Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people pay so much attention to BMI, when waist to height ratio is a better indicator?

89 replies

WaisttoheightnotBMI · 04/02/2022 19:28

Many scientists have said for years now that BMI is outdated - it shows how much you weigh but not where you carry most of that weight.

This is really important for women, because many women are pear-shaped. Carrying fat around your lower half means you're carrying a lot of subcutaneous fat, which can actually protect
your health from serious illnesses like heart disease compared to carrying a lot of visceral fat (around your stomach, which is dangerous as its near to your internal organs).

So you could have a higher BMI but a healthy waist to height ratio because your waist is small or average in proportion to your height.

Take this from Harvard www.hsph.harvard.edu/obesity-prevention-source/obesity-definition/abdominal-obesity/:
"The study found that even women at a “normal weight” BMI less than 25 were at a higher risk, if they were carrying more of that weight around their waist".

Also from Harvard www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/big-thighs-may-be-wise#:~:text=Researchers%20tracked%20the%20volunteers%20for,than%20those%20with%20thin%20thighs.

"Although the BMI provides a reasonably accurate reflection of body fat, it does not tell how that fat is distributed. Research shows that not all fat is created equal. In fact, fat plastered around the body's internal organs (visceral fat) is much more dangerous than fat layered beneath the skin (subcutaneous fat); that's why liposuction and "tummy tuck" operations may improve your profile but won't help your metabolism or your health".

I feel like people here frequently talk about BMI and judge how healthy someone is or isn't based on their BMI, when that's not even the most effective indicator - could we start considering waist to height ratio more now?

OP posts:
Ihaventgottimeforthis · 05/02/2022 14:48

Well yes inherently if you carry fat around your waist, that's more risky health-wise than people who carry it around their thighs, bums etc.
Just because you can't shift fat from specific zones, doesn't make that fact untrue.
I'm nearly 44, short & plump. Finally started to shift my waist fat by starting running 5km every day. 30 years of netball, rugby, rowing, weights & swimming & I still had a fat waist, unfortunately ~because I hate it~ running is the only exercise that has made an impact on body fat.
And eating & drinking a lot less.

Fellrunner85 · 05/02/2022 14:33

Also, even most pro female athletes aren't muscly enough to have an overweight BMI

THIS. Totally this. I find it really irritating when people claim they are overweight on BMI because they're "muscular" - what, more muscular than boxer Nicola Adams (8st), heptathlete Jess Ennis Hill (9st), cyclist Laura Kenny (8st 2), weightlifter Zoe Smith (9st 2)... etc etc? (Weights from Wikipedia, so won't be spot on, but won't be far wrong either).

Or let's look at one of the heaviest, biggest, sportswomen the GB team has had - Fatima Whitbread. She was the butt of jokes for being so "huge" - yet apparently she weighed 10st 10. At 5ft 6.

Are all these people claiming BMI isn't accurate because they're "muscular" honestly claiming that they have more muscle mass than any of these athletes...?

RichardMarxisinnocent · 05/02/2022 14:20

@CeeceeBloomingdale

I am similar to *@Iamclearlyamug*.

I am apple shaped and as I'm short and also short waisted it's the worst combination. My waist measurement will look large whatever my weight and I have big boobs and broad shoulders too meaning my BMI will rarely be much under 25 but my waist will measure much larger than average no matter what I weigh. My healthiest weight is between 9 and 9.5 stones although I'm normally heavier. Even at 8 stone my waist was over 30".

Similar here. My BMI is currently 21.3 but waist is 32 inches. Even at my lightest with a BMI of less than 20 my waist was still at least 30 inches.
WaisttoheightnotBMI · 05/02/2022 14:04

@echt

I urge you all to be 65+:o

My rheumatologist said I needed to lose some weight and build up my quads to take pressure off my sore knees: some osteoarthritis, but general wear and tear, and not why I am referred to him.

I go by clothes fit so knew I was overweight. Did the BMI = overweight. Did the 65+ BMI =normal. Unkindly the scale is called geriatric, but there you go. Smile

Anyway, I'm on it, have painlessly lost several kilos, got the legs going, etc.

Great job, wishing you all the best Smile !
OP posts:
WaisttoheightnotBMI · 05/02/2022 14:03

@SartresSoul

I’m an hourglass so I gain weight pretty evenly everywhere. The only part of me that really stays slim is my back and shoulder region, everywhere else gains. I don’t know where my body shape falls in this thinking since I gain a big bum and also a bit around the mid section. I prefer to go on BMI, easier to manage my weight relying on that.
You can work out what your body shape is by calculating your waist to hip ratio!
OP posts:
WaisttoheightnotBMI · 05/02/2022 14:03

@Leftleg

If my BMI is at the upper end of healthy or overweight my waist is too large, so it works for me. I definitely feel overweight if it goes over 25. I really need to be around bmi 22 to have a healthy waist size as I'm apple shaped.
That's exactly where the waist to height ratio is useful - you're recognising that some 'healthy' BMIs would be unhealthy for you because of your waist size. That's great but many people wouldn't, they'd just say well I fall within a healthy BMI so I'm healthy, without considering their waist.
OP posts:
WaisttoheightnotBMI · 05/02/2022 13:59

@picklemewalnuts

There's a hip/waist ratio, too. Bizarrely I fell foul of that one when I lost weight. Mine got worse rather than better.

No one ever talks about fitness, but surely that's more telling than BMI?

Why don't we have standardised norms for physical activity, like a staircase test and a standing with your arms out test?

My BMI was bad for years. It's much better now, but what makes a difference day to day is how fit I am. I've been obese and fit, and obese and unfit.

Fitness is a better indicator of health than appearance, weight or diameter surely?

A nutritionist reassured me that BMI is a number, not a fitness indicator. It points you in the direction of potential issues. What matters is cholesterol level, blood pressure, blood sugar levels etc. If all those indicators are good, BMI doesn't matter.

I also had a nurse look like she was sucking lemons because my middle age road test result came out green despite my obesity. Not smoking, drinking, being active, low blood pressure and cholesterol all outweighed my obesity. She'd been expecting a glaring red klaxon and seemed most disappointed I wasn't likely to die in the next ten years.

I agree that fitness is really important. Though I'm curious, when you say you've been obese and unfit and obese and fit, did your fitness/more exercise during obesity not help you lose a bit more weight?
OP posts:
Leftleg · 05/02/2022 13:55

If my BMI is at the upper end of healthy or overweight my waist is too large, so it works for me. I definitely feel overweight if it goes over 25. I really need to be around bmi 22 to have a healthy waist size as I'm apple shaped.

WaisttoheightnotBMI · 05/02/2022 13:53

@lumpofcomfort

I don't think either way is perfect as a blunt tool. I'm very slim, have a BMI of 18.5 but due to my body shape am very straight up and down and have no waist and narrow hips. I have barely any fat on either my belly or hips but my waist hip ratio is 0.83 due to my natural frame, which is only just in the "healthy" category.
Yes that's your waist to hip ratio, but your waist to height ratio must be low if you are both slim and straight up and down - you don't store much fat around your stomach which is very good for your health. But your waist to hip ratio tells us that if you did gain lots of weight it would likely be in your stomach so that would be more damaging.
OP posts:
Octomore · 05/02/2022 13:51

@fellrunner85

Doesn't really matter what the measurement is, you will still get people denying they're overweight. If it's not "oh, but rugby players" it'd be "oh, but I just carry more weight there." Either way, people will carry on insisting they look "gaunt" at below 10st or a size 12.

Yes, BMI isn't perfect, but on a population level, it's one of the many tools you can use. Funny how people saying "oh but what about pro athletes" are never pro athletes. And in fact most very muscular sportspeople would be well within a healthy BMI range anyway.

Totally agree.

Also, even most pro female athletes aren't muscly enough to have an overweight BMI.

WaisttoheightnotBMI · 05/02/2022 13:51

@StripedMousse @Sidge @ChazsBrilliantAttitude @CharacterForming @fellrunner85
I think where waist to height ratio is especially useful is showing that nuance - when you give the example of someone having a BMI over 30 being obese and needing to change, then yes that is extreme and most people wouldn't deny they'd need to lose weight at that point. But it's for people with middling or slightly high BMIs where actually, the waist to height ratio is more useful, it shows maybe you don't have to worry about much since your waist is small - fat accumulation near your vital organs is where the health issues really lie.

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 05/02/2022 13:46

Honestly, because they can say BMI isn’t this that and the other

But a waist to height ratio is much harder to wiggle out of

Svara · 05/02/2022 13:46

@ClariceQuiff

And for people saying 'oh that doesn't work for me because I'm an apple shape' isn't that the point? Fat around your waist is more risky than fat elsewhere? So sorry, but it's worth doing something about.

If you have narrow hips, it's hard to achieve the supposedly healthiest ratio, even if there's very little fat round your middle.

Yes, my measurements are 34, 26, 34 at a bmi of 20. I wear a 6 on bottom to fit my hips and 10 on top to fit my chest. When I was very underweight I was 32, 25, 32. So my ratio is okay I think but not if I gain weight.
WaisttoheightnotBMI · 05/02/2022 13:42

@110APiccadilly

Practicality I think - BMI is very simple and doesn't change much depending on who's measuring. If you've got to measure someone's waist that's an extra faff, and also you've got to judge exactly where their waist is. Almost anyone who's had a baby will be able to tell you that their fundal height seemed to be measured differently each time - I imagine waist measurement would also suffer from this.

BMI is only one part of the picture - there's also bodyfat ratios you could look at as well as waist measurement, given that BMI is also affected by having a lot of muscle. To say nothing of lifestyle - a smoker with a BMI of 23 is quite likely to be less healthy overall than a non-smoker with a BMI of, say, 29, even though the non-smoker is overweight. But it's a very easy part to measure and standardise, so I can see why it's used so much.

Very good point raised about lifestyle - smoking and drinking are important indicators! Also relevant when people say they eat endless amount of junk but don't gain weight - that's still going to be bad for their health.
OP posts:
WaisttoheightnotBMI · 05/02/2022 13:40

@DazzlePaintedBattlePants

BMI is a range precisely to accommodate a range of body types and builds! The weight range for a given height to be within the healthy range is very large.

I think there are vanishingly few athletes who fall outside of a healthy BMI. And I wouldn’t consider strongmen or Sumo wrestlers to be healthy - carrying that much extra weight has serious effects on joints and circulation.

"BMI is a range precisely to accommodate a range of body types and builds!"

I don't think that's how people, especially on MN, see BMI though. They'll see someone with a BMI of, say 24.5, and say well you can lose 15kg/ 2.5 stone and still be a healthy weight so you should work on losing weight - when in reality, because of the distribution of fat they may already be very healthy, and losing another 15kg may not be of much help to them, not to mention very very hard to achieve.

OP posts:
WaisttoheightnotBMI · 05/02/2022 13:38

@ColleysMill

Whilst they aren't a total fail safe I have some "smart' scales that measure loads of different components and indicate which bit is in a healthy or unhealthy range

Everything on mine is green except bmi and weight. Body fat coming in at 24% too (green). Visceral fat is on the higher side but still in a green zone.

No I know these scales aren't 100% accurate but nothing the average person can own will be and it's the best I can do.

My other niggle with bmi calculators is the activity amount - even the nhs one the most activity you can put in is 150 mins a week. I gym/home workout with cardio and weights 6 days a week and average 350 to 400 active mins a week - telling me to "exercise more" really isn't the issue. And calorie wise I aim for 1200 to 1500 a day (pretty healthy balanced diet bar the odd biscuit and pint) so unless I'm going to totally stop eating I'm at a loss to how to get bmi down further.

That's interesting, what smart scales do you use if you don't mind my asking?
OP posts:
WaisttoheightnotBMI · 05/02/2022 13:36

@LaurieFairyCake

It's so weird as really nothing tells a complete story

I was 5 stone overweight (obese) with a 29 inch waist - I'm an hourglass shape (my BMI was 38)

Now I'm 1 stone overweight, not obese and my waist is 25 inches (BMI 28)

Yes this is the kind of thing I'm talking about - unless you're very short, a 25 inch waist is small and you probably have a good waist to height ratio and are healthy in that aspect, which you can't tell from BMI.
OP posts:
WaisttoheightnotBMI · 05/02/2022 12:50

@ClariceQuiff

And for people saying 'oh that doesn't work for me because I'm an apple shape' isn't that the point? Fat around your waist is more risky than fat elsewhere? So sorry, but it's worth doing something about.

