Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people pay so much attention to BMI, when waist to height ratio is a better indicator?

89 replies

WaisttoheightnotBMI · 04/02/2022 19:28

Many scientists have said for years now that BMI is outdated - it shows how much you weigh but not where you carry most of that weight.

This is really important for women, because many women are pear-shaped. Carrying fat around your lower half means you're carrying a lot of subcutaneous fat, which can actually protect
your health from serious illnesses like heart disease compared to carrying a lot of visceral fat (around your stomach, which is dangerous as its near to your internal organs).

So you could have a higher BMI but a healthy waist to height ratio because your waist is small or average in proportion to your height.

Take this from Harvard www.hsph.harvard.edu/obesity-prevention-source/obesity-definition/abdominal-obesity/:
"The study found that even women at a “normal weight” BMI less than 25 were at a higher risk, if they were carrying more of that weight around their waist".

Also from Harvard www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/big-thighs-may-be-wise#:~:text=Researchers%20tracked%20the%20volunteers%20for,than%20those%20with%20thin%20thighs.

"Although the BMI provides a reasonably accurate reflection of body fat, it does not tell how that fat is distributed. Research shows that not all fat is created equal. In fact, fat plastered around the body's internal organs (visceral fat) is much more dangerous than fat layered beneath the skin (subcutaneous fat); that's why liposuction and "tummy tuck" operations may improve your profile but won't help your metabolism or your health".

I feel like people here frequently talk about BMI and judge how healthy someone is or isn't based on their BMI, when that's not even the most effective indicator - could we start considering waist to height ratio more now?

OP posts:
Iamclearlyamug · 05/02/2022 11:20

And for people saying 'oh that doesn't work for me because I'm an apple shape' isn't that the point? Fat around your waist is more risky than fat elsewhere? So sorry, but it's worth doing something about.

@Ihaventgottimeforthis but HOW do you suggest this is done when you cannot spot reduce fat? As I explained upthread, I am already a healthy weight, with a very good body fat percentage - but my hips are a full 4 inches narrower than my waist, my bottom half is tiny (I can fit size 8 low rise jeans) but with 34H boobs and wide shoulders I carry more weight up top. If I lose more weight my legs and bum will get even smaller, but my boobs and stomach stay the same whether I’m this weight or 2 stone heavier .

I’d just be interested to know how I can lose weight JUST from my stomach, because if you know the answer you will literally be a millionaire and scientists will bow down to your knowledge 🤷‍♀️

MyAnacondaMight · 05/02/2022 10:32

The two are not contradictory. If you have a BMI above 25 then chances are you’re carrying so much excess fat that it’s impacting your health. For some people, carrying excess fat starts to affect their health at BMI slightly below 25. For these people, a BMI of 23-25 isn’t healthy - they need to carry even less fat overall to compensate for the fact their body lays it down in the worst place possible.

The healthy range for BMI can be huge, especially for taller people. A BMI of 24 isn’t the sign of good health that some people take it to mean - it means that you’re potentially carrying 2+ stone of extra fat that you don’t need, but it’s probably not yet harming you. However, if that fat is mostly around your middle, then that fat could kill you.

Alternatively, they could just bring the healthy BMI limit down to 23, and treat everyone like they might be apple shaped. Weight lifters and professional rugby players aside, I doubt there are many people who wouldn’t benefit from losing that extra stone.

Sidge · 05/02/2022 10:22

BMI is a blunt tool but a useful one. It can be useful in conjunction with other measurements, such as hip/waist and height/waist ratios.

It doesn’t necessarily correlate to health but can be a useful way of identifying other issues. Generally speaking if you have a BMI of 30 you’re going to be rather overweight and conversations about diet, exercise, family risk factors, lifestyle risk factors etc are important.

BMI in isolation doesn’t tell us much and is certainly less helpful if you can’t see the person.

StripedMousse · 05/02/2022 10:13

BMI is still one of the most useful measures we have.

25 or 26 or 7 isn’t going to make a huge difference. Over 30 is definite increased risk. BMI over 40 and the risk is high and on average leads to a reduction in life expectancy of about 10 years. Also longer spent living with a long term condition or disability.

