Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If your neighbours dog was incessantly barking, what would help?

88 replies

Awkwardusername · 05/02/2022 10:52

Obviously it’s annoying, and a total pain for everyone involved, but our 10 month old dog will not shut up at night!

She’s doing it for attention and everything we’ve read basically says ignore it, which we’re trying, but we’re really worried about the neighbours! We only moved in a few months ago and although they’re all friendly etc, they’re all a lot older than us.

We have spoken to them a few times apologising but last night, the dog was on another level!

Is there anything that might help/pacify them a little?

(Please don’t lecture me about the dog by the way, we’re trying our best, and usually if it gets really bad my partner will go downstairs and sleep on the sofa with her but we need to get her back in the habit of sleeping in her crate by herself!)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
longtompot · 06/02/2022 11:28

We had to bring our dog up into our bedroom when our old cat started to have eyesight issues and we had to shut him in the living room. Our dog sleeps on our bed whilst we read but when we turn the lights out she goes in her bed. When the sun starts to come up, she jumps onto our bed and sleeps with us until the alarm.
I think with your dog, as it's such a recent thing, it seems to be connected to her coming into season and she is calling for a mate. Seasons only last a few weeks, so you could be near the end of this and hopefully it won't happen again.

Iamkmackered1979 · 06/02/2022 11:20

Something has obviously happened to make your dog suddenly bark at night sometimes it can be something that’s happened on a walk or something that’s frightened it or similar and now he’s getting lots of attention.

Have you tried him out of his crate at night? My pup has a crate but it is never locked he goes in happily it’s in the kitchen and he has free reign of downstairs. He is loose in the house in the day and goes to ‘bed’ in the kitchen at night (17 months) I think you probably need to go back to basics with him. Boundary train?

Give the crate tonnes of value so lovely treats and games and fun so he associates it with being a good Place to be, there’s more to it but I’m sure a Google will give you more info. Works for our dog and he has a ‘boundary’ everywhere we go it gives him his own place to be. Why does he get let out at 2am? I would not do this, dogs need quite a lot of sleep so you’re disturbing him for no real reason except habit mine have never gone out at 2am or overnight so I would let out before bed - on lead so there’s so messing about (my pup would just want to play) and first thing. You could cover the crate? Does work for my boy he likes it dark but flap at front is always open. Use a baby gate to stop roaming the house if you’d prefer. I don’t have dogs upstairs and I don’t want mine in my room he’s quite happy in his bed downstairs but if it works for you. Id find a dog trainer if I were you someone who trains positively and reward based and can do 1:1 for you to give you methods to try because the barking can get worse and worse

MandyCarter · 06/02/2022 11:10

Keep the crate and buy a dog bed to see what they prefer. We built in the command 'enough' when ours got barky. Reward the behaviour you want
and don't ever send him to his bed/crate for being naughty or not getting it right. He is a baby. It's hard work but very rewarding
You'll get there honestly

pilates · 06/02/2022 11:06

Put a dog bed in your room. You won’t hear a peep out of her.

lovenotwar149 · 06/02/2022 11:01

oops...peoples sleep gets disturbed I meant

Oti22 · 06/02/2022 11:01

We also have a large 10 month old dog and scrapped the crate within a couple of weeks as he hated it. We tried upstairs without a crate but he wanted to be downstairs and he’s sleeps in the safest room downstairs with a large baby gate. He also prefers a towel/blanket or the floor to his bed! He settled so well after we scrapped it. He usually wakes around 7 am and barks once to let us know he’s up but if he wakes earlier (not middle of the night - we ignored him when he did this as going down reinforced the behaviour but this hasn’t happened for months now and wasn’t a regular occurrence) we just let him up with us. It’s taken time but he now likes a little nap on the bed and we get an extra hour or twos sleep. He can go 10 pm - 8 am without needing to go out for the toilet so yours shouldn’t be barking for the loo… Also go off your vets advice around spaying we were told our male should not be done until closer to 2 due to his size. I imagine it’s similar for large female.

lovenotwar149 · 06/02/2022 11:01

The odd night here and there where neighbours are disturbed...fair enough, it happens. When it is repeated due to a dog barking, dodgy house alarm going off in the middle of the night, car alarm going off at 3am repeatedly....peoples sleepiest disturbed...no one likes that! Saying sorry, buying them flowers...yh nicer than saying nothing...bottom line....if peoples sleep are getting disturbed...no one likes that! Good luck with the dog :)

CookPassBabtridge · 06/02/2022 10:59

Jesus wept just have her in your bedroom! We have ours in a crate next to the bed.
Living next to a barking dog is HELL and very very unfair.

TatianaBis · 06/02/2022 10:55

Ditch the crate, they’re awful, have her sleep somewhere for the moment where she doesn’t make a noise and get a trainer in this week.

itwasntaparty · 06/02/2022 10:48

Just ditch the crate, sounds like she's a long way away from your room.

RedChapter · 06/02/2022 10:37

My neighbours dog barks all day, any time anyone or anything is in its sight. Its given full access to all windows and sits all day waiting to go nuts. It's a screaming manic loud bark . I have a dog, I love dogs. But I can say, hand on heart, I truly hate this dog. Terrible thing to say, it's not the dogs fault (and all that) but if it disappeared into thin air, I'd rejoice.
The neighbours are incapable of training the dog and have even given up their occasional token efforts.

Meandthesky · 06/02/2022 10:36

Are you going to have her spayed after this season? (You should)

Either have her upstairs with your or one of you sleep downstairs with her.

MrsKeats · 06/02/2022 10:35

I despise 'crate training' which is a euphemism for locking a dog in a cage.
It's cruel and how can you blame a dog for hating it?

Pinchofnom · 06/02/2022 10:32

Sorry OP but I think you either need to get rid of the crate or invest in a trainer asap.

We’ve been the victims of a neighbours noisy dog (outside barking) which kept our DC up throughout the wee hours. It did generate a fair bit of animosity between the neighbours so I’d recommend trying to get to a solution fast.

Wheelz46 · 06/02/2022 10:30

We crate trained our dog with the intention of moving him to just a bed but this didn't work out, he loves the crate and wouldn't sleep anywhere else, so please ignore the posts saying just ditch it, unless he absolutely hates it.

In terms of barking, mine did go through a phase of being on the noisy side, now we have a pet tracker attached to the collar which you can also set commands on which is connected to your phone. If he barked, we used the command quiet, it worked!

If you don't wish to have a pet tracker, you can get a pet cam where you can also speak to them through, that works a treat too.

MintyGreenDream · 06/02/2022 10:27

Put the crate in a room that isnt a party wall to your neighbours.

lljkk · 06/02/2022 10:23

Neighbour's dog stopped barking when he was crated, felt more secure in a crate (he lived in kennels until 1 yr old & he struggled without boundaries). Ditch the crate if your dog hates it.

sixswans · 06/02/2022 10:18

She might be too young to be alone at night. dog bed in your room?

SoupDragon · 06/02/2022 09:55

Next door's dog is a barker. He barks at everything and anything (whilst my dog watches him silently through the fence). It is always annoying but knowing that they were trying to train him out of it did help with the annoyance although that seems to have stopped now and he barks without reproach.

Nothing seemed to work with him, they even had a trainer in to try and sort out. My dog has never been a barker but I had no input into that at all - he just isn't!

2022booklover · 06/02/2022 09:50

I had a dog who didn’t bark at all ever. But when she came into season (only twice before I had her neutered) she would whine. So it could definitely be that.

That said I’ve never crated my dogs (tried with my current - male, he cried so I just gave up and let him on the bed (he’s small though).

MyGlassKeepsLeaking · 06/02/2022 09:46

Take her out of the crate? It clearly doesn't work to have her in there. Dogs are pack animals, and you all are her pack. She's lonely.

LakieLady · 06/02/2022 09:46

Damn, strikethrough fail.

LakieLady · 06/02/2022 09:45

My last dog beat me into submission in the end.

I decided to try her crate in my bedroom in the hope that she'd finally shut the fuck up settle. It sort of worked.

She didn't bark, but just kept rattling the crate, pulling at it with her teeth and clawing at it. At some point in the small hours, on the 3rd night of next to no sleep, I gave in and opened it.

She was up on the bed within a few seconds, snuggled up next to me, and we both slept solidly for the rest of the night.

She turned out to be the most perfect bed dog, and she was small, even for a lakeland terrier, which are small to start with.They don't moult, so the bed doesn't get covered in hair.

She slept on my bed for the rest of her life. It's 15 months since I lost her, and I still sometimes wonder where she is when I wake in the night.

I can see this might not be an acceptable solution if you had a St Bernard or something though.

HandWash · 06/02/2022 09:43

Surely the answer is to get up at 5am and see to the dog? Making it your problem rather than the neighbour's?

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 06/02/2022 09:36

@user1471604848

My neighbour's dog used to bark so much, that even when it wasn't barking, I could still "hear" the barking in my head. It was awful. Luckily she didn't keep the dog, since she couldn't handle it.

Could you try a collar that stops them barking? (I don't have dogs, so don't know if they're cruel).

They are incredibly cruel.

Dogs who bark when they're alone generally do so because they're terrified and scared - punishing them for vocalising that fear is really unhelpful.

Imagine if you were alone and frightened and every time you shouted for help, you got shocked in the throat or had air or citronella sprayed in your face? Would it make you any less frightened?

Collars will either shut the dog up (and make them shut down as they're too frightened to do anything in case they get punished) or force them into showing their distress in other ways - destruction, toileting on the floor etc.

The only way to cure separation anxiety is to work on it with a behaviourist.

Swipe left for the next trending thread