Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Maths Disagreement

593 replies

TulaOfDarkWater · 04/02/2022 12:41

One person thinks the answer is 165 and the other thinks 67, who is right?

YABU - 165
YANBU - 67

Or what’s the answer if both are wrong?

Maths Disagreement
OP posts:
cherrybonbons · 05/02/2022 04:13

I got
35

Doratheexploret · 05/02/2022 02:53

38

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 05/02/2022 02:25

I know the majority of posters have accepted that the last grey shape has a value of 11 but I think it has to be - for it to be 10, all 3 shapes in the original should have been the same, like 3 overlapped squares, for example.

They are not the same shape, therefore they should not be assigned the same value - the assigned value of each shape within the composite should reflect the shape, therefore it makes FAR more sense that
square = 4
pentagon = 5
hexagon = 6

randomly assigning each a value of "5" because 15/3 = 5 isn't true to the spirit of these wretched brain teasers!
The devil really IS in the detail.

Puffthemagicdragongoestobed · 05/02/2022 01:42

48?

SpeedRunParent · 04/02/2022 23:32

The bunches of bananas are only 3 rather than 4
The clock says 2 rather than 3
The polygon combo only has a total of 11 sides rather than 15
Bidmas / bodmas / podmas dictates the multiplication comes before addition
Therefore:
3*11 = 33
2+3+33 = 38

Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 23:22

@poetryandwine

Yes, I know I was solving 2 different equations correctly. I was showing that if we use the answer of 38 then Y turns out to be 11, which we know is correct. But it we use the answer of 88 then Y turns out to be 27.667. Which we know is wrong.
So the answer isnt 88. It's 38.

vonniee · 04/02/2022 23:15

38
Number of bananas
Time on the clock
Number of sides on each shape

poetryandwine · 04/02/2022 23:10

Actually, @Itsalmostanaccessory, you are solving two different equations correctly. In using the expression 3Y, you are introducing BODMAS. We. do know Y is 11.

So I think that was slightly muddled , but your basic idea that introducing an algebra equation sets us up to use BODMAS correctly was brilliant.

UniversalAunt · 04/02/2022 22:55

BODMAS, BIDMAS or not, many of us need our eyes tested.

These tests do the rounds & after the core maths order of operation, the devil is in the pictorial detail of the question.

As with all tests, the art of the answer is to make sure you read the question carefully.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 22:53

@ArtyChoc
(And everyone else who cannot understand this).

Let's just say the last symbol with the shapes is 11. But lets pretend we dont know that and call it Y.

The equation would look like this;

2 + 3 + 3Y = 38
3Y = 38 - 2 - 3
3Y = 33
Y = 11.

Yay. That's right.

Now use your answer of 88.

2 + 3 + 3Y = 88
3Y = 88 - 2 - 3
3Y = 83
Y = 27.6667

Nope. We know Y = 11. So that doesnt work. It isnt 88.

BODMAS.

poetryandwine · 04/02/2022 22:45

@ArtyChoc,

You are using the values most of us think are meant. But it appears that you are doing your operations from left to right. The rule (BODMAS or BIDMAS) is to perform the multiplication first. It just evolved because a decision had to be made to avoid the confusion we are having on this thread!

buckeejit · 04/02/2022 22:43

I miss these- we had some in our neighbourhood WhatsApp group during lockdown 1 when it all was just fun & games in our estate, (mostly healthy retired folk)

SaySomethingMan · 04/02/2022 22:42

@GeorgieTheGorgeousGoat

I thought it was 38 Confused
Yep? I agree its 38.
Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 22:40

@ArtyChoc

88

2 "o" clock + 3 + 3 x (number of sides) 11

No.
ArtyChoc · 04/02/2022 22:36

88

2 "o" clock + 3 + 3 x (number of sides) 11

buckeejit · 04/02/2022 22:26

Sorry 38

buckeejit · 04/02/2022 22:25

152

Westerman · 04/02/2022 22:18

Im not sure if I have the brackets in the right place, but I think it's 38.
(2 + 3) + (3 x 11) so 5 + 33 = 38.

horsemadgal · 04/02/2022 22:16

I get 38

MummyInTheNecropolis · 04/02/2022 22:14

38

DropYourSword · 04/02/2022 22:13

Sorry @dementedpixie I meant the screenshot you posted was someone doing it incorrectly. Didn't realise it wouldn't post when I quoted you! My comment wasn't directed at you!

DropYourSword · 04/02/2022 22:11

@dementedpixie

That link you posted has a calculation they've done totally wrong *@Mostlyjustrunning*.

1 -2 + 4

Contrary to what they've put, if you do addition then subtraction you get 1 + 4 - 2 = 3. They haven't kept the '-' with the 2.

The is just an example of someone applying it incorrectly!
HarryDresdensLeatherDuster · 04/02/2022 22:09

35

poetryandwine · 04/02/2022 22:06

I agree there appear to be

Two ways to value clocks
(All worth 3, or worth the value of the time)

Two ways to value bananas
(A bunch is 4, or the value is the no of bananas)

At least three ways to value shapes, counting that of @Od130990.

So lots of answers, but only one way to do the maths! IIRC that was first explained clearly upthread by @stuckasastuckthing and it is the method OP used also: BODMAS

blueshoes · 04/02/2022 22:04

@DustyMaiden

This is an eye test
Truly is. The shape was too small for me to count the sides or points so I clearly need to get my eyes checked.
Swipe left for the next trending thread