Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make DS 14 study 5 days a week

142 replies

L0stinCyberspace · 05/02/2022 10:25

Is our study rota too much for DS 14 on a Mon Tue Wed Sat Sunday? 1 hour study max per day, 30 mins for 2 subjects on each day.

DS is very bright but very lazy re. study. Was considered "exceptional" in Maths by a teacher 2 years ago. Crams for all exams and still comes out with high marks. DH and I have noticed DS is disengaged with homework in the last few months and seems negative about classes, apart from 2 practical subjects. Spending nearly all his time online gaming when not playing sport that we bring him to.

His recent PT meeting confirmed our observations so we came up with a rota for study for 5 days a week. He has Thu off for music lessons and Fri off to chill. What do people think?

OP posts:
goodbyestranger · 06/02/2022 19:37

Yes it is the essence of decent parenting.

RocketFire7 · 06/02/2022 19:35

@Poetrypatty

That’s not parenting. DC should be pushed and expected to work hard.

goodbyestranger · 06/02/2022 19:35

RocketFire7 please don't tell other parents what their role is. I have eight DC who are either at uni or out the other side. Too late for me to learn from you I think, but I'm quite content with having ploughed my own lazy furrow along the lines Poetrypatty suggests.

I didn't interfere in screen time or xbox time at all. Their choice, their future.

Poetrypatty · 06/02/2022 19:26

It’s our role as parents to push our DC to work hard and achieve the best they are capable of in all areas of live

I disagree. I think our role is to love and accept them for the people they are.

RocketFire7 · 06/02/2022 19:24

@goodbyestranger

What tends not to end well ime is parents burying their heads in the sand and thinking their DC can wing their way through their exams. It results in DC getting poor grades and not being able to make the future choices they want.

It’s our role as parents to push our DC to work hard and achieve the best they are capable of in all areas of live.

All DC should have a focused age-appropriate study routine in place and parents should be ensuring this is followed rather than allowing lots of screen time.

goodbyestranger · 06/02/2022 19:16

This thread is in AIBU, where opinions expressed directly are ok. If RocketFire7 doesn't want to lay herself open to direct responses, she should stay clear!

LemonsGreen · 06/02/2022 19:07

goodbyestranger gosh, how rude are you! It’s been such a sensible thread with alternative opinions politely expressed until you stormed in!

goodbyestranger · 06/02/2022 18:54

We've had plenty of parents like that at school. Tends not to end well.

goodbyestranger · 06/02/2022 18:54

Well good luck with that RocketFire7. Bad call, I reckon.

RocketFire7 · 06/02/2022 17:03

I don’t see any issue at all with your rules. In an ideal world, of course we’d want DC to be self-motivated. But 14 year old boys are not known for their long-term thinking skills.

All of my DC have study regimes in place and have to do a certain amount of study per day, which is age dependent.

I see it as my responsibility as a parent to do my best to make sure all achieve their potential. This won’t be straight A*s necessarily, but I do believe that all DC should be pushed to work hard and try their best. In some cases that will mean achieving all 9s and in others Cs would be a great result.

Poetrypatty · 06/02/2022 16:23

Why are you getting involved? This kind of over interfering in teenagers lives never seems to go well. Trust in him and leave him to it.

Scarlettpixie · 06/02/2022 16:19

It sounds unreasonable to me. If he is getting all his work done what is the problem? Having a music lesson after school isn’t a day off and Friday eve should be for chilling as he will be tired after the week at school. I think he needs a full weekend day off really at the very least. It also feels a bit like you are micro managing. He needs to learn for himself what work he needs to do to get the results he wants. Finally nothing wrong with cramming for exams so long as he gets the results. It works well for some people (I was one of them).

goodbyestranger · 06/02/2022 15:45

It seems astoundingly unreasonable to me. I've had DC who were pretty focussed on things other than school work but something imposed on them would have never have worked, even had I had the inclination to interfere. I would leave your DS to it OP. If it's going to come good, it will, but it will come from him more easily if he doesn't resent you prescribing what he does with his time. Could backfire massively.

FunnyGoingsOn · 06/02/2022 09:12

It depends on the child but I think it's much better to leave them to decide for themselves if you can. Ultimately they are working for their own good and their own future. I supported them
and facilitated their studies (nice environment etc) but the thought of forcing them to study never crossed my mind. I didn't do guilt tripping or anything either.
Maybe I was lucky but my kids all did well. Maybe one of them could have done better at A levels if he had worked harder but he ended doing a PhD so it was all ok. They went to a normal comp.

The reason I prefer this approach is that it makes the kids realise it's their life and that they are working for themselves and not because they are told too.

It also means they respect me as I didn't spend their teen years nagging them.
Obviously it didn't always run perfectly - we were a normal household.

jgjgjgjgjg · 05/02/2022 23:38

An hour of homework is pretty much what they are expected to do at private school at this age. As well as starting earlier and finishing later than the state school day.

Mischance · 05/02/2022 22:39

The more you press him, the more he will disengage.

Gentle encouragement; statements that you have faith in him to make the right decisions; letting him know you are there to help if needed - this is enough.

