Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle & upper class more money savvy than most?

167 replies

Southerngal5 · 04/02/2022 11:37

DC in very mc school with very affluent parents... The talk non stop is about energy bills, bragging about getting free toys on Facebook groups (but they sell their stuff😉) their dc wear second hand clothes... Is this just my area? Forgot to mention they gave an obsession with Aldi & Lidl...

OP posts:
feb21 · 04/02/2022 12:58

I don't know about any correlation to class. But we're lucky enough to be pretty well off. I also like frugality in its place but we'll splurge on expensive holidays.

My brother is on minimum wage and is clearly far better than me at frugality, out of necessity. He doesn't have a choice so it's not the same. It's more that I like a bargain so I'll typically buy stuff in the sale, or wait until they send me a discount code. And use cash back websites etc.

I've only ever bought one new school blazer and, like the other parents, love the second hand uniform shop. The ones at our private schools have been highly popular and the proceeds go back to school. There's definitely a pride in not having to buy new.

I think the differentiating purchase may be cars, if the post was perhaps referring to people distinguishing between "new" and "old" money. There's the less well off school parents in their flashy cars with personalised plates and some of the wealthy ones in battered old Volvos. Not all, but I'd say that's one of the main areas for ostentatious consumption.

MorrisZapp · 04/02/2022 12:54

I get loads in charity shops because I love it, and ebay too. I buy pyjamas from Primark and most of DS's clothes are from H&M. I take sandwiches because that's what I like. None of this is self denial, it's what I prefer. I love shopping but I hate waste, my friends are all like this too.

Wouldn't enter my mind to pay a hundred quid for a polyester blouse in eg Hush or similar middle class MN approved shop unless I absolutely loved it and it couldn't be found elsewhere.

This thread is odd.

seekinglondonlife · 04/02/2022 12:54

I think this generalisation is more applicable to those who are solidly MC, rather than new money. If anyone remembers the very original series of Rich House Poor House, the rich family were landed gentry, old money types. They often had large houses, filled with antique furniture, but it was all understated. The children from these families used to love going to the 'poor' family homes because "ooooh look, there's a TV in every room!" and they had games consoles. The rich families didn't overly struggle on the budget, because they knew how to manage very well and I suppose they knew it was only going to be for a week. (Although one family went foraging for food to save money and found a plum tree for lunch 😁)
The new money 'rich' homes are now all flashy and crushed grey velvet and they whinge about not having their regular spa treatments and expensive alcohol.

UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 12:54

This is just another way the poor get hit twice. It is so much easier (in a multitude of ways) to get bargains and deals when you aren't poor.

Nothingfallingdowntoday · 04/02/2022 12:54

Money breeds money.

Once you even have a little spare it’s easier to make choices that save in the longer term eg buying in bulk, buying for the future when it’s a good price, buying better to last.

I don’t think it’s a class thing but it is more difficult when you are hand to mouth.

CraftyGin · 04/02/2022 12:50

My kids would never dream of shopping for clothes in anything other than a charity shop (except for underwear, obs).

Goldenbear · 04/02/2022 12:50

It is not down to shopping at Lidl, if you're wealthy you have proper time to manage your investment portfolio- you then still get to shop at Waitrose and waste money if you want to. The idea that wealthy people don't waste money is simply not true. I am on a WhatsApp group that is specific to the locality and has quite a few people on their who are quite well off, they always giving away tickets for stuff they can no longer go to, like tickets to see a comedian or for an exhibition etc. So about £40 worth of tickets to anyone that wants them. In theory that is pretty wasteful and it is not exactly counting the pennies.

About10thusername · 04/02/2022 12:50

I think the middle classes have more of a range of things to spend their money on than those who are struggling. Such as holidays, fancy stuff for expensive hobbies (...usually cycling), building work, mortgage, etc etc. So saving money on things like second hand toys and cheaper food is an easy 'sacrifice'.
('If we do all our shopping in Aldi instead of Waitrose, after 3 months we would have saved enough money for a weekend in Paris / get the living room redecorated / an outdoor pizza oven...')

Southerngal5 · 04/02/2022 12:49

@Datada

I think it's a business type of mindset, which anyone can have for cutting costs. There probably is a trend now, to show off frugality, there are websites on this. I think if a person is working long hours in a low paid job, they won't have time for a lot of mental arithmetic and bargain hunting. Budgeting and frugality do take quite a bit of time and energy to do. Second hand shopping is pot luck and you can actually still spend quite a lot if done regularly. So frugality is easier for the middles and uppers.
That's actually a very good analogy.. This particular group of mums are sahm & had previously had high powered jobs, it's almost like they run their homes as buidnesses... No expense will be spared on the children's education or extracurriculars, holidays, theatre etc... It's the day to day living & household expenses where they hold back.. I'm definitely going to start making notes as I'm terrible & would love a holiday this year
OP posts:
RavenclawDiadem · 04/02/2022 12:49

When you are not watching every penny you are comfortable in your own skin. Nothing to prove to anyone. No "fear" that someone is going to think you're struggling for money or judge your kids being poorly turned out. Your middle class mums have no issues with NCT second hand sales or bargains from the charity shop. Happy to share bags of handmedowns at the school gates, use discount codes, coupons.

Less affluent parents would prefer new to second hand. Second hand is dirty, nasty, smelly. Branded goods in their supermarket trolley prove to anyone who might be looking that they can afford "the best". Similarly the leased car on the driveway.

Massive generalisations of course but having moved from an area with high rates of unemployment and poverty to a much more affluent area, the difference is stark. SIL, who has never had much money sloshing around, won't even donate to a charity shop in case someone sees her going in. Her daughter refuses to shop on sale rails or use discount codes because "that's for povs". It's a really odd way of thinking and I can't get my head around it.

Mreggsworth · 04/02/2022 12:48

My parents in law are very money savvy. Neither of them have ever had jobs paying over 20k, I honestly dont know how but they managed it even writing it down it doesnt seem to add up to me.

They bought some run down flats when there was a property price crash, rented them out for years, sold them, had some very small investment/involvement in friends/families small businesses that paid off. They will go shop to shop doing price comparisons to make sure they get cheapest deal, they'll massively bulk buy items in sale. They change providers constantly. Did lots of little extra earners e.g car boot sales, selling things on Ebay, he would hire himself out as a man with a van on evenings/ weekends occasionally. She would occasionally help a friends business with deliveries.

They paid off their mortgage at 40, now in their late 50s, have a holiday home, range rover, 2 boats, and a few hundred thousand in the bank and both will have very generous civil service pensions.

Me and my partner make quite a bit more than did, but are no where near savvy enough (or can be bothered to live our lives that way) to maximize our earnings that much. (We would also never be able to buy multiple flats these days).

I dont think it's a class thing personally, just some are better at it than others. If you are completely skint however you dont have the luxary of being savvy and forward thinking, you tend to have to do whst it takes to tackle things in the now, like bulk buying wouldnt be an option, or small investments.

Maybe it's not a class thing but a job thing, perhaps if someones career involves strategy and maximising profit, making plans etc they adopt that in their own lives too.

KarenTheGammonRemoaner · 04/02/2022 12:47

@Southerngal5

My problem is little luxuries eg I like going for a coffee with said mums to the local Costa maybe once a week or fortnight... A coffee date was mentioned this morning & then the chief (& probably the most well to do) suggested as the morning were getting brighter & warmer we should bring flasks of tea/coffee to the park & one or two of us could russle up some scones... Other mums enthusiastically agreed & of course said how overpriced costa was anyways....
Since getting a Tassimo I can't have any other coffee :( None is strong enough. I only like strong black coffee and everywhere sells weak coffee like brown water. I have to take flasks of Tassimo with me anywhere now. I'm addicted but I am a total caffeine addict. It costs us £20 a month but it stops me buying coffee out.

I've lived on hardly anything and our income has fluctuated over the years and mine my entire life. My husband and I have had many job changes over the time we've been together so we are both able to manage on very little.

Life is all about being adaptable.

BarbaraofSeville · 04/02/2022 12:46

But it is life changing for many. You can free up thousands of pounds a year by shopping in Aldi not Waitrose, driving a less flash smaller car, shopping around for deals instead of paying full price, taking a picnic to the theme park instead of spending £50 on burger meals for lunch, buying second hand, or simply buying less stuff.

You only have to watch a few episodes of Eat Well for Less or Shop Well for Less to see that there are people who can trim their daily spending by thousands of pounds a year without particularly missing what they cut down on and this frees up money for the big thing they think they can't afford. Obviously that's an extreme example, but there's usually something that most people can do.

MorrisZapp · 04/02/2022 12:43

I can't work out if you'd prefer middle class people to waste their money or be careful with it?

AuntyBumBum · 04/02/2022 12:42

YABU - we're well-off, I've never thought about switching energy providers, am lucky enough not to need to engage with energy prices, and have never heard anyone I know mention it.

Shiningpath · 04/02/2022 12:41

Working class often are working 50-60hrs a week in physically exhausting jobs.

Well that’s a massive generalisation. Clearly doesn’t apply to a lot of GPs, lawyers or accountants who would be very solidly middle class.

peedawg · 04/02/2022 12:40

I don't know, the affluent people I know aren't going to have their life changed because they saved a few thousand pounds shopping at aldi.

Flsh · 04/02/2022 12:40

not surprisingly, people saying it’s not a class thing all also seem to be stating how well off they are

SockFluffInTheBath · 04/02/2022 12:38

@CrinklyCraggy

I think "comfortable" are much happier to talk about being frugal, to see it as a bit of a game almost. A far different thing when you've got no choice.
I pulled a face at that, but I think you’re right. We have the MN 6-figure income but shop in Aldi and drive older cars. We both grew up with not very much and nearly lost everything in the 2008 recession so we don’t like to fritter now. We don’t talk about it with friends, it’s not a game as such but it’s not strictly through necessity either.
Goldenbear · 04/02/2022 12:36

I do know a couple of families like this, my DD's friend's Mum is 'working hard' as she wants the best for her girls, the best being, 'private school' but they have a bit of sad day to day existence, for example, a thin and crispy Aldi pizza was shared amongst 5 of them when DD went for a playdate recently. The girls are 10 so DD took what she thought was one slice but it was three! Needless to say she was starving and she is quite slight and does not have a big appetite but it was made out that her appetite was huge by the Mum! On the other hand, we waste money on meals out quite regularly, we can afford to and have a teenage boy who generally will come out with us if food is involved! We go up to London and visit galleries/theatre but also have the coffees, the dinners. I like the occasional stratch card but I don't conform to the demographic stereotype on this. It is far from my only thing to look forward to. It is easy to pigeon hole people but I really don't think it is a class thing.

seekinglondonlife · 04/02/2022 12:35

My point Ponoka7 is that the wealthier families didn't seem to feel the need to make a show out of presents or events. I remember one birthday party where the whole class was invited, they hired a party bus and then got Dominos delivered. The child was presented with a £500 present. The day must have cost an absolute fortune and the mum was a single parent on benefits. Contrast this with dd's best friend, who both parents are solicitors. Her birthday present was going to see a ballet, as "the tickets are £30 each!".

NotDavidTennant · 04/02/2022 12:33

There's a different mentality depending on where you are on the income ladder.

Driving round to find cheap petrol so that you can afford your gas bill this month is a different kettle of fish to driving round to find cheap petrol so you can have a bit more spending for this year's trip to the Maldives.

People in the first group are going to see that as a horrible experience to avoid wherever possible, whereas people in the second group will see it as a fun challenge,

Xenia · 04/02/2022 12:32

I don't think you can generalise. We live in a very nouveau riche bit of outer London where people like to flash the cash with expensive cars and watches. They tend to be new money and mostly Asian (most people are not white where I live not that that's relevant but it is crazy rich Asians sort of money). We cannot call them working class so they will be middle class. then you get more careful with money even if they have a lot middle class which is probably what I am - happy to spend a fortune on school and university fees but happy to wear the same clothes until they have holes in as it is not important to me. Neither group is worse or better than the other. My older children eg had 100% second hand school uniform (not least because after school fees and a massive mortgage and huge full time childcare bills in the 1980s/90s we did not have a lot of spare money).

Some less well off people are very careful with money and others spend more than they have.
I don't think it is a class thing - most just what your family is like. My parents grew up up being bombed during WWII in the UK and then had rationing and national service in the 1950s - if your parents went through all that then you tend to be quite careful with money.

Mothermorph · 04/02/2022 12:32

I think its easier to talk about savings when it's a choice to whereas people struggling to last til pay day probably aren't talking about their savings and bargains.
The irony is its expensive to be poor. Pre pay meters definitely used to be more expensive for fuel, corner shops and small shops are always more expensive than large out of town supermarkets. It's no good knowing about the bargains in Aldi if you don't have the means to get there.
If you're overdrawn on your bank account you are charged for the overdraft facility and for each day you're overdrawn. If you can't easily get credit you will be limited to loans or brighthouse type companies with extortionate interest rates.

lemongrasstea · 04/02/2022 12:32

The unsaid assumption of your post is that working class (so poor, then) people fritter away all their money on giant TVs and champers then, is that right? Everyone needs to be frugal these days, but to perpetuate this demeaning working class big spenders stereotype is kind of disgusting

Swipe left for the next trending thread