Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect a better response from my manager?

107 replies

secretsofthesun · 04/02/2022 17:43

Primary school teacher here. Yesterday one of my students hurt me to the point that I had to leave school and go to A&E. This is the third time the child has been violent towards me - the first two times were minor in comparison, but after this I've had enough.

Spoken to my head as I no longer feel safe with the child in my class and they have said that the child is fine to remain with me and that I need to find better ways to handle them. I've asked for suggestions for ways to handle them as I'm already following the behaviour policy and the child's specific behaviour plan and been told I "should know what to do". AIBU to expect a better response? This is my second year teaching and first year with a child like this so I'm not sure if I'm expected to suck it up as part of the job.

OP posts:
Smileyaxolotl1 · 04/02/2022 19:46

Scarby9
Are you saying that after the child stabbed two member of staff they were allowed back to that school?

BeaLola · 04/02/2022 19:26

I'm so sorry - I hope you are ok

I would definitely be going to your Union & take their advice

Please document / keep a diary of it all . I would also suggest you put your concerns in writing to the HT and make sure it includes the incidents so far - there is then a paper trial - your HT sounds appalling

For for those talking about how can a primary school teacher be hurt by a pupil my DS has suffered a lot of trauma in his past prior to adoption - he has not been violent at primary or secondary school or at home however even at primary in later years he was physically stronger than me - if he had been violent I expect I would have ended up in A&E

Scarby9 · 04/02/2022 19:21

To posters doubting a primary age child could injure someone badly enough for A & E, I have experience of children throwing chairs (Reception, Y4 and Y5) - at the first sign in the Y5 class, the other children got up and left, speedily but without fuss, through the fire door into the playground. The girl hurled chairs and overturned tables while the teacher stood guard in the doorway until she calmed down.

Another, Y3 child who stabbed both the teacher and TA. The teacher in the back of the hand with a pair of scissors, the TA with a sharp stick. In both cases, proper injuries. After the scissors injury everything sharp had to be removed from the room, and from the other children, hence the stick.
There are some very disturbed and traumatised children.

Westerman · 04/02/2022 19:21

I'm so sorry that you're having to go through this, OP. It is happening to my primary teacher stepdaughter, too. She is attacked several times a week and her first thought is always for the other children; she will always try to protect them from the violence and disruption. Like you, her headteacher seems powerless. I believe her union are involved already but what can be done? Can she call the police? I worry so much for her.
If this situation is happening in every school up & down the country, it seems no wonder that teachers are leaving in droves and there are recruitment problems.
And just how badly are the other kids in the class being affected?

Dontfuckingsaycheese · 04/02/2022 19:14

Your post regarding the not wanting to send the child home waved red flags at me. There could be more going on here, possibly safeguarding stuff that you, naturally, may not be privy to. However, whatever the reason it is horrendous they are not prioritising safety in you room - yours and indeed the other children’s. Next time it could be one of the children in AandE. This cannot all be put on you to deal with. You have done what any one of us would do in any work situation- asked your boss to make your workplace as safe as possible. If they do nothing that really is a poor show all round and I would be wondering if I really wanted to stay working in a place that would do that.

Sideswiped · 04/02/2022 19:13

@secretsofthesun, I think approaching your union is a very good idea. It sounds like your Head has their head in the sand and is ignoring the problem.
If you have any colleagues that you can trust that might be able to register their objections, that would help, and your Head wouldn't be able to ignore it any more.
You have a right to feel safe at work, and the child involved should have a 1-2-1 at the least.
YANBU

Onebabyandamadcat · 04/02/2022 19:11

I'm so sorry this has happened to you OP. I'm a primary teacher who has also been assaulted (and yes that's what it is - an assault) at work more than once. Thankfully never ended up in a&e but through luck more than anything - the threat to "kick that baby out of you" at 8 months pregnant was a particular low point. You can't refuse to teach the child but you can insist on a risk assessment, an additional member of staff or (if none of that works) I'd always be removing myself and my class the minute the child started to become aggressive. This is management's problem to fix. Speak to your union - they'll support you all the way. In Scotland, the EIS would also encourage you to report it to the police (again, this is an assault). Also make sure it is recorded as a violent incident with an injury via official channels (our council has an online system) this makes it harder to brush under the carpet. I'd also be sending an email to my HT detailing the incident and their solution, asking them to confirm this is their advice. Then you have a paper trail.

titbumwillypoo · 04/02/2022 19:10

Suzi888 "You have to sit there and take it. You can’t put one finger on them." Well actually you don't have to sit there and take it and any child being violent can be restrained if it meets the legal threshold of reasonable, proportional or necessary. That's why I asked about her about what training she'd had.

Velvian · 04/02/2022 19:09

Yanbu op. My primary school DD is taller than her teacher and she is not the only one.

HackAttack · 04/02/2022 19:07

Although for the record, I still put in agreed consequences including completing all of his work, no devices and apologising to the people who wholeheartedly did not deserve it

HackAttack · 04/02/2022 19:04

He is an 8 year old child with serious additional needs so, yes, it was not his fault that when he was shouted at for crying out due to bullying witnessed by others you are damn right he was not at fault.

Teaforme123 · 04/02/2022 19:01

@HackAttack

I will say this on a flip side, my 8 year old, who does have diagnosed needs, had a wonderful year last year, never aggressive at home, had had a number of major meltdowns this year which have included throwing chairs because of his teachers refusal to work with him how his teacher did the previous year.

The teacher is the problem, not him, after extensive challenge from the Ed psych and me he is settled again but he was not at fault for what happened.

Are you for real?! So absolutely not his fault he chucked chairs about?! Jeeeeeeeesus!
Cherrybomb197 · 04/02/2022 18:59

Cannot believe some of the responses on here. If a
Child is violent enough that a teacher has ended up in A&E: then clearly the teacher should not need to “put up” with it. The child clearly needs some support

HackAttack · 04/02/2022 18:56

I will say this on a flip side, my 8 year old, who does have diagnosed needs, had a wonderful year last year, never aggressive at home, had had a number of major meltdowns this year which have included throwing chairs because of his teachers refusal to work with him how his teacher did the previous year.

The teacher is the problem, not him, after extensive challenge from the Ed psych and me he is settled again but he was not at fault for what happened.

SomethingSuss · 04/02/2022 18:53

@Bizawit

This is a primary school child making you feel unsafe and putting you in A&E? I think I’d find it more understandable if they were an older kid..
You ever had a chair flung at you? Or a flipped table almost break your knee? A primary aged child may lack the strength to, for example, punch hard enough to require medical attention but flipped or thrown objects are very dangerous.
C152 · 04/02/2022 18:51

YANBU at all but, unfortunately, you'll come against this sort of attitude a lot. Have you joined the Teacher's Union and asked for their advice?

Suzi888 · 04/02/2022 18:48

@Bizawit

This is a primary school child making you feel unsafe and putting you in A&E? I think I’d find it more understandable if they were an older kid..
Why? You can’t just punch them in the face can you! You have to sit there and take it. You can’t put one finger on them.

What a ridiculous comment.

YANBU OP.

AutomaticMoon · 04/02/2022 18:45

@annonymousse

My daughter is a primary school teacher. She has been bitten and kicked and regularly has to evacuate her classroom due to the behaviour of one child. Small child but strong and difficult to restrain and she has bruises from that child every week.
That’s an idea, OP. Can you evacuate the rest of class and move to another room? This was actually done to me in school but I wasn’t abusive, the teacher was the abusive one in my case. But it’s a way to exclude the child from class when they’re violent. I think your union should help you get a plan in place.
Smileyaxolotl1 · 04/02/2022 18:42

Sorry you are going through this OP.
I find it fascinating how different primaries are to secondary.
I can assure you that if I was assaulted by a secondary school child in my job to the extent that a hospital visit was required it would be highly unlikely that the child would remain in the school and if they did I would definitely never have to teach them again. (As a far milder example I was told I could refuse to teach a girl who had set up a nasty social media account about me)
I find it absolutely disgusting and shocking what primary school teachers (and the children who share classes with these types of pupils) are expected to endure.

AutomaticMoon · 04/02/2022 18:42

@secretsofthesun

Primary-aged children can be shockingly violent at times... I don't want to be specific as to avoid being too identifying (not that I imagine many teachers went to A&E yesterday, but still).

I think the child would benefit from a 1:1 TA and potentially a reduced timetable. They are usually triggered by not getting their own way and having to do work (which is essentially multiple times everyday. SENCO is involved but there is no diagnosed need. At a minimum I think the child needs to be either internally excluded or sent home on the days they are extremely violent as they are not safe to be around other children. Essentially every other adult in school aside from the head thinks they should go home on these days, but the head always disagrees.

I plan on going to my union on Monday, but my head seems to act like everything's fine so I wasn't sure if I was in the wrong by wanting more done. I appreciate the reassurance on here.

It’s extremely demoralising to not have appropriate support from managers. I had this after being sexually harassed and verbally abused at work and it really triggered a mental breakdown but I already had cPTSD. Please look after your health, OP, as it doesn’t seem to be a concern of your head teacher.
annonymousse · 04/02/2022 18:40

My daughter is a primary school teacher. She has been bitten and kicked and regularly has to evacuate her classroom due to the behaviour of one child. Small child but strong and difficult to restrain and she has bruises from that child every week.

TheFallenMadonna · 04/02/2022 18:38

Sending a child home is a suspension (fixed term exclusion) which is why the Head is reluctant. Do contact your union. Do ask for a risk assesment to be made if that is not part of the behaviour plan, write a report on the incident detailing how you followed the recommendations of the behaviour plan and what happened as a result, and ask for the behaviour plan to be updated. Do you have a mentor as you are only in your second year?

ChristmasPlanning · 04/02/2022 18:37

Shocking OP that your HT is not supporting you. I'm not a teacher but agree your union is a good next step.

AutomaticMoon · 04/02/2022 18:37

@HelloPanda12

Don’t underestimate primary school children. A friend of mine told me about a young boy she was doing 1-1 with who had hit a teacher over the head with a laptop and split her head open. Luckily the school had a more professional way of handling the situation, your head seems like he or she isn’t bothered OP and it isn’t right for you to have to be wary in your own classroom.
Frightening. Humans have impulse control in the brain (most) but this only finishes development in our 20s! So children can be v dangerous indeed as there’s no impulse control. It’s like with psychotic people becoming super strong because there’s nothing holding you back from using full force, ITMS.
titbumwillypoo · 04/02/2022 18:37

SamphiretheStickerist I asked the questions because they're relevant to giving useful advice.
FawnFrenchieMum I conflated the two years teaching with the year 2 comment below it (my bad)

Swipe left for the next trending thread