Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think dead people’s letters should die with them?

116 replies

Hyggemama · 04/02/2022 19:38

Just curious what people’s opinions are on this after having an experience which made me a bit uncomfortable.
Background: When elderly relatives of mine died recently some other relatives took it upon themselves to trawl through their historic personal letters. Granted some were circa 1930s/40s so had really interesting first hand accounts of historical events. However I also felt that a lot was probably very private and deeply personal, e.g. those written during teenaged years. I wouldn’t want my future relatives to be reading WhatsApps I sent when I was 15. But on the other hand dead people can’t be mortified can they?!
Anyway, I’d be interested to know do you think… please vote
YANBU: it’s an invasion of privacy, personal correspondence should not be read by others after death.
YABU: Out of respect for their lives / history I actually want to find out as much as I can and am entitled to read through their letters etc

OP posts:
saraclara · 04/02/2022 20:38

@ShavingTheBadger

My mum died 26 years ago when I was 23. I'd walk into a burning building to get the letters she wrote to me when I was away at college out. I also have a letter that my grandfather (in Libya in WW2) to his brother (in the Faroe Islands) telling him he'd received a letter from my gran telling him my dad had started walking and he was "over the moon". It's my little link to much loved family who are no longer here.

There's a twitter feed called Letters Of Note which is great - some are funny, sad, beautiful.

I'm sorry that you lost your mum so young. But those letters were sent to you. So of course you should have them and read them, along with any that you sent her.

But I don't think that I should read my parents love letters. And I don't want my kids to read my letters to their late dad and I certainly don't want them reading every WhatsApp or messenger post I've ever made.

ShinyMe · 04/02/2022 20:28

@saraclara
I actually hated reading Anne Frank's diary. She didn't intend it to be read by the likes of me and it felt intrusive.

If you read it again, you'll realise that she absolutely did. She started it as a normal teenage diary, but realised that it would be a suitable historic document and went back over it, editing it through the war and rewriting it many times to make it suitable for publication. She heard a BBC broadcast about Mass Observation and how they were collecting personal diaries and writings about wartime experiences and from then on began editing her work with the express intention of making it publishable. She wanted people to know what it was like. There are several published versions based on different versions - the original, the edited and an amalgamation of them.

Oinkypig · 04/02/2022 20:21

I think it’s the amount of digital footprint that makes it feel strange. When letters were written they would have taken time to craft it which is so different to instant WhatsApp conversation. There is an NI comedian called paddy raff who does a sketch imagining what would happen if all digital information is lost and a historian in the future analysing an retrieved section of Facebook. I can’t seem to link if you Google paddy raff profiles of the past bbc the section should come up.

ABitBesottedWithMyDog · 04/02/2022 20:20

Recently found among the possessions of a close family member a letter from the 60s that we wish we had never clapped eyes on. Tragic contents that really affected our view of the dead and their marriage.

Notthissticky · 04/02/2022 20:18

@ShavingTheBadger

My mum died 26 years ago when I was 23. I'd walk into a burning building to get the letters she wrote to me when I was away at college out. I also have a letter that my grandfather (in Libya in WW2) to his brother (in the Faroe Islands) telling him he'd received a letter from my gran telling him my dad had started walking and he was "over the moon". It's my little link to much loved family who are no longer here.

There's a twitter feed called Letters Of Note which is great - some are funny, sad, beautiful.

The letter about your dad having started to walk is so sweet! So lovely to realise that people have had the same joys and worries throughout the ages - I sent a video of my eldest walking to about 20 different people over WhatsApp, I can totally see how it would merit a mention in intercontinental snail mail during the warSmile
Summerfun54321 · 04/02/2022 20:15

I’d be more mortified about the drawer in the kitchen full of crap I’ve been meaning to sort for years than any kind of letter. My correspondence isn’t a patch on the general embarrassing shite in my house.

BooksAndHooks · 04/02/2022 20:14

They are really important for family history, social history etc. I absolutely treasure the letters my great grandfather sent home saying he was being sent out in WW1, send fresh underpants and the sad letters following the death of their baby son.

I would assume anything really scandalous would not have been kept.

RonCarlos · 04/02/2022 20:12

I got rid of my teenage diaries and ex-boyfriend love letters for that reason.

I kept the funny letters from my friends at school and a few nice letters I wanted to keep.

I did it when I was on maternity leave because I couldn't bear the thought of my future child knowing what an idiot I was!

My family have old family letters and postcards from my grandparents and beyond, but nothing on the same scale of embarrassing.

FourTeaFallOut · 04/02/2022 20:12

Maybe, but they might keep them around because they bring them comfort rather than seeing themselves as a custodian of the letters for later generations. And that comfort isn't something you would give up because you expect to kick the bucket in coming months/ years.

Unless you have been gifted them in an inheritance, how do you know that you haven't taken something essential that you were never invited to see?

ShavingTheBadger · 04/02/2022 20:09

My mum died 26 years ago when I was 23. I'd walk into a burning building to get the letters she wrote to me when I was away at college out. I also have a letter that my grandfather (in Libya in WW2) to his brother (in the Faroe Islands) telling him he'd received a letter from my gran telling him my dad had started walking and he was "over the moon". It's my little link to much loved family who are no longer here.

There's a twitter feed called Letters Of Note which is great - some are funny, sad, beautiful.

LethargicActress · 04/02/2022 20:09

A huge amount of our historical knowledge must come from personal letters. As long as things are treated respectfully and a reasonable amount of time has passed since the death, I think it’s ok. I agree that people ought to destroy anything they don’t want to be read in future.

Snowisfallinghere · 04/02/2022 20:03

If I were in possession of truly mortifying letters that I don't want relatives reading when I die, I'd either dispose of them long before then, or I'd instruct a trusted friend or family member to dispose of them for me after I die. I don't think most people care that much otherwise they'd have got rid of them years ago.

Also don't you think an elderly person with letters from 1930s-40s would be aware that they are of historical value by this point and deliberately be keeping them for a future generation to take care of?

GTAlogic · 04/02/2022 20:02

I think that once you're dead, you're dead and therefore you won't be affected by people reading your letters and diaries etc. but destroying them would be almost like destroying their memories. A lot of what we know about history comes from first hand sources such as letters and diaries and it would be a shame to lose that.

JenniferWooley · 04/02/2022 20:00

My girls were very young (6&8) when their beloved grandfather (my stepfather) passed away suddenly, they're now 20 & 22 and love reading his old diaries which are full of anecdotes & stories about them.

As they were so young their memories of him are limited, the diaries help fill in the gaps and trigger memories they may have forgotten over time.

GizmosEveningBath · 04/02/2022 20:00

I have letters my great grandmother wrote to my gg grandmother while she was in service. I also have letters my DGGM's sons wrote to her while they were serving in WW2. They are a fascinating part of history.

My husband has kept every letter I wrote to him while he was in Afganistan, I have kept the letters he returned. I don't mind if the DCs want to read them in the future, they are a part of their history. I also don't mind if they want to get rid of them, I don't want them to feel beholden to stuff.

mizzo · 04/02/2022 19:59

This is why it's important to clear things out regularly!
My Mum gave me a box of childhood stuff recently and it contains letters and diaries from when I was a teenager. They were so cringy, contained information I don't want my children knowing ever, so I threw them out.

escapingthecity · 04/02/2022 19:58

We have some of my grandfather's letters from WW2 which are an amazing insight into his experience. We also have some of the love letters between him and my grandmother which have helped us understand them both much better.

Akire · 04/02/2022 19:57

I think if you don’t want them to be read you would got rid long time ago. If you kept an up-to date journal you could ask someone on your death to destroy it. If you made no provision then you have no reason to complain. Even if you had them in locked box with the key details in your will so only one person would know, always a way around.

Boood · 04/02/2022 19:56

One of my grandmothers died before I was born. A few years ago I was able to read a letter she wrote to her parents-in-law shortly after she married my grandpa (they were married abroad during the war, so nobody could go to the wedding, and she hadn’t met any of them). It was really moving- she was very young, and it really came across how much she loved Grandpa, and how happy and excited she was. I’m really glad the letter survived and I was able to read her own words.

saraclara · 04/02/2022 19:56

@RedToothBrush

Why do people keep diaries?

Ultimately, they are to be read.

Same for letters too imo.

I kept a diary for a year or two so that I could look back on things and remember them..I never for one moment expected anyone else to read them, and I'd be mortified if they did..
LaurieFairyCake · 04/02/2022 19:56

When I'm dead you can read anything I wrote - it gives an insight into me as a real person

I couldn't care less about my great grandchildren reading about my extremely active sex life when I was a teenager 🤷‍♀️

saraclara · 04/02/2022 19:55

@FourTeaFallOut

I wouldn't want any of my private letters passed on to relatives or worse, put on public display.

I mean, imagine if our private text messages and emails were picked over because they were considered quaint and entertaining in years to come? Awful.

Yep. All of that.
saraclara · 04/02/2022 19:54

@Allthekittycats

Under your terms, we wouldn’t have a ton of historically important information. Anne Franks diary anyone?
I actually hated reading Anne Frank's diary. She didn't intend it to be read by the likes of me and it felt intrusive.
RedToothBrush · 04/02/2022 19:53

Why do people keep diaries?

Ultimately, they are to be read.

Same for letters too imo.

Allthekittycats · 04/02/2022 19:52

Under your terms, we wouldn’t have a ton of historically important information. Anne Franks diary anyone?

Swipe left for the next trending thread