Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Maths Disagreement

593 replies

TulaOfDarkWater · 04/02/2022 12:41

One person thinks the answer is 165 and the other thinks 67, who is right?

YABU - 165
YANBU - 67

Or what’s the answer if both are wrong?

Maths Disagreement
OP posts:
Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 21:18

@KhaleesiOfChaos

Just scroll up and read the step by step outline.
The answer is 38.

BeautifulBirds · 04/02/2022 21:15

Or

2+3+(3x11)

KhaleesiOfChaos · 04/02/2022 21:15

I got 88! The merry are fewer bananas in each bunch on the last equation. The clock says 2 not 3 and there are 11 sides to all the shapes. So isn't it 2+3+3=8. Then times 11 = 88?

user03848921 · 04/02/2022 21:14

@Warblerinwinter you have a maths degree but you are saying this doesn’t make sense without brackets ? 🤔

x+x+2*x You wouldn’t know to multiply first without brackets?

NotYourOscarSpeech · 04/02/2022 21:13

@Warblerinwinter

No brackets- therefore no single correct answer. Who on earth wrote it like that with no brackets Dumb really
Nobody - and I mean nobody - who thinks this is true has a maths degree.

I’ve seen some blatant Pinocchios on Mumsnet over the year but this one takes the biscuit.

BeautifulBirds · 04/02/2022 21:13

2+3+(3x10)

35

monkeysox · 04/02/2022 21:12

Sorry. 2+3+3x11
38

monkeysox · 04/02/2022 21:11

3+3+(4x11)=50

Blossom64265 · 04/02/2022 21:07

Multiplication always happens before addition.

That has never changed.

We aren’t talking about higher order, possibly theoretical situations where the assumptions define the rules of the equations. We are talking about basic calculations. You could just as easily have a stack of stones in front of you that you are moving around.

Warblerinwinter · 04/02/2022 21:07

[quote user03848921]@Warblerinwinter you don’t need brackets when something is being multiplied. Try it on a calculator without brackets using BODMAS. The answer is 38.[/quote]
Ha ha! I have a maths degree. I know you can put into a calculator…you can put any numbers into a calculator and it will just give you an answer, doesn’t mean it makes sense. Maths is a beautiful and precise language…that calculation isn’t. It’s ambiguous

Mostlyjustrunning · 04/02/2022 21:04

@UniversalAunt

Yes to BIDMAS as well as BODMAS, as the I refers to indices.

However there is some discourse about BIDMAS/BODMAS/PEDMAS, as this pithy article explains.

Time to ditch BODMASS

Yes I guess BOPS simplifies things.

I’m pretty sure I never learnt BODMAS but always knew the order of operations.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 20:57

@Mischance

This is a fascinating thread - if only because it is not about men behaving very badly! But, that aside, it is clear that there is nothing at all pure about maths and that the answer to this problem somewhat depends on when you were at school. The answer 165 would, without any doubt, have been marked as correct (honest guv - I did really well at Maths O-level back in the dark ages!)
No, it wouldn't have been.
Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 20:56

@Whichcatthatcat

I learnt at school to start at the left and work through, unless there were brackets. So 2+3 =5 + 3 =8 ×11 = 88.

I don't know how a new method was invented that came up with a different answer. Surley maths is maths and can't ever change, numbers do the same thing forever.

This just isnt true. Go look at old textbooks. You're taught BODMAS.

Someone on here actually explained about teacher strikes and things getting in the way of maths being taught properly for a certain generation but outside of that, you would not have been taught differently. Maths has not changed.

user03848921 · 04/02/2022 20:56

The answer is not 165, it’s 38 as each side of the shape counts as 1. Each banana is 1 and the value of the clock is the time. Zoom in on the picture. If you are confused about addition and multiplication check it on a calculator.

Mischance · 04/02/2022 20:53

This is a fascinating thread - if only because it is not about men behaving very badly! But, that aside, it is clear that there is nothing at all pure about maths and that the answer to this problem somewhat depends on when you were at school. The answer 165 would, without any doubt, have been marked as correct (honest guv - I did really well at Maths O-level back in the dark ages!)

Whichcatthatcat · 04/02/2022 20:51

I learnt at school to start at the left and work through, unless there were brackets. So
2+3 =5 + 3 =8 ×11 = 88.

I don't know how a new method was invented that came up with a different answer. Surley maths is maths and can't ever change, numbers do the same thing forever.

user03848921 · 04/02/2022 20:51

@Warblerinwinter you don’t need brackets when something is being multiplied. Try it on a calculator without brackets using BODMAS. The answer is 38.

poetryandwine · 04/02/2022 20:37

It is worth noting that the OP’s answer of 67, well explained by @NeedToBeBrave1, is mathematically valid. Her method is identical to that of @stuckasastuckthing. The difference is that OP and @NeedToBeBrave1 have assumed that each clock has value 3, each banana bunch 4 and each shape 15.

For correct maths I voted YANBU, the rest is a matter of interpretation.

QueenofLouisiana · 04/02/2022 20:30

38

BODMAS/ BIDMAS is taught in year 6, I'm pretty certain that it hasn't just been invented for SATs!

Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 20:30

@debbrianna

165
FFS. Seriously?
debbrianna · 04/02/2022 20:28

165

jimmyreckon · 04/02/2022 20:23

But it's not new @GettingStuffed we learnt it in the 80s and Ddad said he learnt it in the 50s

You don't need brackets for Bodmas

In the order or working , multiplication is always done Before addition or subtraction

@bongobingo43

Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 20:20

@bongobingo43

No. That's exactly the point.
Bodmas.
Brackets first. If no brackets then move onto order (like 2 squared). If no squaring then move onto division. If no division then move onto multiplication. If no multiplication then move onto addition. If not addition then move onto subtraction.

The sum is
2 + 3 + 3 × 11

No brackets or squaring. So next check for multiplication. There is one! Do that first to give,

2 + 3 + 33.

Next, check for addition. We have two. Do those. That gives,

If the sum was,
(2 + 3 + 3) × 11

Then we would add the first 3 numbers right at the start because brackets come first.

So, it is the exact opposite of what you said. With no brackets, you go right to the end and do the multiplication first.

LazJaz · 04/02/2022 20:20

38

dementedpixie · 04/02/2022 20:19

@bongobingo43

Why is everyone talking about BODMAS when there are no brackets. You add the first 3 numbers together then multiply that answer by the final number
Doesn't need to be brackets as × and ÷ still take priority over + and - so you do the × first
Swipe left for the next trending thread