Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think psych wards should be single-sex?

111 replies

UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 00:56

This is something I have thought about a lot. And am interested in others opinions and maybe what can be done about it?

I have spent time on 3 acute wards that were mixed-sex and also one long term ward that was women only (in fact the whole hospital was).

On all 3 of the wards men came onto me, while I was very vulnerable. On one occasion I started a relationship with a man on the ward. I was also touched inappropriately on many occasions. There was also aggression by men. I was obviously not thinking straight and would stand up to men who bullied/abused women. I was threatened on many occasions and actually punched once. This was just normal life on the ward. Looking back I feel I really wasn't safe guarded.

When I got to the women's hospital it was bliss! The general level of aggression (and aggressive swearing) was so much lower! Like a 1 compared to a 10. The type of abuse that happened all the time like inappropriate touching just did not happen. There were not people trying to come onto you all the time.

I just think psych wards should be single sex and preferably single sex hospitals! Because men can still target you when on leave if they are in the same hospital. What do you think?

OP posts:
Porcupineintherough · 04/02/2022 14:17

YANBU most wards should be single sex (the exceptions being very specialist provision like ICU where patients are bed bound anyway)

Whatifitallgoesright · 04/02/2022 14:10

Baroness Emma Nicholson would like to hear of your experiences. She is discussing it today in House of Lords

twitter.com/Baroness_Nichol/status/1489561195883511811?s=20&t=7aalw7o8P1zyrQwraibBsQ

"David Blencathra’s and my Single Sex Ward Amendments are up for debate today - we are asking for a full and open analysis of why thé NHS prioritises on non medical grounds which is contrary to the eternal medical principle of health comes first. Cases of worse health or assault."

writingonpaper · 04/02/2022 13:57

@MorningStarling

I'm clearly out of step with everyone else but I don't have a problem with wards being mixed sex. For one thing, it saves any argument over where trans people should be placed and a debate over who classes as trans enough to go in particular ward. But generally, aside from that, I don't believe it is natural to segregate men from women. Our natural behaviour is to mix.
This post so clearly articulates how, despite the outlining of abuse on this thread, that gender ideologues believe that trans people need to be centred over women, not matter the cost to women, even at the cost of sexual abuse.

As to, its not natural to segregate, actually it is when women are vulnerable. That's why we created single sex spaces. As unfortunately, all history tells us that it is 'natural' (as in inevitable) that there are men who will physically and sexually attack women when they can.

writingonpaper · 04/02/2022 13:53

Tbh, I've seen similar threats in residential care. I've seen very frail elderly ladies beaten up by males in dementia care. The warning signs were there and ignored

I was thinking this too. Its a concern that no-one seems to be bothering with. I've heard from colleagues of cases where there are concerns that men in residential care are sexually exploiting women with dementia, as the women is not really capable of consent and is manipulated into thinking she is in a relationship with the man.

Deadringer · 04/02/2022 13:49

@MorningStarling

I'm clearly out of step with everyone else but I don't have a problem with wards being mixed sex. For one thing, it saves any argument over where trans people should be placed and a debate over who classes as trans enough to go in particular ward. But generally, aside from that, I don't believe it is natural to segregate men from women. Our natural behaviour is to mix.
Even though it is clear from this thread that that women are being raped and sexually assaulted in mixed wards? I suppose that's natural too? ffs.
Irridescantshimmmer · 04/02/2022 13:20

Yeah I agree all wards should be single sex and especially for the reasons you described OP, I consider myself lucky, I have never been admitted to one and by the sounds of things looks like people may need help to recover from experiences on these wards, which sound horrendous.

Predatory males are abhorrant.

UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 13:14

@Teaforme123

I know of a child who was conceived in a psychiatric unit...
Oh, I am sure there are many. As I say there is only so much the staff can do if men and women are mixing.
OP posts:
Teaforme123 · 04/02/2022 13:08

I know of a child who was conceived in a psychiatric unit...

shouldistop · 04/02/2022 13:05

Wards should be single sex definitely and I agree that men should not be staying on postnatal wards.

UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 13:03

@heathspeedwell

Absolutely agree that all wards should be single sex. The Times newspaper reported that women are nine times more vulnerable to sexual assault in mixed-sex spaces.

Having single sex psych wards protects vulnerable men too.

I have a male relative who was sectioned a few years ago. While on the ward one of the nurses accused him of inappropriate sexual activity with another patient. Luckily witnesses confirmed that it was the female patient who initiated the relationship with him, but of course the nurse was right to be concerned because when people are that unwell neither of them can really consent.

My relative continued to date this woman for months after they left the hospital. Being in a co-dependent relationship exacerbated their mental health problems. They would both have recovered from their breakdowns far more quickly if the wards had been single sex.

I completely agree with everything you say. The same happened to me and it was not a good relationship, unfortunately. When I look back I partly think they should have done more to prevent the relationship happening and also that there is only so much they can do if men and women are mixing. It is unfair to both parties as neither can consent.
OP posts:
heathspeedwell · 04/02/2022 12:54

Absolutely agree that all wards should be single sex. The Times newspaper reported that women are nine times more vulnerable to sexual assault in mixed-sex spaces.

Having single sex psych wards protects vulnerable men too.

I have a male relative who was sectioned a few years ago. While on the ward one of the nurses accused him of inappropriate sexual activity with another patient. Luckily witnesses confirmed that it was the female patient who initiated the relationship with him, but of course the nurse was right to be concerned because when people are that unwell neither of them can really consent.

My relative continued to date this woman for months after they left the hospital. Being in a co-dependent relationship exacerbated their mental health problems. They would both have recovered from their breakdowns far more quickly if the wards had been single sex.

SilverDragonfly1 · 04/02/2022 12:44

@GiantHaystacks2021

That's Dickensian. Dreadful.
Worse than Dickensian by some margin. Woman and men were very strictly segregated in Victorian institutions, to the point of parents being separated from each other and their children in workhouses.
UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 12:23

[quote JustOneCup]@Lockdownbear

Totally agree. I’ve got a large family and every postnatal stay was hell due to partners of women staying

Loud talking , loud eating, loud phone calls at 1/2/3 am. Tv or phone son loud watching stuff at ridiculous hours ….
Arguments …..

Men snoring and farting and finding the farting oh so hilarious

Having my curtains pulled back and being looked at

Having my curtains pulled back and my chair take as apparently I didn’t need it !

One night the man next to my cubicle decided to push his chair far back so it pushed my curtain and I was acutely aware his head was literally cm away from my bed separated by a thin curtain and he took up most of MY cubicle space

I couldn’t leave my baby to go for a shower as the ward was so busy

The men used the bathrooms so they were totally occupied 99% of the time with no just patients but their shitting/showering partners ….
It was HELL[/quote]
That sounds dreadful - I'm so sorry. I only stayed in with my eldest and back then the men could come for visiting hours only. It was fine - they still got to bond with their babies but gave time for women to rest/use showers/sleep at night.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 12:17

[quote 334bu]www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-7860747/More-1-000-patients-sexually-abused-mixed-sex-NHS-mental-health-wards-2-5-years.html[/quote]
Safeguarding was often raised but the assaults were never reported to the police. As far as I know there was no investigation. I was too unwell to raise this at the time. It was over 3 years ago now. But I want to know why it was allowed to happen now.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 12:12

@Maddiemoosmum0203

I agree in principle they should be single sex I have been sectioned and on various wards/units I personally found the one mixed unit I was on was actually the calmest and I struggle with males due to past trauma maybe it was because it was private so more staff/activities etc The womens wards I have been on have been chaotic but much safer against the awful situations like you faced with OP I’m so Sorry you had to deal with that
Thank you Smile

The women's hospital I was in was also private. I think you are right that higher staff ratios and more activities, definitely helps keep things calmer. I always thought the OTs in the NHS hospitals would love the budget of the OTs in the private hospital I was in.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 12:07

@beastlyslumber

Yes, all wards should be single sex. It's absolutely awful to have mixed-sex wards of any kinds. Of course women are going to be incredibly vulnerable.

I'm so sorry you experienced this, OP.

Thank you Smile
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 12:06

@Gowithme

What about PALS maybe they would be the people to tell about your shocking experience. I think all wards should be single sex.
Thank you. I really feel I need to speak about it/debrief. This was over 3 years ago and I haven't got over it.
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 12:05

@Deadringer

Absolutely they should be single sex. My brother has a mental illness and has had a few stints in a psych ward, the last time he was in a young woman attached herself to him, she kept telling everyone she was his wife, in his mental state he believed her (his wife had died a few months before). As far as we know nothing happened between them but we really didn't think that staff did enough to keep them apart. That young woman was very vulnerable and needed protecting. God knows what goes on in some of those places, it's a disgrace that they are mixed sex.
I can relate to this too. A women thought one of the men was her boyfriend. He had done nothing to give this impression but she was unwell and it made her think that. She told her family they were moving in together etc and they made complaints as they thought the man was initiating it. She also gave him money which he would refuse but one time he was short for fags and accepted the money. He was unwell too so wasn't able to see this as inappropriate. Family complained. I stepped in and made sure the money was given back and told the woman to stop trying to give him money/leave him alone. She wasn't happy as she thought I was stealing her boyfriend, poor woman.
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 12:00

@RedCandyApple

My ex was sectioned and he said that there was women there as well, it really surprised me as I thought they would be kept separate, he said he got into a fight with a man as he was starting on a woman in there.
It is really common for certain men to pick on the most vulnerable women. I hated this and would always stand up for them but would put myself in very dangerous situations as I was so disinhibited due to being mentally unwell. There were some men who were lovely and would look out for the women, though.
OP posts:
JustOneCup · 04/02/2022 11:59

@Lockdownbear

Totally agree. I’ve got a large family and every postnatal stay was hell due to partners of women staying

Loud talking , loud eating, loud phone calls at 1/2/3 am. Tv or phone son loud watching stuff at ridiculous hours ….
Arguments …..

Men snoring and farting and finding the farting oh so hilarious

Having my curtains pulled back and being looked at

Having my curtains pulled back and my chair take as apparently I didn’t need it !

One night the man next to my cubicle decided to push his chair far back so it pushed my curtain and I was acutely aware his head was literally cm away from my bed separated by a thin curtain and he took up most of MY cubicle space

I couldn’t leave my baby to go for a shower as the ward was so busy

The men used the bathrooms so they were totally occupied 99% of the time with no just patients but their shitting/showering partners ….
It was HELL

carefreecardigans · 04/02/2022 11:53

@Etak123

I’m so sorry this happened to you x I spend lots of time in hospital and it’s always mixed wards but single sex bays. We no longer have a mental health ward at our local hospital but I know a few people who have been on it in the past. Unfortunately a young man I know very well was in there when he was also very vulnerable and ill and he was traumatised to say the least. It’s so hard to say because everyone who gets sectioned ( been very close many times in the past) is very ill and deserves individual sensitivite supportive care. They are not in control properly, therefore not responsible for their actions so it only makes sense to have single sex wards. Unfortunately with the 12 years of Tory austerity the health and social care budget and the nhs have taken so many cuts that they just can’t afford it. It’s not right and poor people like you are/have paid the price. The only thing we little people can do about any of it is vote, on mass, against the tories and talk to people, explain how they have destroyed our country and try to work together to get funding back where it’s needed x
I'm interested in your comment on social care cuts, because obviously services are not what they should be but funding has in real terms increased year on year. Those in the know where has been cut and where is the extra going? It is a disaster zone, I think everyone dreads getting ill enough to need hospital care.

www.kingsfund.org.uk/projects/nhs-in-a-nutshell/nhs-budget

OP your experience was horrific, please lodge a complaint with PALs, and write to your MP. Women's safety is being eroded on all sides.

UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 11:41

@KitBumbleB

My friend was sectioned and ended in an two inappropriate "relationships" because she was so ill. She was on a mixed sex ward. It was easier to have sex than it was to smoke.
It's awful this has happened to so many women.
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 11:40

@Supersee

There's no such thing as single sex now as men (and women but we're not hearing much from them) can decide to be whatever sex they like without question so 🤷‍♀️

The world has gone fucking mad.

Yes, that was an issue as I said above.
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 11:39

@MorningStarling

I'm clearly out of step with everyone else but I don't have a problem with wards being mixed sex. For one thing, it saves any argument over where trans people should be placed and a debate over who classes as trans enough to go in particular ward. But generally, aside from that, I don't believe it is natural to segregate men from women. Our natural behaviour is to mix.
@MorningStarling Well, does it really in a psychiatric ward? Do you put a transwomen in the women's wing for their bedroom or the men's?

Have you been on a psychiatric ward? Yes, it may be natural to mix but is it 'natural' for the women to be frequently sexually assaulted? To be frequently verbally and physically assaulted? Is that really 'natural'?

OP posts:
Maddiemoosmum0203 · 04/02/2022 11:35

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.