Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tip or not to tip….

116 replies

MumWithYOPD · 05/02/2022 07:36

Went out with colleagues to a restaurant last night and as some people ate off the set menu, some didn’t, some drank alcohol, some didn’t the bill was passed around for everyone to work out their own bill. That went surprisingly well. With the exception of one person everyone rounded up their meal to include a tip for the waitress (it was a really busy restaurant, she worked hard, was attentive and helpful, we didn’t have to wait long, she was great) The one person in question didn’t even guesstimate their bill they gave the precise amount. AIBU to think that if you receive good service in a restaurant the waitress/waiter should be shown this by way of a tip?
And to preempt the question, the person concerned is financially secure.

OP posts:
Chikapu · 05/02/2022 16:27

So you'd rather not socialise with this person ever again because you think you're Lady Bountiful because you left two quid on the table? Jinkies!

19lottie82 · 05/02/2022 16:26

Also, I’m not judging you. Just letting you know that you sound seriously unhinged

Well, yes, you are! And no, they don’t.

19lottie82 · 05/02/2022 16:25

My bil has family in the US and we asked him about tipping, he said oh we don’t bother. We were astounded and wondered how often staff have ranted about him in
the kitchen!

Wow! I’d be surprised if they even let him back into the same restaurant again!

That’s really poor, it actually “costs” a server to serve a customer as they are expected to tip out the bartenders and kitchen staff, whether they get a tip from a customer or not.

hahahabants · 05/02/2022 16:24

Also, I’m not judging you. Just letting you know that you sound seriously unhinged

hahahabants · 05/02/2022 16:22

You feel uncomfortable about the fact that someone has decided not to tip a waiter/waitress?😂
The issue with people like you is that the focus is on people who don’t tip for whatever reason instead of focusing on companies who pay their staff incredibly low wages instead of a reasonable wage. There is no law to say you MUST tip. Many people ask for service charge to be removed off of a bill as you don’t HAVE to pay it.

Looking at someone sideways because they didn’t round their bill up £2/£3 is incredibly judgmental and strange. You sound like a lovely person but eh, each to their own

livvymc · 05/02/2022 16:11

[quote freecuthbert]@livvymc

My comment was directed at the people with the line of thinking "if you can't afford to tip then don't eat out" which was said on this thread. It's already vanishingly rare for me to go out for a meal, if tipping became compulsory then I couldn't afford it, simple. People saying, oh you can bung in an extra quid are missing the point because people would still complain that is miserly. And if you can afford one quid, you can afford another quid surely etc... and then where does it end? You do know some people think it's rude not to tip 20% or whatever arbitrary number?

Where did I say only care workers have a hard job? It's quite patronising to then list off other jobs where people are hard workers as if I didn't know that. You know I know care workers aren't the only people who do gruelling work, right? Lots of people work very hard. But wow thank you for pointing that one out too. I was talking about me and my job! Well I'm happy for you that you can afford to tip and leave a few quid on a low income, good for you. Do you also tip your hairdresser, bin men, post men, and so on as lots of people do?[/quote]
Do you think it’s more miserly to leave £1 or 2, than nothing?!
And to be frank, it was you that said “I guess care workers don’t deserve treats etc” I didn’t specify a role, you did! That’s why I was pointing out that you could go on forever naming jobs. Why make it specific to your job? You could say “no one on a low income who works hard deserves treats”!
And yes, I do tip my hairdresser on the very odd occasion I get my hair done. I factor it into the price. So for example, if my hair costs £27, I make sure I have £30, as if that is the price.
If I can’t afford the £30 this month, I’ll save a bit and wait until next month.
Binmen and milkman get a fiver at Xmas, again factored into Xmas budget.

MumWithYOPD · 05/02/2022 16:09

@hahahabants

yes, seriously, if they’re going I’d rather not go. They’re a nice person but someone that can’t even round their food and drinks bill up to the next £ is something that really doesn’t sit comfortably with me. I’d rather remove myself from the scenario than finding myself saying something that could embarrass them or that I would regret. I work with this person I’m not obliged to socialise with them.

That is sooooo ridiculous. They’re doing nothing wrong by paying the exact amount of their order. You’re acting as if they’ve ordered the most expensive stuff off of the menu and suggested everyone’s split the bill when you’ve only had a £5 drink. They’re paying for what they’ve ordered, not ordered expensive items and tried to get other people to chip in to pay for it which is what many cheeky people do. You sound really judgmental btw

@hahahabants I’m removing myself from a situation I feel uncomfortable with. I don’t find that ridiculous. Why should I spend my free time with someone I don’t want to socialise with anymore? Judgemental? Not that you’re judging me much 🙄
OP posts:
MumWithYOPD · 05/02/2022 16:02

@SickAndTiredAgain

They’re a nice person but someone that can’t even round their food and drinks bill up to the next £ is something that really doesn’t sit comfortably with me.

Does rounding up to the nearest pound even qualify as tipping? I guess technically it does, but if that’s what you count as tipping then it can barely be more than not tipping at all, which you think is outrageous.

When you say everyone else rounded up their meal to include a tip, did you mean just to the next pound? If yours was £19.50 (or whatever) and you paid £20, I don’t think you can judge someone for not giving an additional 50p.

@SickAndTiredAgain I’ve not been clear. Everyone rounded by £2+ which as the average was about £22 most paid £25. Maybe because I’ve been to America a few times I view it differently to those who don’t ever tip. I’ll tip minimum 10% unless service is bad or there’s a service charge already added.
OP posts:
hahahabants · 05/02/2022 15:56

yes, seriously, if they’re going I’d rather not go. They’re a nice person but someone that can’t even round their food and drinks bill up to the next £ is something that really doesn’t sit comfortably with me. I’d rather remove myself from the scenario than finding myself saying something that could embarrass them or that I would regret. I work with this person I’m not obliged to socialise with them.

That is sooooo ridiculous. They’re doing nothing wrong by paying the exact amount of their order. You’re acting as if they’ve ordered the most expensive stuff off of the menu and suggested everyone’s split the bill when you’ve only had a £5 drink. They’re paying for what they’ve ordered, not ordered expensive items and tried to get other people to chip in to pay for it which is what many cheeky people do. You sound really judgmental btw

SickAndTiredAgain · 05/02/2022 15:47

They’re a nice person but someone that can’t even round their food and drinks bill up to the next £ is something that really doesn’t sit comfortably with me.

Does rounding up to the nearest pound even qualify as tipping? I guess technically it does, but if that’s what you count as tipping then it can barely be more than not tipping at all, which you think is outrageous.

When you say everyone else rounded up their meal to include a tip, did you mean just to the next pound? If yours was £19.50 (or whatever) and you paid £20, I don’t think you can judge someone for not giving an additional 50p.

stuffedcookie · 05/02/2022 15:39

I have a good friend who doesn't tip. He's never worked in hospitality and doesn't understand it. I bought us a Groupon deal for a meal before and asked if he would get the tip and he left 50p.

Another time I left coins on the receipt tray and he followed me into the street and handed me it back saying 'you left this on the table' thinking it was a mistake.

feb21 · 05/02/2022 15:38

As I've said, I tip unless the service is dire. But I really wouldn't judge my friends if they didn't.

Unless the restaurant is full, and you're depriving the waiting staff of a table of tipping customers, I'm sure the restaurant and their staff would rather have the extra customers. It helps pay staff salaries and gives them shifts. And yes, I know the wages aren't great and they rely on tips but there's a middle ground here.

MumWithYOPD · 05/02/2022 15:35

@Butchyrestingface

I need to get over it or if there’s a work function just not go in future, stick to socialising with friends.

Seriously? You're going to avoid work meals because ONE person in a group didn't tip?

@Butchyrestingface yes, seriously, if they’re going I’d rather not go. They’re a nice person but someone that can’t even round their food and drinks bill up to the next £ is something that really doesn’t sit comfortably with me. I’d rather remove myself from the scenario than finding myself saying something that could embarrass them or that I would regret. I work with this person I’m not obliged to socialise with them.
OP posts:
hahahabants · 05/02/2022 15:34

Nothing wrong with paying the precise amount when that’s literally what you’ve ordered…

I think it’s ridiculous this person has even been singled out when they haven’t done anything wrong. You don’t HAVE to tip someone. Even if they’ve given you great service, it’s literally their job….

curlii103 · 05/02/2022 15:31

I find it irksome. Lots of people work for nmw and dont get tips.

Cheesechips · 05/02/2022 15:29

[quote freecuthbert]@livvymc

My comment was directed at the people with the line of thinking "if you can't afford to tip then don't eat out" which was said on this thread. It's already vanishingly rare for me to go out for a meal, if tipping became compulsory then I couldn't afford it, simple. People saying, oh you can bung in an extra quid are missing the point because people would still complain that is miserly. And if you can afford one quid, you can afford another quid surely etc... and then where does it end? You do know some people think it's rude not to tip 20% or whatever arbitrary number?

