Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slim BMI

110 replies

fingersdoublecrossed · 04/02/2022 11:15

Purely posting here for traffic.

At about which BMI would you consider yourself or others to be 'slim'?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cherrybonbons · 05/02/2022 11:34

@anon12345678901

Well I've just checked and my bmi is 24.5, but I'm size 8 in clothes. I'm 5ft4 but I hit the gym 5 times a week and weight train. Muscle carries differently to fat though. I wouldn't go off the bmi at all, it depends on an individual's build, usually you can see when someone is overweight or getting close to it. That would be the indicator I'd look out for with my child.
You've just described me- I'm 5ft 3 and gym 4-5 times a week. I weigh between 60 and 61kg usually without much tracking of what I eat

My body fat is 18.5%
I could cut my diet and get down to 57kg but I wouldn't enjoy my life at all and I feel my body is already slim.
BMI is a really poor indicator - mine is 24.8

Flickflak · 05/02/2022 05:46

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

anon12345678901 · 05/02/2022 05:18

Well I've just checked and my bmi is 24.5, but I'm size 8 in clothes. I'm 5ft4 but I hit the gym 5 times a week and weight train. Muscle carries differently to fat though. I wouldn't go off the bmi at all, it depends on an individual's build, usually you can see when someone is overweight or getting close to it. That would be the indicator I'd look out for with my child.

readingismycardio · 05/02/2022 05:00

I'm a size 8 and my BMI is 22. I could probably go a bit lower, but I'm not willing to put the work in it Grin

cherrybonbons · 05/02/2022 04:09

Oh yeah and body fat percentage is 18.5% I'm just trying to give an indicator of why bmi is useless because I was in the 18-20 range I would look extremely ill and not slim

cherrybonbons · 05/02/2022 04:06

I am also a comfortable size 8

cherrybonbons · 05/02/2022 04:06

24.8 for me.I always laugh when I see that.
I am slim- I just gym and weight lift a lot. So bmi is a useless indicator tbh

Chichimcgee · 05/02/2022 03:17

I wouldn’t go on bmi at all, I’m classed as obese but wearing size 8 maternity jeans (I am 37 weeks pregnant, not just wearing maternity jeans to say I’m a size 8 lol) before pregnancy I was a size 12 bottom, size 16 top. So not slim but I wouldn’t have ever thought obese!

Thecaravan · 05/02/2022 03:14

Sorry @JeeezLouise

Thecaravan · 05/02/2022 03:14

Yes @JeezLouise me too! My waist is 79cm currently with a bmi of 19. Classic apple- all weight goes on around my middle so I have to work to keep my weight down to make sure the waist to hip ratio is okay.
I also have severe scoliosis which has never been treated so have one massive hip and a twisted hump ribcage which I think makes clothes fit differently so despite my low weight, I am still a size 12-14.

JeeezLouise · 05/02/2022 01:13

Waist circumference and waist to hip ratio are better indicators of whether you are overweight than BMI is. If your waist is >80cm that is considered overweight, which sadly for me happens well before I hit a BMI of 25.

Passthecake30 · 04/02/2022 22:49

I look slim at 19/19.5. 6ft tall and narrow shouldered/small feet.

ZealAndArdour · 04/02/2022 22:39

I’m 6ft tall and look slim with a BMI of 31. My collar bones are totally visible and I can easily feel my ribs through my chest and abdomen. My legs are long and gangly.

I have very big boobs and wide hips though on a lanky frame.

Shinydiscoballs1 · 04/02/2022 22:33

In a size 8 and described as slim by others, just did the calculator and it says I'm 22.3 though

NewbieSM · 04/02/2022 21:54

Currently I'm sitting at a BMI of 18.8, weight 47kg and am short at 5 ft 2. I'm definitely slim but in proportion, don't look skinny, work in an active job and gym/ run a few times a week. Have been at the top end of my 'healthy' range and was definitely chubby, there isn't much vertical space for the weight to go when you are as short as me haha. But honestly bmi is mostly useless as a tool for determining health or fitness, everyone's body composition is different along with other factors, age, ethnicity, build etc.

Giraffesandbottoms · 04/02/2022 21:54

I feel like when Angelina jolie was in her prime she was a 20 wasn’t she? Maybe a 21? I remember it’s when BMI became popular and people saying her BMI was X ans that’s “perfect” 😬

pictish · 04/02/2022 21:49

Couldn’t agree more. I’m obsessed with my weight. I went from 19 stone to 9. It took three years of healthy eating and exercise to be fit and slim…so you know, I’m a bit precious about it. What I DON’T do is weigh myself or worry about my bmi. I’m pretty happy with where I’m at and keep living well to maintain it. I don’t care about the numbers but how I feel in myself. We’re all different. We shouldn’t compare because we can’t.

5128gap · 04/02/2022 21:48

Mines about 21. I've a size 6 24" waist, with 37" hips and fattish bum, so am both very slim, and also rather plump, depending on which bit of me you're looking at. Six months ago it was 20 and my ribs were visible and I couldn't find anything to fit my waist, so that was too low for me.

KittyWindbag · 04/02/2022 21:43

These threads tend to attract people who are a bit obsessed with their weight (including me :( ) so might not be the best representation and also could be, for want of a less hideous word, triggering. After all what real evidence can anyone take from this thread, everyone is different and bmi a broad range. I think it will only serve to make people already a bit obsessed compare themselves unfavourably.

TheCanyon · 04/02/2022 21:39

I'm usually about 18.8/18.7, feel pretty good at that. Not overly skinny, slim but with curves. A year ago when I was unwell I was at 17.3, I looked ridiculous as I have big shoulders/hips. The last month I am SO hungry, Have ate like hell and my bmi is now 19.6, I feel really chunky tbh.

Pythonesque · 04/02/2022 21:29

For me, if I ever get my BMI below 25 I suspect some people will see me as slim. When it was 25-30 I got looks of surprise when I commented that I needed to lose some weight.

I'm very tall (5'11" or so but nearly 6' in the past/when I go back to an osteopath and my spine straightens out a bit...) but "in proportion" rather than long-limbed; so at the moment I look like an overweight average height person if seen from any distance. I've even had people surprised when I've mentioned I'm tall.

Grumpsy · 04/02/2022 21:05

At 18 I had a bmi of about 23/24 with a 23 inch waist. If I had a lower bmi I would have looked ill.

Now I’m older I’m fat 🙈

FurbleSocks · 04/02/2022 21:02

The NHS BMI calculator suggests under 18.5 is underweight.

8st 13lbs I'm sure I wouldn't have any energy but I'm sure I'd be slim!

Slim BMI
MrsCapGarland · 04/02/2022 21:02

I wonder what Darcy Bussell was when she danced regularly? Slim, athletic and powerful. And a beautiful woman.

ffscovid · 04/02/2022 21:00

Slim, probably around 19-21 for most 'average build' people.

18 or below is more 'skinny' than 'slim' (not in a good way).