Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you sleep trained your baby

411 replies

babyjellyfish · 05/02/2022 11:12

What approach did you take, how old was your baby and how successful was it?

Looking for a range of views and experiences.

Thank you.

OP posts:
CrimbleCrumble1 · 06/02/2022 16:20

I used a book called Core Sleep (it’s probably dated now). My three DC slept a short night (11-5, 10-5,11-6 type of thing) at 8 weeks. By 12 weeks all three slept 12 hours. They probably then woke once a year each when they were poorly.

babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 16:15

@humblesims So what happened in the end? Did it eventually get better?

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 16:14

@Giraffesandbottoms I just read Jay Gordon's article on night weaning. Is that the method you followed? Is it something you're supposed to do while bedsharing or can it be done with the baby in their own cot?

My baby is more or less night weaned now because he doesn't need to eat overnight, he needs to be hungry enough for a full feed at 7am because he needs to take some medication with a large meal in the mornings, and feeding him during the night is no longer a failsafe way to get him to go back to sleep anyway. Sometimes when I feed him out of desperation he just has a nice little 3am snack and then goes back to babbling away and doing gymnastics. We really need him to sleep in his own bed and stop waking up for hours at a time because the bedsharing is no longer working for any of us.

OP posts:
humblesims · 06/02/2022 16:09

Controlled crying. My DCs are grown up now and this was back in the early 2000s. EBF baby that would never be put down and was exhausting for me and my well intentioned DH and DM persuaded me that controlled crying was the answer. It was so hard and distressing for me and (obviously) for the child (I didnt do it with my second). It would sort of work for a while until his routine changed, or he got a cold or ...whatever.
As parents you look back at the way you did things when they were little and realise it's such a short time and I would rather have suffered the sleepless nights than the memory of controlled crying. But, it's just my experience.

Giraffesandbottoms · 06/02/2022 16:03

Also I’ve suggested Jay Gordon to be helpful

Giraffesandbottoms · 06/02/2022 16:03

@babyjellyfish

I see that, but for example both of my children are appalling sleepers. My 18 month old was up 10+ times last night. I am on my knees today. However even if I give him to my DH so I can go and wee he SCREAMS. It’s frustrating and it’s heartbreaking but it’s not an option for me to listen to this. It would make me feel cruel, personally. They also both HATED the buggy AND the car. They screamed every time they went in until the second they came out. My mother said with DS1 he would stop and fall asleep eventually. He never, ever did. I was sobbing in the park when he was 2 months old as I had to walk the dog and he wouldn’t stop crying. I have a bias about it because as soon as I used a sling things were much better and I regretted massively the stress and pain and upset I caused him - AND ME - by listening to advice re “he will stop crying” blah blah because I thought she knew better. Not all children are the same. I can see if you have a baby who fussed a bit when put down it might be different. But screaming is very different.

babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 15:57

@humblesims Can you tell me more? What methods did you try?

OP posts:
humblesims · 06/02/2022 15:56

It's hard to advise someone else how to parent. All I can say is that I did it with my first child and it is my greatest regret. It was awful for everyone. Worked for short periods but, for me and my child, I dont think it was worth the pain for all concerned.

babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 15:50

@Giraffesandbottoms

I wouldn't call someone who decides not to sleep train a "martyr". I think everyone is just trying to do what they feel is the best thing for them and their children.

However, the flip side of that is that it isn't very kind to use language such as "cruel" and "barbaric" about sleep training in the context of someone asking for advice about the best way to do it.

Comments such as "I would rather put up with broken sleep for as long as it lasts than listen to my baby cry" and even "you don't need to train your baby to sleep, you need to train yourself to accept a lack of sleep" Confused aren't actually helpful. And I do wonder how many of those people actually have a baby who wakes up every hour, or have a baby who wants to play every night between midnight and 4am most nights, or are trying to hold down a full time job. If their baby was different or their circumstances were different, they might have had to take a different approach.

I think everyone is just trying to do what they feel is best for their babies and their families, and we shouldn't be judgemental about each other.

OP posts:
Giraffesandbottoms · 06/02/2022 15:40

Also just for people who need to pick up a dictionary:

Martyr - someone who dies because of their religious faith.

Not a martyr - Mother who doesn’t want to sleep train because, on balance, she doesn’t think it’s the right thing to do (maybe in general or maybe just for her child). She’s still probably tired and it’s fine to complain about that. Like it’s fine for everyone to complain about things that they could technically probably change but don’t want to for a number of reasons. Eg people complaining about being fat. It doesn’t mean they don’t deserve sympathy and understanding.

Some people have a total lack of understanding on here about truly clingy babies and how upsetting some mothers find hearing their children cry.

Heartofglass12345 · 06/02/2022 15:04

I didn't sleep train as such, but I got them used to going in their Moses basket awake during the day while I was doing stuff, and would put them in there when I wanted them to sleep. Obviously there were times they fell asleep on us after a bottle, but generally they had their naps in there. In the evenings we had them in the Moses basket sleeping next to us in between their evening bottle and the last bottle they had before we went to bed, then took them up to our room.
My eldest slept really well most of the time, ironically he's now 8 and thinks sleep is for the weak Grin
My youngest would always have a little cry before he fell asleep but you could tell he was tired by the way he was acting so he would fall asleep not long after. We would pick them up and comfort them if they were crying, but if they were fed, changed and comfortable we would leave them for a few minutes and they would usually fall asleep.
When they went into their own rooms at around 6 months we would go in and comfort them if they were crying, sometimes giving a bottle to the eldest if he couldn't settle, and the youngest had a dummy while he was a newborn for a few weeks which helped.
My children were both premature so I don't know if that made a difference, they spent the first few weeks of their lives in incubators so weren't used to being held.
I think if you need to do it so that you can get some sleep, then you need to do it.

cadburyegg · 06/02/2022 14:14

I sleep trained DS1 at 6 months because he was spitting his dummy out every half an hour during the night. Worked a treat.

Have attempted to sleep train DS2 on numerous occasions. Whatever method I tried it either didn't work or worked for about 2 nights then went back to how it was before. Either way he still comes into my bed most nights and he's nearly 4. I get the most sleep this way and figure that he'll grow out of it eventually!

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 06/02/2022 14:09

@babyjellyfish

The OP asked for views on sleep training approaches from those who did it: she’s made that clear in a subsequent post.

Yes, I think perhaps I should have made that clearer.

People who never sleep trained their baby either had babies who slept reasonably well without sleep training (or by cosleeping), or were able to live in a sleep deprived state until their baby figured it out.

Unfortunately none of those things are applicable to our situation, so I want to hear from people who did it to try and work out what could be the best approach for us. I am pretty sure that me falling asleep at the wheel and having a fatal car accident would be far more traumatic for my baby than a bit of crying in his cot.

Our motivation for sleep training was that DH had fallen asleep driving home from work.

My second forgot how to sleep at about 18 months. When she was 2 we sleep trained her. We made sure she was healthy, not hungry, had everything she needed. Then we became very boring in the night. No milk or cuddles. Just the same reassuring phrase every time, and a reassuring rub, then we’d leave and come back 5 minutes later. The time we left he gradually got longer. Eventually she worked out that being awake in the night was boring, and she slept instead. It took about 2 weeks.

We did it based on HV advice, and we agreed what our approach was, so that we weren’t making difficult decisions in the middle of the night.

We had tried cosleeping but it doesn’t work when your baby/toddler has no interest in actually sleeping and just lies next to you chatting and wriggling.

Good luck.

JudgeJ · 06/02/2022 14:09

Agree. People would rather complain about no sleep than do anything about it too. As for causing mental damage what a load of shit, MN is crazy at times.

Brave post, especially on MN but I do agree, there's almost a martydom about lack of sleep. I know times change etc etc ad nauseum but both my babies were in their own room from day 1 and we all slept well. I'm sure that some of the current ways discourage sleep but, as the saying goes, crack on!

VestaTilley · 06/02/2022 13:44

Yes, aged 7 months, gentle controlled crying after a consultation and written plan from a sleep consultant.

I’d highly recommend it, but you must follow the plan to the letter. And please never resort to just leaving your baby to scream.

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 06/02/2022 13:39

@MarvEll

I'm very interested in the posters who did it earlier than we did with ours, as we ended up waiting until about 10 months, but with the next one I definitely feel more confident to do it earlier. Second pp about consistency, and getting day time sleep right. And also when you first do whichever brand of sleep training you go in for, make sure you and partner are both on board, support each other. We did me for nights 1&2, then him for 3&4 and then me again. But by then it was sorted
Our GP cleared us to sleep train DC3 at three months based on his weight! I didn’t see the point of sleep training before the 4-month regression, so we waited until he started waking up every 2 hours at 4 months, then we did Ferber. I think it took around 5 nights. I kept one night feed (even though the GP said we didn’t have to) and went to him to feed him whatever time he first woke up as long as it was after 2am. Any other wake up, my DP handled. We eliminated the last feed at around 6 months. Now at 8 months old DC3 sleeps roughly 7-5:30. And my friends and relatives all consider him a bad sleeper! Mumsnet is s funny place sometimes. It feels like they expect a 14-year-old should still be waking up multiple times a night to breastfeed hahaha!
Sexnotgender · 06/02/2022 13:18

I am pretty sure that me falling asleep at the wheel and having a fatal car accident would be far more traumatic for my baby than a bit of crying in his cot.

Totally. Your needs matter too. Sleep deprivation is a form of torture.

My daughter is almost 10 months, I’m very lucky that she’s a good sleeper. What worked for me was separating feeding and sleeping. We do feed then bath then bed.

She’s been in her own room since just after 6 months, I had intended to keep her in our room longer like my son who was in with us until about 14 months but she was a much lighter sleeper and we were definitely disturbing her.

babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 11:25

The OP asked for views on sleep training approaches from those who did it: she’s made that clear in a subsequent post.

Yes, I think perhaps I should have made that clearer.

People who never sleep trained their baby either had babies who slept reasonably well without sleep training (or by cosleeping), or were able to live in a sleep deprived state until their baby figured it out.

Unfortunately none of those things are applicable to our situation, so I want to hear from people who did it to try and work out what could be the best approach for us. I am pretty sure that me falling asleep at the wheel and having a fatal car accident would be far more traumatic for my baby than a bit of crying in his cot.

OP posts:
Giraffesandbottoms · 06/02/2022 10:47

@Piglet89

It’s not goady that you have a different approach. It’s goady because you say things like “showing him who is the boss” about a baby. But you already knew that. Just like on the thread about baby food you knew that coming on and saying you fed your 1 year old or 10 month old (can’t remember but something silly) chocolate every day and the way you phrased it in particular was goady.

I just don’t believe anyone feels the way you do, sorry. Doing those things isn’t the issue. It’s the gleeful way you describe them and the provocative nature of your phrasing.

Anyway wanted to explain but not going to make the mistake of getting drawn in further.

Clueless2000 · 06/02/2022 10:36

Whenever sleep training is mentioned on here, lots of posters immediately assume sleep training=controlled crying. It doesn’t. There are lots of methods which don’t include leaving your child to cry.

So PP, are you asking if people sleep trained their children or are you asking if they used the controlled crying method?

I sleep trained using the Baby Whisperer pick up put down method. It involves being with your child the whole time, no controlled crying, they don’t get distressed and it was hands down the best thing I ever did. Worked amazingly well and I had a happy, secure, well rested baby.

Piglet89 · 06/02/2022 10:20

@Giraffesandbottoms I genuinely find it quite puzzling that you think my posts “goady”. As I said to a PP, why would you care how we dealt with our son’s sleep? You have a different approach and parenting style: that’s fine. You do you, as they say nowadays. We aren’t co-parenting, so it’s not important we agree on this stuff.

The OP asked for views on sleep training approaches from those who did it: she’s made that clear in a subsequent post. My approach isn’t yours, but I did do some sleep training and I explained what I did. That’s all useful data for OP. She doesn’t have to do it herself, but she can know someone out there did.

But to even think about getting worked up about it, such that you have to say “Oh no, she’s just goady, I’ll tell myself to ignore her”: I mean, just why?!

MooseBreath · 06/02/2022 10:15

Yes. I used the Ferber Method at 6 months. It took about a week and a half, but it made a massive difference in DS's sleep. Before sleep training, he was waking up every 40 minutes all night (from 2 months old) and I was so exhausted that I couldn't be a good parent. After sleep training, he would typically go 6 hours, have a bottle, then back to sleep for 6 hours. So much better, and he was happier for it!

FlamingRoses · 06/02/2022 09:53

Yes.

CIO for first, after trying CC. Didn’t work for them.

CC for second.

Sceptre86 · 06/02/2022 09:37

With the older two no, they wouldn't sleep unless rocked or held. With my 5 month old I'm not sure if this counts as sleep training but if I put her down semi drowsy after a feed she falls asleep on her own. I will stand outside the door and if she is babbling leave her to it and she falls asleep by herself. If she cries I would intervene and rock or cuddle her till she fell asleep. She has been sleeping through since she was 3 months old but I think that is all down to her and not influenced by me.

I wouldn't try controlled crying but as far as I'm aware that is different to sleep training.

MarvEll · 06/02/2022 09:31

I'm very interested in the posters who did it earlier than we did with ours, as we ended up waiting until about 10 months, but with the next one I definitely feel more confident to do it earlier.
Second pp about consistency, and getting day time sleep right.
And also when you first do whichever brand of sleep training you go in for, make sure you and partner are both on board, support each other. We did me for nights 1&2, then him for 3&4 and then me again. But by then it was sorted

Swipe left for the next trending thread