The message you are sending out to a boy who is doing just fine academically is that he cannot be trusted to manage his own revision. You need to hand him some responsibility and most importantly trust, rather than hover over him micromanaging his studies.

A young relative of mine did no homework (he said it was easier to do the detention than do the homework), achieved sufficient GCSEs to get on a college course from which he went on to university, where he is top of his year. He made his own decisions and has been proved right - he did not want his free time cluttered up with what he felt was unnecessary homework. We gave him our thoughts but trusted him to know his own mind. He has been proved right.

Now I am not holding this up as what everyone should do, but trying to demonstrate that there are different ways of getting there. We could have pressured him and made his life a misery, but chose to trust him.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 05/02/2022 21:13

It’s not something I’d want to force on my DC.

Unless he’s studying for specific exams right now, I’d just make sure he’s done his set homework and talk to him about the importance of putting effort it. At the end of the day if he’s being lazy he’s only failing himself. Hopefully he’ll see that.

JBEM4 · 05/02/2022 21:08

What are your expectations when it comes to his GCSE's?

Will you expect the highest grades possible or enough to allow him to progress to A Levels?

Never understood the pressure placed on kids to get high grades across the board at GCSE level especially if C grades are enough to progress to A Levels.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 05/02/2022 19:23

Lots felt how would he ever learn how to study unless he worked out the need and motivation for himself. I do have a different viewpoint there! To me that's a bit like asking how will he ever learn how to wash himself on a daily basis unless I let him stink grin because that definitely would happen, unless I asked him to shower!!

No, the correct analogy would be to explain to him what happens if he doesn't shower - his friends and potential gf's/bf's wouldn't want to hang out with him and would probably make nasty comments to him. It would be a painful lesson but he'd learn to shower regularly. If he doesn't do the correct level of studying then there's potential for a disappointing outcome too.

Seems a productive day all round though and to echo a pp earlier, seems a very well balanced and well debated thread all round. Unusual for AIBU I guess Wink

PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 19:07

Not sure the shower analogy works OP, that usually changes once hormones kick in properly. I couldn't persuade my 2 teen boys to not shower every day if I tried now.

L0stinCyberspace · 05/02/2022 18:37

Thank you very much for the replies.

It's interesting that the majority feel it's counterproductive, with a few saying it's OK and a few others saying modify approach or timing.

DH and I discussed it and are going to halve the time. We gave DS the option of 5 x 30 mins study sessions, however he wants to space them per week, until Easter. This means he'll have the weekend off completely. Then maybe back to the existing plan, nearer end of year tests.

I take the point that it is ineffective to just have him revise, so we're going to source videos online to support his learning and mix the approaches up a bit more, as well as teasing stuff out and testing him.

A few of you were asking why I pushing him for high marks. This isn't to do with me wanting to have an academic career path. If he wants to do a trade or other work that's totally ok but we are trying to get him to learn how short study done regularly actually commits to memory in a way that cramming doesn't. His teachers at the recent PT meeting also felt he had disengaged and needed to do more, because his potential previously been high. If he was a pass level student I'd want him to reach his potential based on that level too, iykwim.

Lots felt how would he ever learn how to study unless he worked out the need and motivation for himself. I do have a different viewpoint there! To me that's a bit like asking how will he ever learn how to wash himself on a daily basis unless I let him stink Grin because that definitely would happen, unless I asked him to shower!!

Really was glad of the replies and advice, thanks.

OP posts:
PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 16:43

I totally agree, careers advice is so important, I had no idea what I wanted to do, got really good results and essentially could have had my pick of A levels, I was given no advice but I wanted to do music, when the course got cancelled last minute I had no clue what to do so I ended up doing leisure and tourism. I actually found one tiny bit of the course really interesting and did professional exams in that afterwards through work. I was lucky as I got a really good public sector admin job at 18 then manage to do the exams whilst being funded by them.

With DS2 (Y9) he has looked at the course he wants to do already and knows what he needs to get for it. Maths, Eng lang and Science. Science is a week subject for him overall but since looking at the course he is now revising for his end of unit tests and managed 1 mark off a 5 this time which is much better than last unit. He needed to find his own motivation.

Washermother33 · 05/02/2022 15:38

OP they need to work out for themselves the correlation between work and the best grades . They need to want it themselves . I nagged my son a lot about working harder , in reality it needed him to be disappointed in his own results in tests and report to start working hard . I’m still waiting for my younger one to wise up . You are right to worry but not to micromanage

TheMoth · 05/02/2022 15:32

I was a procrastinator who was good at exams. My parents thought I worked hard cos I spent a lot of time in my room mooning over posters of fit men and writing stories. I spent a lot of time at 14 on my mega drive.

I think good careers advice is more important. I outperformed most of my friends at gcse and a level, then ended up earning less than them because I didn't really know what sort of career to go for. The friends with more clued up parents chose more wisely.

TwoleftUggs · 05/02/2022 15:18

Wasn’t sure whether to hit U or NU as I think there’s nothing wrong with having a study schedule as such, but I do think both weekend days is harsh.