Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the Bank of England for real here?

238 replies

TheWhalrus · 04/02/2022 12:29

So, just now the Bank of England announces that to combat inflation, employers should be looking to not increase staff salaries (www.theguardian.com/business/2022/feb/04/bank-of-england-boss-calls-for-wage-restraint-to-help-control-inflation). So at a time of massive inflation, we're apparently not supposed to be trying to earn more or aspiring for a higher salary in order to maintain our own living standards? Rather the Bank of England expects us to knuckle down and accept these circumstances because they can't control inflation.

Has this guy (annual salary £575,538) been smoking something? Or does he really have no grasp at all of reality?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 04/02/2022 17:19

[quote bindud]@MarshaBradyo

are you saying QE has not caused an issue with asset inflation? That was my point. [/quote]
Not really, just asking a direct question.

I think the economic shock of the pandemic has been huge but I wouldn’t know where to start in terms of managing that. So if people on thread have good ideas on how then I’m interested in hearing more.

bindud · 04/02/2022 17:13

@MarshaBradyo

are you saying QE has not caused an issue with asset inflation? That was my point.

bindud · 04/02/2022 17:12

I don't think hirings at that level are decided via interviews.

Clearly I was being facetious!

The answer why I think he's worth his money is that I worked for many years in the industry that has been supervised by the PRA under his command (previous job), and I rate them very highly.

He was a favourite for the role because of the above but my comment was referring to past employment.

Regarding his new job, I have read through the economic affairs committee report and evidence presented to the house of lords in July 2021 (when it was obvious to everyone that high inflation times are knocking on the door), and the Bank of England has a very clear, rational and tangible position on the matter, despite being faced with very difficult circumstances.

Yes a difficult time to take on the role.
However in November the BOE gave the impression it would act in one way but didn't. Their growth forecasts have been consistently wrong & they have underestimated inflation. That is not a good performance in my book although you can disagree.

The comment about pay rises was a stupid thing to say as it's bad PR.

MarshaBradyo · 04/02/2022 17:02

@bindud

Cheap money has created a massive problem.

Exactly QE has created this mess

The pandemic has cost an absolute fortune - how would you deal with it if different to this?

Ie in terms of BoE actions

Gowithme · 04/02/2022 17:00

What a dick.

bindud · 04/02/2022 16:59

Cheap money has created a massive problem.

Exactly QE has created this mess

bindud · 04/02/2022 16:56

Not really, no. A better option would be never to have propped up insanely expensive house prices in the first place, but it's a bit late for that now

yep

Puzzledandpissedoff · 04/02/2022 16:55

So the interest rates on peasants' mortgages going up to 7%-8%, and mass defaults on consumer loans is a better option?

Not really, no. A better option would be never to have propped up insanely expensive house prices in the first place, but it's a bit late for that now

It's just a pity some didnt think of the longer term consequences when they were shouting about "the market being RED HOT round here", but while I feel it for those who have no choice but to move house, it seems a bit silly to buy at near-zero interest rates and somehow hope that'll never change

Meandthesky · 04/02/2022 16:53

Well perhaps people on over £500k a year can afford for their normally massive pay rises not to keep pace with inflation but the majority of people can’t, especially those an already low incomes.

It’s implying it will be all our fault for asking for enough money to pay our bills and keep a roof over our heads. Rather than blaming the government and their rich mates

forinborin · 04/02/2022 16:41

@Changedmane

Forinborin I would argue 1) it feeds into the rich, white men telling poor people what sacrifices they will have to make whilst earning a fortune narrative (that is enraging the population- see Boris thread, or Sunak thread or antiwork on reddit) 2) on the worst possible day when people have been informed of price rises 3) in the worst possible way whilst being tone deaf to the fact that many haven’t had payrises thanks to austerity for years I don’t think the B of E intended offence to be fair. But, if people are clearly offended by this- that’s the time to apologise for offense caused. They aren’t annoyed at fiscal policy they are annoyed at the patronising, talking down tone- you greedy plebs better not ask for more- back to your workhouses while billions of money has been squandered. We don’t want to hear a very rich person tell us how greedy and grabby we are after we have suffered through austerity/covid/Brexit/ now the energy crisis. That is the message people have taken from this -whether it was intended or not-
My point is that the anger is completely mistargeted in this case. And the author of the comment is hardly very rich on par with Sunak etc - very well paid, yes, but still an employed worker.
Changedmane · 04/02/2022 16:40

There we go Grin

Is the Bank of England for real here?
Is the Bank of England for real here?
MarshaBradyo · 04/02/2022 16:38

@forinborin

Trouble is, they know the other way to restrict inflation is to raise interest rates and they'd rather not do that because of the sh1tshow it could cause, so it's back to "suck it up, peasants" Hmm, so the interest rates on peasants' mortgages going up to 7%-8%, and mass defaults on consumer loans is a better option?
It doesn’t sound great to me either
forinborin · 04/02/2022 16:35

Trouble is, they know the other way to restrict inflation is to raise interest rates and they'd rather not do that because of the sh1tshow it could cause, so it's back to "suck it up, peasants"
Hmm, so the interest rates on peasants' mortgages going up to 7%-8%, and mass defaults on consumer loans is a better option?

ambushedbywine · 04/02/2022 16:25

I saw this and was raging. Parents should just tell their kids don’t worry that the house is cold and you’re hungry, at least mummy and daddy’s wages are contributing to inflation. Unbelievable

Changedmane · 04/02/2022 16:23

Forinborin I would argue 1) it feeds into the rich, white men telling poor people what sacrifices they will have to make whilst earning a fortune narrative (that is enraging the population- see Boris thread, or Sunak thread or antiwork on reddit)
2) on the worst possible day when people have been informed of price rises
3) in the worst possible way whilst being tone deaf to the fact that many haven’t had payrises thanks to austerity for years
I don’t think the B of E intended offence to be fair. But, if people are clearly offended by this- that’s the time to apologise for offense caused. They aren’t annoyed at fiscal policy they are annoyed at the patronising, talking down tone- you greedy plebs better not ask for more- back to your workhouses while billions of money has been squandered. We don’t want to hear a very rich person tell us how greedy and grabby we are after we have suffered through austerity/covid/Brexit/ now the energy crisis. That is the message people have taken from this -whether it was intended or not-

Puzzledandpissedoff · 04/02/2022 16:17

If there is too uch spare money floating about the economy try stop printing it you utter hypocritical shower of shites?!

Ah, but that's passed off as "quantitative easing" - aka the economics of the madhouse

Trouble is, they know the other way to restrict inflation is to raise interest rates and they'd rather not do that because of the sh1tshow it could cause, so it's back to "suck it up, peasants"

forinborin · 04/02/2022 15:58

[quote Porfre]@forinborin

I think people are venting on this thread because the Bank of Englan have announced a dumbass statement that people shouldn't ask for a pay rise.

I'm sure if the an NHS spokesperson or a councillor came out with a similar statement there would be plenty of threads pulling them apart.

What with Sunaks faux " I feel your pain".

The £200 rebate that's seems to be loan you cant opt out of, and all the other crap this week I'm not surprised people are venting or expressing their disgust at this announcement.

Especially when the Bank of England's monetary policy has directly contributed to the cost of living crisis.[/quote]
I can understand, and believe me as a single parent household I am not overly excited about what is to come either.

My point is that getting angry at this statement is somewhat similar to getting angry at a doctor who suggests that a type-2 diabetic patient limits sugar consumption. And then bringing in the doctor's salary as an argument - "of course, the doctor is paid well so can afford to eat as much sugar as he wants!"

BigGreen · 04/02/2022 15:54

Asset princes!! Whoops, should be asset prices

BigGreen · 04/02/2022 15:54

When I say 'printing money' I mean creating new central bank reserves that are used to buy UK government bonds in Quantitative Easing (which is what has put asset princes up and massively benefitted the wealthiest in society to the detriment of others). article here.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 04/02/2022 15:51

Cheap money has created a massive problem.

Traditionally, the way to control inflation is to get positive real interest rates (base rate above inflation). However, if they got base rate up to a realistic level, say 3.5%, mortgage rates would double and triple and we would have a massive crash.

So, they are talking about controlling wages. They can do it (for a while) in the public sector, but it won’t wash in the private sector, where there is plenty of bargaining power.

And that means a further brain drain from public sector to private sector, and an eventual crash anyway (they can’t duck interest rates forever).

Cheap money is a continual tax on wage earners and a payment to those with assets (houses and stocks).

That road is rapidly running out.

Brainwave89 · 04/02/2022 15:36

The other thing that tends to go with this higher inflation levels is industrial strife. The first to be hit will be those in the public sector where HMG looks to hold back costs by limiting wage rises to 2%- when inflation is 7% you will lose ground really quickly. Trust me there is trouble ahead.

Porfre · 04/02/2022 15:29

@forinborin

I think people are venting on this thread because the Bank of Englan have announced a dumbass statement that people shouldn't ask for a pay rise.

I'm sure if the an NHS spokesperson or a councillor came out with a similar statement there would be plenty of threads pulling them apart.

What with Sunaks faux " I feel your pain".

The £200 rebate that's seems to be loan you cant opt out of, and all the other crap this week I'm not surprised people are venting or expressing their disgust at this announcement.

Especially when the Bank of England's monetary policy has directly contributed to the cost of living crisis.

forinborin · 04/02/2022 15:23

Reading the article- they don't directly create most of the money but their policies influence the amount that can be created.
Indirectly, yes, through influencing appetites for borrowing and lending. It does not have an immediate effect though, and there are other important influencing factors (like government spending, tax policy etc etc).

mumda · 04/02/2022 15:21

ultra insanely low interest rates indicate the bank of england are playing a very bizarre game.
Print money.
Inflate house prices with silly cheap lending so people are so massively in debt no one can afford for house prices to drop.

Porfre · 04/02/2022 15:11

[quote forinborin]@Porfre
The Bank of England does not print money. There is a good article linked by a previous poster about the new money creation in the modern economy.

Their policies, indeed, are influenced by the government decisions on spending and borrowing. Strangely, I don't hear the same outrage against the NHS, or local councils, who are in a similar position.

Andrew Bailey is in his post for just over a year. He has been the head of the PRA before for 7 years and yes, has done a stellar job there.[/quote]
Reading the article- they don't directly create most of the money but their policies influence the amount that can be created.

Swipe left for the next trending thread