Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think dead people’s letters should die with them?

116 replies

Hyggemama · 04/02/2022 19:38

Just curious what people’s opinions are on this after having an experience which made me a bit uncomfortable.
Background: When elderly relatives of mine died recently some other relatives took it upon themselves to trawl through their historic personal letters. Granted some were circa 1930s/40s so had really interesting first hand accounts of historical events. However I also felt that a lot was probably very private and deeply personal, e.g. those written during teenaged years. I wouldn’t want my future relatives to be reading WhatsApps I sent when I was 15. But on the other hand dead people can’t be mortified can they?!
Anyway, I’d be interested to know do you think… please vote
YANBU: it’s an invasion of privacy, personal correspondence should not be read by others after death.
YABU: Out of respect for their lives / history I actually want to find out as much as I can and am entitled to read through their letters etc

OP posts:
Annonymiss123 · 04/02/2022 22:21

My paternal grandmother died young, before my parents even met. Somebody gave my dad a letter that my grandmother had written to them. It was just mundane “news” but something she wrote (ranting about a CF) made me laugh because it could have been written by me - I could just see my reaction being exactly the same. It made me feel really close to this woman who died 10 years before I was born.

buckeejit · 04/02/2022 22:17

Yabu. It's another layer of connection & either have it in a box labelled destroy do not read or destroy it yourself

TheresSomebodyAtTheDoorNeil · 04/02/2022 22:16

Yabu.

We found the letter my grandad sent my nana after the woman who bullied her kicked her in the stomach. This sent her into premature labour and her little boy was born very disabled. He died when he was around 4.

We found it very comforting, it also explained a lot about why she was the way she was (( she'd always favoured boys in the family)) and put a lot of ghosts and resentment to rest.

TheMarzipanDildo · 04/02/2022 22:15

Letters are different I suppose.

TheMarzipanDildo · 04/02/2022 22:14

Hmm. I think that one of the drives of diary writing is the unconscious desire to survive our own deaths in some form.

However, I have no evidence for this hypothesis so may be talking out of my arse.

Toddlerteaplease · 04/02/2022 22:10

We found the letters my grandad wrote to my grandma when she was in hospital having my mum. They were lovely to read. And I was Hmmat him going to other peoples houses to have a hot dinner cooked for him. But it was 1953!

TeaAndStrumpets · 04/02/2022 22:04

It's a tricky one. DH and I met at 17 and wrote each other letters constantly, particularly when we were at separate universities. As I recall, lots of gossip and jokes, but toe curling romantic stuff too Blush They are all packed away in a box and haven't been looked at for 50 years ( just had our golden wedding) I can't bring myself to get rid of them, but feel really odd at the thought of our DDs reading them. In a way because I think it would be very sad for them. I really don't know.

downbad · 04/02/2022 21:56

@Tryingtokeepgoing sorry for your loss. Yes I think leading to questions you can never get an answer to is really hard.

downbad · 04/02/2022 21:53

It’s an interesting one. When my dad died, I found lots of letters between him and my mum when they were first getting together and initially it felt amazing to have that connection. But then I got to ones where they’d had arguments and were talking about things they’d done wrong (including ruining a major occasion) and I found it really, really upsetting. I guess I’d had this idealised version of their marriage and it was worse because I couldn’t find out the context or what happened next etc. Obviously everything worked out because they were together happily for many years but I stopped reading them because I felt like I was torturing myself. He was also a very private man so I felt a lot of guilt reading them too.

I realise this is mostly about my thoughts/feelings, which is bad!

Tryingtokeepgoing · 04/02/2022 21:50

@saraclara

If you have letters that contain explicit details of your life that you want kept private then I suggest you destroy them.

Again, when?

Exactly. Therein lies the problem. My husband died, suddenly, a few years ago at 47. He had some letters, pictures, newspaper clippings etc from way before I met him, when he was just 24. Most of it I got rid of…looking at it could only have lead to questions I would never get an answer to, and it would have been a huge intrusion of privacy. I kept things in my handwriting, because they’re a comfort to have around, in a memory box. But I don’t really want anyone to read them when I’m dead, and I’d hope that whoever has to sort them out takes the same approach as I did.
RoseMartha · 04/02/2022 21:49

I disagree also. They are amazing to read and very much a treasured possession. I write in a journal and would want someone to read it after I die but not while I am alive.

It is important for memories and just knowing and understanding that person more.

It is a piece of history.

YesitsBess · 04/02/2022 21:48

Cassandra Austen burned three thousand (approx) letters from Jane Austen. I understand why, but am retrospectively furious at her for it.

I agree with a period of privacy before reading, maybe 20 years, but to destroy them is destroying first person accounts of history.

AryaStarkWolf · 04/02/2022 21:43

I agree with you OP I'd hate people reading my personal letters

sammylady37 · 04/02/2022 21:42

@saraclara

I think this is a very black and white area. You either value privacy or you don't.

The problem is that after death, those who don't value it don't seem to even consider what the deceased might have wanted.

As for getting rid of stuff you don't want others to read, when exactly do you do it? Many people die suddenly (or at least with not a lot of warning) and at all sorts of ages.
In on my mid 60s. Do I destroy everything now and deprive myself if it for possibly another twenty years or so?

And of course our digital conversations would need constantly deleting in case we get run over by a bus after one of them.

I agree with you.

I have private letters from an old lover that I’ve kept, they remind me of a very simple and extremely happy time in my life, I am still in touch with him and I occasionally take the letters out and read them. I reminisce fondly while doing so. Why should I deprive myself of that now, and for the rest of my life (hopefully a few decades) because someone in the future won’t respect my privacy?

I’m a deeply private person and hate the thought of people intruding into areas of my life where their intrusion isn’t welcome.

Redshoeblueshoe · 04/02/2022 21:41

Saraclara if you don't want them to be read do it sooner rather than later

bedheadedzombie · 04/02/2022 21:35

@saraclara I tore put a few pages of my teenage diary when I was around 35. Exactly for this reason: so no-one would read it when I die.

I now keep a diary for myself and my daughter. My mum died 12 years before I had her and if that happens to me then I want dd to have a snapshot of what it was like for me when she was a baby/ growing up. So I do write with that in mind: that she might read it someday.

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 04/02/2022 21:35

I burnt the diaries from my teenage years myself. Anything left is stuff I don’t mind being read.

murmuration · 04/02/2022 21:33

I’ve totally always assumed that any letters and diaries of mine will be read after my death! Even since I was a kid I’ve addressed my diaries to hypothetical future descendants, sometimes even writing directly to them and invite them to reflect on whether my speculations turned out as I expected or not. I’ve kept cards and letters, again imagining others reading them. It never occurred to me someone might think it an invasion of privacy - they would soon be relieved, I think, if they read my diaries, since I clearly assume they’ll be reading them.

saraclara · 04/02/2022 21:33

If you have letters that contain explicit details of your life that you want kept private then I suggest you destroy them.

Again, when?

Redshoeblueshoe · 04/02/2022 21:32

I have a few fabulous letters from the 60's, sent to and from my siblings. They absolutely echo the phrase "show me a boy at 7, and I will show you the man" the sense of humour hasn't changed, when my eldest DB died it was so lovely to read the letters again.
If you have letters that contain explicit details of your life that you want kept private then I suggest you destroy them.

saraclara · 04/02/2022 21:31

@StoneofDestiny

Should Samuel Pepys diaries be hidden away too?
He wrote them to be read. But even if he hadn't, if he'd destroyed then we'd not miss them because we wouldn't have known they existed.

We've probably 'missed out' on millions of people's diaries and letters. So what?

saraclara · 04/02/2022 21:29

I think this is a very black and white area. You either value privacy or you don't.

The problem is that after death, those who don't value it don't seem to even consider what the deceased might have wanted.

As for getting rid of stuff you don't want others to read, when exactly do you do it? Many people die suddenly (or at least with not a lot of warning) and at all sorts of ages.
In on my mid 60s. Do I destroy everything now and deprive myself if it for possibly another twenty years or so?

And of course our digital conversations would need constantly deleting in case we get run over by a bus after one of them.

StoneofDestiny · 04/02/2022 21:23

Should Samuel Pepys diaries be hidden away too?

Hyggemama · 04/02/2022 21:19

It is so interesting that there are such a broad and strong range of views. I’m glad I asked as it definitely isn’t straight cut!

In my own experience, the last person surviving in the relationship had dementia for years so their property was fairly disordered when they passed. Arguments that they would have sorted the private from the shareable are a bit null in this scenario but I agree applicable to most. Of course many also have the foresight to bin anything particularly incriminating or embarrassing years before. But as a few have found, some very personal letters and even stuff that can tarnish memories can get through.

It is lovely to hear how cherished many letters are. It puts me in a mind to write more letters for my own future generations to keep in the same way, lest they have to go by my Facebook / insta posts to build a less than favourable impression of their (once beloved) deceased.

OP posts:
WonderfulYou · 04/02/2022 21:15

It’s absolutely an invasion of privacy but I’d still need to read them and find out about the history.
I would HATE someone to read through my texts though.

I don’t think diaries are meant to be read. Aren’t they just a way to put your thoughts and feelings down on paper, a bit like talking to a therapist or on here - it’s reflecting on the day.

I would definitely read them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread