Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you sleep trained your baby

411 replies

babyjellyfish · 05/02/2022 11:12

What approach did you take, how old was your baby and how successful was it?

Looking for a range of views and experiences.

Thank you.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThatsNotMyMuffin · 10/02/2022 11:05

Later has been several times accused of cherry picking evidence. She presents good evidence, but it's all basically to back up her parenting choices. Also a lot of the evidence and studies she gives is 'parent reported' which is not really an appropriate way to collect data. If I spent a week not eating sugar, I'm more likely to report that I feel I've lost weight etc. So relying on parents reporting after they have done sleep training is going to have a huge confirmation bias, as well as a placebo effect.

OP so glad you're getting better sleep!

Sexnotgender · 10/02/2022 10:46

@babyjellyfish

Last night baby slept through from 8:15 to 4:30am and then with a little encouragement slept for another hour. (Apparently; it was my husband's turn to sleep in there next to him.)

I did a face mask and then got 7 hours' uninterrupted sleep in the spare room. Grin

Slashing his daytime naps in half seems to be helping, but it's still early days.

We'll carry on like this until the weekend and then I think we'll take one side off his cot and try putting his mattress back in it, still with someone sleeping on the mattress next to him so he knows he's not alone.

That’s fantastic. Hope you feel a little more positive now.
Samanabanana · 09/02/2022 15:10

@GrendelsGrandma you know there's no sabertooth tiger but your baby doesn't!

Piglet89 · 09/02/2022 14:01

Agreed thank you @coraka - lovely, balanced posts.

Somethingsnappy · 09/02/2022 13:21

@coraka, I just wanted to say well done on your kind, thoughtful and thought-provoking posts, especially in the face of some very harsh criticism!

JustAnotherUserinParadise · 09/02/2022 13:08

@babyjellyfish that's brilliant progress! Fingers crossed it continues for you!

Piglet89 · 09/02/2022 12:13

@nanbread I do think there has been research done on links between autism and sleep issues.

nanbread · 09/02/2022 10:17

We tried it, multiple times (never full CIO), didn't work, I was close to mental breakdown through lack of sleep. Didn't sleep through until 4yo. Turns out DC is probably autistic and I wonder if it is linked.

RedHelenB · 09/02/2022 10:11

I let my babies cry themselves to sleep, it's how they settled. Sounds harsh but babies cry when they're tired and the best thing to sort that was to be able to self settle
. None of them cried for long and when they were poorly they had a different cry and obviously slept with me then.
Don't think any of them remember how they went to sleep as babies now they’re grown

babyjellyfish · 09/02/2022 10:04

Last night baby slept through from 8:15 to 4:30am and then with a little encouragement slept for another hour. (Apparently; it was my husband's turn to sleep in there next to him.)

I did a face mask and then got 7 hours' uninterrupted sleep in the spare room. Grin

Slashing his daytime naps in half seems to be helping, but it's still early days.

We'll carry on like this until the weekend and then I think we'll take one side off his cot and try putting his mattress back in it, still with someone sleeping on the mattress next to him so he knows he's not alone.

OP posts:
coraka · 09/02/2022 00:22

[quote Xds1453]@coraka

I know what it’s like to be severely sleep deprived? I was hallucinating when I left hospital after a traumatic crash c section and haemorrhage and week on the ward with 1 hour sleep or less a night. Breastfeeding so still no chance to catch up once home, a baby with tongue tie and severe colic who constantly cried and never had these long naps in the day that everyone told me about. I obviously developed PND and on top PTSD . My baby didn’t sleep in stretches for months, I was a mess and felt suicidal, all I wanted was to sleep properly but guess what …I didn’t leave my baby to scream for 50 bloody minutes. I will say it’s cruel because it is , I hope no one else looking for tips on here copies you. CIO is horrendous. Gentle sleep training should be the only thing people try.[/quote]
I’m sorry you had such a difficult time - so many of us have similar stories of childbirth and early motherhood. We all make huge sacrifices and take huge personal risks to give our babies life. I’m glad you are happy with your decision, I hope you received good support and that things are going better for you now.

Breastfeeding is another one where terrible guilt and pressure is put on mothers. It’s so hard when things don’t go according to plan and we all want to do what’s “best”. Unfortunately we will never have perfect knowledge, there are so many decisions to make and risks to weigh up, vaccinations, schooling, tonsillectomies, contact sports, it’s never-ending as a parent. But I try not to agonise over the past and simply repeat what I said before, that we all make the best decisions we can with the information we have at the time and we do it with love.

I’d like mothers who are currently suffering as we were to be able to access support and information so that they can make their own decisions and be at peace with them.

Scottishskifun · 09/02/2022 00:14

I think there are many misconceptions about sleep training and many different methods!

We did sleep training with DS, he woke every 40 mins, I wasn't safe to function let alone get behind the wheel of a car!
We followed the Lucy Wolfe method of stay and comfort and it worked for us. We still refer back to the book when we get a bit of regression but most nights sleeps through from 7ish til 7am at 3 years old.
I didn't follow the suggested feeding plan and still gave a night feed til he was 1 year but he dropped that himself.

I did receive judgement for it but tbh it was done partly for my health and I became a far better mother for not surviving on 10 mins of broken sleep every hour!
Do what's best for you and your family!

coraka · 09/02/2022 00:06

@5keletor

You can't really trust the research quoted by Emily Oster as far as I can tell. She mainly seems to reference that support her idea that sleep training isn't damaging, yet she acknowledges that there isn't enough research to prove it either way, which is contradictory... so research doesn't show that it isn't damaging. It's easy to find "research" that backs up what you want to believe, but the source, sample sizes, and amount of trials conducted are very important in deeming whether it's worthwhile.

Also, let's not worry people that feeding their baby to sleep will cause that baby not to sleep. 🤦‍♀️ I see enough mums in support groups feeling extremely upset because they've been led to believe that feeding to sleep is what has caused their baby to wake numerous times, and HCPs and peer supporters having to reassure them it's not the case and that they've done nothing wrong.

Oster is an economist whose entire career involves analysing statistics. She looks at all the available studies on different topics and assesses the strengths and weaknesses of each. She points out when there is missing or contradictory data and seeks to explain her reasoning for a general audience. Of course you can still look at the same evidence and draw a different conclusion about which risk you’re willing to take, but I don’t see why you’d think that there’s any reason to doubt her methods. Unless you were very committed to a particular view already and not willing to consider the evidence.
Lovingeveryrainbow · 08/02/2022 23:09

I did. Whether DS napped or not he was put down for some quiet time, and eventually I did that in the evening too. He learned to self soothe and drift into sleep. I used to hear him in there babbling until he fell asleep. He does the same now but with books.

RidingMyBike · 08/02/2022 22:20

The point about Emily Oster is that she looks at the research available and assesses it's quality as well as what it's actually saying. She doesn't cherry pick to suit what she thinks.

GrendelsGrandma · 08/02/2022 22:12

[quote Xds1453]@coraka

I know what it’s like to be severely sleep deprived? I was hallucinating when I left hospital after a traumatic crash c section and haemorrhage and week on the ward with 1 hour sleep or less a night. Breastfeeding so still no chance to catch up once home, a baby with tongue tie and severe colic who constantly cried and never had these long naps in the day that everyone told me about. I obviously developed PND and on top PTSD . My baby didn’t sleep in stretches for months, I was a mess and felt suicidal, all I wanted was to sleep properly but guess what …I didn’t leave my baby to scream for 50 bloody minutes. I will say it’s cruel because it is , I hope no one else looking for tips on here copies you. CIO is horrendous. Gentle sleep training should be the only thing people try.[/quote]
Uh @xds1453 I'm sorry you had such a hard time. However I don't think anyone advocates sleep training for very tiny babies, most guides seem to start at six months.

EezyOozy · 08/02/2022 22:12

I did controlled crying with my 10mo who was waking up regularly (and was grumpy , just wanted to go back to sleep but couldn't, everything we did seemed to annoy her). I was also pregnant and very ill / shattered and had to go back to work. Controlled crying for 2 nights (NOT cry it out). Slept through on 3rd night.

5keletor · 08/02/2022 22:09

*seems to reference studies that...

5keletor · 08/02/2022 22:08

You can't really trust the research quoted by Emily Oster as far as I can tell. She mainly seems to reference that support her idea that sleep training isn't damaging, yet she acknowledges that there isn't enough research to prove it either way, which is contradictory... so research doesn't show that it isn't damaging. It's easy to find "research" that backs up what you want to believe, but the source, sample sizes, and amount of trials conducted are very important in deeming whether it's worthwhile.

