Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people pay so much attention to BMI, when waist to height ratio is a better indicator?

89 replies

WaisttoheightnotBMI · 04/02/2022 19:28

Many scientists have said for years now that BMI is outdated - it shows how much you weigh but not where you carry most of that weight.

This is really important for women, because many women are pear-shaped. Carrying fat around your lower half means you're carrying a lot of subcutaneous fat, which can actually protect
your health from serious illnesses like heart disease compared to carrying a lot of visceral fat (around your stomach, which is dangerous as its near to your internal organs).

So you could have a higher BMI but a healthy waist to height ratio because your waist is small or average in proportion to your height.

Take this from Harvard www.hsph.harvard.edu/obesity-prevention-source/obesity-definition/abdominal-obesity/:
"The study found that even women at a “normal weight” BMI less than 25 were at a higher risk, if they were carrying more of that weight around their waist".

Also from Harvard www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/big-thighs-may-be-wise#:~:text=Researchers%20tracked%20the%20volunteers%20for,than%20those%20with%20thin%20thighs.

"Although the BMI provides a reasonably accurate reflection of body fat, it does not tell how that fat is distributed. Research shows that not all fat is created equal. In fact, fat plastered around the body's internal organs (visceral fat) is much more dangerous than fat layered beneath the skin (subcutaneous fat); that's why liposuction and "tummy tuck" operations may improve your profile but won't help your metabolism or your health".

I feel like people here frequently talk about BMI and judge how healthy someone is or isn't based on their BMI, when that's not even the most effective indicator - could we start considering waist to height ratio more now?

OP posts:
DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 05/02/2022 07:43

BMI is a range precisely to accommodate a range of body types and builds! The weight range for a given height to be within the healthy range is very large.

I think there are vanishingly few athletes who fall outside of a healthy BMI. And I wouldn’t consider strongmen or Sumo wrestlers to be healthy - carrying that much extra weight has serious effects on joints and circulation.

ColleysMill · 05/02/2022 07:39

Whilst they aren't a total fail safe I have some "smart' scales that measure loads of different components and indicate which bit is in a healthy or unhealthy range

Everything on mine is green except bmi and weight. Body fat coming in at 24% too (green). Visceral fat is on the higher side but still in a green zone.

No I know these scales aren't 100% accurate but nothing the average person can own will be and it's the best I can do.

My other niggle with bmi calculators is the activity amount - even the nhs one the most activity you can put in is 150 mins a week. I gym/home workout with cardio and weights 6 days a week and average 350 to 400 active mins a week - telling me to "exercise more" really isn't the issue. And calorie wise I aim for 1200 to 1500 a day (pretty healthy balanced diet bar the odd biscuit and pint) so unless I'm going to totally stop eating I'm at a loss to how to get bmi down further.

InvincibleInvisibility · 05/02/2022 07:25

In RL the only person Ive met who disparages BMI is morbidly overweight. Yet seems to use "look at rugby players" as an excuse to dismiss their massive BMI.

Its not a fail safe tool but it is a good indicator (amongst others). And is a lot easier than measuring waist size

TheReluctantPhoenix · 05/02/2022 07:19

BMI is terrible, as it assumes people are flat, and that everyone has the same muscle percentage, so short and muscly people appear fatter and tall and weak people appear thinner.

However you can calculate BMI easily and quickly and is a good ready reckoner for ‘Miss Average’.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 05/02/2022 07:10

I am similar to @Iamclearlyamug.

I am apple shaped and as I'm short and also short waisted it's the worst combination. My waist measurement will look large whatever my weight and I have big boobs and broad shoulders too meaning my BMI will rarely be much under 25 but my waist will measure much larger than average no matter what I weigh. My healthiest weight is between 9 and 9.5 stones although I'm normally heavier. Even at 8 stone my waist was over 30".

fellrunner85 · 05/02/2022 07:09

Doesn't really matter what the measurement is, you will still get people denying they're overweight. If it's not "oh, but rugby players" it'd be "oh, but I just carry more weight there." Either way, people will carry on insisting they look "gaunt" at below 10st or a size 12.