Where did I say only care workers have a hard job? It's quite patronising to then list off other jobs where people are hard workers as if I didn't know that. You know I know care workers aren't the only people who do gruelling work, right? Lots of people work very hard. But wow thank you for pointing that one out too. I was talking about me and my job! Well I'm happy for you that you can afford to tip and leave a few quid on a low income, good for you. Do you also tip your hairdresser, bin men, post men, and so on as lots of people do?[/quote]
Yes I always tip my hairdresser! They're often paid so poorly. It's not really customary to tip the postman and bin man though.

mandajmo · 05/02/2022 15:27

I always tip, unless very poor service. I always split the bill equally with however many people are there regardless of how many courses, drinks etc. life's too short to spend it with meanies Smile

Wingedharpy · 05/02/2022 14:40

If a service charge hasn't been added, I'm inclined to tip - but not before I've asked the waiter/ess what that particular establishment does with the tips. I want it to go to the server, or I'm happy for it to be split amongst all staff, after all, the poor devils in the kitchen who cooked the meal, never get anything extra.
@Susu49: DH likes to lurk around the bins in December so he can proffer his Christmas tip. Last year, they told him they thought he was approaching them to complain when they saw him heading towards themGrin

freecuthbert · 05/02/2022 14:38

@livvymc

My comment was directed at the people with the line of thinking "if you can't afford to tip then don't eat out" which was said on this thread. It's already vanishingly rare for me to go out for a meal, if tipping became compulsory then I couldn't afford it, simple. People saying, oh you can bung in an extra quid are missing the point because people would still complain that is miserly. And if you can afford one quid, you can afford another quid surely etc... and then where does it end? You do know some people think it's rude not to tip 20% or whatever arbitrary number?

Where did I say only care workers have a hard job? It's quite patronising to then list off other jobs where people are hard workers as if I didn't know that. You know I know care workers aren't the only people who do gruelling work, right? Lots of people work very hard. But wow thank you for pointing that one out too. I was talking about me and my job! Well I'm happy for you that you can afford to tip and leave a few quid on a low income, good for you. Do you also tip your hairdresser, bin men, post men, and so on as lots of people do?

UseOfWeapons · 05/02/2022 14:36

I only ever tip for really good service. I always thank those who have been looking after me, but my personal opinion is that if they’ve simply done their job, and no more, then no tip. I went out with a group of colleagues a couple weeks ago, and we all all agreed our waitress was fantastic, and agreed on a tip, each of us paying the same. Having said that, it’s very much a personal choice, so if someone else didn’t tip, I wouldn’t think anything of it.

Butchyrestingface · 05/02/2022 14:34

@freecuthbert

I'm a care worker on a low income and I don't get tipped! Don't even get a bonus. If I ate out it would be a rare treat for me, and no I wouldn't tip. I would then be paying the waiting staff more than what I earn, and my work is so bloody hard. So basically going by some of the comments here I shouldn't ever go for a meal out. I guess care workers don't deserve treats or anything nice!
I do tend to tip out of habit but I am really sympathetic to this view.
girlmom21 · 05/02/2022 14:34

@Susu49 we tend to do a crate of beer or something and just leave it on the wall with a note on bin day so there's enough for all of them to have a couple. Our bin men are always lovely and we have the same postie all year round luckily

Butchyrestingface · 05/02/2022 14:33

I need to get over it or if there’s a work function just not go in future, stick to socialising with friends.

Seriously? You're going to avoid work meals because ONE person in a group didn't tip?

Susu49 · 05/02/2022 14:25

@girlmom21 yes - I wouldn't tip for bad service. I also don't tip if a service charge has been added unless they were so good I wanted to tip more!

I've never tipped bin men Blush where would I leave the tip? They never come at the same time and all they do is wheel a bin up and down a few feet!

I've tipped posties in the past but where I live now we seem to get half a dozen different ones every day....At hairdressers I leave tips for apprentices but not the stylist.

livvymc · 05/02/2022 14:11

@freecuthbert

I'm a care worker on a low income and I don't get tipped! Don't even get a bonus. If I ate out it would be a rare treat for me, and no I wouldn't tip. I would then be paying the waiting staff more than what I earn, and my work is so bloody hard. So basically going by some of the comments here I shouldn't ever go for a meal out. I guess care workers don't deserve treats or anything nice!
I think you are taking this a bit personally. I completely agree that the job you do is amazing. But so are a lot of other jobs. Nurses, doctors, cleaners, paramedics, I could go on forever! Saying “I guess care workers don’t deserve treats” is unnecessary. I guarantee no one on this thread thinks that! Millions of people have jobs that are bloody hard, it doesn’t mean they don’t tip. Millions of people are on low incomes and don’t get bonuses, myself included! But I’ll always leave a tip, even just a few quid. But it’s absolutely your choice!
Swipe left for the next trending thread