Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle & upper class more money savvy than most?

167 replies

Southerngal5 · 04/02/2022 11:37

DC in very mc school with very affluent parents... The talk non stop is about energy bills, bragging about getting free toys on Facebook groups (but they sell their stuff😉) their dc wear second hand clothes... Is this just my area? Forgot to mention they gave an obsession with Aldi & Lidl...

OP posts:
Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/02/2022 13:51

I have been guilty of this. When the children were younger I worked 3 days a week. I meal planned (from Lidl)everything including after school to minimise expense, took a picnic everywhere, theme parks were from cereal packets. We had some real bargain basement ski holidays driving through France with handed down ski gear, frozen homemade meals and UK supermarket chocolate in the boot to minimise spend in resort. You are right there was an element of challenge to managing it.

ChildHeadache · 04/02/2022 13:50

Your sil may well think its a waste to buy boden and/or shop second hand. In that csse its priorities isn't it? Others would see an M and S picknic as excessive so wouldn't see you as frugal at allwith m ands and boden!! Particulalry those on low income.

Its one of those irregular verbs.

I am frugal/make good choices
They waste money.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 04/02/2022 13:48

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

Not this shit again.
yep
MrsLargeEmbodied · 04/02/2022 13:47

i remember my dd had a idiotic know it all friend who said that poor people are poor because they spend their money on alcohol

JustMarriedBecca · 04/02/2022 13:47

Disagree it's class. My brother and I were raised by the same parents. We have similar incomes, him from working his way up, mine as a several years post graduation professional career (solicitor).
I save money, am conscious of pensions and will shop at Aldi and Lidl.
He will spend hundreds on random stuff he doesn't need because he has money in his pocket.

I personally find living frugally quite a project (done the wedding and baby thing, then the house thing) and find it a bit of a challenge. But we have lots of holidays and I buy Boden for the kids. It's how we choose to spend money.

My SIL (who has substantially less money than we do) would think nothing of a trip to the zoo, £30 on chicken nugget meals and another £20 on toys in the shop. We'd go with them to the zoo, take a M & S picnic and the kids don't expect toys from gift shops. I do think she often seeks to spend more as a status symbol of the fact she can 'keep up' when frankly I couldn't give a shit.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 04/02/2022 13:46

i love a bargain but it doesnt mean i have any savings.

Goldenbear · 04/02/2022 13:41

I agree with that balance is more akin to real life but I do know someone who conforms to that stereotype and I do think there is a problem with being tight not just frugal. When does frugal turn in to tight.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/02/2022 13:39

Not this shit again.

MiddleNameJane · 04/02/2022 13:37

On these threads, a big stereotyped bogeyman always appears: the wealthy, greedy SAHM, selling off her kids' old underwear whilst cackling over the free stuff she's hoovered up off Freecycle while other people are working.

Also the stereotype of the working class Mum who wouldn't dream of buying secondhand ever.

I'm sure these people exist in the extemes, but in my world, I notice that at my DCs' school (mixed demographic) everyone seems to use the secondhand uniform shop. I see parents, including SAHMs donating stuff as well as selling. Donating to the PTA. Giving generous birthday gifts etc. Sure some also love being frugal, but I can't see much wrong with that 🤷🏻‍♀️

RedHelenB · 04/02/2022 13:34

@Southerngal5

DC in very mc school with very affluent parents... The talk non stop is about energy bills, bragging about getting free toys on Facebook groups (but they sell their stuff😉) their dc wear second hand clothes... Is this just my area? Forgot to mention they gave an obsession with Aldi & Lidl...
Think you're describing mumsnet here. Honestly don't get the Aldi/Lidl obsession, co op much better.
Goldenbear · 04/02/2022 13:32

Yes I was thinking that- mind you second most boring conversation at my school gates, Covid, LFs and PCRs.

InisnaBro · 04/02/2022 13:30

@Southerngal5

DC in very mc school with very affluent parents... The talk non stop is about energy bills, bragging about getting free toys on Facebook groups (but they sell their stuff😉) their dc wear second hand clothes... Is this just my area? Forgot to mention they gave an obsession with Aldi & Lidl...
Leaving aside the finances and class stuff, are these people not incredibly dull to be around?

I mean, I'm not interested in my own switch of energy suppliers, far less anyone else's. No one's expecting the school run to be the Algonquin Round Table, but this sounds like the conversational equivalent of watching concrete set.

Goldenbear · 04/02/2022 13:21

The Waitrose shoppers though, they are not all poor are they, with cars bought on HP. So not everyone has to make the food budget sacrifice to go Skiing! Is it really just the ostentatious eating in expensive restaurants- not really. It maybe comforting to tell ourselves this but it is not true!

Iggly · 04/02/2022 13:17

It’s easy to be savvy when you have more money. You have more choices and can do things like buy in bulk, drive to a cheaper supermarket, buy things that will last for longer but cost more upfront.

OrangeShark27 · 04/02/2022 13:15

As well if you have the money you are constantly thinking about saving it, planning how your going to save it etc.

If there's no money to save a lot of the savvy/frugal tips are just day to day realities. Someone who really has no money does a lot of these things but it's not a tip or a trick it's just life.

If your forced to shop in say a charity shop, there's going to be more emotions attached to charity shop clothes, maybe embarrassment, you might not necessarily want people to know you are struggling. When you get a bit more money it's natural to want to spend that on something you can't usually afford like new clothes.

If there's no emotions attached to shopping in charity shops, if its not a forced choice ans everyone already knows your rich then it's much easier to make that decision, and present it as a choice you've made because your savvy and frugal, rather than I had to shop in a charity shop because I had no money.

ElftonWednesday · 04/02/2022 13:14

Also buying stuff second hand is not only frugal but better for the environment. DDs are well into charity shops.

Whammyyammy · 04/02/2022 13:13

I loathe the class system, so don't use it.
Our combined income is circa £90k, no kids. We drive a 7 year old BMW and my husband an 8 year old motor bike. Both owned, no hp etc and we're not expensive.
My husbands mate has a new RR sport and his wife a new audi soft top, both on hp/pcp/never never. Both in low paid jobs, have 2 DC and always moaning they're skint 🤷‍♂️

I don't think I'm savvy, just not lavish

ElftonWednesday · 04/02/2022 13:12

I earn a very good salary and still shop mostly at Aldi because it's better value for money and a better shopping experience. I'm not tight but I'm not keen to spend an extra £50 a week for the privilege of spending an extra half hour going round a massive Sainsbury's with fifty varieties of baked bean or whatever and then spend fucking ages queuing due to their slow-assed checkout staff, slow-assed customers packing and the fact only half the tills are open.

HowlingKale · 04/02/2022 13:12

I agree about the poorer person's treat OrangeShark. Thinking about it, my mum's growing up was the department store tea and scone: pre Costa / post Lyons Tea Rooms era. She was never going to be going away on holiday!

Goldenbear · 04/02/2022 13:12

We don't even have a Home Bargains where I live so everyone must be solidly middle-class!

The trouble is there is a smugness about it which is a bit sad really. I mean I find it embarrassing for someone to lump me in any class category but the MC one, surely the most boring of all classes! I don't conform by playing poker online and liking jewellery as a gift! I'm lucky as DH and I are similar and enjoy spending money on doing stuff not just holidays. We don't bother with education as luckily our DC are naturally very bright - what a relief!

HowlingKale · 04/02/2022 13:08

Don't most people twig they can't afford everything they want and so budget?
Op you sound a bit naive around money up to this point. Not particular to one class but maybe shows that your parents didn't discuss budgeting with you as you grew up?

My parents lived week to week on fluctuating income and I was made aware. So no I don't associate being frugal with being middle class.

OrangeShark27 · 04/02/2022 13:08

It's easy to cut back on your expenses if its going to go towards a fancy holiday. These cost cutting exercises are not going to get you a fancy holiday on their own, but if you have a decent salary to start with it can be enough to tip you over.

These peoples treats are the holidays, the nice houses etc. Whilst a poorers person's treat is the Costa. If you are getting a better treat you can cut out the smaller things, but if you won't get the better treat by cutting out Costa you are just making your life miserable.

Wealthy people will tell themselves that they are Wealthy because they shop in aldi not waitrose, as if the poor haven't thought of that.

Tbh if all these women had high flying jobs and are now sahms it's likely they will have had to make a lot of cut backs in order to become SAHMs and maintain their lifestyle. It's easy to think that you are oh so savvy when you've had to make a lot of basic savings, but it doesn't acknowledge that there is still a large amount of money coming in and they are still spending a lot of money that many people don't have in the first place.

SvartePetter · 04/02/2022 13:04

I get the feeling that it is wrong to be middle class and frugal from some posters. Does the middle class have an obligation to consume?

I'm definitely frugal. I have just put half a tin of corn and half a tin of black beans in the freezer, will probably make something next week. Really try to not waste food. We check all our providers regularly. I've been spending a few weeks to see if I can get some ikea furniture second hand on FB marketplace. I buy clothes from the charity shop.

Today I have also made an additional payment into my pension, and I have been reviewing my investment portfolio. I will also take my kids to the coffee shop after school because we all really enjoy it.

Am I consuming in the wrong way?

seekinglondonlife · 04/02/2022 13:01

In my town shopping in charity shops firmly puts you in the MC bracket, it's cheaper to shop in Primark and Home Bargains.

peedawg · 04/02/2022 12:59

Again you know when the large stately homes were built they were flashy had all the latest technology, it's only later cash poor generations that live up to the mn bs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread