Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think dead people’s letters should die with them?

116 replies

Hyggemama · 04/02/2022 19:38

Just curious what people’s opinions are on this after having an experience which made me a bit uncomfortable.
Background: When elderly relatives of mine died recently some other relatives took it upon themselves to trawl through their historic personal letters. Granted some were circa 1930s/40s so had really interesting first hand accounts of historical events. However I also felt that a lot was probably very private and deeply personal, e.g. those written during teenaged years. I wouldn’t want my future relatives to be reading WhatsApps I sent when I was 15. But on the other hand dead people can’t be mortified can they?!
Anyway, I’d be interested to know do you think… please vote
YANBU: it’s an invasion of privacy, personal correspondence should not be read by others after death.
YABU: Out of respect for their lives / history I actually want to find out as much as I can and am entitled to read through their letters etc

OP posts:
endlesssighing · 05/02/2022 11:14

My grandfather’s dad was in the trenches in WW1 at 16. His Mother kept all his letters and they all start ‘My Dearest Mam’ and they’re really beautiful. This young lad was at war and his handwriting would put us to shame.

She kept them in a little wooden box and wrapped them in a ribbon. It’s the most precious family heirloom we have. Letters are the most intimate memories we have of our ancestors. Treasure them.

Lightning020 · 05/02/2022 11:10

I had better remember to throw away years of journals by the time I am 80. I wouldnt want my ds to read them when I am gone. My private thoughts are just that. Not that I have very exciting journals but they feel sacred somehow.

Monitaurus · 05/02/2022 11:08

My parents left their love letters neatly tied and numbered precisely because they wanted me to read them. What I discovered was very important in understanding that they had very passionate but stormy relationship, there was a child born before they met ,that their communication problems endured to the end and the grief they suffered.plus a lot of detail and social commentary and gossip . I wish my letters and email were so completely fascinating.

Supertree · 05/02/2022 11:01

I would hate it. And I would be annoyed at the thought of a relative reading them with the assumption that I would have destroyed them if I didn't want anybody else to read them. I'm not expecting to die any time soon!

My mother in law sadly died quite young a few years ago. She'd already asked me to help her clear out her house because she knew she was terminally ill. It wasn't much of a difficult task as she was very organised but she wanted to point out to me where important things were kept and the history of some items. After she'd died, we came across a notebook in the loft. My husband had a quick look at the first few pages to see whether it contained anything important and realised it was a personal diary, written after the man she'd been having an affair with and just left his dad for committed suicide. I think it might have been a part of the therapy she was doing at the time. There is no way she would have wanted us to read it and I assume she just forgot it was up there. There's absolutely no way my husband would have read it and he destroyed it without telling anybody because he suspected other relatives would have tried to look at it out of sheer nosiness and something to gossip about.

CrunchyCarrot · 05/02/2022 10:25

Some of what's written is going to be very private or personal. I have 20 years' worth of diaries and am in the process of getting rid of them, because of exactly this, I don't want anyone else reading my silly teenage/20s nonsense. It is taking ages though as I tend to read through everything!

BitcherOfBlakiven · 05/02/2022 10:22

I don’t know about other families, but my Grandmother has told me I’m free to read her things (and her mother’s things) when she dies. I only know her as my Grandmother, and the few stories she’s told me about her as a child. I want to know who she was before I existed.

Prescottdanni123 · 05/02/2022 10:15

My grandmother kept all of the letters that her brother sent her when he was serving in the RAF during World War 2. He was sadly killed in action. The letters, along with his personal effects, the telegram, the letter of condolence from the King were kept in one of her jewellery boxes for the rest of her life. No way would me or my parents ever get rid of them. Reading the letters shows how close they were and keeps their memory alive. Reading the letters are also the closest that me and my dad will ever get to actually knowing the brave young man who lost his life fighting for his country before the age of 20.

CHIRIBAYA · 05/02/2022 10:13

I have some letters in my attic that my grandfather wrote to my grandmother during the war. She was expecting my father when he was killed in Belgium so my father never knew his father, never even knew where he died or how. His letters are the only connection I have with him, a sense of the grandfather I might have loved and been loved by. It is all that is left of a 23 year old life; so I hold them very dear. Like so much in life, the answer lies in the relationship to the deceased and that will be different for all of us.

EdithStourton · 05/02/2022 10:00

Oh, and anything I want to keep, but keep private - someone will be told where it is and to destroy it.

But ultimately, I'll be dead, so I won't care.

EdithStourton · 05/02/2022 09:58

Anything I don't want read I will burn or delete before I die.

If I die unexpectedly, they can try and decipher my handwriting, and find the interesting stuff amongst the clutter on my laptop. There is a long rant about my ILs on there that the DC should find entertaining.

sammylady37 · 05/02/2022 09:45

@GeneLovesJezebel

They should have destroyed them if they didn’t want them reading. They will have known that someone would have to clear out their belongings.
Again, when should someone destroy items they want kept private? I’m 42, I hope to live another few decades. Should I destroy sentimental items that I cherish now in case I die unexpectedly early, but in doing so prevent myself having joy and comfort in those items for hopefully many decades to come? What about if someone planned to destroy items once they turned 75, or 80, but developed dementia and didn’t do it?
GeneLovesJezebel · 05/02/2022 09:35

They should have destroyed them if they didn’t want them reading.
They will have known that someone would have to clear out their belongings.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 05/02/2022 09:34

I have my grandfather’s diaries. They are mostly just day to day stuff but it’s an amazing privilege to see a snapshot of his life. The earliest one is 1919.

Thighdentitycrisis · 05/02/2022 09:29

My DF left love letters he had written to his fiancé in the 1940’s. They had never married as her parents didn’t agree and I suppose she returned the letters. It gave me a better insight into him as a person

lljkk · 05/02/2022 09:24

My first thought was the Paston Letters.

We have postcards & letters written by our distant ancestors, wonderful family history in them.

Workconundrummergirl · 04/02/2022 22:44

You're lovely @gumball37

gumball37 · 04/02/2022 22:43

Just bought a second hand nightstand. Removed the drawer and found cards from wife to husband and handmade cards from grandkids to grandad... Managed to track down the previous owner. Man died 15 months ago and his widower is so happy to be receiving them back. Sentiment is very dear to some people

Workconundrummergirl · 04/02/2022 22:41

I think if it's a relative you knew it would probably feel more invasive than if it were one you didn't, so Nana vs Great great Aunt. I think the feeling of invasion comes from imagining the person knowing you know

SomePosters · 04/02/2022 22:38

The quote got lost but that was to the poster who said Anne Franks diaries felt like an invasion of privacy

SomePosters · 04/02/2022 22:36

She said repeatedly she wanted to be an author and that she wanted people to know what had happened. She understood her diaries might be a historical resource and kept them with this in mind recording more than just her own feelings

Her father published them after the war ended
They are the saddest thing I have ever read but I am grateful that he shared his daughters legacy with the world

We need to learn from history in order to not repeat our mistakes

NichyNoo · 04/02/2022 22:29

Been a while since I implemented GDPR in my company but if I remember rightly, privacy law isn’t applicable to dead people. Because they’re no longer around to be disadvantaged or embarrassed.

campion · 04/02/2022 22:24

I agree @downbad, it's a tricky one with no right or wrong answer to the original question.
My mum kept a diary all her life and I think she used it a bit like therapy, as someone said. I don't know for sure as I didn't read them. Before she died she was very clear that she wanted them destroyed and so that's what happened. I did keep a couple from when she first met my dad at 18 but I really didn't want to read any of her thoughts about me or other family members. We had a good relationship and I didn't want to read a criticism or misunderstanding because I would have churned that over, probably out of all proportion. I like to hold on to what I feel we had. I did feel some angst when they were destroyed but I also felt I'd honoured her wishes.

On the other hand, my dad took me completely by surprise one day about 20 years ago when he produced his father's diary from 1917 when he was a soldier serving in the trenches! I didn't even know it existed and, as he'd died aged 47 I never knew him. Despite it being mostly mundane stuff mixed with occasional drama (!) it's fascinating as a record but, more importantly, it's the only tangible connection with a grandfather I never met. His description of a week back home, going to the picture house with his sister, having a party etc really brings him to life.

The famous diaries are valuable in so many ways and interesting to read but people's personal thoughts aren't necessarily for wider consumption.

SpikeySmooth · 04/02/2022 22:24

I regularly write a journal to help with my MH but I also regularly burn/bury/otherwise destroy them. I don't want my relatives knowing my innermost thoughts! They would be shocked!

As for letters/postcards I throw them away once they've served a purpose. I have an anonymous Twitter account and nothing I say on WhatsApp is of any interest to anyone except the person receiving it (and even then it might only be to remind them to get bread and milk from the shop).

DreamTheMoors · 04/02/2022 22:22

My mum kept my dad’s WWII letters to her in a bundle tied with red ribbon.
I had every intention of placing them in her casket to be buried with her, but in my grief and with all the other planning, I forgot.
That bundle is now in a trunk with other family things, unread. Those letters are sacred.

I did read an article yesterday about a letter Edward wrote about an affair Albert (King George) was having with a married woman and Edward’s laughing about his attempts to facilitate it - going up for auction.
I felt so bad for Her Majesty, having something so private being sold off like it was a teacup.

SirVixofVixHall · 04/02/2022 22:22

My grandmother kept a diary from childhood, she destroyed them a week before she died ( she wasn’t unwell, she had a sudden stroke, so the timing was strange).
I feel really sad that she did this, I would like to have them very much.
I have a box of all my parents love letters from when they were courting, and I haven’t read them as it feels intrusive, I think I am too close. I want my daughters to have them though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread