Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slim BMI

110 replies

fingersdoublecrossed · 04/02/2022 11:15

Purely posting here for traffic.

At about which BMI would you consider yourself or others to be 'slim'?

OP posts:
Verbena87 · 04/02/2022 20:58

Mine was 17.5 when I was running a lot. Regular periods and felt fine, though I do look better now carrying another stone.

MrsCapGarland · 04/02/2022 20:53

In my twenties and thirties I was BMI 17.5. I was not on the pill and my periods were extremely punctual. Now I’m mid fifties and post menopause my BMI is around 20 and I definitely have a muffin top. My skeleton is slight and I’m not meant to be BMI 25.

ferntwist · 04/02/2022 20:52

19 or 20

migmogmash · 04/02/2022 20:51

I'm 5ft 7 and currently have a BMI of 16 (and an eating disorder, I'm not trying to be competitive, I'm just unwell) My view on my own body is understandably very distorted, but I know that when I was last at my target of 19.5 during inpatient treatment, friends still thought I looked too thin/unwell and I thought I looked huge. So based on that, 20-23? I do agree it depends on body type, how toned you are etc. I'm not a massive fan of BMI to be honest as I don't think it takes everything into account and it causes people to overly focus on a number rather than whether they are healthy and happy at the weight they are.

WinnieMac · 04/02/2022 20:29

@LaurieFairyCake

Someone up thread said slim is 'under 18'

Which is incredibly distorted 'periods stopping' territory Hmm

Not really. Mine was under 18 prior to each pregnancy. I became pregnant very quickly each time, and had perfectly regular periods. Some people seem not to want to acknowledge that low BMI equates to 'slim', rather than 'underweight' for some women (possibly a minority, but still women!) who are X height with X build.
CottonSock · 04/02/2022 19:08

I'm also 5feet tall and at bmi 25 I'm a size 12 and too big, in my opinion, for my height. I look best in the middle of the normal range so I think bmi works for my build. I'd like to be 22.

Thecaravan · 04/02/2022 19:03

Therefore I don't think there's a particular bmi that's skinny. Depends very much on frame, bone structure etc.

Thecaravan · 04/02/2022 19:02

My BMI is 19 and I know there's some parts of me that are slim like my arms and legs but I still have a podgy stomach. My face is gaunt which I hate as it makes people think I'm skinnier when my stomach and hips etc are not that thin.

StuntNun · 04/02/2022 18:34

It depends on bone structure. I'm very fine-boned and in the middle of the normal BMI range I would still have a fair amount of abdominal fat. I need to be down around 19 to look slim.

Svara · 04/02/2022 18:34

@LapinR0se

My BMI is 19.5 which is “normal” according to the CDC website. So I assume under 18 is slim.
To me slim is a subcategory of the healthy weight range, somewhere in the lower half depending on build. Underweight (and also near the bottom of the healthy weight range for people with a large build) I'd call thin.
Blinkingbatshit · 04/02/2022 18:23

I haven’t been very well the past 12 months and I’ve dropped from a BMI of 21 (healthy size 10) to a BMI of (just!) under 18 (scrawny size 6☹️). I can tell you the biggest shock in size change between those 2 is my bust going from 30DD (occasional E!) to 30B - I really miss them!! Hoping to get better and get a chance to enjoy getting it back on - definitely looked & felt better ‘bigger’👍!!

Giraffesandbottoms · 04/02/2022 18:22

BMI is 19 and I’m slim

LaurieFairyCake · 04/02/2022 18:18

Someone up thread said slim is 'under 18'

Which is incredibly distorted 'periods stopping' territory Hmm

PurpleDaisies · 04/02/2022 18:17

@LapinR0se

My BMI is 19.5 which is “normal” according to the CDC website. So I assume under 18 is slim.
19.5 is at the lower end of the healthy range. I would assume you are slim.

Maybe some of the differences are down to what people think slim means.

Svara · 04/02/2022 18:12

Either this thread has brought out all the competitively underweight posters, or my definition of “slim” is different from everyone else’s. To me, “slim” is a size 10-12

How many posters have said an underweight bmi is what they'd call slim? Healthy range is 18.5 to 25, 21.75 right in the middle of that. Many people are saying the lower half of the healthy range is slim. My bmi is 20 and I'm a 6 bottom, 8 to 10 top .

LaurieFairyCake · 04/02/2022 18:07

25 or less

I'm only 5 ft tall but at 25 BMI I'm a size 8

That's slim to me Confused

Zazdar · 04/02/2022 18:05

Really I think the problem with the question is how you are supposed to know someone’s bmi just by looking at them.

It's the same problem when people use dress sizes to define slim.

It's pointless unless you know how tall somebody is.

Darbs76 · 04/02/2022 18:05

I’m 23 and people say I’m slim but I carry all my weight on my stomach and I’m towards the upper of my ideal weight - so I’d say 21 or under

LapinR0se · 04/02/2022 18:05

My BMI is 19.5 which is “normal” according to the CDC website. So I assume under 18 is slim.

PurpleDaisies · 04/02/2022 18:03

@littlepeas

People saying under 20 are being goady.
How do you figure that out?

My bmi is 20. I still have wobbly bits. I think I’m slim but I can see how someone might disagree if they looked at my stomach and thighs.

Really I think the problem with the question is how you are supposed to know someone’s bmi just by looking at them. You can look at someone and see if they are slim but they don’t usually advertise their bmi.

Zazdar · 04/02/2022 18:02

Either this thread has brought out all the competitively underweight posters, or my definition of “slim” is different from everyone else’s. To me, “slim” is a size 10-12

It's certainly different to mine. I was a size 10-12 and I was very definitely podgy.

It may not be the same for others.

FurbleSocks · 04/02/2022 18:02

@Tergeo

Definitely. I'm BMI 24 and a size 14. I'm within the healthy range but literally no one would call me slim! Healthy yes but not slim. I'm 5 ft 10.

I'm the same height, size and bmi. To be slim I would need to be around bmi 22. Well that's what I'm aiming for at the moment.

Same! BMI 23 and size 12-14, definitely not slim. DH and to be fair, the GP has pointed out I could do with losing a bit.

I'm going for 21 just so I can have a fabulous time when we go on holiday and go up to 22!
Boood · 04/02/2022 17:57

Either this thread has brought out all the competitively underweight posters, or my definition of “slim” is different from everyone else’s. To me, “slim” is a size 10-12- healthy, not synonymous with “skinny” or “tiny”. A realistic ideal, not unattainable for the majority over 25.

RicStar · 04/02/2022 17:52

I think its interesting I am short 5"3, my bmi is around 26 (would love it to be less but its pretty much always been here or higher)- I think people would say I was normal - definitely not slim but I run and walk a lot and am quite toned wear a size 12 mostly, dsis is 5'10 also a size 12 and much heavier than me, and carries weight differently but her BMI is much lower than mine but I dont think she is perceived as slim either -also normal . So what I am saying is I don't think slim appearance and BMI are that correlated. I would agree dress size is probably a better indicator.

Svara · 04/02/2022 17:51

@littlepeas

People saying under 20 are being goady.
Could they be talking about themselves? I said 18.5 to 22 in general but I have a small build myself and look healthy at a bmi of 22 or less, slim around 18.5 to 20.