Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think their should be a wieght limit on school bags?

66 replies

VelvetChairGirl · 04/02/2022 13:59

just the title really.

my son has to carry everything in a backpack he isnt allowed any other type of bag, they have no personal storage spaces in classes or a locker, so all the books and equipment, water bottle etc have to go in the backpack and be carried all day around the school.

I ended up carrying his bag for him yesterday and my shoulder hurts today, he's only 11 its too much.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wafflesnsniffles · 04/02/2022 18:46

5 exercise books and his lunch really doesn't weigh that much

Funny joke. Not. What secondary school kid goes to school with only 5 exercise books and lunch?

We had lockers when I was at school (90s) but I always had a bag stuffed with stuff. The lockers werent always accessible either.

phoenixrosehere · 04/02/2022 17:48

I ended up with a herniated disk in my lumbar region from a heavy backpack at 16. I had to do physical therapy to sort it and quit dance classes for a year. It was that, some type of injections into my spine and worse case scenario back surgery if physical therapy and injections didn’t work. The exercises I realised later were mainly yoga positions. I will say it made me more aware of how my body moves and how not to put stress on any part of my spine.

TyrannysaurusXXrightshoarder · 04/02/2022 17:45

Our DDs school always used to have lockers for every pupil. Until they had a brand new school building built that opened last September (parts of the old buildings were in such a bad state of repair demolition was the only option). It’s all brand spanking new. Except no one considered how wide the corridors would need to be for lockers. Not one single corridor is wide enough for both two way walking traffic and lockers, so now there aren’t any. There’s only enough for one year group, in the last remaining old building, and they have been given to Year 7. Every other year group has to bring everything in and home again every day.

etulosba · 04/02/2022 17:29

I can't remember carrying anything much to school (1960s). All our books, equipment was kept in our desks. But all lessons except for science and art were taught in the form room, with teachers for the various subjects coming to us.

I'm probably of a similar age an we had to carry everything and traipse between rooms. Eight lessons a day too, not five.

The only people that used backpacks then were mountain climbers.

MajorCarolDanvers · 04/02/2022 17:14

My son carries

At least 8 books, pencil case, water bottle, packed lunch.
3 days a week full outdoor gym it (no indoor gym cause of "Covid")
One day a week a musical instrument, stand and music book.

Its bloody awful and he has to lug it all from class to class.

There are lockers in school but they are still taped off for "Covid Reasons".

DysmalRadius · 04/02/2022 17:11

Do they have a firm rule about sack barrows?! Could you get him a folding one that he can strap the stupid rucksack to at least for the journey to and from school?

This whole set-up sounds so pointlessly stupid - I remember struggling with the same kind of thing when I was in secondary, but at least we had lockers, so we weren't carrying them around all day. It's a shame that schools aren't set up to actually accommodate students and their learning, and disappointing to learn that things have actually gone backwards over the last 25 years... Shock

Nodancingshoes · 04/02/2022 16:36

My sons schoolbag weighs a ton...2 Art sketchbooks (thick and heavy) several other books, lunchbox, waterbottle plus PE kit. I feel sorry for him having to lug all that around. We had lockers in my day

Hawkins001 · 04/02/2022 16:30

@VelvetChairGirl

just the title really.

my son has to carry everything in a backpack he isnt allowed any other type of bag, they have no personal storage spaces in classes or a locker, so all the books and equipment, water bottle etc have to go in the backpack and be carried all day around the school.

I ended up carrying his bag for him yesterday and my shoulder hurts today, he's only 11 its too much.

What about those backpacks that double with a handle and wheels ? Although I understand your perspectives op. For me it was , laptop, tablet, textbooks for different lessons, then on the side, research project s for psychology and genetic engineering
Comtesse · 04/02/2022 16:24

My 11 year old’s backpack weighs 6.6kg today. There is no WAY I would carry so much for work. There are no lockers and wheely bags aren’t allowed. I think it is appalling, makes me seriously angry. There is no way that young kids should be carrying that kind of weight all day every day.

Calennig · 04/02/2022 16:19

All our books, equipment was kept in our desks. But all lessons except for science and art were taught in the form room, with teachers for the various subjects coming to us.

When DD1 started at the secondary they did this.

I suspect it helped with the previous loss of students during day that under that head had declined and possibly loss of pens and equimpent between classes.

Then head left and it changed - apparently the teachers often prefer staying still and kids moving as means they can have their books and things round them and they can group in subject areas.

ikeepseeingit · 04/02/2022 16:12

It's ridiculous isn't it OP? I was made to carry everything as well around school. It was an all-girls school and I think I was one of about 3 in my year that even had a backpack! The rest all had these giant Primark handbags that would break. I tried a messenger bag for a year or two until my mum told me I was being insane. She was right. It got worse in GCSE when I was also made to carry 2 textbooks for all 5 lessons each. I used to come home with such a sore back, not something a 15-year-old needs!

Aderyn21 · 04/02/2022 15:56

Ours have to take an iPad, which comes with a keyboard and a heavy protective case. I thought this would be instead of all the books, but no, it's just one more thing in addition to all the other stuff dc has to cart around!

VelvetChairGirl · 04/02/2022 15:49

@LongBlobson

My y8 some days has packed lunch, water bottle, pencil case, reading book, exercise books, woodwind instrument, music book, PE kit... They can barely lift it and have to walk over half an hour to school. Not sure what the answer is though.

At least they don't seem to have text books - at that age we had to bring text books to and from school too!

The one thing that would help is wearing PE kit on PE days like they do at primary. But I think the secondary kids often get too muddy and sweaty to wear it all day.

Lockers aren't a thing apparently since covid.

My kids school they were the P.E kit on P.E day all day.
OP posts:
Jessesgirl13 · 04/02/2022 15:49

I actually have back/shoulder issues from carrying my heavy school bag on the same shoulder when in high school. Im only 5ft 1 so was tiny in school and really struggled with the weight of it!

JaffaCakeGal · 04/02/2022 15:41

Not RTFT but I can sympathise as I remember from school! One day we were timetabled to have PE and Food Tech on the same day. Plus multiple exercise books and text books and other usual stuff, it was a joke. Then lugging it all home when you had the same class the next day because no lockers, ridiculous.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 04/02/2022 15:34

@Guacamoleontoast

I can't remember carrying anything much to school (1960s). All our books, equipment was kept in our desks. But all lessons except for science and art were taught in the form room, with teachers for the various subjects coming to us. We did have to carry ingredients for cookery though, in a wicker basket covered with a divided cloth. PE kit was kept in lockers and taken home very rarely when it needed washing.
This makes SO much more sense. I really wonder why more schools don't do this.

Surely it's quicker and easier to keep the kids in one place?

KaiKanWhenever · 04/02/2022 15:34

I totally agree - I swear it's going to create a generation of back problems in later life!

My DD15 has to carry around a heavy laptop, water bottle and course books! It's so heavy and I feel so sorry for the younger students.

emmathedilemma · 04/02/2022 15:32

YANBU when i went to secondary school we had lockers or desks that we could leave things in but even the weight of books /files that needed to go home for homework was ridiculous, we had backpacks that were half our own weight, plus PE kit, hockey stick / tennis racquet, musical instrument, home economics basket (the work of the devil!). The size and weight of some of the textbooks was crazy. This might be manageable for 15/16 year old but not a small 11/12 year old. If he's got a backpack make sure he carries it on both shoulders and has it adjusted properly so it's not pulling down or backwards.

Rummikub · 04/02/2022 15:30

I picked up my dd2 back pack
It was ridiculously heavy.
The paid for locker is inconvenient to get to.

The coat thing is ridiculous. Have to remove it before entering school then shove it in your bag.

Agree that schools are poorly designed and not considering needs of pupils.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/02/2022 15:29

Yes and remember girls are being made to carry the same- far less upper body strength!

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 04/02/2022 15:27

Totally agree. Add into that a big instrument case. My Ds is like a twig and half the size of most his year group. He has to walk to bus and was crying when he came home last week as he struggled to get to it on time due to the weight of instrument case. It's new - I struggled carrying it! I'm now dropping him off on those days but overall with other pe kit etc it's too much.

80sMum · 04/02/2022 15:27

When I was at school, in the '60s and '70s, we used to have desks with a lift-up top, beneath which we stored our books. The only things that were taken home were the pencil case and the specific books needed for that evening's homework.

There was no homework until secondary school, so I never took anything home during my primary school years, except for my PE kit and pencil case on the last day of term.

Until recently, I worked in a school and frequently used to offer my assistance to small children struggling with ridiculously heavy backpacks - and they were often also burdened with a separate, huge, drawstring bag of PE kit, an item of sports equipment (tennis racket, hockey stick, lacrosse stick etc) and a musical instrument! I was aghast that the children were expected to lug so much stuff around the school.

MermaidEyes · 04/02/2022 15:12

Add to that, when they have cooking and PE on the same day...my dc needs a friggin wheelie suitcase!

Mariposista · 04/02/2022 15:05

Kids in Spain all have wheelie bags. They are brilliant!

pumpkinsquish1 · 04/02/2022 15:02

We didn't have lockers at my school and in high school I never unpacked my bag as I was so disorganised I couldn't remember everything for each subject every day so I lugged it all around all week.

And when I was at school it was deeply, deeply uncool to have your backpack on both shoulders so I think everyone in my year now has back problems!

Swipe left for the next trending thread