If you have narrow hips, it's hard to achieve the supposedly healthiest ratio, even if there's very little fat round your middle.

That’s not really true though because we’re talking about waist to height ratio, not waist to hip ratio. If there’s very little fat around your middle you’ll have a small waist so when measured against your height, you’ll have a good waist to height ratio regardless of how narrow your hips are. That’s the case for a lot of celebrities - many have straight up and down bodies, so their hips are narrow but their waist is obviously small too.
OP posts:
WaisttoheightnotBMI · 05/02/2022 12:48

@Ihaventgottimeforthis

I think waist to height ratio is much easier to measure than BMI, you just need a piece of string, you don't even need to know your weight. And for people saying 'oh that doesn't work for me because I'm an apple shape' isn't that the point? Fat around your waist is more risky than fat elsewhere? So sorry, but it's worth doing something about.
Yes I agree with you that’s exactly the point! Apple and pear shapes could have the exact same BMI but the apple shape is at more risk so they shouldn’t be complacent about it. In that case if their waist is disproportionately big, they can try to lose weight - yes it’ll take longer to lose weight from their waist because those women lose weight around their legs and hips first, but eventually the weight loss reaches the stomach (and the reverse is true for pear shapes). I think this works for a lot of people, but I acknowledge it’s trickiest when you’re very very Apple shaped - because you really wouldn’t have much to lose at the lower half so can’t really try to lose more.
OP posts:
BiBabbles · 05/02/2022 12:46

Possibly in part because stepping on a scale is easier & more socially accepted than getting out the measuring tape, which can seem to some to be overkill and there are arguments on where exactly people should be measuring against our different proportions.

BMI is a joke, think about Rugby players or strongman competitors they can be mega fit but their BMI is morbidly obese

Being strong doesn't mean being fit. There are people who can lift or push a fuckton but are in poor health.

There is argument in the "overweight" category and around where the cut off should be because there is evidence, particularly as we age, that there is protective benefits of being a bit heavier. Our rigid categories there have a lot of limits before getting into ethnicity, sex, disabilities, social attitudes and more. It's why it's better to have more types of data and a wider discussion on benefits and risks & how they vary for different groups and for individuals.

Once we hit morbidly obese (over 35 BMI), then that argument falls apart and really, a lot of muscle also raises the risks of certain health issues. It's very taxing on the body and those athletes are at high risk for many health issues from joint problems to recent research that strongly suggests that intense sports - including rugby - may increase the risk of MND and other conditions.

Whether those risks are worth it is up to the players, but we shouldn't be using people at the extremes as examples just because they can do things many people can't as if that strength is all good or their situations can be applied to others who are the same weight.

Steelesauce · 05/02/2022 12:22

Id never heard of waist to height or hip to waist ratios. Tested it out and I'm healthy on both. My BMI is 23 and I am a natural pear shape. 5'8 as well. I don't look good under 10 stone. 10st 7 is perfect for me but I'm above that at the moment!

ClariceQuiff · 05/02/2022 11:45

@iloveeverykindofcat

I think if you are an apple shape the unfotunate truth is that you have a lot less leeway on how much fat you can healthily carry than a pear shape can. Unfair but that's life.
Like a pp said, you have to look at it holistically. Someone with a ginormous bum and tiny waist might still have furred up arteries, and if they're overweight they'll be putting strain on their joints and so on. I accept that, all things being equal, an overweight pear might be less at risk than an overweight apple, but how often are all things equal?
iloveeverykindofcat · 05/02/2022 11:37

I think if you are an apple shape the unfotunate truth is that you have a lot less leeway on how much fat you can healthily carry than a pear shape can. Unfair but that's life.

purplesequins · 05/02/2022 11:36

yabu

both bmi and waist measurment together give a good prediction of health.

if anything, as pp say, the top end of 'healthy' bmi range is too high for many ethnicities.

CharacterForming · 05/02/2022 11:29

BMI is also ethnicity dependent. The NHS, and the Indian health authorities advises that people of South Asian descent should aim for a BMI below 23. China and Japan set a cut off of 24. Those three countries also set their obesity cut-offs lower.

Swipe left for the next trending thread