Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle & upper class more money savvy than most?

167 replies

Southerngal5 · 04/02/2022 11:37

DC in very mc school with very affluent parents... The talk non stop is about energy bills, bragging about getting free toys on Facebook groups (but they sell their stuff😉) their dc wear second hand clothes... Is this just my area? Forgot to mention they gave an obsession with Aldi & Lidl...

OP posts:
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 04/02/2022 19:25

I think its not frugality in the sense of having to make ends meet, its prioritisation of spending. It's much easier to prioritise your discretionary spending when you comfortable for money. We have the mythical MN income (and school fees Wink) and I am frugal in some ways. We have second hand furniture and washing machine, the school has a great second hand uniform shop etc. However, it is a luxury sort of frugality - it's being able to prioritise spending to things that matter more and make a difference.

Having a new car or washing machine doesn't matter to me, they won't particularly improve my life. Paying off the mortgage a couple of years early will make a big difference so I am going to chose the latter.
However, if I lived in rented accommodation with no prospect of ever being able to buy a property and knowing that savings above a certain amount would impact my income then I might be more inclined to buy stuff because that is what would have the biggest positive impact on my life.

Luxury frugality is a bit of a game for reasonably well off people where they can challenge themselves to make sensible choices to free up cash for other things. We do it because we can and we want to so it doesn't feel painful - to have to live watching every penny because you have no other choice is anything but fun.

Ionlydomassiveones · 04/02/2022 18:51

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Camomila · 04/02/2022 18:44

I never understand why foods that are cheap basics in their country of origin, see also hummus, falafel, anchovies or pasta dishes like spaghetti puttanesca that are eaten by everyone in their countries of origin are seen as 'aspirational' in the UK.

I suppose it's because the ingredients don't grow well here so we are not as used to them. It works both ways, I was chatting to a friend in Italy once who I'm sure knows three or four ways to cook an aubergine but she'd never tried a parsnip.

peedawg · 04/02/2022 18:35

@OhWhyNot I wouldn't be shocked I used to work at a private school, but you're right it is mind blowing.

Monopolyiscrap · 04/02/2022 17:14

@Porcupineintherough I hadnt realised you meant that. Yes poverty carries a lot of stigma and shame with it and lots of people will thus avoid anything associated with poverty.

OhWhyNot · 04/02/2022 16:46

It’s very competitive cutting back and savings a little here and there to pay for school fees Hmm

You would be shocked how many really struggle sending their children to fee paying schools (eye roll x 1000)

Many have the time to do this ….

Porcupineintherough · 04/02/2022 16:40

@Monopolyiscrap I mean quite simply that some people dont do second hand. Second hand carries a stigma with it in some people's eyes, and some people can feel judged for not buying new - and some people are judged more harshly than others for not being able to afford new stuff, in the same way they are judged for their clothes or having scruffy kids. It's really complicated actually, depends on your ethos, the ethos you were brought up with, your own social standing. And money, of course.

Monopolyiscrap · 04/02/2022 16:22

I hate the white supremacy system that means racism is used to try and keep people in their place. I shall just opt out of it then?
Incredible naivety.

mewkins · 04/02/2022 16:10

@Whammyyammy

I loathe the class system, so don't use it. Our combined income is circa £90k, no kids. We drive a 7 year old BMW and my husband an 8 year old motor bike. Both owned, no hp etc and we're not expensive. My husbands mate has a new RR sport and his wife a new audi soft top, both on hp/pcp/never never. Both in low paid jobs, have 2 DC and always moaning they're skint 🤷‍♂️

I don't think I'm savvy, just not lavish

I like this approach. I'm opting not to use the class system too. It's bollocks and designed to keep people in their place.
Monopolyiscrap · 04/02/2022 15:54

I am better off than I used to be, though still working class. I take a flask of tea and picnic food when out and about.
But when I was totally skint I would treat myself to a coffee in a cafe occasionally. Not because I was stupid, but that was a big treat. I couldn't afford going out for a meal never mind holidays. So a coffee in a cafe it was.

Monopolyiscrap · 04/02/2022 15:50

@Porcupineintherough what are you talking about buying second or third hand? White goods are not good value bought second hand. Plenty of people buy second-hand furniture on eBay or similar and plenty of working-class people buy second-hand furniture from charity shops. Or do you just mean working-class people don't tend to be at the auction houses?

ChildHeadache · 04/02/2022 15:50

Yes so wc children cant "delay gratification" 🙄... wheras their drink or food out my be their little treat in the week as they arent going skiing/£250 meal /other expensive thing.

Obviously those on 60k have considerably more money than those on 20k.

Its the "oh maybe its me? Im just so good at this while they just spend" or lack of understanding that is irritating. And looking down on others that don't have their budget.

So far we have m/c frugal people buying in boden/ m and s lunches/ £250 meals out/ski trips etc. Absolutely no problem with those but is not on to then look down on how those who cant afford that spend their money

LouLou198 · 04/02/2022 15:29

No idea what class I am, but we both are lucky to have reasonably paid jobs. We have a nice home, drive nice cars and go on luxury holidays. Day to day though we are very frugal, and don't "fritter" money away. My youngest wears hand me downs from my eldest, we make the most of Clubcard vouchers for days out, where we will take a picnic rather than buy food when out. Same at work, we take our own lunches and dh takes a travel mug of coffee in a morning rather than using the Costa that others do.

Porfre · 04/02/2022 15:07

@Furbulousnous

There’s no-one more savvy than WC parents on a low income budget. No-one.
Agree
familychallenge · 04/02/2022 15:02

I think as many have said it's easier to be frugal if you have resources and also if it's something of a game, ie not essential to your survival. I'm a big buyer in bulk when things are cheap and have the resources to store them. I also have a well equipped kitchen and if I experiment with something cheap to cook and it's a disaster I can still feed us.

I think the no waste mindset is a good one if you can get into it. I'm happy to spend money on things I value, but also try not to spend it on things that have little value to me.

But when you have to be relentlessly frugal to get by it's very wearing.

onlychildhamster · 04/02/2022 14:59

@Porfre surely it should be based on percentages rather than actual amount saved. Rule of thumb is to save 20% of after tax income (though of course it's way way easier for high income people and almost impossible for poor people). I try to aim for 25% to put into mortgage overpayments.

Porcupineintherough · 04/02/2022 14:56

@Furbulousnous

Buy cheap, buy twice maybe true but there are plenty of people who can only afford the cheap.
And plenty of people that prefer cheap brand new over quality second/third hand.
Porfre · 04/02/2022 14:54

I think you mean people who earn more generally have more left over after their bill's are paid, but not always.

I'm not sure how you can say someone who earns 17k a year and manages is less money savvy than someone who earns 60k and manages to save 2k a year.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 04/02/2022 14:52

@HowlingKale

Martin Lewis is a bit of a social hero in my book. He actually does good in the world.
More than a bit of a social hero, the guy is a complete hero!

The work he does on financial literacy is amazing, he saves so many people so much money and tries very hard to hold the government to account. His campaigns have on several occasions resulted in real changes that have improved lives.

He also does much less high profile work on childhood bereavement.

The fact that he hasn't been knighted yet is disgraceful.

Itsnotdeep · 04/02/2022 14:50

ime the poorest families I know are the best with money - because they have to be. They have to shop around, they have to budget carefully, they have to get the best deals. They can't afford luxuries at all. (and for some of them, bus fare is a luxury).

So I kind of disagree with you OP.

In terms of people with money, there is a class thing that w/c people think it makes them look poor to get things second hand. m/c people have no issue with second hand uniform, second hand baby gear, bikes and cars. This is of course a huge generalisation.

onlychildhamster · 04/02/2022 14:48

Buy cheap, buy twice maybe true but there are plenty of people who can only afford the cheap.

In principle I believe in this but at the same time I am still wearing a £10 dress I bought from ASOS in 2013 so 9 years ago. A few of my favourite work dresses were from charity shops. I think a big part of consumerism is the constant need to refresh your look; for me I wear things until they have holes (the ASOS dress has no holes)..

I realized how badly poor people are punished for being poor when I realized my friend in Yorkshire had the same outgoings as me living in London. I asked why, when her rent was lower than my mortgage. She had a car (cos no public transport). She had debt from the time she was unemployed (I was able to stay with family, cos DH's mum owned a house; it wasn't possible for her as her mum lived in a park home). Unlike people on ok incomes, they are punished for yesterday's debt and having no safety net. My friend prided herself for being very frugal and she coupon clipped to the extent I never did.

I0NA · 04/02/2022 14:37

@SvartePetter

I get the feeling that it is wrong to be middle class and frugal from some posters. Does the middle class have an obligation to consume?

I'm definitely frugal. I have just put half a tin of corn and half a tin of black beans in the freezer, will probably make something next week. Really try to not waste food. We check all our providers regularly. I've been spending a few weeks to see if I can get some ikea furniture second hand on FB marketplace. I buy clothes from the charity shop.

Today I have also made an additional payment into my pension, and I have been reviewing my investment portfolio. I will also take my kids to the coffee shop after school because we all really enjoy it.

Am I consuming in the wrong way?

Yes indeed you are.

You are not allowed to spend/ not spend your own money on the things that you want.

And because you are the despised “ middle class “ you deserve to be sneered at.

And if you are also white and female you need to apologise just for existing .

vivainsomnia · 04/02/2022 14:36

I was quite a spender in my 20s and would often get to the end of the month and wonder where it had all gone.

Until I decided in my early 30s to keep a tab on everything I spent for 5 months. What an eye opener this was. The accumulation of little things that didn't cost much until they all added together. The expensive items that I really didn't need and oy seemed a great buy at the time.

It totally changed my view on spending. Suddenly, I found myself with quite a bit at then end of the month without seemingly having made huge changes.

I'm now in a good position financially and can afford not to care much but I haven't forgotten how easy it is to spend meaninglessly and will still try to get the best deal and avoid impulse buying.

Furbulousnous · 04/02/2022 14:34

Buy cheap, buy twice maybe true but there are plenty of people who can only afford the cheap.

Furbulousnous · 04/02/2022 14:33

There’s no-one more savvy than WC parents on a low income budget. No-one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread