Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the Bank of England for real here?

238 replies

TheWhalrus · 04/02/2022 12:29

So, just now the Bank of England announces that to combat inflation, employers should be looking to not increase staff salaries (www.theguardian.com/business/2022/feb/04/bank-of-england-boss-calls-for-wage-restraint-to-help-control-inflation). So at a time of massive inflation, we're apparently not supposed to be trying to earn more or aspiring for a higher salary in order to maintain our own living standards? Rather the Bank of England expects us to knuckle down and accept these circumstances because they can't control inflation.

Has this guy (annual salary £575,538) been smoking something? Or does he really have no grasp at all of reality?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HootOwl · 07/02/2022 00:13

@bindud

Yep. Sneaky way of introducing a new tax that will also go up and up. When this was what NI was meant to cover?

I agree with that, it will be like VAT, permanent.

Start taxing those with CAPITAL. It's not about earnings

Absolutely, this is the major problem.

Yep. Income tax was amso apparently temporary, to fund the Napoleonic war! Yet still here...

Once a tax is introduced it won't go away, ever. It will only go up. Gordon Brown said the NI hike he did would "fix the NHS once and for all". 😂😂😂 Everyone with a brain knew this was a lie. And here we are again.

HootOwl · 07/02/2022 00:11

@bindud

So yeah, like with Brexit, the scale of this damage is a self-inflicted wound. And people are right to point it out and say, why should I or my children be the ones paying when I never agreed with this strategy in the first place, because all of the epidemilogical evidence at the time said it was madness?

Imo it's fruitless, it's happened & it's done. No amount of moaning about paying for it will stop you paying for it.

True. But we're still right to have lost all sympathy for those that did. And stop voting for policies that would help them (to our own detriment). That goodwill is gone and won't be back.
bindud · 06/02/2022 10:36

Also the tax band freezes will reduce take home pay.

bindud · 06/02/2022 09:14

So yeah, like with Brexit, the scale of this damage is a self-inflicted wound. And people are right to point it out and say, why should I or my children be the ones paying when I never agreed with this strategy in the first place, because all of the epidemilogical evidence at the time said it was madness?

Imo it's fruitless, it's happened & it's done. No amount of moaning about paying for it will stop you paying for it.

bindud · 06/02/2022 09:12

Yep. Sneaky way of introducing a new tax that will also go up and up. When this was what NI was meant to cover?

I agree with that, it will be like VAT, permanent.

Start taxing those with CAPITAL. It's not about earnings

Absolutely, this is the major problem.

bindud · 06/02/2022 09:08

Lol. Boris wants to keep his job. I wouldn't be looking to him for economic advice if I was you!

That's not the point I was making with my post! The point was if Boris with the week he is having can criticise you & make you the headline it's a PR blunder.

HootOwl · 06/02/2022 00:00

[quote ParsleySageRosemary]Oh of course political jobs for 500k + are subject to much more rigorous checks than your average TA or teacher or care assistant, and are not at all limited to only the most very capable people who happen to have been born into high places or possess 'appropriate' social links.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2021/nov/08/ministers-chose-tory-peer-as-independent-recruiter-for-major-job[/quote]
Yeah that's disgusting. Not aware of any evidence that this happen in the case of AL but happy to be corrected?

As I said, insane people voted for a Government run by Boris Johnson, proven liar and moral desert. What did they expect to happen?! 🤣

HootOwl · 05/02/2022 23:51

You can't change geopolitical factors as a small country.

You could choose not to shoot yourself in the foot so that aby prospect of mitigating them is unavailable, however.

I guess it's a case of you reap what you sow.

I hope all of the "we knew what we were voting for" nutters are happy now.

HootOwl · 05/02/2022 23:48

@Jaxhog

Yes, but if everyone's salary goes up, then so will inflation. That's what happened in the 1970s when inflation hit 17+%
Yep. But this is imported inflation. So the policy response needs to be different.

The BOE can do little about it. The Government needs to improve productivity. And strengthen the £ by showing the UK is a stable place to do business etc.

Oh....

Brexit voters 👀👀

Jaxhog · 05/02/2022 23:35

Yes, but if everyone's salary goes up, then so will inflation. That's what happened in the 1970s when inflation hit 17+%

ParsleySageRosemary · 05/02/2022 23:31

Oh of course political jobs for 500k + are subject to much more rigorous checks than your average TA or teacher or care assistant, and are not at all limited to only the most very capable people who happen to have been born into high places or possess 'appropriate' social links.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2021/nov/08/ministers-chose-tory-peer-as-independent-recruiter-for-major-job

HootOwl · 05/02/2022 22:55

@Puzzledandpissedoff

You and the other poster who seemed to think there are no interviews for roles at this level ...

Why on earth would I imagine there were no interviews or "homework" done?
And how on earth does that negate the issue of political interference in such matters?

People were saying there was no interview process to select the best candidate on merit. Implying the Government simply "appoints" somebody. That is not how it works. I don't always agree with the outcomes at senior levels, but there IS a process and there are interviews with qualified people (not politicians 😂😂😂😂) for senior, technical roles. I was correcting in inaccurate assertion that people in these roles are just "appointed" by Govt with no interview or analysis of skills and experience by independent people: they are not.
HootOwl · 05/02/2022 22:51

Btw I am not saying I agree with the AL stance on payrises, at all. I just think many posts are attacking the wrong target.

BJ said "we want wages to rise", but he has no control over what private companies do. So, all public sector employees should now be insisting on 7% increase this year as a minimum or refuse to work, now the pay freeze is ending. That os not a payrise, just preventing a paycut.

He said "we have no control what private companies do". Ok. But you have control over public sector pay. So raise that at least on line with inflation then because anything less is a pay cut and a kick in the teeth.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/02/2022 22:49

You and the other poster who seemed to think there are no interviews for roles at this level ...

Why on earth would I imagine there were no interviews or "homework" done?
And how on earth does that negate the issue of political interference in such matters?

HootOwl · 05/02/2022 22:44

@Puzzledandpissedoff

He's not a banker, he's a civil servant

Nominally, yes; the Governors also appointed by the Chancellor of the Exchequer - in other words yet another political appointment

All senior Civil Service posts are by definition appointed by the Government?! Obviously. You and the other poster who seemed to think there are no interviews for roles at this level are clearly nowhere near these processes and have no idea how they work. I'm not big fan of AL as it happens but he went through a rigorous process to get that job. You think people appoint you on £575k without doing any homework or interviews or challenging you first? Dreamland.
HootOwl · 05/02/2022 22:41

@bindud

Plus it's deflection, as I've repeatedly said the economy was not in good shape before covid & tax hikes were inevitable.
Blame the Brexit voters for that.

Your comments at @vickyc90 are disingenuous. She doesn't have to say "given the Government's lockdown strategy" what would have had less catastrophic, obvious results later (now). She is perfectly entitled to say that the Government should have a) closed borders until we knew what we were dealing with (not "oh sorry, Boris is on holiday with Carrie so can't go to Cobra meetings" 😒😆🙈), then protected the vulnerable and carehomes and fewer people would have died AND the economy wouldn't be so fucked. The evidence was there at the start. Many people (including me) said this and were shouted down.

So yeah, like with Brexit, the scale of this damage is a self-inflicted wound. And people are right to point it out and say, why should I or my children be the ones paying when I never agreed with this strategy in the first place, because all of the epidemilogical evidence at the time said it was madness?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/02/2022 22:31

He's not a banker, he's a civil servant

Nominally, yes; the Governors also appointed by the Chancellor of the Exchequer - in other words yet another political appointment

HootOwl · 05/02/2022 22:07

@bindud

The bill’s arriving now, no point shooting the messenger.

The bill was coming before Covid. The tax rises were inevitable with the ageing population, the state of the NHS & social care. And let's not forget Brexit.

The new h&s levy won't cut it & I expect it will increase.

Yep. Sneaky way of introducing a new tax that will also go up and up. When this was what NI was meant to cover?

Previous generations spent all of the windfalls, enjoyed the dividends in their defined benefit pension funds, while cutting public services to the bone. And then to fund those pensions, on top of the financial crisis and recession and pandemic, has meant very low salary growth for those working.

Companies will have to be forced to increase salaries to a workable level. Even an inflationary increase this year won't cut if after 10 years of accumulated inflation and wage stagnation. Usually when going into a period of economic hardship there has been a boom beforehand so people have had a chance to save and improve their situations beforehand. Not this time.

It is PAYE workers being screwed over again and again because there's no excape for them while the self employed and (even small) business owners get taxed SO much less. A level playing field must come now. Employees have already reached the limit of how much they can be squeezed.

It is taxes on businesses and capital gains tax, dividend tax that need to go up. Not another payroll tax, or another tax on employee pensions. They do this because it's easy, the easy targets. People need to write to their MPs. If they get enough complaints then they get scared they won't be re-elected and they speak up. It's the only way.

Ask them why an employee gives up 32% of income at basic tax rate level, or 41% with student loan on top. Still on an under-average income. Why? When capital gains tax is 20%? Dividend tax rates start at 7.5%.

This is what distorts the economy the most atm. House prices are a problem but a red herring if you want change. Start taxing those with CAPITAL. It's not about earnings. And it doesn't need to be a wealth tax like they had in France and other countries which is totally unworkable and includes the value of people's homes who have no actual money and makes people homeless. Just raise capitals gains tax and dividends taxes to the rates of income taxes. The mechanism is there already.

Of course our current Government - and especially Sunak!!!! - would never contemplate this.

jimmyjammy001 · 05/02/2022 22:01

Why on earth should the public do his job for him and not ask for pay rises to control inflation, he has had ample opportunity to control inflation, but instead he has been praying that inflation is 'transitory' and hoping it will just go away whilst everyone else said it wouldn't

ParsleySageRosemary · 05/02/2022 21:53

What do you expect from the hopelessly corrupt banking sector? Morals? Caring about people and fluffy-wuffy bunnies?

forinborin · 05/02/2022 21:20

@Changedmane

Let me risk a kicking by bravely jumping into the fray to answer “what is yoyr better suggestion?”

Say nothing. Let it be known in business magazines to the leaders of industry what you need to happen-don’t worry they got the memo years ago during which time people haven’t had payrises. Get a clue - telling the average person in the street to not ask was foolishness that riled up a huge amount of people for no reason.
Use your superior experience , skills and intellect to not kick people in the guts on the same day huge increases in energy prices happen. Oh and tax the massive companies not currently paying tax.

Well, I think, it has not been aimed at the average person, or even the average employer. I think it was a message to the government, made as clearly and as publicly as possible without being accused of meddling in politics, not to resort to short-term popular measures such as an emergency increase in the min wage, for example (or some equivalent). Well, it is my reading of the situation.
forinborin · 05/02/2022 21:15

@Iwonderifiwonderwhy

Yanbu. Incredibly tasteless coming from a banker especially one on his salary.

Bank salaries and bonus structure are a huge part of why houses are so expensive in the UK. I’d suggest banks stop paying crazy salaries but everyone else should do what they want.

He's not a banker, he's a civil servant. And actually turned down his bonus last year.
Iggly · 05/02/2022 20:04

The thing to remember that the people on excessively high salaries are not special. They’re just ordinary human beings who’ve ended up on that path. I’ve met many people on six figure salaries and used to be intimidated but then a light bulb went off and I realised that yes they may “know” more things in certain areas, but given equal opportunities, so may others could take their place.

Iggly · 05/02/2022 20:00

Skills, specialist knowledge and training, qualifications, experience, intellectual ability

The ones who claim that is the case are also the ones who benefit from such claims.

The disparity is too big.

Postdatedpandemic · 05/02/2022 19:43

Hey, it is the UK we like to keep the income inequality as high as possible.

BoE and the Government have choices; do they keep the rich happy, do they keep the poor fed, do they acknowledge the limits to growth, do they want to be re-elected in a couple of years. You can't meet all of these choices.

Swipe left for the next trending thread