Yes, BMI isn't perfect, but on a population level, it's one of the many tools you can use. Funny how people saying "oh but what about pro athletes" are never pro athletes. And in fact most very muscular sportspeople would be well within a healthy BMI range anyway.

lljkk · 05/02/2022 07:01

Confused Being morbidly obese doesn't stop Sumo wrestlers from being very fit.

that fact Doesn't make it perfectly healthy for office admin occupation Jo in Swinton to have a BMI of 35.

Nat6999 · 04/02/2022 23:19

BMI is a joke, think about Rugby players or strongman competitors they can be mega fit but their BMI is morbidly obese. The healthy BMI limit doesn't make sense, for me to be a healthy BMI I would have to weigh under 9 stone but when I lost weight & got down to just under 10 stone I looked like I was dying, I didn't have an ounce of fat on me.

LaurieFairyCake · 04/02/2022 23:06

It's so weird as really nothing tells a complete story

I was 5 stone overweight (obese) with a 29 inch waist - I'm an hourglass shape (my BMI was 38)

Now I'm 1 stone overweight, not obese and my waist is 25 inches (BMI 28)

Arbeity · 04/02/2022 23:03

@lljkk

Outdated is the wrong word, BMI is limited not "outdated"

MNers are obsessed with BMI.

Exactly. It tells part of the story. Waist/height ratio tells another.

Unfortunately, like most things in life, health is a little more complicated than a simple measurement. But they are all tools to prompt thought about whether you need to do something. That is their power, along with their simplicity

CharacterForming · 04/02/2022 23:02

I agree that waist measurement is an important guide to whether you're at a healthy weight.

I have however noticed that people who say on MN that BMI is bollocks because they're a size ten at BMI 32 and they look "gaunt" if they drop below a BMI of 28 (I may be exaggerating for effect) normally go very quiet if you say "possibly, we're all different, what's your waist measurement?"

lljkk · 04/02/2022 22:58

Outdated is the wrong word, BMI is limited not "outdated"

MNers are obsessed with BMI.

WaisttoheightnotBMI · 04/02/2022 22:07

@Iamclearlyamug

I still think it depends on your body shape - since it’s not possible to spot-reduce fat, I’m not sure what else a person could do if they are already a healthy weight but their waist is “too big”

"The study found that even women at a “normal weight” BMI less than 25 were at a higher risk, if they were carrying more of that weight around their waist".

I’m 5’7 and weigh 10.5st and a body fat percentage of 23% so well within a healthy range, but I have a tiny bum and legs, but broad shoulders, massive 34H boobs and a round tummy - there is just nothing I can do about that, it’s the way I’m built. I think it’s a shame that because of one measurement I’m deemed unhealthy 🤷‍♀️

Thank you for your response - I totally see what you mean and you're right we can't spot-reduce fat. I think my issue is so many people here rely on BMI like its the be-all and end-all - they'll say your BMI is 25, you're overweight and need to lose weight, or your BMI is 19 so you're healthy. When in reality they know nothing about that person's body shape/fat distribution and so they may actually be in a much better position than BMI lets on. I just think it's important to be aware of that, and that waist to height ratio is often more informative than BMI about health and risk factors.
OP posts:
Iamclearlyamug · 04/02/2022 20:18

I still think it depends on your body shape - since it’s not possible to spot-reduce fat, I’m not sure what else a person could do if they are already a healthy weight but their waist is “too big”

"The study found that even women at a “normal weight” BMI less than 25 were at a higher risk, if they were carrying more of that weight around their waist".

I’m 5’7 and weigh 10.5st and a body fat percentage of 23% so well within a healthy range, but I have a tiny bum and legs, but broad shoulders, massive 34H boobs and a round tummy - there is just nothing I can do about that, it’s the way I’m built. I think it’s a shame that because of one measurement I’m deemed unhealthy 🤷‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread