Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slim BMI

110 replies

fingersdoublecrossed · 04/02/2022 11:15

Purely posting here for traffic.

At about which BMI would you consider yourself or others to be 'slim'?

OP posts:
WinnieMac · 04/02/2022 17:49

@littlepeas

People saying under 20 are being goady.
Not necessarily. Something can be true without it being goady!
WinnieMac · 04/02/2022 17:48

Mine is between 18 and 19 and I am slim - but I am very small all round and would look like a whale if my BMI were 23, for instance. My DD is a completely different build and would look seriously ill and undernourished with a BMI of 23.

littlepeas · 04/02/2022 17:45

People saying under 20 are being goady.

ViceLikeBlip · 04/02/2022 17:44

My bmi is 21.5 and I'm very squidgy round the edges. But of course there are plenty of people heavier but more toned. Bmi is a very crude tool- it was never really designed to be taken quite so seriously.

Dutchesss · 04/02/2022 17:40

My BMI is 22 and I'm size 8-10. I think I look slim. Blush

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 04/02/2022 17:40

@fingersdoublecrossed

Purely posting here for traffic.

At about which BMI would you consider yourself or others to be 'slim'?

It depends on people's body compositions and sometimes their ethnicity.

I've been morbidly obese by body composition at a BMI of 22.

Some S E Asian people are assessed as crossing the threshold to overweight at BMI 23.

BMI is a good rough guide but you can predict little by it without a lot of additional information.

AuntieStella · 04/02/2022 17:37

Which athletes were you thinking of?

Different poster chipping in here, but its be weighlifters, the heavyweight categories in martial arts, throwers in athletics field events. Also rugby players (esp front row)

Builders and people in the Armed Forces ofthen have high BMI because of very high muscle mass. It doesn't mean BMI as a screening is useless. It just means that it is (as it has always purported to be) a screening tool, which will show up who is an unusual weight for their height. Then you can check if the person is a dedicated sportsperson in a muscly sort of sport or has a very physical job, in which case it'll be OK

All screening tools work like that

Tergeo · 04/02/2022 17:36

Definitely. I'm BMI 24 and a size 14. I'm within the healthy range but literally no one would call me slim! Healthy yes but not slim. I'm 5 ft 10.

I'm the same height, size and bmi. To be slim I would need to be around bmi 22. Well that's what I'm aiming for at the moment.

Same! BMI 23 and size 12-14, definitely not slim. DH and to be fair, the GP has pointed out I could do with losing a bit.

tackling · 04/02/2022 17:32

BMI 18 or lower.

AuntieStella · 04/02/2022 17:30

Anywhere in the healthy range, varying a bit depending on your frame

I look slim at about 22, but when at my full-on racing form (distance runner) it's usually around 20

pictish · 04/02/2022 17:27

I’m average height and weigh 9st 2. I’m a BMI of 22 and generally wear an 8. I think most would describe me as slim. I don’t know if 22 is ‘good’ or not.

Natty13 · 04/02/2022 17:20

Mone is 24 or 25 and I'm a size 6 so my answer is no BMI, it depends on your build.

Postdatedpandemic · 04/02/2022 14:08

@About10thusername

I've met Olympic athletes who apparently have unhealthy high BMI levels. It's a load of tosh and has very little to do with how healthy or fit you are.
Daley Thompson had a BMI of 25.71 , which is fine. If someone is in the overweight category you look at them and ask; peachy or porky.

Which athletes were you thinking of?

Thatsplentyjack · 04/02/2022 14:05

Definitely. I'm BMI 24 and a size 14. I'm within the healthy range but literally no one would call me slim! Healthy yes but not slim. I'm 5 ft 10.

I'm the same height, size and bmi. To be slim I would need to be around bmi 22. Well that's what I'm aiming for at the moment.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 04/02/2022 14:05

I'm 5'4 with a tiny frame and feel right at BMI 20

FlamingRoses · 04/02/2022 14:01

Mine is 24 I think and I would class myself as chubby. I guess 22.

thecatneuterer · 04/02/2022 13:58

For me personally, 20. Generally, probably around 22.

RealBecca · 04/02/2022 13:51

I look skinny at 19-20 (size 8, 5"9) and at 23 I am comfy size 12. So maybe 21/22 is slim.

ChiefInspectorParker · 04/02/2022 13:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

nicecoffeecup · 04/02/2022 13:39

As others have said, it also has to do with the body shape and muscle. I do sports and some running I'd think I'm slim range 22-24. However, I during lockdown my sports/exercise mostly stopped for 9 months, and while my BMI was still in that range I did not consider myself slim (muscle->fat).

Slim is a perception, and I think age is a factor too. I'm in my 50s, and considered slim, but not when I'd look at my DD and some of here friends!!

Lucimaya · 04/02/2022 13:34

My BMI used to be 19 and looking back at photos, I didn't realise at the time how ill and scrawny I was.

Now it's 24.7, I'm a size 8-10 and 5ft 8. Much healthier, but I do think BMI is outdated and not very relevant anymore.

There is 'slim' and ill looking. I definitely looked like the latter when it was anything under 23.

YeOldeTrout · 04/02/2022 13:33

Hmmm...

Given the weird things MNers say about BMI I won't use those boundaries, but I'd discuss things like waist size on a nominal 5'6" tall woman age 20-45 yo.

to me, very subjective,

Thin = approaching underweight or actually underweight (Waist ≤ 25")

Slim = Lower side of healthy size but maybe not Thin (waist 25-28")

Stout or Plump = a little fat, or Not necessarily fat, but Could lose weight and still not be Slim (waist 29-31/32")

Fat : bigger than above

Dixiechickonhols · 04/02/2022 13:30

Height helps I think and also perception of what is slim. I’d describe my teenage daughter as very slim at a 18 bmi size 4/6, xs in hollister. She’s tall though at 5ft 10.
I’m 5 ft 8 and don’t feel slim at top end healthy bmi 25 I feel slim 22/23 but it’s all relative.

PurpleDaisies · 04/02/2022 13:26

@About10thusername

I've met Olympic athletes who apparently have unhealthy high BMI levels. It's a load of tosh and has very little to do with how healthy or fit you are.
Most people aren’t Olympic athletes though. I agree that it doesn’t measure fitness but for the most part, it does tell you if you’re higher risk for certain health issues.
Chickydoo · 04/02/2022 13:25

I'm 5'7'
My BMI is 19.1
I am slim not skinny by any means.