Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Maths Disagreement

593 replies

TulaOfDarkWater · 04/02/2022 12:41

One person thinks the answer is 165 and the other thinks 67, who is right?

YABU - 165
YANBU - 67

Or what’s the answer if both are wrong?

Maths Disagreement
OP posts:
rainrainraincamedowndowndown · 04/02/2022 14:15

3 + 4 + 4 x 15 = 67

steppemum · 04/02/2022 14:15

grey shape - each shape is the number of sides, so in the last sum the grey shape = 11
bananas = 1 per banana, so in the last row = 3
clock = time on clockface and in last row = 2

last row is:

2+3+3x11

BODMAS

2+3+ (3x11)
6 + 33

answer = 39

Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 14:15

@Cantleave

You use the number on the clock face which, for the last line, is 2.

You use the number of bananas which, for the last line, is 3.

Then you use the number of sides which, for the last line is 11.

That's 2 + 3 + 3 x 11 = 38.

But the shapes also work if they are each assigned the same value, 5. Because there isnt enough information. Both work though; all shapes worth 5 or by counting the number of sides.

In that case the answer is 35 (because there are 2 shapes in the last line).

There isnt enough information to tell us if the shapes are worked by counting the number of sides or by each shape being worth 5.

The answer can be 35 or 38.

bongsuhan · 04/02/2022 14:15

"no way of knowing what value the new shapes are" sry

LincolnshireYellowBelly · 04/02/2022 14:15

I get it as 35

thelittlestrhino · 04/02/2022 14:14

@Cantleave

The clocks, bunches of bananas and shapes are not the same on the final line of the calculation as they are on the initial 2... The whole long thread is about how that may influence the final calculation.

bongsuhan · 04/02/2022 14:14

[quote Itsalmostanaccessory]@ThumbWitchesAbroad

But how do you know you're meant to count the sides?
It works by counting the sides. But they all also work by assigning each shape with the same value.
They haven't shown you which it is. They could have done in the second line by removing the square and the answer would tell us if the square was 4 or 5. They haven't told us.

You cant assume in maths. They haven't given enough information. So it could be both 35 or 38. Both work. You cant give one single answer.[/quote]
This. There is no answer, because you have now way of knowing what the new shapes are, you can just guess.. These "challenges" use the ambiguity to generate interest and clicks on SM. It works well, as this thread (and others like it) shows.

Longingforatikihut · 04/02/2022 14:14

There are only 3 (not 4) bananas in the bunches of the unsolved equation, the time is 2 o'clock not 3 o'clock and the number of sides/corners of the layered shapes is different when you assent the square sooooo...

2+3+3x11 = 38

lookinginhammersmith · 04/02/2022 14:14

38

KeepYaHeadUp · 04/02/2022 14:14

In final sum:

  • 1 less banana = 3
  • clock is on 2 not 3 = 2
  • 4 straight sides missing = 11

BODMAS

11 x 3 = 33
2 + 3 + 33 = 38

Cantleave · 04/02/2022 14:12

[quote Itsalmostanaccessory]@Cantleave

Nope. It isnt 67.

It's 38 or 35[/quote]
Nope. Sorry, but it is you who is definitely wrong. It is 67.
Pretty ridiculous to say this mathematical equation could be 38 or 35! There cannot be 2 solutions!!
To simplify…..
3+4+4x15
No brackets, power or division, so goes to Multiplication which is -
4x15 =60
Then to addition
3+4+60=67

katepilar · 04/02/2022 14:12

ups, no. 38

thelittlestrhino · 04/02/2022 14:11

[quote Itsalmostanaccessory]@thelittlestrhino

Not really. Both worked out using the previous calculations. It's just "find x".[/quote]
Not necessarily, you simply do not have enough information on there to prove that the time on a clock or the number of bananas makes a difference to their value.

I also assumed the same as most people, and would have suggested an answer of 38, but that is based on assumptions which cannot be proven conclusively with the information given.

KeepYaHeadUp · 04/02/2022 14:11

I made it 38

katepilar · 04/02/2022 14:10

19

TeenPlusCat · 04/02/2022 14:08

You can't really 'do' algebra without understanding the order of operations.

3y^2 means 3 times y times y not 3 times y times 3 times y
The is the O and the M bit of BODMAS.

BODMAS is not a new thing invented this century!!

isitxmasalready · 04/02/2022 14:07

its 38.
All shapes are slightly different in the last sum
2 o'clock, not 3 + 3 bananas (not 4) +3 bananas (not 4) x 11 points on the shape rather than 15 points in the original shape

Iusedtoliveinsanfrancisco · 04/02/2022 14:06

11 course

Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 14:06

@thelittlestrhino

Not really. Both worked out using the previous calculations. It's just "find x".

Allchange2017 · 04/02/2022 14:06

@ChildHeadache

It's 38.

Check no. Of bananas, number of sides and time on clock. And remember bodmas.

This
thelittlestrhino · 04/02/2022 14:04

[quote Itsalmostanaccessory]@ThumbWitchesAbroad

But how do you know you're meant to count the sides?
It works by counting the sides. But they all also work by assigning each shape with the same value.
They haven't shown you which it is. They could have done in the second line by removing the square and the answer would tell us if the square was 4 or 5. They haven't told us.

You cant assume in maths. They haven't given enough information. So it could be both 35 or 38. Both work. You cant give one single answer.[/quote]
Yet you are clearly assuming that you know what the value of bananas and clocks are in the final calculation. There is not enough in the picture to conclude that if the clock shows 3 o'clock it has a value of 3 then having a time of 2 o'clock means it must have a value of 2. Likewise with the bananas. Both assumptions.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 04/02/2022 14:03

@StrongSunglasses

It isnt just the shapes.
The number on the clock is different.
The number of bananas is different.

You were taught wrong or dont remember. Maths has been the same for many centuries. Multiply first. It will never be 165.

GivenchyDahhling · 04/02/2022 14:02

The idea that some posters think order of operations in arithmetic is some kind of new thing in maths has me 😳

If I’m being generous, I think some confusion comes from the commutative nature of addition/subtraction and multiplication/division. So BIDMAS/BODMAS/PEDMAS or whatever you want to call it is not a “strict” order as division and multiplication are an equal pair, as are addition and subtraction, so in those cases you read left to right rather than rigidly performing division before multiplication.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 04/02/2022 14:02

@stuckasastuckthing

Also think 38

(Time is 2 rather than 3; 3 bananas rather than 4; 11 sides on the combined shapes rather than 15)

So 2 + 3 + (3x11) = 38

That's how I make it (look at clock face, count bananas, count sides of figures).
OfstedOffred · 04/02/2022 14:02

...38

Swipe left for the next trending thread