Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Maths Disagreement

593 replies

TulaOfDarkWater · 04/02/2022 12:41

One person thinks the answer is 165 and the other thinks 67, who is right?

YABU - 165
YANBU - 67

Or what’s the answer if both are wrong?

Maths Disagreement
OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 05/02/2022 08:24

38

Toddlerteaplease · 05/02/2022 08:23

I got 3+4+4+15

JustUseTheDoorSanta · 05/02/2022 08:22

Only 3 bananas not 4 in the final row, and the clock shows 2 not 3, and you have 11 shape sides not 15. Then ensure you multiply.
2 + 3 + (3*11) = 38

Toddlerteaplease · 05/02/2022 08:22

I got 26

hivemindneeded · 05/02/2022 08:21

@TeenPlusCat - Thank you. When I first heard of BODMAS or BIDMAS, in my late forties/early fifties, I mentioned on a thread that it just wasn't taught at my school. Lots of people said, of course it was, it always has been. But judging by the vast number of people on here who instinctively add up from left to right then multiply the total, it seems it isn't properly taught - or wasn't - to a huge number of people. A lot of people have no idea of its existence.

ldontWanna · 05/02/2022 08:19

@hivemindneeded

Though you could argue that each shape, regardless of number of sides = 5.
That's what I did. Still annoyed it was number of sides and got it wrong.
malmi · 05/02/2022 08:19

It's the mathematical convention to carry out operations in a certain order when there are no brackets. If we don't "assume brackets" (i.e. use the right order) then we can't solve it because you have to do some things before other things to get a consistent answer.

TeenPlusCat · 05/02/2022 08:18

hivemindneeded

Because to do maths you have conventions. The 'rule' is multiplying comes before addition. You don't need the brackets because competent mathematicians know the rules and follow them. in theory brackets are superfluous.

However as seen on this thread, most people are not competent mathematicians. So anyone with half a brain writing things like this for 'the general public' would put brackets in to be on the safe side.

Similarly, I used to have 'discussions' with software developers over the need (in my opinion) to put in unnecessary (in their opinion) brackets at times to rally show they were being clear which order they wanted things to be done in a line of code. This was to help people maintaining the software later who might be less familiar with the code and therefore might accidentally screw it up.

hivemindneeded · 05/02/2022 08:14

Though you could argue that each shape, regardless of number of sides = 5.

hivemindneeded · 05/02/2022 08:13

@Gingernaut - you missed a facet from one of the shapes. There are 11 sides in total, not 10.

hivemindneeded · 05/02/2022 08:12

@NumberTheory

I also make it 2 + 3 + (3 x 11) = 38

Though given the way it's written, I don't think it's unreasonable to think it's (2+3+3)x11 = 88

Because Bodmas is a convention, not an infallible necessity of math, and no competent mathematician would write an equation like this without brackets or other more obvious indicator of precedence.

I really don't think of these as maths questions. They always seem more to do with observation skills to me.

That's what I never understand about these questions. If there are no brackets, why assume brackets? I just don't get it.
NumberTheory · 05/02/2022 08:08

I also make it 2 + 3 + (3 x 11) = 38

Though given the way it's written, I don't think it's unreasonable to think it's (2+3+3)x11 = 88

Because Bodmas is a convention, not an infallible necessity of math, and no competent mathematician would write an equation like this without brackets or other more obvious indicator of precedence.

I really don't think of these as maths questions. They always seem more to do with observation skills to me.

BarbaraofSeville · 05/02/2022 07:32

It's maths combined with a logic problem.

If it was 'school maths' or part of some sort of test, it would need clearer instructions to show that it's not just about deducing that bananas = X but Bananas = xy.

Plus the illustration would need to be clearer because having people look at tiny pictures, mostly on a phone screen, where the detail is relevant, isn't sufficiently inclusive to people with less than perfect eyesight.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 05/02/2022 06:18

This thread has just reminded me of why I HATED maths at school.

This isn't maths — it uses some of the conventions of maths but flouts other ones, in an attempt to confuse people.

TinselTitsAndGlitteryBits · 05/02/2022 06:11

This thread has just reminded me of why I HATED maths at school.

Beautiful language, understood in every country (according to Ms Jarvis anyway) - my arse!

Gingernaut · 05/02/2022 05:42

@Lazypuppy

Bananas are different to. I get it as 2+3+3×10
2 o'clock + 3 bananas + 3 bananas × 2 shapes becomes 2 + 3 + 3 × 10.

With no brackets, I make that 80

According to BODMAS, I make that 35

VashtaNerada · 05/02/2022 05:19

I also got 38. You have to assume that the value of the clock is 1 for each hour, the value of the bananas is 1 per banana, and the value of the shape is 1 for each corner. Of course it could theoretically be different and a square is worth ten for no reason whatsoever, but you have to make the assumption that it’s possible to work it out from the information you’ve been given.
And then you do your multiplication before your addition.

Random65 · 05/02/2022 05:18

38

Doona · 05/02/2022 05:18

I vote for 38, but I also think 67 is a fair answer. Not everyone who needs glasses can be bothered finding them and nor should they have to.

SomeOwlsCoo · 05/02/2022 05:12

It always makes me laugh on these threads (or IRL actually) when people claim maths has changed and BODMAS didn't exist when they were at school (including my brother, who is younger than me. I definitely learned BODMAS so how he thinks they hadn't invented it when we were at school is anyone's guess)

I have a friend in his 90s. He has a maths degree from Oxford. When he was helping me with some maths a few years ago he asked if I knew about order of operations. I had actually forgotten it, but once he explained remembered. And knew it as BODMAS.

But if it existed when he was at school 70-80 years ago, it must have existed when MNetters were at school. (I can't imagine we have many, or indeed any, users in their 90s)

tcjotm · 05/02/2022 05:01

@ClumpingBambooIsALie

It's one of those Facebook things where you've got to look closely at things like the exact number of bananas in the bunch. It's counting on you assuming they're the same symbol because you've been conditioned by years of school maths problems. Irritating.
Yeah redoing it on this basis I end up with 88. But my eyes can’t really see the bananas clearly enough.
SomeOwlsCoo · 05/02/2022 04:34

I make it 38. Now off to rtft and see how many agree with me.

sashh · 05/02/2022 04:32

@GettingStuffed

Unfortunately there's two types of maths. The stuff we did in schools years ago when you worked left to right unless there were brackets, this new maths means to do things in a particular order.

Who decided this way was better? So it's possible to be two "correct" answers depending on when you went to school.

I'm 55, this is not 'new' maths.

I get 38

top line each straight line =1 so 4+5+6=15 lines per shape, the last one is missing the square so =11

The bunch of bananas each banana =1 so in row 2 the bunch is 4

The clock = time displayed

cherrybonbons · 05/02/2022 04:18

Ignore me the shape is worth 11 not 10.
So the question would be (3x11) and add the 5

So 38

cherrybonbons · 05/02/2022 04:16

The pentagon only has 2 in this pic not 3 so is worth 10
The bananas are 3 not 4 bunch and the clock is pointing at 2pm not 3pm

So BODMAS rules means you do multiplication first
(10x 3) = 30
Add the banana and the clock which is 5 altogether

2+ 3 + (3x10)

Swipe left for the next trending thread