Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Maths Disagreement

593 replies

TulaOfDarkWater · 04/02/2022 12:41

One person thinks the answer is 165 and the other thinks 67, who is right?

YABU - 165
YANBU - 67

Or what’s the answer if both are wrong?

Maths Disagreement
OP posts:
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 05/02/2022 11:00

@TeenPlusCat

I had fun at university. A friend liked to drink 'pineapple juice and diet coke' (yes, mixed together). I always had to clarify to the bar staff.
Dear God. No wonder you had to be explicit.
TeenPlusCat · 05/02/2022 10:58

I had fun at university. A friend liked to drink 'pineapple juice and diet coke' (yes, mixed together). I always had to clarify to the bar staff.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 05/02/2022 10:58

I must remember to pronounce my brackets clearly Grin

TeenPlusCat · 05/02/2022 10:57

The mathematician would not fare so well working at a fish and chip shop, hearing "cod and chips three times please", and handing over a single piece of fish and three bags of chips.

Grin

Though when speaking spaces / commas do the work of brackets.

  • cod and chips-three-times
  • cod-and-chips three times
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 05/02/2022 10:49

@hivemindneeded

But *@Itsalmostanaccessory*, if you haven't been taught any mathematical conventions it would seem logical to progress left to right, like you do with reading. So you 2+3+3xY could be read accummulatively as 2+3=5, then take that 5 and +3=8, then x that 8 by Y. Surely you can see how many people would arrive at this method of working things out if they haven't been taught otherwise. It's what loads of people do on these sorts of brainteasers, so clearly maths teacher has failed colossally.

Translate it into real life and it's not clear whether it means make 11 sets of 2 apples, 3 pears and 3 oranges
or one set of 2 apples, 3 pears and 33 oranges.

The mathematician would not fare so well working at a fish and chip shop, hearing "cod and chips three times please", and handing over a single piece of fish and three bags of chips.
TeenPlusCat · 05/02/2022 10:44

I've seen maths teachers on MN bemoaning they have classes swear blind they haven't covered something before, when the teacher knows they have because she taught it to them the previous academic year.

My guess is yes it was taught, but no it wasn't revisited sufficiently for it to become ingrained.
Much like I suspect half the English grammar now being taught at primary which then isn't built on at secondary.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 05/02/2022 10:42

@hivemindneeded

I get people think they haven't been taught it/dont remember it/some really were taught very badly by teachers who have failed.
But once it has been explained, that should be it. Look at the mess if this thread because they just wont listen.

At the start of this, they might not have known, but anyone reading it certainly should understand it now. Yet... still people post nonsense.

The inability to read and actually take it in is astounding.

hivemindneeded · 05/02/2022 10:40

@Gettingstuffed just isn't wrong about the teaching. She may have been taught wrongly but she (or he) like me was simply not taught BIDMAS. Doesn't matter how long it's been around. If you're not taught it, you don't automatically work it out for yourself.

hivemindneeded · 05/02/2022 10:38

But @Itsalmostanaccessory, if you haven't been taught any mathematical conventions it would seem logical to progress left to right, like you do with reading. So you 2+3+3xY could be read accummulatively as 2+3=5, then take that 5 and +3=8, then x that 8 by Y. Surely you can see how many people would arrive at this method of working things out if they haven't been taught otherwise. It's what loads of people do on these sorts of brainteasers, so clearly maths teacher has failed colossally.

Translate it into real life and it's not clear whether it means make 11 sets of 2 apples, 3 pears and 3 oranges
or one set of 2 apples, 3 pears and 33 oranges.

PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 10:37

@gettingstuffed there is definitely only one way of doing it, order of operations wasn't necessarily taught properly in schools till about the 80s however you would have been given brackets if not taught it. Do the calculation on a calculator with no brackets and it will give you the correct answer.

PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 10:35

@bruffinyes I corrected myself after, I am on my phone and they are too small for my eyes Grin

NoVaxDjokovic · 05/02/2022 10:35

@GettingStuffed

Unfortunately there's two types of maths. The stuff we did in schools years ago when you worked left to right unless there were brackets, this new maths means to do things in a particular order.

Who decided this way was better? So it's possible to be two "correct" answers depending on when you went to school.

Order of operations was around in the 1800’s

So either you are the worlds oldest person (congrats) or you are wrong…

bruffin · 05/02/2022 10:27

[quote PugInTheHouse]@TulaOfDarkWater if shapes were all the same it would be 3+4+(4x15) = 67

I think the actual answer is

2+4+(4x11)=50

2 =clock
4=bananas
11=number of sides on the shape[/quote]
There are only 3 bananas

5566rfghh · 05/02/2022 10:27

@GettingStuffed

Unfortunately there's two types of maths. The stuff we did in schools years ago when you worked left to right unless there were brackets, this new maths means to do things in a particular order.

Who decided this way was better? So it's possible to be two "correct" answers depending on when you went to school.

Maths is maths!!!! This way isn't better, it's CORRECT. You're remembering wrong or else you were taught incorrectly. So no it doesn't depend on when you went to school.
PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 10:26

Sorry my eyesight is crap, I think there are 3 bananas on the last one so

2+3+(3×11)=38

PugInTheHouse · 05/02/2022 10:25

@TulaOfDarkWater if shapes were all the same it would be 3+4+(4x15) = 67

I think the actual answer is

2+4+(4x11)=50

2 =clock
4=bananas
11=number of sides on the shape

UniversalAunt · 05/02/2022 10:12

‘ I vote for 38, but I also think 67 is a fair answer. Not everyone who needs glasses can be bothered finding them and nor should they have to.’

Fair answer? Oh dear, there are no runner up prizes in getting maths right, otherwise bridges would fall down, medicines would not be correctly dosed etc.

However that said, this is why showing your workings, in homework, exams & research, is important as everything will be correct until the method & workings go wrong, & as we all know points mean prizes.

TeenPlusCat · 05/02/2022 09:59

[quote Itsalmostanaccessory]@NumberTheory

You dont need bracket in this.
You only need them if you are NOT competent. We didnt have brackets for simple things like this in high school, nor were they added when I was at uni and working through various equations because they are not needed.[/quote]
I think Number is well aware. Smile

The point really is that unless you can really be confident that all readers of your equation are competent (ie within a STEM situation) the safer thing is to include brackets.

The original puzzle plays on people not being fully competent, and stupid 'tricks' that really are nothing to do with maths anyway.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 05/02/2022 09:50

@NumberTheory

You dont need bracket in this.
You only need them if you are NOT competent. We didnt have brackets for simple things like this in high school, nor were they added when I was at uni and working through various equations because they are not needed.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 05/02/2022 09:45

I just dont know how many people can be so unaware of primary level maths.

If you have this equation:

2 + 3 + 3 × Y

When solving it, do you make it this,:

2Y + 3Y + 3Y

Or this,

2 + 3 + 3Y.

You make it the latter. You dont times every number by Y. You only join it with the number it was being multiplied by. Because there are 3 Ys.

The only time you would times Y by everything is if the equation was,

Y(2+3+3).

In that case, each number is multiplied by Y.

Replacing Y with a number doesnt change this.

So 2 + 3 + 3Y
Is the same as 2 + 3 + 3 × 11

And you do the 3 × 11 first to get 33. Then add the rest.

The fact that people continue to post totally nonsense after this has been explained over and over makes it very obvious that even if they were taught it properly, they still couldn't do it so would rather pretend that it is "new" maths.

malmi · 05/02/2022 08:38

Everyone instinctively applies BODMAS when calculating "6-½" (to get 5.5).

Logically it should not be different when written as "6-1÷2".

It's still 5.5 (not 2.5) because you still do the 1÷2 first.

Otherwise the result is dependent on presentation/formatting instead of the actual numbers and operations.

NumberTheory · 05/02/2022 08:36

[quote hivemindneeded]@TeenPlusCat - Thank you. When I first heard of BODMAS or BIDMAS, in my late forties/early fifties, I mentioned on a thread that it just wasn't taught at my school. Lots of people said, of course it was, it always has been. But judging by the vast number of people on here who instinctively add up from left to right then multiply the total, it seems it isn't properly taught - or wasn't - to a huge number of people. A lot of people have no idea of its existence.[/quote]
In the UK schools, while it's been a part of most curriculums for a long time, far more emphasis has generally been placed on clear communication rather than relying on order of operations. US schools seem to like order of operations a lot more - I suspect, though have absolutely no proof, because of their reliance on multiple choice testing and the way it lends itself to "trick" questions to test if you know it.

Blabla81 · 05/02/2022 08:33

Now have 38 after realising the last shape is worth 11.

Blabla81 · 05/02/2022 08:29

@Lazypuppy

Bananas are different to. I get it as 2+3+3×10
This is what I got too. So I got 35 as an answer.
TeenPlusCat · 05/02/2022 08:28

I was born in '67 and did BODMAS at primary level.

However except when explicitly testing BODMAS knowledge and to know that O comes before M for algebra I can see you can easily 'avoid' remembering it. Hence people claiming it wasn't taught to them. It might not have been taught with the acronym, but I think it is highly highly unlikely it wasn't taught at all.

3y^2 (3 y squared)

O then M : You have to know you square the y before multiplying it by 3.
So if y=5 then 3y^2 = 75, it does NOT equal 225.

Swipe left for the next trending thread