A lot of rugby players do have excess fat not just muscle… doesn’t mean they’re healthy either.
www.shs-conferences.org/articles/shsconf/pdf/2019/09/shsconf_shw2019_02011.pdf

Yes definitely better to be fit than not (ie doing physical activity) but longer term there isn’t evidence that it just cancels out the risk from obesity. Just as it doesn’t for smoking. Risk is multi factorial and we have to look at our lifestyles holistically.

DiddyHeck · 05/02/2022 10:07

@fellrunner85

Doesn't really matter what the measurement is, you will still get people denying they're overweight. If it's not "oh, but rugby players" it'd be "oh, but I just carry more weight there." Either way, people will carry on insisting they look "gaunt" at below 10st or a size 12.

Yes, BMI isn't perfect, but on a population level, it's one of the many tools you can use. Funny how people saying "oh but what about pro athletes" are never pro athletes. And in fact most very muscular sportspeople would be well within a healthy BMI range anyway.

This, 100% 👏👏

If you're overweight then you're overweight and all the arguing over BMI and everything else isn't going to change that.

SartresSoul · 05/02/2022 10:00

I’m an hourglass so I gain weight pretty evenly everywhere. The only part of me that really stays slim is my back and shoulder region, everywhere else gains. I don’t know where my body shape falls in this thinking since I gain a big bum and also a bit around the mid section. I prefer to go on BMI, easier to manage my weight relying on that.

echt · 05/02/2022 09:49

I urge you all to be 65+:o

My rheumatologist said I needed to lose some weight and build up my quads to take pressure off my sore knees: some osteoarthritis, but general wear and tear, and not why I am referred to him.

I go by clothes fit so knew I was overweight. Did the BMI = overweight. Did the 65+ BMI =normal. Unkindly the scale is called geriatric, but there you go. Smile

Anyway, I'm on it, have painlessly lost several kilos, got the legs going, etc.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 05/02/2022 09:42

BMI is straightforward and gives people a goal to aim at.
I need to lose weight and it’s easier to set a goal of losing 2 stone than losing 3 inches off my waist.

If someone is obese or top end of overweight then they are likely to need to lose weight whatever measure you use.

ClariceQuiff · 05/02/2022 09:34

Bizarrely I fell foul of that one when I lost weight. Mine got worse rather than better.

Yes, I am similar. My hips seem the go-to spot for my body to take fat from, for some reason. I end up with concave buttocks if my BMI gets below 20, but my waist never gets particularly small.

picklemewalnuts · 05/02/2022 09:22

There's a hip/waist ratio, too. Bizarrely I fell foul of that one when I lost weight. Mine got worse rather than better.

No one ever talks about fitness, but surely that's more telling than BMI?

Why don't we have standardised norms for physical activity, like a staircase test and a standing with your arms out test?

My BMI was bad for years. It's much better now, but what makes a difference day to day is how fit I am. I've been obese and fit, and obese and unfit.

Fitness is a better indicator of health than appearance, weight or diameter surely?

A nutritionist reassured me that BMI is a number, not a fitness indicator. It points you in the direction of potential issues. What matters is cholesterol level, blood pressure, blood sugar levels etc. If all those indicators are good, BMI doesn't matter.

I also had a nurse look like she was sucking lemons because my middle age road test result came out green despite my obesity. Not smoking, drinking, being active, low blood pressure and cholesterol all outweighed my obesity. She'd been expecting a glaring red klaxon and seemed most disappointed I wasn't likely to die in the next ten years.

fellrunner85 · 05/02/2022 09:16

I find the "professional rugby player" excuse is usually best countered with "are you a professional rugby player." And the answer is invariably no.

The answer is usually closer to "well no, but I chuck a kettlebell around a couple of times a week so like to pretend I'm muscular, when in reality I'm just in denial about my weight."

That was me, for years. Then I finally gave up making excuses and lost the weight. Turns out I wouldn't look "gaunt" at a healthy BMI after all. Who knew?! Grin

ClariceQuiff · 05/02/2022 09:11

And for people saying 'oh that doesn't work for me because I'm an apple shape' isn't that the point? Fat around your waist is more risky than fat elsewhere? So sorry, but it's worth doing something about.

If you have narrow hips, it's hard to achieve the supposedly healthiest ratio, even if there's very little fat round your middle.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 05/02/2022 09:00

I think waist to height ratio is much easier to measure than BMI, you just need a piece of string, you don't even need to know your weight.
And for people saying 'oh that doesn't work for me because I'm an apple shape' isn't that the point? Fat around your waist is more risky than fat elsewhere? So sorry, but it's worth doing something about.

Dentistlakes · 05/02/2022 08:59

BMI isn’t perfect but it does work for the majority. The healthy ranges are huge so different body types are accommodated. The “rugby player” excuse so many trot out in these threads doesn’t apply to the majority of the population. If your BMI shows you are overweight or obese you probably are.

bluejelly · 05/02/2022 08:53

BMI isn't perfect but is a good general indicator. Personally not something that keeps me awake at night!

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 05/02/2022 08:41

Its just a rough guide. If your BMI is over 30 you probably need to lose weight. If you a professional sports person you probably have access to a trainer who can give you tailored advice.

I know from experience the healthy weight for my body is about 10.5-11st, at the upper end of of the healthy BMI range. It appears im dense. I'm currently a lot above that and trying to lose weightvand get some fitness back.
My daughter is still young, but her Child BMI is on the 8th Centile.... but she's definitely healthy. She just has long legs and a narrow frame.

bindud · 05/02/2022 08:38

I also think BMI works well for average heights but not so weep for short or tall people.

lumpofcomfort · 05/02/2022 08:38

I don't think either way is perfect as a blunt tool. I'm very slim, have a BMI of 18.5 but due to my body shape am very straight up and down and have no waist and narrow hips. I have barely any fat on either my belly or hips but my waist hip ratio is 0.83 due to my natural frame, which is only just in the "healthy" category.

bindud · 05/02/2022 08:37

It's so weird as really nothing tells a complete story

I agree, build & shape can make such a difference.

bindud · 05/02/2022 08:35

My doc told me about waist/height measurement years ago. I've seen the conversation on here with regards to waist measurement which also doesn't make sense (eg to ignore height).

ClariceQuiff · 05/02/2022 08:29

You can lower your BMI by losing weight, but you can't change how your body distributes fat, so it makes more sense to focus on BMI as it will be meaningful to everyone.

110APiccadilly · 05/02/2022 08:14

Practicality I think - BMI is very simple and doesn't change much depending on who's measuring. If you've got to measure someone's waist that's an extra faff, and also you've got to judge exactly where their waist is. Almost anyone who's had a baby will be able to tell you that their fundal height seemed to be measured differently each time - I imagine waist measurement would also suffer from this.

BMI is only one part of the picture - there's also bodyfat ratios you could look at as well as waist measurement, given that BMI is also affected by having a lot of muscle. To say nothing of lifestyle - a smoker with a BMI of 23 is quite likely to be less healthy overall than a non-smoker with a BMI of, say, 29, even though the non-smoker is overweight. But it's a very easy part to measure and standardise, so I can see why it's used so much.

Cheesechips · 05/02/2022 08:03

Arbeity thank you! I was always surprised when reports say how many people are obese but then when I tipped that mark I saw why. If I tell people my BMI is obese they give me a look Hmm I just don't want to set myself up for problems as I get closer to 40. Running for example hurts my ankles and knees a bit even though Im fairly fit. Low carb is helping!

Arbeity · 05/02/2022 07:59

@Cheesechips

I have gained some weight, I weighed myself recently and I just tipped the obese number of BMI. I'm very curvy but I certainly don't look obese. I have big hips, bum and boobs and strong muscly legs and a flat stomach and a petite face. However I am now on a diet to lose a few lbs as was feeling the strain on my joints a little and was starting to get a double chin.
But obesity is so common now, most people who are don't look it. Particularly st the lower end. Our expectations have shifted. Strain on joints and double chin are definitely signs of obesity.

I would be the same as you btw, my stomach never really puts on weight. It's all bum, boobs and face. So I could argue that the waist height ratio doesn't work. But it's like bmi, in that is shows part of the picture.

Good for you for not burying your head in rhe sand until it becomes even more difficult to loose. And good luck for your weight loss

Cheesechips · 05/02/2022 07:53

I have gained some weight, I weighed myself recently and I just tipped the obese number of BMI. I'm very curvy but I certainly don't look obese. I have big hips, bum and boobs and strong muscly legs and a flat stomach and a petite face. However I am now on a diet to lose a few lbs as was feeling the strain on my joints a little and was starting to get a double chin.

Swipe left for the next trending thread