Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make DS 14 study 5 days a week

142 replies

L0stinCyberspace · 05/02/2022 10:25

Is our study rota too much for DS 14 on a Mon Tue Wed Sat Sunday? 1 hour study max per day, 30 mins for 2 subjects on each day.

DS is very bright but very lazy re. study. Was considered "exceptional" in Maths by a teacher 2 years ago. Crams for all exams and still comes out with high marks. DH and I have noticed DS is disengaged with homework in the last few months and seems negative about classes, apart from 2 practical subjects. Spending nearly all his time online gaming when not playing sport that we bring him to.

His recent PT meeting confirmed our observations so we came up with a rota for study for 5 days a week. He has Thu off for music lessons and Fri off to chill. What do people think?

OP posts:
PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 13:48

Nachos2 - My DS1 is able and also got top grades in his mocks. I didn't make him study for an hour a day. He has been in top sets throughout his schooling. I just value other skills equally rather than forcing him to study all the time. Being able to do lots of things rather than just get 9s at GCSEs is way more important.

DS2 struggles as has a processing issue. To force him to study more is very stressful. He knows what he wants to do at college and what he needs to get there. He is very determined however we do not want him to study too much over his quality of life. He should pass all his exams but if he doesn't he can retake. There is plenty of time.

Getting As does not equal being a high earner!

Whattochoosenow · 05/02/2022 13:48

“Our study rota” ??
He’s 14 ! Far better to have a rational chat about life choices and opportunities.

PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 13:44

@Porcupineintherough the comments re not being rounded/sociable were in response to the poster saying her and her DH can afford private school for their DCs as they didn't go out partying like their peers and studied instead!

Porcupineintherough · 05/02/2022 13:41

Sounds about right to me OP.

Also a bit Hmm at the idea that an hour's study would stop you being well rounded and sociable. For my two it would just mean a hour less of farting around on line and have no impact on their social lives at all.

Nachos2 · 05/02/2022 13:37

MintJulia sounds like good parenting to me.

Assuming the child is able there are some low standards on here.

You all know that a good education, good grades means better prospects and choices in life. So many threads on MN wondering how people can earn more money, get on the housing ladder, save towards a pension. If it’s too late for you then look to your kids and encourage more homework less gaming and social media. They must have down time too of course but they will enjoy it more when they have done their hour of homework/study.

Raise your standards. Let your kids (again assuming they are able) feel what’s it like to be in a top set or get a A in a subject they enjoy.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 05/02/2022 13:17

@MintJulia

YANBU. My ds is 13 and had the same issue. Now we have an evening routine.

In from school, change, snack, homework until it's finished. Absolutely no gaming/internet beforehand.

At the weekend, we agree what needs to be done on Saturday morning. Agree when he will do it. I set an alarm on my phone. If he doesn't do it, the router goes off.

No negotiation.

I know you aren't feeding him glass or making him wear shoes two sizes too small but that's genuinely awful. What an existence. plus he's going to be completely under prepared for times in the not too distant future when he has to take responsibility for his time management.
VainAbigail · 05/02/2022 13:06

@MintJulia

YANBU. My ds is 13 and had the same issue. Now we have an evening routine.

In from school, change, snack, homework until it's finished. Absolutely no gaming/internet beforehand.

At the weekend, we agree what needs to be done on Saturday morning. Agree when he will do it. I set an alarm on my phone. If he doesn't do it, the router goes off.

No negotiation.

Your poor son when it comes to GCSE time.
PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 12:58

That last paragraph refers to young adults going into work, I understand that an older adult with more maturity that won't necessarily apply to.

PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 12:57

AlexaShutUp totally agree, I would also prefer my DCs didn't value studying and high exam grades over being a well rounded and sociable person. This is so so important to get on in life.

DS1 plays lots of sport, one in particular that takes up a huge amount of time. Is a working musician, again which takes up a lot of time but is also motivated at school. He will do well at school and is a well balanced lad so far.

DS2 has learning difficulties, autism and ADHD also, he will have to study more but whilst academically he is capable of 5-7 grades we will be concentrating on him getting 4/5 grades in order to get on the college course he wants. I don't want him spending all his spare time studying.

If I was employing someone in my team at work I would want a well rounded, sociable individual who works hard, has motivation, common sense as well as the required qualifications. People who are micromanaged by parents will often only have the latter.

Gosports · 05/02/2022 12:45

What will he study though? Will you provide the materials? You’ll need a pretty in depth knowledge of his subjects if you want to start providing further reading etc.

AlexaShutUp · 05/02/2022 12:44

And yes, it's true that you can't make a kid study. One of dd's friend's parents did this during the GCSE years. They even locked his phone away to "help him focus". He just used his laptop to communicate with his friends instead.

I would have reacted very badly to being forced to sit down and study for an arbitrary length of time. It would totally demotivated my dd now too if we did this.

Warblerinwinter · 05/02/2022 12:40

@TheJoyOfCats

I was "made" to study from age 13 to 18 for 30 hours per week on average. I physically sat in the room I was supposed to be studying in but mainly day dreamed:) not much work done
This. You can’t make a child of any age “study”. If you do they’ll go to their room but they’ll still day dream, doodle, listen to music or whatever- and if pushed they’ll lie about what they’re doing. Result is you’ll never know how much studying they do. Better to say that he has to have x amount of time without gaming on these days . Let him decide what he does with that time. Spend your time rewarding him verbally when he does study and encouraging it, ask him what his study plans are, sure, provide advice on how he might do that. But do not kid yourself if he’s at his desk, even looking at books, he is automatically studying
Warblerinwinter · 05/02/2022 12:32

I think study days on both Saturday And Sunday at that age is a bit mean. Better for him to choose one of those days but double time- so same amount but not spread. That way he gets a full day at weekend when he doesn’t have to think about work.
How’d you like it being made to think about work or be in work 7 days a week?
As he gets older he may need to step up to 7 days for brief periods before exams etc ,( I did 10 hours/7days for 10 weeks prior to my end of year exams at uni ) but working 7 days a week is not a healthy habit, and certainly not at this age.
Instead try to also get him to go out for exercise r face to face time with mates rather than gaming

AlexaShutUp · 05/02/2022 12:26

Frankly the reason we can afford school fees now is because we studied when everyone else was at parties.

The idea of my dd missing out on a social life now so that she can waste her money on private school fees for my future grandchildren sounds absolutely horrendous in my view. That is not what I want for her at all.

No silver spoons here either, but I did plenty of socialising as a teenager and still managed to excel in my exams, go to Cambridge etc. We could afford private school fees for dd now but choose not to because we are confident that she will do just as well in state. So far, this has proved absolutely right and she is thriving. Excels academically and in her extracurricular activities, while also doing lots of socialising on the side. She's 16 and that kind of balance is what I want for her. Not some weird regimented life without any time to just be.

VioletOcean · 05/02/2022 12:25

My DD in secondary does maths everyday and any homework. She doesn’t do anything on a Friday but it’s at least an hour on the other days if not more. I have to nag her as she’s a lazy pickle !

Goldenbear · 05/02/2022 12:23

It's not really relevant whether they do something at private school, it is about the ability of the child in question. My DS is in year 10 and is bright, can pass exams easily, he is working at considerably higher level than his (very good) privately educated cousin who stuggles in Maths and science, he studies way more than DS due to the timetables of private schools, does sport on Saturday etc. But if anything he is resentful of doing that as he is an excellent football player but is forced to do all these other sports as he is a brilliant sportsman overall, he massively resents his time being micromanaged like this.

I agree though with the self motivation, my DS wants to be an Astrophysicist and this is all his own interest as we are both from Arts backgrounds. He is passionate about it so is motivated to get the grades - he is very much in command of his own destiny and that's the way it has to be I think. Guess what, to PP, he plays the guitar, football every lunchtime and goes out at the weekend as he is very sociable. Yes, he does leave at 3.15 from school but that in itself is irrelevant to his prospects.

My DS is nearly 15 and plays the guitar and plays football every lunchtime

Mischance · 05/02/2022 12:13

So this is work over and above school homework?

This is very unreasonable. His studies are important, but so are other things in his life - and vegging out is not to be disregarded as unimportant.

If his homework is getting done then leave him be.

Seeline · 05/02/2022 12:13

I would address the gaming addiction. If he is only allowed to play for a limited time each day, he'll need to find something else to fill his time.

Namenic · 05/02/2022 12:10

How are you going to make sure it is quality study - not just staring at a book for an hour? I don’t think you are unreasonable, but I think you will have to do it with him. 20mins per day spent with him - you testing him on a subject or asking him to explain the plot of a book they are doing in English is worth 1 hour of him staring into space. I think kids would have more motivation if the adult shows an active interest in helping them improve. Maybe look up cool you tube videos for the subject together (works for science and maths) - there are some maths dvds for teenagers (Matt Parker I think - which make it interesting - bought these but have not watched yet). Do some maths challenge questions or puzzles with him.

But yes - no games until all homework done to acceptable standard (assuming he has no learning difficulties and is capable of doing the homework).

PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 12:05

My DCs are at a private school, neither DH or I studied at school, DH really struggled but we did as young adults so that's a load of nonsense. Their school is 840 till 345. No Saturday school and they still tend to do OK. 25% of the school have learning difficulties such as dyslexia also.

It's not a particularly academic or pushy school. They have a policy that they get no holiday homework either as they recognise kids need a break. They also give a guide on how long children in each year group should spend on homework each day. They say that if for example it has taken over half hour then they should not continue unless they desperately want to. Obviously it gets more and more each year.

Nachos2 · 05/02/2022 12:03

I’m back! Forgot to say OP if you can encourage his reading that will be hugely beneficial. Doesn’t have to be Dickens or Jules Verne, anything at all, tech magazines whatever.

CatatonicLadybug · 05/02/2022 12:01

Former teacher, also former student who was rubbish at anything labelled ‘studying’ but got top marks. My question is not how long is marked out for studying but what the studying entails. Once homework is finished, is he working through revision books and practice papers or is it something more engaging that will actually keep his mind leaping to the next interesting thing? Does he read outside assigned texts? Does he follow current events related to any subjects he’s taking? Will he have a conversation with you or anyone else about any topics he’s studying?

Practice papers have their place in letting you know how to channel what you’ve learned into something you can demonstrate to the examiner, but by and large lesson time will spend a significant amount of hours on this. Reading and engaging with a subject in a wider sense is what teachers wish they could get into the course but they can’t with finite hours and set curriculum.

I would try to ease off applying a set time and instead look at the content.

I do agree with previous posters that overloading the weekend may be too much - there’s a reason why most of us would think a six day work week sounds exhausting. It’s certainly possible and plenty of people do it, but not many of them will tell you it’s easy or refreshing. Maybe the weekend study becomes an ‘if needed’ if you feel it is a good time for your family.

TheJoyOfCats · 05/02/2022 11:59

I was "made" to study from age 13 to 18 for 30 hours per week on average. I physically sat in the room I was supposed to be studying in but mainly day dreamed:) not much work done

Nachos2 · 05/02/2022 11:55

Alternative point of view. My children are in an independent school, they sign in at 8.30 am. First lesson is 8.50 am. They finish school at 5 pm. They have lessons on Saturday until lunchtime and then matches/sport. Wednesday they have matches/sport in the afternoon rather than lessons. Almost everyone plays an instrument or has singing lessons, many kids also have Lamda and tennis lessons after school. They have 1-2 hours homework every single day.

I have name changed to say this - my daughter has a friend in a state school, she is out of school at 3 pm I think, no sports, no music and a lot less homework. The kids in the independent sector work a lot harder, it’s the norm. People seem to think rich parents just throw money at education without acknowledging the higher standards expected of the kids in the independent schools. Thankfully Christmas and Easter they have a month off and summer hols are 8 weeks. They are set holiday homework in some subjects.

I think your schedule for your 14 year old son is very reasonable. Frankly the reason we can afford school fees now is because we studied when everyone else was at parties. My dad was a security guard and my DHs dad was a policeman. My mum worked in a factory part time and DHs mum was a teaching assistant. No silver spoons.

Education is a long game so I wouldn’t pile on the pressure age 14 but an hour after school is sensible and your DS sounds very able.

PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 11:53

@SisterJude this depends on whether predicted grades are 4s or 9s though surely. If predicted grades are 9s and they are getting 6s or 7s then no issue at all, if predicted 4s and getting 3s then it's a much bigger problem.