children from 12 months onwards, not babies.

Co slept until they happily went to bed without crying.

If
I had put them in a cot in a separate room and they cried, I would have gone immediately to them

heyitsthistle · 05/02/2022 23:56

Day after day my then 10 month old woke up 8 times between midnight and 8am. I used the Ferber method of sleep training (not cry it out) and within a week everyone slept soundly through the night, parents included. Life was suddenly a million times better. It was hard for two nights (much easier on night 3), but no more difficult than the constant waking from before then.

I also became a more responsive mother during the day. Judge me all you like for leaving my baby to cry, but damn it worked. She's now 2.25 and sleeps through the night every night. No issues.

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 05/02/2022 23:55

I found the Emily Oster book “Crib Sheets” helpful for understanding the evidence behind sleep training versus not. Our GP (and all of my doctor and therapist friends!) were all fiercely in the sleep training camp.

I hesitated to sleep train my eldest, but eventually did at 7 months when I was heading back to work and couldn’t hand the sleep deprivation anymore. It was such a non-event. 3 nights and done, always checked on her every few minutes, she never cried longer than about 30 minutes. She was sooooo much better rested afterwards - HER mood noticeably improved, let alone mine!

I then sleep trained DC2 at 6 months, and DC3 at 4 months. Life with my babies is enjoyable now. I’m not just scraping by in sheer exhaustion. And I promise you, we’re fully “bonded”. I’ve done extended breastfeeding until toddlerhood, I carried them in a cloth carrier, we did baby led weaning, we talk about feelings hahaha I’m totally an “attachment parent”… but we SLEEP, and it’s glorious!

Piglet89 · 05/02/2022 23:47

@CafeConLechePorFavor I didn’t do it to ruffle feathers - this is genuinely my parenting approach - unfashionable tho it be, nowadays.

I posted to show the OP that a different approach from all the (erroneous) “5 mins crying causes irreversible brain damage” approach is available.

Excitedforxmas · 05/02/2022 23:44

Not training as such but every night did same routine. Bath, bottle book and bed awake. Slept through the night at 10 weeks and 14 weeks old and we never looked back. Occasionally up but nothing mad and usually went back after a bottle. . Best thing we did with the 2 of them.

Piglet89 · 05/02/2022 23:44

@MammaBear18 seriously? Exasperated? Why the fuck would you care what I do with my family?

And they absolutely do need to be taught how to sleep - at least to a pattern that roughy matches that of the adults who are their caregivers, so those caregivers don’t end up zombies who lose their jobs or, worse, lives, because they’re so bloody exhausted.

CafeConLechePorFavor · 05/02/2022 23:40

[quote Piglet89]@babyjellyfish I did full on cry it out for 2 hours at a stretch for a couple of nights.

PM me if you want details: my son’s stubbornness is a reflection of my own and I needed to show him who was boss (hint: it’s not him).[/quote]
I hadn't read this comment when I posted. I'm not entirely convinced that you didn't just make your profile to jump on this thread to ruffle feathers. I won't bite. But no words can express what I think of this.

MammaBear18 · 05/02/2022 23:05

[quote Piglet89]@babyjellyfish I did full on cry it out for 2 hours at a stretch for a couple of nights.

PM me if you want details: my son’s stubbornness is a reflection of my own and I needed to show him who was boss (hint: it’s not him).[/quote]
Babies sleep for better part of the day/night in utero. They don't need teaching how to sleep, they are born with that ability.

And more importantly, they are not manipulative. I'm beyond exasperated at the second part of your comment.

cherrytopcake · 05/02/2022 23:04

@Scrunchies

Most of MN doesn’t agree with sleep training. That doesn’t mean it is wrong. There are some good Facebook groups which might help you, that have a different audience.

Personally I did, it was life changing, and I would do it again. But people here will say it’s child abuse 🤷‍♀️

I did. And will do it again. Totally worth it. I have the happiest pre schooler we could ask for. Sleep trained her around 9 months and changed everyone's sleep for the best. Give you child the gift of sleep. Best gift ever. My daughter loves sleeping. It was shit before, when she needed us to fall asleep. And it was shit during the two weeks we sleep trained. But now we have a child who looks forward to bed and falls asleep by herself.
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 05/02/2022 23:03

Sleep training does not teach babies not to have needs, it just teaches them not to continue expressing their needs. It breaks the link between a baby signalling that they need help and an adult responding

You obviously really believe that - but do you think that those mothers that did do it now have children they’re not close to, who won’t go to their parents for love and attention? When it was the norm for babies to be left for four hours between feeds - the horror the average 21st century mum would feel if they were asked to do that - but realistically, do are parents have any memory or upset around that? And clearly I’m not talking about neglect like the Romanian orphanages of the 90s - I’m talking about normal, being able to step away from your child without feeling some sort of guilt or shame.

I did a gradual retreat thing with my third - I had three year old twins and a full time job and I needed to sleep. Sure he didn’t like it (he was 14 months old) but by the third day he was quite willing and able to go to sleep on his own after a cuddle and a story. He’s ten now - not only does he not remember that at all, but I have a fabulous, really close relationship with both him and his brothers (who to be fair, I actually can’t remember what I did with them).

Allowing a baby to cry is not the same as making a baby cry. I agree with those that say parents who won’t try any form of sleep training are martyring themselves for no good reason - they’re also the types that won’t put the baby down while they have a five minute shower or brush their teeth and then are upset they never have time to do anything.

JustAnotherUserinParadise · 05/02/2022 22:57

Yup... Did gradual retreat for about a month from 9.5 months made bedtime easier but didn't fix the night wakings. Then night weaned whig was pretty easy and took maybe a week, but also didn't fix the night wakings.
Finally controlled crying at about 10.5 months, 49 mins crying the first night, 29 the second, and that's all. She's slept through for11/12 hrs from the first night, it's been about a month now.

My only regret is not doing it sooner! We tried at about 7 months and I caved after a minute of crying!

I was following a few "gentle sleep" people on Instagram who are all about not sleep training, saying lots of waking is normal etc... And it actually makes me quite angry - I feel lied to, like I could have been sleeping all this time.

It's made such a difference, I have the energy to work well, me and DH have our evenings back!

Porcupineintherough · 05/02/2022 22:54

@jgjgjgjgjg to a certain extent it does, actually. It teaches them they dont need anyone else to get back to sleep between sleep cycles. It's called self settling, really useful skill.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 05/02/2022 22:53

Ds1 seemed to have no problem expressing his needs

Swipe left for the next trending thread