Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Maths Disagreement

593 replies

TulaOfDarkWater · 04/02/2022 12:41

One person thinks the answer is 165 and the other thinks 67, who is right?

YABU - 165
YANBU - 67

Or what’s the answer if both are wrong?

Maths Disagreement
OP posts:
EmoIsntDead · 04/02/2022 21:58

@GettingStuffed

Unfortunately there's two types of maths. The stuff we did in schools years ago when you worked left to right unless there were brackets, this new maths means to do things in a particular order.

Who decided this way was better? So it's possible to be two "correct" answers depending on when you went to school.

God, this could NOT be more wrong. Unless you went to school some time around the 16th century? If so, brava on your IT skills.

Cries in maths teacher

Unsure33 · 04/02/2022 21:54

38

You have to count the bananas
Look at the hour
X before addition
And count the points on the shapes

Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 21:54

@Od130990

Scroll up and read.

Multiplication always before addition if there are jo brackets to indicate otherwise.

In order to get 80 from your numbers, it would need to be
(2+3+3) × 10 = 80.

Without brackets, you multiply first.
2+3+3×10
=2+3+30
=5+30
=35.

I agree that the shape issue could be either each shape is worth 5, and then the answer is 35. Or each side is worth 1 (15 sides with all 3 shapes. 11 sides once you remove the square.)
If it is 11, then the answer is 38.

EmoIsntDead · 04/02/2022 21:52

@celiamary

There are no brackets in the problem. All bananas are equal, all Clock face are equal. Final line is 3+4+4*15 Ignore BODMAS because working left to right takes precedence over going right then switching back L to R If 4*15 +4+4 then bracket should be used All IMHO of course.
You can't have an opinion about the correct order of operations. It's a mathematical rule. A universal truth.

B for brackets (P for parentheses would be more accurate here though)
O for orders (or E for exponents or I for indices)
DM for divide and multiply. Both of equal importance.
AS for add and subtract. Both equal importance.

Od130990 · 04/02/2022 21:51

2 + 3 + 3 x 10 = 80

Clocks on 2 not 3
And only 3 bananas each bunch
And square removed from the 3 shaped in previous lines; so because there's 3 shapes & ones missing I'm gonna assume each shape represents 5 as originally they were worth 15.

DropYourSword · 04/02/2022 21:49

It's 38.

As your second post asks which it would be if the symbols hadn't changed, one of you is correct as it would have been 67.

I'm pissing myself that someone with a "maths degree" has no idea about order of operations!

Also, all these people arguing about "new maths" must have gone to school in very early 1900's, as it was established by 1920.

poetryandwine · 04/02/2022 21:47

A casual search suggests that the BODMAS rule evolved during the 16th and 17th centuries to remove exactly the ambiguity demonstrated here. The Wikipedia article ‘Order of Operations’ is quite decent.

I am not completely sceptical of those who are sure they were taught differently. I am however sure that in this case they were taught wrongly. It is less uncommon than we would hope

SukiPook · 04/02/2022 21:43

Definitely 38.
2 + 3 + (3 x 11)

usethedata · 04/02/2022 21:35

38 here also

Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 21:35

@Warblerinwinter

You keep the sign with it's number.

1 [-2] [+4]

Now you do the addition first.
-2 + 4 = +2.

So,
1 + 2 = 3.

It isnt hard.

2 [+3] [+3] [×11]

You do the multiplication first.
+3 × 11 = +33

Then the addition of the rest to get 38.

That's maths. Noting new about it.

hivemindneeded · 04/02/2022 21:33

I make it either 88 or 38 depending on this BIDMAS stuff I swear we were never taught at school which I think means you only multiply the number closest to the multiplication sign not the sum of numbers preceding it.

Calculator says 38, so I'm going with that.

NotYourOscarSpeech · 04/02/2022 21:33

@Warblerinwinter Google “commutative”. You’re seriously embarrassing yourself.

user03848921 · 04/02/2022 21:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Mostlyjustrunning · 04/02/2022 21:32

[quote user03848921]@Mostlyjustrunning You would use the sign of 2 (-2) when you added to 4 which gives 2. Then you get three. But if you don’t remember that always use operations left to right. BODMAS hasn’t failed really.[/quote]
No BODMAS hasn’t failed at all but people’s interpretation of it does frequently.

EmoIsntDead · 04/02/2022 21:31

@Warblerinwinter did you get your maths degree on the back of a cereal packet? I can't for one minute believe someone well versed in maths doesn't know multiplication comes before addition in a simple calculation. No ambiguity there.

I'm embarrassed for you.

TetherWhether · 04/02/2022 21:31

Oh sod

3 x 11
+3
+2

38

Or I may be very tired!

TheNewGnuKnew · 04/02/2022 21:30

I make it 38.

2+3+(3x11)

TetherWhether · 04/02/2022 21:29

3 x 15

  • 3 +2

50

Bodmas
And the number of bananas matter and the time matters.

user03848921 · 04/02/2022 21:29

@Mostlyjustrunning You would use the sign of 2 (-2) when you added to 4 which gives 2. Then you get three. But if you don’t remember that always use operations left to right. BODMAS hasn’t failed really.

pourmeanotherglass · 04/02/2022 21:29

Either 38 or 88.
Last row is 2 +3+3×11. ( shape is different and has 11 sides, clock says 2,, there are 3 bananas).
If you use bodmas is 5 + 33 = 38
If you solve left to right is 8x11=88.

Warblerinwinter · 04/02/2022 21:28

[quote user03848921]@Warblerinwinter you have a maths degree but you are saying this doesn’t make sense without brackets ? 🤔

x+x+2*x You wouldn’t know to multiply first without brackets?[/quote]
Bodmas doesn’t work…it can be applied to only the examples where bodmas does work ( e.g. 1-2+4 bodmas style is very very wrong)
And you’re quite right…I certainly wouldn’t know to multiply first…without brackets could be interpreted either way
These types of equations are lazy and a modern phenomenon….It’s like writing without punctuation
I never heard of bodmas and their various off shoots through my entire education in maths from late 60s to early 80s. Never needed to. People wrote equations out full hand. It takes nano seconds to put brackets in while you’re thinking through problems, same as punctuation. Although my punctuation isn’t always perfect🙄
I look at your equation and my brain goes into melt down same as it would with a sentence without punctuation.
Each to her own…but good luck trying to use bodmas with a child to explain 1-2+4

EmoIsntDead · 04/02/2022 21:27

It's 38.

Each group of polygons in the first line is 15. A square, a pentagon and a hexagon is 15 sides in total. In the last pic the polygons care missing the square so the pentagon and hexagon makes it 11.

Bananas are 1 each.

Clock is worth 3 but it's set to 3 o'clock, in the final pic it's set to 2.

Final line reads as 2 + 3 + 3 x 11.

Multiplication proceeds addition so 2 + 3 + 33 = 38

Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 21:25

They've got confused about negative numbers.

-2 + 4 = +2
They think it equals -6.

Instead of actually adding 4 and going up the number line, they've "added 4" and made it more negative. Think they got confused and didnt know how to add onto a negative. Thought it made it more negative!

Mostlyjustrunning · 04/02/2022 21:24

@dementedpixie

That link you posted has a calculation they've done totally wrong *@Mostlyjustrunning*.

1 -2 + 4

Contrary to what they've put, if you do addition then subtraction you get 1 + 4 - 2 = 3. They haven't kept the '-' with the 2.

It wasn’t me that posted it, but at first I thought they had it wrong but I think they are explaining that people might think it has to be Addition THEN subtraction due to BODMAS therefore Products then Sums is better.
dementedpixie · 04/02/2022 21:18

That link you posted has a calculation they've done totally wrong @Mostlyjustrunning.

1 -2 + 4

Contrary to what they've put, if you do addition then subtraction you get 1 + 4 - 2 = 3. They haven't kept the '-' with the 2.

Maths Disagreement
Swipe left for the next trending thread