Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make DS 14 study 5 days a week

142 replies

L0stinCyberspace · 05/02/2022 10:25

Is our study rota too much for DS 14 on a Mon Tue Wed Sat Sunday? 1 hour study max per day, 30 mins for 2 subjects on each day.

DS is very bright but very lazy re. study. Was considered "exceptional" in Maths by a teacher 2 years ago. Crams for all exams and still comes out with high marks. DH and I have noticed DS is disengaged with homework in the last few months and seems negative about classes, apart from 2 practical subjects. Spending nearly all his time online gaming when not playing sport that we bring him to.

His recent PT meeting confirmed our observations so we came up with a rota for study for 5 days a week. He has Thu off for music lessons and Fri off to chill. What do people think?

OP posts:
ChateauxNeufDePoop · 05/02/2022 15:18

@steppemum

I'm on teenager no 3, she is now 14.

I owuld say that the amount of study is excessive, and you are mocromanaging.

BUT you obviously have an issue aorund homework and him getting work done.

More effective would be to have some off line time every day.
Decide when and how much is reasonable, and then the internet goes off. So for example, come in from school at say 4 pm. Can play online till 6. Dinner at 6, no online after dinner.
Or the onternet goes off at 8pm.

But relax that at weekends.

All of mine are exam crammers, and to be honest, so was I. If you are an exam crammer, then you do all the work last minute and come out with straight good marks.
You can't make him be somethign he isn't, but you can give him sone structure and support

This is a good approach and one my parents did with me. I was involved in a couple of sports at the weekends so evenings were a critical time for homework as I was home alone 4-6 after school most days although tended to not do much during that time.

As such we knew evenings were critical so we cross referenced my homework diary with social calendars and at times even the Radio Times if there was something significant on TV like a family film or sport event to make sure every thing got done (it always did) and yet I never felt like I was sacrificing anything to study so was happy to do the studying. If there was a blanket rule of when I had to do the homework with punishments if I didn't I wouldn't have done as well as I did at GCSE's and I thought I took that skill even more into A-Levels where I was very productive with my free periods.

steppemum · 05/02/2022 15:06

I'm on teenager no 3, she is now 14.

I owuld say that the amount of study is excessive, and you are mocromanaging.

BUT you obviously have an issue aorund homework and him getting work done.

More effective would be to have some off line time every day.
Decide when and how much is reasonable, and then the internet goes off. So for example, come in from school at say 4 pm. Can play online till 6. Dinner at 6, no online after dinner.
Or the onternet goes off at 8pm.

But relax that at weekends.

All of mine are exam crammers, and to be honest, so was I. If you are an exam crammer, then you do all the work last minute and come out with straight good marks.
You can't make him be somethign he isn't, but you can give him sone structure and support

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 05/02/2022 15:01

[quote Eightiesfan]@ChateauxNeufDePoop

Not lazy parenting at all, and the router does not get turned off. I have asked him to do something and most of the time he does. If he doesn’t spend the time, he tells me and will make up the time at the weekend.
My DS2 has ADHD so struggles to focus unless it is something he’s engaged with in which case he’s hyper-focussed. As I’ve said all children are different, my DS2 needs that routine, he’s very black and white so unless he is told to do something he’ll take it as being optional, and this includes some homework. If this after-school study time did not exist he would without a shadow of a doubt spend all his time gaming - that would be lazy parenting![/quote]
My example and your example are at both ends of the scale and both are lazy parenting. There needs to be a joined up approach to this to get the kids to buy into it - especially as in this instance it's not his set homework, it's extra stuff.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 05/02/2022 14:59

@UnderTheSea20k

I can’t understand how people think this is weird or in anyway wrong. If your own parents don’t think you have it in you to make something of your life, how can you believe it? He needs to learn to self regulate though and take more pride in his own work.
But he isn't learning self regulation at all?
alfagirl73 · 05/02/2022 14:49

You can't "make" someone study... on top of which, not everyone learns or studies the same way. Hours spent does not always equate to quality learning/studying. I wish my parents had realised this and actually bothered to understand me, how I think and how I work. Similar to another PP I had to sit in a room in silence and do over 20 hours a week of study from age 14-17. I don't work like that and my only saving grace was that no one bothered to check what "studying" I actually did... which was just as well as I spent most of it writing stories! Oh and I did fine in my exams and am now in a successful, professional career.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 05/02/2022 14:49

@AlexaShutUp

Frankly the reason we can afford school fees now is because we studied when everyone else was at parties.

The idea of my dd missing out on a social life now so that she can waste her money on private school fees for my future grandchildren sounds absolutely horrendous in my view. That is not what I want for her at all.

No silver spoons here either, but I did plenty of socialising as a teenager and still managed to excel in my exams, go to Cambridge etc. We could afford private school fees for dd now but choose not to because we are confident that she will do just as well in state. So far, this has proved absolutely right and she is thriving. Excels academically and in her extracurricular activities, while also doing lots of socialising on the side. She's 16 and that kind of balance is what I want for her. Not some weird regimented life without any time to just be.

Excellent post.

Lots of naturally bright kids do the minimum that they need to do, and get to good universities, without missing out on socialising. I understand if you're not someone that finds academic stuff easy, you might have to work really hard all of the time to get there, but that's certainly not the case for everyone.

Wafflesnsniffles · 05/02/2022 14:49

If he crams for exams and does well Id leave him to it. Forcing him to study will only cause arguments. Plus hes likely to lie to say yes Ive studied when really he hasnt.
Very important he finds his own groove, his own willingness and motivation to crack on with whatever he needs to, to get the grades he wants. If he does badly in whatever tests he has coming up he will probably realise he needs to do more........ meantime Id leave him to it.

PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 14:47

Isn't that what pretty much everyone is saying though? Self regulation and motivation is the key. Giving DCs the tools to do this and showing them the results you can achieve by working hard. This is different to insisting a child does a specific amount of work at this specific time. Sometimes the requirement could be working on something specific for over am hour, sometimes this could be just 15 mins of finishing homework.

Eightiesfan · 05/02/2022 14:44

@ChateauxNeufDePoop

Not lazy parenting at all, and the router does not get turned off. I have asked him to do something and most of the time he does. If he doesn’t spend the time, he tells me and will make up the time at the weekend.
My DS2 has ADHD so struggles to focus unless it is something he’s engaged with in which case he’s hyper-focussed. As I’ve said all children are different, my DS2 needs that routine, he’s very black and white so unless he is told to do something he’ll take it as being optional, and this includes some homework. If this after-school study time did not exist he would without a shadow of a doubt spend all his time gaming - that would be lazy parenting!

UnderTheSea20k · 05/02/2022 14:43

I can’t understand how people think this is weird or in anyway wrong. If your own parents don’t think you have it in you to make something of your life, how can you believe it? He needs to learn to self regulate though and take more pride in his own work.

Nachos2 · 05/02/2022 14:37

I hope the OP is finding the thread helpful. I think the general view seems to be the 14yr old does his set homework and anything else is up to him. It’s a polite non name calling thread on the whole Smile.

I am texting in the freezing cold watching a C team hockey match. Occasionally I dutifully shout “go again” to encourage a second tackle. I am largely ignored by the other mums as we don’t ski / shoot / didn’t go to school with their grandparents in 1847 etc. I don’t care, it gives me more time to daydream and their kids are nice to my kids so big picture it’s fine.

My two kids are v different, one is soooo laid back and needs encouraging (you may call it pushing) the other is extremely determined and academic and I am frequently taking books off them and saying that’s enough, watch something funny on YouTube.

If they are happy kids and stay off drugs we are doing ok, but 15 mins extra maths every evening might make all the difference to their prospects!

Porcupineintherough · 05/02/2022 14:27

@cherryonthecakes for every child who refuses to study there are another 9 that kind of want to, that mean to, but find it hard to get down to, or dont know how to do it effectively. These children you can help. Things I do with my kids are:
-Provide them with a suitable space to study (for ds1 this is the kitchen table, for ds2 it's his room).
-Talk to them about what they need to do an when they are going to do it.
-Remind them when it's time to get down to it.
-Test them on what they've revised or stuff like French vocab.

  • teach them effective ways of revising
  • keep an eye on school books and teacher's comments so I can see if it's starting to go wrong
  • talk to them about particular pieces of work they are struggling with, or help them identify sources of support
  • encourage them to evaluate their own work and effort.

So not rocket science but not just leaving them to it either. Although these days, after years of the above, I can leave it more and more to them.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 05/02/2022 14:26

@Eightiesfan

Good for you OP, yes he might only be Y9, but time goes fast and the sooner he gets into a study routine the better. Lockdown has meant that our children have lost over 2 years of education in real terms. I ask my DS2 to do 2.5 hours of schoolwork every day before he’s allowed to game. We live across from the school so he’s home by 2pm on Tuesday and 3pm the rest of the week, so I do not think this is unreasonable, as he spends an equal amount of time gaming afterwards. Each child is different so what is fine for one child will not work for another, as mothers we make that decision as we know are children best. My DS1 is doing his A levels and I have never had to get involved in his study routine or constantly check if he’d done his homework, revised etc as he is far more conscientious than his DB and much more organised.
People aren't necessarily disputing that, just think the routine is excessive and as the child has had no input into it will not comply with it as much as OP thinks depending on his personality. Also, my own thoughts are it needs to be a joint effort to put together something for engagement and so the kid learns about time budgeting and prioritising. Ironically I think saying "do x amount of homework or the router goes off" is lazy parenting.
Goldenbear · 05/02/2022 14:23

Nachos2, that approach is not setting them up for excelling in anything- that drive and passion for something has to come from within.

Heronwatcher · 05/02/2022 14:23

Don’t micromanage him like this- you’re storing up trouble. He’s got to want to learn for himself. By all means encourage him and point out the benefits of getting decent exam results where appropriate but I’d stop at that.

Eightiesfan · 05/02/2022 14:21

Good for you OP, yes he might only be Y9, but time goes fast and the sooner he gets into a study routine the better. Lockdown has meant that our children have lost over 2 years of education in real terms. I ask my DS2 to do 2.5 hours of schoolwork every day before he’s allowed to game. We live across from the school so he’s home by 2pm on Tuesday and 3pm the rest of the week, so I do not think this is unreasonable, as he spends an equal amount of time gaming afterwards. Each child is different so what is fine for one child will not work for another, as mothers we make that decision as we know are children best. My DS1 is doing his A levels and I have never had to get involved in his study routine or constantly check if he’d done his homework, revised etc as he is far more conscientious than his DB and much more organised.

gingercat02 · 05/02/2022 14:19

My Y9 (13) does an hour of school stuff - home work or some BBC bitesize or a bit of a maths app Tues to Fri but he decides for himself what to do. I think it's a good habit to be in and it means he doesn't spend all weekend doing homework

PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 14:18

Also I would add that being a high earner is not the most important thing in life. I want my kids to do something they love. DH and I have high paid jobs but it's not something we 'dreamed' of doing. We chose a well paid career.

Our DCs have things they are passionate about , if they can work in those areas and earn a decent living I would much prefer that than them being 'high earners'.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 05/02/2022 14:15

@Nachos2

MintJulia sounds like good parenting to me.

Assuming the child is able there are some low standards on here.

You all know that a good education, good grades means better prospects and choices in life. So many threads on MN wondering how people can earn more money, get on the housing ladder, save towards a pension. If it’s too late for you then look to your kids and encourage more homework less gaming and social media. They must have down time too of course but they will enjoy it more when they have done their hour of homework/study.

Raise your standards. Let your kids (again assuming they are able) feel what’s it like to be in a top set or get a A in a subject they enjoy.

You're of course bang on about good education and good grades but that is by no way guaranteed just by saying "right, do one hours study now or no internet later". Massive difference.
PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 14:15

OK, so my DS1 is able to get 8s and 9s in his GCSEs if he studied more, he'll likely get 7s and 8s. I don't believe it'll make any difference to him at all.

I am not disagreeing that doing well at school doesn't help with earning more, in most cases it will, I am talking about not sacrificing everything else for the best possible grades. I don't believe that helps you become a high earner. You need to be self motivated etc to do that, not micromanaged.

For me, teaching/showing my kids how important it is to work hard at school/college/work and how that has direct results is the most important thing. They both play instruments and work hard at their sports too, this does help with proving that hard work pays off.

There is a lot of research to show that playing an instrument or doing sport helps improve results also, this is due to how practicing these things shows a very obvious result. My DS is 15 and already being paid as a professional musician to a reasonably high level. He works extremely hard but I only ever remind him that he probably needs to practice X/Y/Z today, he chooses to do it/how hard he works at it.

If you look at the education system in the states the children who seem to do well are those involved in many different areas. My friends DS studied over there for university. He was at a top school and they push them to do lots of extra curricular stuff but also insist they achieve good grades. They have to be extremely motivated on their own. He is very successful and was never pushed to just study, he played lots of team sports etc also during GCSEs and A levels.

cherryonthecakes · 05/02/2022 14:12

How do you make a child study ?
How do you make sure he's doing something meaningful rather than sitting at a desk and doing something too easy or pointless so that he can tick it off as done ?
Are you able to keep up monitoring him in all subjects? I'd have no idea if MFL learning he was doing was the right difficulty or something aimed at year 7s,
What would you do if he said no?
Would you make sure he wasn't wasting time getting a drink, going to the loo, looking for the "right" pen etc ?

It sounds like your heart is in the right place but not sure you can force it.

Tee20x · 05/02/2022 14:09

How old is he? Why have you devised a study rota - he's lazy, work on that. You can't force him to study he could just be staring blankly at the page.

YoBeaches · 05/02/2022 14:05

If he's so bright that he does his homework on other classes because he's bored, and prefers to study hard in advance of exams, I'd prob consider a tutor or a group that could provide more stimulation once or twice a week.

I'm not sure what the purpose is of your current approach? If he's getting good results, what are you trying to gain?

Whattochoosenow · 05/02/2022 13:53

Also one of the best things he can do when he’s old enough is to get a part time job. Having to be responsible for time keeping and working for someone else actually affects all areas of life.
Mine was a kitchen porter at 15 and he quickly realised that although it was good for pocket money, for some people it’s a full time job, and it made him work harder at school.

Porcupineintherough · 05/02/2022 13:51

Getting As does not equal being a high earner!

There's a pretty strong correlation bw educational attainment and future prosperity, esp if you control for inherited wealth.