Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If your neighbours dog was incessantly barking, what would help?

88 replies

Awkwardusername · 05/02/2022 10:52

Obviously it’s annoying, and a total pain for everyone involved, but our 10 month old dog will not shut up at night!

She’s doing it for attention and everything we’ve read basically says ignore it, which we’re trying, but we’re really worried about the neighbours! We only moved in a few months ago and although they’re all friendly etc, they’re all a lot older than us.

We have spoken to them a few times apologising but last night, the dog was on another level!

Is there anything that might help/pacify them a little?

(Please don’t lecture me about the dog by the way, we’re trying our best, and usually if it gets really bad my partner will go downstairs and sleep on the sofa with her but we need to get her back in the habit of sleeping in her crate by herself!)

OP posts:
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/02/2022 11:40

Realistically, you have two options here, neither of which involve trying to pacify your neighbours.

1 - your DP sleeps downstairs all night and slowly starts to move away from the dog when she's happy to sleep all night with him there. So, that might involve sleeping all night on the sofa - then when she's happy with that, move to the hallway, then the room next door, then upstairs etc.

2 - move the dog upstairs and just let her sleep in with you. You can slowly move her crate away as she settles (if you really feel you need to) but this way, you at least get to sleep in your own bed!

Leaving your dog to whine and cry until it "gets really bad" isn't fair on the dog or your neighbours - and I guarantee they can hear more than they let on they can.

I say all of this as a dog owner with a dog that dislikes being left, so we've had to work really hard to help him settle by himself. It's restrictive and frustrating but it was my choice to get him, not my neighbours', so they shouldn't have to be woken up by his behaviour.

Our neighbours have a dog that is just left in the garden to bark and it's so frustrating as he sets everyone else's dogs off as well, but I'd hate to complain as I dislike confrontation and wouldn't want to get ostracised or to cause bad feeling, lol.

HappyDays40 · 05/02/2022 11:28

We tried leaving our dog downstairs and lasted 20 minutes it was a disaster and it kept waking our son.
He sleeps on the bed now either on the bed of ours or with our son

Serenity45 · 05/02/2022 11:28

Our lab is 8 months old now and we tried to do the crate training thing as it seemed to be the 'right' way to go about it. Happy as Larry in it during the day, taking herself off for naps etc. Left in it in spacious kitchen overnight, and even with us setting alarms to go down every 3 hours ish to let her out (she was 3 months at the time) she was so distressed and anxious (howling / barking / crying) we couldn't continue. We gave it 2 weeks of being really firm and might have continued had we not gone on holiday.

We'd rented a dog friendly posh cabin which was essentially one massive room so pup was 'in with us' as nowhere to shut her away. It was a revelation. She slept through a good 8 hours every night, no mess inside and no anxiety (she is generally a very confident / social pup so not prone to being anxious).

When we got home we tried her in the kitchen again for a night or two...cut a long story short she happily sleeps in an open snuggly dog bed in our bedroom (we are lucky to have plenty of space for this). She knows she's not allowed on the bed, though will occasionally hop on in the morning if we aren't up. We all sleep better and I don't have the guilt.

Every dog is different and this works for us. Crate training is great as dogs may need to be crated at times e.g. at vets, but you don't have to slavishly follow what all the professionals say is the 'right' way (not saying you're doing this btw!). We have an enclosed carrier for car journeys that she's only just outgrown and was fine with, so it really was just being away from us overnight that was distressing. She doesn't have separation anxiety either - happily stays with family when we've been away on non dog friendly trips.

thereisonlyoneofme · 05/02/2022 11:28

My dog starts getting excited at exactly 7.15 every morning. No idea what starts it as heating goes on at 6.30, no one next door goes out to work or makes a noise ! I end up getting up and she starts barking while I am getting my slippers and robe on and trying to get downstairs before she annoys the neighbours. I know 7.15 isnt particularly early unless its the weekend, havent been able to stop this. Its not needing a either.

VanGoghsDog · 05/02/2022 11:28

@twoladsnow

"VanGoghsDog

Is there anything that might help/pacify them a little?

Flowers?"

No. That just guilts the neighbours into not complaining and would only work for a short time

Which is exactly what the OP was asking!

Confrontayshunme · 05/02/2022 11:23

I dread the weekends because my NDN lets her dog bark for 20 minutes alone every morning at 6ish at every night about 11pm. During the week I get up at 6 am just before him, but I loathe them both so much now and the only thing that would make it better is if she stops him barking. She doesn't even try to stop his alarm barking anymore, but it is the leaving him to bark that is SO annoying. You need to tell them exactly what steps you are doing to fix it, and promise that if they do not work in two weeks that you will revert to whatever it takes to stop him, even if that means YOU staying up all night with him saying shhhhh every time he starts.

FirewomanSam · 05/02/2022 11:21

I am both a dog owner (not a particularly barky one but he has his moments) and the neighbour of a very barky dog. I think communication is the best thing you can do. Keep checking with them to make sure they genuinely can’t hear her, and make it clear that you really do want to know if she’s bothering them.

I was going to say move her as far away from any shared walls as possible, especially from their bedrooms, but it sounds like you’ve already done that.

Be as generous and helpful as you can with other matters to maintain a good relationship and obviously, it’s helpful they make noise of their own from time to time that you can ‘let slide’ so there’s a bit of give and take!

But I second all the points about stopping the dog from barking in the first place. There’s nothing wrong with comforting her if she’s in distress and it’s been shown that ‘crying it out’ really isn’t all that helpful for dogs. If you don’t want her in your bedroom maybe you can sleep downstairs with her (all night, not just when the barking gets bad) for a few days until she feels more comfortable being alone again? A trainer would be able to help with this.

MrsSkylerWhite · 05/02/2022 11:17

Are you planning on having her neutered?

Awkwardusername · 05/02/2022 11:17

@MayThePawsBeWithYou

Why does she need to be alone in a crate, how does she go to the toilet. I would ket her sleep upstairs with you, she is lonely. Does she have a long walk before bedtime.
She goes to the toilet before she goes to bed and then when my partner gets up in the night, so I don’t think it’s that!

Yep, long walk before bed, later than usual at the minute though as she’s in season so we’re swerving other dogs!

OP posts:
Awkwardusername · 05/02/2022 11:16

@DistrictCommissioner

If it’s only starting at 5am, does she need to be let out for the toilet??
Don’t think so, my partner gets up at about half two like clockwork for a wee so he lets her out at the same time!
OP posts:
MayThePawsBeWithYou · 05/02/2022 11:14

Why does she need to be alone in a crate, how does she go to the toilet. I would ket her sleep upstairs with you, she is lonely. Does she have a long walk before bedtime.

DistrictCommissioner · 05/02/2022 11:11

If it’s only starting at 5am, does she need to be let out for the toilet??

Awkwardusername · 05/02/2022 11:08

@Elphame

How is the dog if you go out and leave it? Does she bark then as well?

Some breeds are very prone to separation anxiety and if you have one you may need professional help.

She’s not bothered at all, it’s only on a night!
OP posts:
Awkwardusername · 05/02/2022 11:06

Actually now I’m thinking about it, it’s about 5am she starts barking normally (happy enough in there until then at least!) so maybe the noise of the pipes when the heating is coming on is the problem?! Disturbing her?

I can feel myself making excuses for her here, sorry!

The neighbours have been adamant they can “barely hear her” and I know the walls are quite thick; she’s downstairs at the back of our house and their bedroom is upstairs at the front of theirs but I’m so paranoid and don’t want to be the annoying neighbour!

OP posts:
Elphame · 05/02/2022 11:05

Oh - I've just seen your update.

Yes that could very well be the problem. She'll be calling for a mate!

Elphame · 05/02/2022 11:04

How is the dog if you go out and leave it? Does she bark then as well?

Some breeds are very prone to separation anxiety and if you have one you may need professional help.

Awkwardusername · 05/02/2022 11:03

@DistrictCommissioner

How long has it been going on for?
A week or two now; it isn’t every night though! Most nights however so I feel awful!

She normally bloody loves her crate, so not sure what’s changed! She’s in season at the moment so I’m wondering if that’s why she’s kicking off?

She’s a large dog so we have her in a crate to protect her (still growing) joints at night, as she enjoys nothing more than backflipping off the sofa!

OP posts:
BringBackCoffeeCreams · 05/02/2022 11:03

You do whatever is necessary to stop the barking as soon as it starts. Ignoring it because it's 'for attention' is an absolute cop out. Letting your dog disturb your neighbours is inexcusable. My DH used to walk our dogs for hours in the middle of the night as it was the only thing that shut them up.

Devilmakes3 · 05/02/2022 11:00

Can she sleep in your room or one of the kids rooms? You cannot just have her barking night after night that really isn’t an answer. She is scared and/or lonely address those emotions and you have addressed the issue.

twoladsnow · 05/02/2022 11:00

@Eloradannin2nd

I've also been your neighbour, several times over. It doesn't matter what you say to your neighbours, you will be making their lives hell until your dog stops barking. I've been at the point where even when the dog next door wasn't barking, I couldn't relax in my own home because I was on edge waiting for it to start again. Yours is disturbing your neighbours at night, that's unforgivable, sorry.
Yep, it's bloody awful.

I used to hear the spring on the crate door, wait 30 seconds for the incessant barking to start.

One of the owners who worked from home would go and sit in his car to get some peace. Wanker!

Whattochoosenow · 05/02/2022 10:59

We got fed up with sleepless nights, ours sleeps in the bedroom. At some point we’ll start gradually moving her bed out of the door. She’s happy and settled.
Ours isn’t crate trained. She has the run of the kitchen and utility room when we go out, with the radio on, Adaptil plug in, and Pet Remedy sprayed on her bed.

SpringSparrow · 05/02/2022 10:59

If your dog is barking to the extent it’s disturbing your neighbours, then you need to stop it. If that means the dog is upstairs with you or you are downstairs with the dog so be it. They could complain to the council about the noise. Not sure why you have a ten month dog in a crate either!

girlmom21 · 05/02/2022 10:59

Don't shove your dog in a crate?

If you don't want the dog on the sofa that's fine. Get them a nice bed and train them to stay off the sofa.

GeneLovesJezebel · 05/02/2022 10:58

Have the dog in your room. It wants to be near you.

MrsBungle · 05/02/2022 10:58

My dog hated her crate and hated sleeping alone. She now sleeps silently in my room and we are all happier.

Swipe left for the next trending thread