Also, let's not worry people that feeding their baby to sleep will cause that baby not to sleep. 🤦‍♀️ I see enough mums in support groups feeling extremely upset because they've been led to believe that feeding to sleep is what has caused their baby to wake numerous times, and HCPs and peer supporters having to reassure them it's not the case and that they've done nothing wrong.

Xds1453 · 08/02/2022 21:29

@coraka

I know what it’s like to be severely sleep deprived? I was hallucinating when I left hospital after a traumatic crash c section and haemorrhage and week on the ward with 1 hour sleep or less a night. Breastfeeding so still no chance to catch up once home, a baby with tongue tie and severe colic who constantly cried and never had these long naps in the day that everyone told me about. I obviously developed PND and on top PTSD . My baby didn’t sleep in stretches for months, I was a mess and felt suicidal, all I wanted was to sleep properly but guess what …I didn’t leave my baby to scream for 50 bloody minutes. I will say it’s cruel because it is , I hope no one else looking for tips on here copies you. CIO is horrendous. Gentle sleep training should be the only thing people try.

Giraffesandbottoms · 08/02/2022 20:11

The term "bad sleeper" is incredibly misleading. There's no such thing as a bad sleeper but definitely such a thing as a bad habit

BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!

Crumbleburntbits · 08/02/2022 17:44

Yes, my DC were all sleep trained at 6 months. They are all happy, healthy adults now and have not been damaged by being taught to sleep in their own beds!

BobbyeinArkansas · 08/02/2022 17:26

Yes, gently. By gently I mean always keeping the light off when they woke up at night. Lots of shush/pat and not to much engagement or eye contact but cuddles if they were needed.
The baby was sleeping from 7-7 with an 11pm dream feed from 2 months.
By 6 months it was 7-7.
We have never looked back.
The term "bad sleeper" is incredibly misleading. There's no such thing as a bad sleeper but definitely such a thing as a bad habit. Such as feeding to sleep for example. Babies should learn to self settle.
If you're happy to have years of broken sleep, then by all means feed to sleep, lie beside them until they fall asleep etc.
But I value sleep and trained my baby accordingly.

Gynaesaur · 08/02/2022 16:50

How have so many people managed to completely ignore the fact that sleep training a baby rarely means just leaving them alone to cry? As has been stated over and over and over again.

If people want to post sad face emojis and "Oh, I could never..." then it surely isn't hard to find a thread about something more dire than slowly retreating from a baby who's safe, fed and warm in their own home.

GrendelsGrandma · 08/02/2022 16:21

@Samanabanana

I can't imagine leaving a baby or toddler alone in a room crying. And I say that as the mother of a child who slept terribly until they were two (and a baby who will only sleep in my arms Grin). They all learn to sleep through the night eventually, it's not a skill you can teach, it's developmental. All babies left to cry will go silent eventually, bevause evolution taught them that if no one comes to their rescue when crying, it's safer to shut down Sad
@samambanana

What you're saying is, having spent years and years of sleep deprivation, you refuse to believe that there could have been an alternative. Because that would mean you'd gone through all that unnecessarily.

Yes, they learn to sleep eventually. Some mothers would lose their jobs, relationships and physical/mental health in the process.

Sleep training doesn't necessarily involve leaving a baby alone in a room. With many methods, you're there with them but not letting them fall asleep in your arms.

Babies don't 'go silent', they go to sleep. I know. I had babies who sleep trained and they were definitely asleep. Most of the time they were happy to go in their cot as they liked being there. Are you saying a baby that goes in the cot and is happy and gurgling and chatting to themselves is terribly distressed but putting on a show for its parents' benefit?

Honestly. Keep your sad faces, don't lecture people about something you haven't done and don't understand. This thing about evolution making them stay silent in terror - maybe they're upset the first night (and most sleep training methods mean a parent is nearby to provide reassurance). After a few nights, they just start to associate their cot with sleep. Up until then they associate milk/boobs/parents' arms with sleep. Sleep training teaches them different sleep cues. That's all it is. You're not leaving them alone in a cave with a sabre-toothed tiger, FFS.

Swipe left for the next trending thread